Time-reversal symmetry and its violation (T-violation) are fundamental across diverse physics domains, from particle physics to fluctuation theorems and reciprocity. While time-reversal symmetry for isolated systems is simply determined by the Hamiltonian, quantifying the magnitude of T-violation, especially in noisy quantum processes, has been a subject of ongoing debate. Here, we propose an operationally meaningful framework to quantify the intrinsic T-violation of quantum channels. We integrate operationally defined time-reversal transformations into dynamical resource theory to formulate T-violation as a resource. T-violation decomposes into two distinct components: kinematic T-violation originating from antiunitary motion-reversal, and nonunitality driven purely by thermodynamics. This decomposition resolves the longstanding confusion between broken time-reversal symmetry and non-invertibility. Finally, we analyze the resulting resource theory of kinematic T-violation, showing that it is neither quality-like nor quantity-like, and proving the existence of a universal golden unit even within classical channels.
AI Summary
The paper asks how to quantify time-reversal violation in noisy quantum dynamics while distinguishing it from non-invertibility. Given a physically specified antiunitary motion reversal $\Theta$, it defines channel T-symmetry through equality of original and motion-reversed process probabilities, using an operational formalism that exchanges preparations and effects. Algebraically, symmetry means $\mathcal E=\mathcal E_\Theta$, where $\mathcal E_\Theta=\operatorname{Ad}_{\Theta^\dagger}\circ\mathcal E^\dagger\circ\operatorname{Ad}_\Theta$. This condition implies unitality but does not require invertibility.
Nested classes of completely symmetry-preserving and unitality-preserving superchannels define resource theories of total T-violation, nonunitality, and kinematic T-violation within unital channels. The paper establishes that free superchannels act as CPTP maps on normalized Choi operators, enabling Choi-distance monotones. Information-geometric Pythagorean identities then decompose reverse-relative-entropy T-violation exactly into nonunitality plus the kinematic violation of the closest unital channel, for full-rank Choi states. The forward-relative-entropy identity is established for qubit channels.
For unital channels, averaging a channel with its reverse-process simulator gives the closest symmetric channel for relative entropy, trace distance, and Frobenius distance. The forward-relative-entropy measure lies in $[0,1]$ bits. Explicit superchannel constructions show that a single-qubit unitary and a classical three-state circulator are each universal golden units, convertible into any unital channel. A multiplicative fidelity monotone rules out exact replication of intermediate resources and finite-copy conversion of nonmaximal resources into maximal ones.
The decomposition is not extended to rank-deficient Choi states. General necessary-and-sufficient conversion criteria, probabilistic operations, and resource generation through sequential channel composition remain open.
Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsPossible error
Central claim may not hold: The advertised general-channel quantitative decomposition is proved only for strictly positive Choi states, with deficient-Choi-rank channels explicitly left unresolved.
The decomposition uses particular relative-entropy measures and a projected unital channel, and its forward-relative-entropy version is established only for qubits.
The golden-unit positivity proof contains an incorrect projector decomposition, although orthogonal ancillary vectors and coefficients of one half repair it.
The claimed monotonicity of flip/twirl quantities under arbitrary deterministic superchannels is false, as a replacement superchannel can create T-violation from a T-symmetric input.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
Comments
24 pages, 5 figures, 1 table. Comments are welcome
Time-reversal symmetry and its violation (T-violation) are fundamental across diverse physics domains, from particle physics to fluctuation theorems and reciprocity. While time-reversal symmetry for isolated systems is simply determined by the Hamiltonian, quantifying the magnitude of T-violation, especially in noisy quantum processes, has been a subject of ongoing debate. Here, we propose an operationally meaningful framework to quantify the intrinsic T-violation of quantum channels. We integrate operationally defined time-reversal transformations into dynamical resource theory to formulate T-violation as a resource. T-violation decomposes into two distinct components: kinematic T-violation originating from antiunitary motion-reversal, and nonunitality driven purely by thermodynamics. This decomposition resolves the longstanding confusion between broken time-reversal symmetry and non-invertibility. Finally, we analyze the resulting resource theory of kinematic T-violation, showing that it is neither quality-like nor quantity-like, and proving the existence of a universal golden unit even within classical channels.
The paper asks how to quantify time-reversal violation in noisy quantum dynamics while distinguishing it from non-invertibility. Given a physically specified antiunitary motion reversal Θ, it defines channel T-symmetry through equality of original and motion-reversed process probabilities, using an operational formalism that exchanges preparations and effects. Algebraically, symmetry means E=EΘ, where EΘ=AdΘ†∘E†∘AdΘ. This condition implies unitality but does not require invertibility.
Nested classes of completely symmetry-preserving and unitality-preserving superchannels define resource theories of total T-violation, nonunitality, and kinematic T-violation within unital channels. The paper establishes that free superchannels act as CPTP maps on normalized Choi operators, enabling Choi-distance monotones. Information-geometric Pythagorean identities then decompose reverse-relative-entropy T-violation exactly into nonunitality plus the kinematic violation of the closest unital channel, for full-rank Choi states. The forward-relative-entropy identity is established for qubit channels.
For unital channels, averaging a channel with its reverse-process simulator gives the closest symmetric channel for relative entropy, trace distance, and Frobenius distance. The forward-relative-entropy measure lies in [0,1] bits. Explicit superchannel constructions show that a single-qubit unitary and a classical three-state circulator are each universal golden units, convertible into any unital channel. A multiplicative fidelity monotone rules out exact replication of intermediate resources and finite-copy conversion of nonmaximal resources into maximal ones.
The decomposition is not extended to rank-deficient Choi states. General necessary-and-sufficient conversion criteria, probabilistic operations, and resource generation through sequential channel composition remain open.
We propose the resource theory of a special antiunitary asymmetry in quantum theory. The notion of antiunitary asymmetry, in particular, PT-asymmetry is different from the usual resource theory for asymmetry about unitary representation of a symmetry group, as the PT operator is an antiunitary operator with P being any self-inverse unitary and T being the time-reversal operations. Here, we introduce the PT-symmetric states, PT-covariant operations and PT-asymmetry measures. For single qubit system, we find duality relations between the PT-asymmetry measures and the coherence. Moreover, for two-qubit states we prove the duality relations between the PT-asymmetry measures and entanglement measure such as the concurrence. This gives a resource theoretic interpretation to the concurrence which is lacking till today. Thus, the PT-asymmetry measure and entanglement can be viewed as two sides of an underlying resource. Finally, the PT-symmetric dynamics is discussed and some open questions are addressed.
Time-reversal had always been assumed to be a symmetry of physics at the fundamental level. In this paper we will explore the violations of time-reversal symmetry at the fundamental level and the consequence on thermodynamic systems. First, we will argue from current physics that the universe dynamics is not time-reversal invariant. Second, we will argue that any thermodynamic system cannot be isolated completely from the universe. We then discuss how these two make the dynamics of thermodynamics systems very weakly irreversible at the classical and quantum level. Since time-reversal is no longer a symmetry of realistic systems, the problem of how macroscopic irreversibility arises from microscopic reversibility becomes irrelevant because there is no longer microscopic reversibility. At the classical level of a thermodynamic system, we show that the H theorem of Boltzmann is still valid even without microscopic reversibility. We do this by deriving a modified H theorem, which still shows entropy monotonically increasing. At the quantum level, we explicitly show the effect of CP violation, small irreversible changes on the internal states of the nuclear and atomic energy levels of thermodynamic systems. Thus, we remove Loschmidt's objection to Boltzmann's ideas.
Deriving an arrow of time from time-reversal symmetric microscopic dynamics is a fundamental open problem in many areas of physics, ranging from cosmology, to particle physics, to thermodynamics and statistical mechanics. Here we focus on the derivation of the arrow of time in open quantum systems and study precisely how time-reversal symmetry is broken. This derivation involves the Markov approximation applied to a system interacting with an infinite heat bath. We find that the Markov approximation does not imply a violation of time-reversal symmetry. Our results show instead that the time-reversal symmetry is maintained in the derived equations of motion. This imposes a time-symmetric formulation of quantum Brownian motion, Lindblad and Pauli master equations, which hence describe thermalisation that may occur into two opposing time directions. As a consequence, we argue that these dynamics are better described by a time-symmetric definition of Markovianity. Our results may reflect on the formulations of the arrow of time in thermodynamics, cosmology, and quantum mechanics.
Quantifying how much a quantum state breaks a symmetry is essential for characterizing phases, nonequilibrium dynamics, and open-system behavior. For mixed states, however, conventional diagnostics of weak symmetry breaking can miss a stronger form of symmetry breaking associated with the possibility of exchanging conserved charges with an environment. We develop a resource theory of strong symmetry breaking by identifying the appropriate free states and free operations, and, for channels on a fixed system, by showing that the latter are precisely the operations realizable without exchanging the conserved charge with the environment. We systematically construct measures of strong symmetry breaking, including strong entanglement asymmetry and covariance matrices of symmetry generators, for a broad class of symmetry groups. We further completely characterize i.i.d. convertibility between arbitrary states under any compact Lie group strong symmetry. This identifies the combinations of resource-theoretically valid measures that quantify strong symmetry breaking for arbitrary states, including all mixed states. In particular, for U(1) symmetry, if the states have positive variances of the conserved quantity and equal strong-symmetry periods, the conversion rate is completely determined by the variance ratio whenever the input is pure or the output is weak symmetric. Thus, for these state conversions, the variance of the conserved quantity plays an operational role analogous to that of entanglement entropy in entanglement theory or quantum Fisher information in the resource theory of weak asymmetry. We further show how weak symmetry breaking is irreversibly converted into strong symmetry breaking in open-system dynamics. We illustrate the framework with examples from quantum field theory, strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking, and a strong-symmetry analogue of Mpemba-type dynamics.
The Bayesian inverse of a quantum channel E is a channel F in the reverse direction of E that yields time-symmetric correlations for sequential measurements performed on open quantum systems. Such an operational form of time-reversal symmetry for open quantum systems is quite remarkable, as the dynamics of open quantum systems are inherently irreversible due to system-environment interactions. Similar to the Petz map, a Bayesian inverse F is defined with respect to a fiducial reference state ρ for the channel E. However, Bayesian inverses do not always exist, and it is often a non-trivial task to determine the set of states ρ for which a Bayesian inverse of E exists. In this work, we solve the general problem of quantum Bayesian inversion for unital channels acting on a single qubit. Our analysis is streamlined by demonstrating that finding a Bayesian inverse for a unital qubit channel may be reduced to finding a Bayesian inverse of a Pauli channel, which is simply a mixture of unitary channels associated with the Pauli matrices. As such, we provide a complete description of when operational time-reversal symmetry is attainable for sequential measurements of a single qubit in the presence of unital noise.
Time is used in non-relativistic quantum theory as a classical concept. On the one hand, time is the parameter entering Schrödinger's equation and measured by an external laboratory clock. But it could be considered that time also plays the role of an observable when a given event occurs (e.g., when a particle crosses through a potential barrier), and one would expect that like every observable, it should be represented in the theory by an operator whose properties are predictors of the outcome of time measurements made on physical systems. Several time operators have been proposed in different publications, but still, there is not a widely accepted consensus. That subject, among others concerned with time in quantum mechanics, is analyzed in the present chapter, where we focus on the analysis of time-reversal symmetry in non-relativistic quantum systems. The search for symmetries in Physics helps to study the structure of theories. Briefly speaking, a symmetry is a transformation that does not change the structure of the theory. We start with the analysis of Schrödinger’s Equation verifying that for obtaining a time-symmetric description of the dynamics of a particle, the operation of time-reversal must include conjugation represented by the action of an antiunitary operator acting over a wave function. In particular, we analyze quantum systems whose evolution is determined by a set of external parameters varying cyclically, discussing how even though these parameters return to their initial values, the state of the system acquires a geometric phase, which depends on the path followed by the external parameters in the parameter space and which in general can be associated with the lack of the time-reversal symmetry of the system.