arXiv:2609.36029
Out-of-Time-Ordered Correlators Beyond Lindblad
Elisa Vallini, Felix Fritzsch, Pieter W. Claeys
Abstract
Out-of-time-ordered correlators (OTOCs) provide a powerful probe of quantum chaos and scrambling. While the Lindblad formalism is often used to describe OTOCs in open systems, microscopic mechanisms that give rise to the Lindblad equation at the level of time-ordered correlation functions do not necessarily justify this approach at the level of OTOCs. Starting from a microscopic model of a subsystem coupled to a random bath, we show that the resulting OTOC dynamics contains an additional contribution compared to the standard Lindblad approach. This contribution, induced by correlations between different replicas, allows key properties of the underlying unitary dynamics such as long-time freeness to be retained and information scrambling to be captured more faithfully. As an application, we show that this extended formalism can be used to numerically study OTOCs in large closed systems by replacing part of the system with a dissipative boundary, offering a way to study operator spreading and higher-order correlations beyond directly accessible system sizes.
AI Summary
A Lindblad equation that correctly describes reduced observables and two-point correlations need not determine an OTOC by independently evolving its operator copies. This paper asks how correlations between those copies modify OTOCs and whether retaining them enables smaller open systems to approximate scrambling in larger closed systems. The construction couples a subsystem through an intermediate site to a bath subjected to independent Haar-random unitaries at each step. At infinite temperature, taking the infinite-bath and continuous-time limits produces a unital Lindblad generator $\mathcal L$ with Hermitian jump operators $J_\alpha$. Averaging the two-replica circuit gives $F_{AB}(t)=\langle A_{\mathcal L}(t)BA_{\mathcal L}(t)B\rangle-\sum_\alpha\int_0^t ds\,\langle([A_{\mathcal L}(s),J_\alpha]B_{\mathcal L^\dagger}(t-s))^2\rangle$. The integral represents replica correlations, not bath memory. Analytical arguments show that it restores Hilbert–Schmidt norm conservation and multiplicative identities inherited from unitary evolution. For ergodic dynamics, it also yields the fourth-order late-time plateau predicted by free independence. Numerical illustrations use a boundary-dephased mixed-field Ising chain. An eight-spin open chain with boundary rate $\gamma=1$ approximates correlations and OTOCs of a fourteen-spin closed chain. For the traceful observables tested, the corrected OTOC approaches $3/16$, versus $1/8$ under independent Lindblad evolution. The derivation assumes a maximally scrambling Markovian bath and infinite temperature. The closed-system approximation is demonstrated numerically with a tuned boundary rate, rather than controlled error bounds. Conserved components require separate treatment of late-time predictions; explicit higher-order and non-Markovian extensions remain future directions.
Error found: The claimed general formalism is derived only for infinite-temperature correlators with Hermitian jump operators and an infinite Haar-randomized bath, rather than arbitrary Lindblad dynamics or microscopic environments. The dissipative-boundary application demonstrates agreement between accessible system sizes but does not establish predictive accuracy beyond accessible sizes or transferability of the fitted boundary rate.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- Main and Supplemental Material, 18 pages, 4 figures