arXiv:2609.35112
From Quantum to Classical Dissipative Spin Dynamics
Alireza Ataei, Leila Ataei, Olle Eriksson, Vahid Azimi Mousolou
Abstract
The Landau-Lifshitz-Gilbert (LLG) equation provides the fundamental description of dissipative magnetization dynamics. A recently proposed quantum analog, the quantum Landau-Lifshitz-Gilbert (QLLG) equation, extends this framework to quantum spin systems. However, whether the QLLG equation recovers the LLG equation in the classical large-spin limit for interacting spin systems remains an open question. Here, we demonstrate this connection by deriving the LLG equation as the classical large-spin limit of the QLLG equation. We establish this correspondence analytically and verify it numerically for an interacting spin system. These results provide a quantum-to-classical description of dissipative spin dynamics, offering a microscopic foundation for the LLG equation. From numerical calculations provided here, we also conclude that quantum effects become much less noticeable for systems with larger number of spins in the Hamiltonian.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether the nonlinear quantum Landau–Lifshitz–Gilbert (QLLG) equation recovers classical Gilbert-damped dynamics for interacting spins, where evolution can generate correlations even from initially uncorrelated states. It considers bilinear spin Hamiltonians, including exchange, Dzyaloshinskii–Moriya and anisotropic interactions, with initial states that are products of spin-coherent states. The classical limit is $S\to\infty$, $\hbar\to0$, with $\hbar S$ fixed. The analysis first evaluates the magnetization equation on the product coherent-state manifold, obtaining classical LLG dynamics with Gilbert damping $\alpha=\kappa$, the QLLG damping parameter. It then bounds the maximum local total spin variance, $V(t)=\max_i\sum_\alpha\operatorname{Var}(S_i^\alpha)$, by $V(t)\le\hbar^2S e^{C't}$, with $C'$ independent of $S$. This gives $|\langle\mathbf S_i\rangle|/(\hbar S)=1+O(S^{-1})$ at fixed finite times, which is used to establish asymptotic confinement to the coherent-state manifold and correspondence with LLG. Numerical comparisons use an interacting two-spin model with $\kappa=0.3$, scanning $t,B\in[0,2]$, and restricted-Boltzmann-machine variational simulations of Heisenberg chains with $N=20,40$. Magnetization-length and angular errors decrease with $S$, with angular errors decreasing more slowly; two-spin correlations and entanglement are also reported to decrease. Smaller errors in the longer chains motivate a suggested system-size suppression of quantum effects. The stated correspondence applies to coherent-product initial conditions and finite-time large-$S$ dynamics, with the variance estimate identifying times $t\ll\log S/C'$. The numerical system-size comparison covers the particular models and parameters studied, rather than establishing a general size-dependent bound.
Central claim may not hold: The analytical proof controls normalized spin length but does not establish product-coherent-state confinement or the leading covariance required to derive Gilbert damping. The combined covariance formula has a sign opposite to the preceding calculations and would produce antidamping rather than the final LL equation. Differentiating the stated Hamiltonian gives an interaction effective-field coefficient hbar/S, not the displayed 1/S² unless hbar S=1. The numerical angle error omits normalization of the quantum magnetization and therefore conflates directional disagreement with spin-length loss. The claimed suppression of quantum effects with system size rests on comparing two-spin maxima over time and field against chain site averages at a single time and field.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.