Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.35008

Enantiomer-specific pumping of chiral molecules in high-$J$ rotational states

Fen Zou, Yan Gao, Peng Zhang

quant-phSubmitted Sep 28, 2026• Announced Sep 29, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Enantiomer-specific state transfer (ESST) based on electric-dipole transitions has attracted considerable interest in the studies of manipulating molecules with electromagnetic fields. It also holds promise as a powerful tool for enantiomer detection and separation. To date, experimental demonstrations of ESST have focused mainly on molecules in the lowest rotational angular-momentum states, namely, $J=0$ and $J=1$. Realistic molecular samples, however, may contain appreciable populations in higher-$J$ rotational states, making it desirable to develop ESST schemes applicable to such states. Nevertheless, one cannot derive such schemes via a simple and straightforward extension of existing low-$J$ schemes, because higher-$J$ manifolds contain more magnetic sub-levels and involve more complicated networks of electric-dipole transitions. Here, we propose an ESST scheme for chiral molecules involving the $J=1$ and $J=2$ rotational states. Specifically, our scheme is based on enantiomer-specific pumping driven by three linearly polarized microwave fields and one laser beam. Under this scheme, one enantiomer is pumped into an enantiomer-specific dark state within a sub manifold with $J=1,2$, whereas the other enantiomer is dissipatively pumped out of this manifold. Our strategy can be extended to systems involving rotational states with even higher angular momenta.

AI Summary

Enantiomer-specific state transfer has mainly been demonstrated using $J=0,1$ rotational states. This paper asks how to implement it in higher-angular-momentum manifolds, where degenerate magnetic sublevels create more complicated transition networks. It proposes dissipative enantiomer-specific pumping involving two $J=1$ rotational levels and one $J=2$ level, comprising eleven magnetic states. Three mutually orthogonal, linearly polarized microwave fields isolate an invariant three-state cyclic subsystem through superpositions of magnetic sublevels. An analytical Hamiltonian reduction identifies a detuning at which one enantiomer has a dark eigenstate with no population in the upper rotational level, while the other lacks that dark state. Adding a laser coupling the upper level to an electronically excited manifold enables repeated excitation and spontaneous decay: some population of the selected enantiomer remains trapped, while the other is pumped into external rovibrational states. Reversing the detuning exchanges the selected handedness. Master-equation simulations illustrate the pumping and its sensitivity to collisional relaxation. For microwave and laser Rabi frequencies and spontaneous-decay rates of $6$–$20\,\mathrm{MHz}$ after division by $2\pi$, the retained-state enantiomeric purity is approximately at least $0.99$ for $\kappa/2\pi\lesssim1\,\mathrm{kHz}$ and $0.9$ for $\kappa/2\pi\lesssim10\,\mathrm{kHz}$. Proposed applications include enantiomer detection and state-selective ionization or dissociation for separation. The simulations assume equal spontaneous-decay branching ratios, identical laser Rabi frequencies across magnetic sublevels, and a simplified collisional relaxation model. High purity requires sufficiently weak collisions. Extension beyond $J=2$ is suggested rather than explicitly demonstrated.

Little sign of AI-generated textIncrementalStrong assumptionsPossible error

Error found: The claimed extension to higher angular momenta is not established by an explicit construction or a general argument beyond the demonstrated J=1,2 case. The collision-free master equation has multiple stationary states, so the retained dark-state population depends on the initial state, contrary to Section III.B's assertion of initial-state independence.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
9 pages, 5 figures

Related papers

Enantiomer-Specific Pumping of Chiral Molecules

Fen Zou, Yong Li, Peng Zhang

Enantiomer-specific state transfer (ESST), which involves transferring enantiomers with different handedness of a chiral molecule into different-energy internal states, is a challenging yet significant task. Previous ESST methods are based on dynamic processes and thus require the preparation of initial states and precise control of microwave operation times. We propose a novel ESST approach, called enantiomer-specific pumping (ESP), which is based on a dissipative process and thereby eliminates the need for these two technical requirements. This approach utilizes a special microwave-induced dark state that appears exclusively for the enantiomer with a specific handedness. Specifically, in ESP, the enantiomer lacking the dark state can be pumped out of the subspace of relevant internal states, while the enantiomer with the dark state maintains a finite probability within this subspace, offering high efficiency in ESST. Notably, ESP facilitates enantiodetection without the need for enantiopure samples as reference.

arXiv:2406.15978•The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters•Oct 14, 2024•3 citations

Two-Path Interference for Enantiomer-Selective State Transfer of Chiral Molecules

Jin-Lei Wu, Yan Wang, Jin-Xuan Han +5 more

Using a microwave-regime cyclic three-state configuration, enantiomer-selective state transfer (ESST) is carried out through two-path interference between a direct one-photon coupling and an effective two-photon coupling. A phase difference of $\ensuremath{\pi}$ in the one-photon process between the two enantiomers makes the interference constructive for one enantiomer but destructive for the other. Therefore only one enantiomer is excited into a higher rotational state, while the other remains in the ground state. The scheme allows flexibility in the pulse waveforms and the time order of the two paths. We simulate the scheme for a sample of cyclohexylmethanol (${\mathrm{C}}_{7}{\mathrm{H}}_{14}\mathrm{O}$) molecules. The simulation results show that robust high-fidelity ESST can be obtained when experimental concerns are considered. Finally, we propose to employ the ESST scheme to implement enantioseparation and determine enantiomeric excesses.

arXiv:2003.10334•Physical Review Applied•Apr 8, 2020•61 citations

Pump-control approach to enantiospecific state transfer

Бо Лю, Yong Li, Chong Ye +1 more

Enantiospecific state transfer of chiral molecules is extremely important because enantiomers coexist in many biologically active compounds and play significantly different physiological, pharmacological, and biological roles. The inherently strong electric-dipole optical approaches based on the cyclic three-level model of chiral molecules have been extensively discussed. But, for the cases of large chiral molecules and/or chiral molecules of low asymmetry, the four-level model with two sub-loops is more realistic to describe the molecules. Based on the four-level model, we propose a pump-control approach to realize the highly efficient enantiospecific state transfer. In our approach, two pump pulses are applied to generate molecular coherence between the ground state and the first excited state of our working model. According to the coherence of the molecules, we adjust the phase and pulse area of the control pulse, then we obtain the highly efficient enantiospecific state transfer in the first excited working state. In addition, we further optimize the fraction of enantiopure samples by adjusting the area of the two pump pulses.

Optics Express•Jul 17, 2024•4 citations

Enantiomer-specific state transfer of chiral molecules in cyclic three-level systems with SU(2) structures

Jian-Jian Cheng, Yu-Yuan Chen, Yong Li +1 more

We propose a streamlined method of fast enantiomer-specific state transfer (ESST) of chiral molecules in cyclic three-level systems. Such three-level enantiomers are chirality-dependent systems driven by one of the three Rabi frequencies differing with a sign for the left- and right-handed chiral molecules. When the Hamiltonian of the three-level chiral molecules possesses the specific SU(2) algebraic structure, the populations transferred to the two excited states are shown to be exchanged between the left- and right-handed chiral molecules if they are initially prepared in their ground states. By employing unitary SU(2) transformation and inversely engineering time-dependent Hamiltonians with designed Rabi frequencies, we can make the left- and right-handed chiral molecules evolve respectively to different excited states from their initial ground states simultaneously. Thus a fast ESST is achieved.

Physical Review A•Jan 23, 2023•12 citations

Robust and high-efficiency dynamical method of enantio-specific state transfer

Jianjian Cheng, Lei Du, Yong Li +1 more

We propose a simple dynamical method to realize fast enantio-specific state transfer (ESST) of chiral molecules. Driven by three external electromagenetic fields, the chiral molecules are modeled as cyclic three-level systems, where the overall phase differs by π for the left- and right-handed chiral molecules. We unveil that the ESST is allowed when the amplitudes of three Rabi frequencies in the cyclic three-level systems are equal. Our method is robust and highly efficient in the sense that the external fields can have arbitrary waveforms. This thus provides the opportunity of simplifying the experimental implementations of ESST through pulse design.

Optics Express•Feb 5, 2024•7 citations

Cyclic three-level-pulse-area theorem for enantioselective state transfer of chiral molecules

Yu Guo, Xun Gong, Songshan Ma +1 more

We derive a pulse-area theorem for a single-loop cyclic three-level system without applying the rotating-wave approximation while explicitly taking into account the time delays of control fields. This corresponds to an archetypal model for exploring enantioselective state transfer (ESST) in chiral molecules driven by three linearly polarized microwave pulses. By dividing the closed-loop excitation into two separate stages, we obtain both amplitude and phase conditions of three control fields to generate high fidelity of ESST. As a proof of principle, we apply this pulse-area theorem to cyclohexylmethanol molecules, for which three rotational states are connected by $a$-type, $b$-type, and $c$-type components of the transition dipole moments in both center-frequency-resonant and -detuned conditions. Our results show that two enantiomers with opposite handedness can be transferred to different target states by designing three microwave pulses that satisfy the amplitude and phase conditions at the transition frequencies. The corresponding control schemes are robust against the time delays between the two stages. We suggest that the two control fields used in the second stage should be applied simultaneously for practical applications. This work contributes an alternative pulse-area theorem to the field of quantum control, which has the potential to determine the chirality of enantiomers in a mixture.

arXiv:2110.09031•Physical Review A•Jan 3, 2022•33 citations
Enantiomer-specific pumping of chiral molecules in high-JJJ rotational states
Enantiomer-specific state transfer (ESST) based on electric-dipole transitions has attracted considerable interest in the studies of manipulating molecules with electromagnetic fields. It also holds promise as a powerful tool for enantiomer detection and separation. To date, experimental demonstrations of ESST have focused mainly on molecules in the lowest rotational angular-momentum states, namely, J=0J=0J=0 and J=1J=1J=1. Realistic molecular samples, however, may contain appreciable populations in higher-JJJ rotational states, making it desirable to develop ESST schemes applicable to such states. Nevertheless, one cannot derive such schemes via a simple and straightforward extension of existing low-JJJ schemes, because higher-JJJ manifolds contain more magnetic sub-levels and involve more complicated networks of electric-dipole transitions. Here, we propose an ESST scheme for chiral molecules involving the J=1J=1J=1 and J=2J=2J=2 rotational states. Specifically, our scheme is based on enantiomer-specific pumping driven by three linearly polarized microwave fields and one laser beam. Under this scheme, one enantiomer is pumped into an enantiomer-specific dark state within a sub manifold with J=1,2J=1,2J=1,2, whereas the other enantiomer is dissipatively pumped out of this manifold. Our strategy can be extended to systems involving rotational states with even higher angular momenta.
Enantiomer-specific state transfer has mainly been demonstrated using J=0,1J=0,1J=0,1 rotational states. This paper asks how to implement it in higher-angular-momentum manifolds, where degenerate magnetic sublevels create more complicated transition networks. It proposes dissipative enantiomer-specific pumping involving two J=1J=1J=1 rotational levels and one J=2J=2J=2 level, comprising eleven magnetic states.
Three mutually orthogonal, linearly polarized microwave fields isolate an invariant three-state cyclic subsystem through superpositions of magnetic sublevels. An analytical Hamiltonian reduction identifies a detuning at which one enantiomer has a dark eigenstate with no population in the upper rotational level, while the other lacks that dark state. Adding a laser coupling the upper level to an electronically excited manifold enables repeated excitation and spontaneous decay: some population of the selected enantiomer remains trapped, while the other is pumped into external rovibrational states. Reversing the detuning exchanges the selected handedness.
Master-equation simulations illustrate the pumping and its sensitivity to collisional relaxation. For microwave and laser Rabi frequencies and spontaneous-decay rates of 666–20 MHz20\,\mathrm{MHz}20MHz after division by 2π2\pi2π, the retained-state enantiomeric purity is approximately at least 0.990.990.99 for κ/2π≲1 kHz\kappa/2\pi\lesssim1\,\mathrm{kHz}κ/2π≲1kHz and 0.90.90.9 for κ/2π≲10 kHz\kappa/2\pi\lesssim10\,\mathrm{kHz}κ/2π≲10kHz. Proposed applications include enantiomer detection and state-selective ionization or dissociation for separation.
The simulations assume equal spontaneous-decay branching ratios, identical laser Rabi frequencies across magnetic sublevels, and a simplified collisional relaxation model. High purity requires sufficiently weak collisions. Extension beyond J=2J=2J=2 is suggested rather than explicitly demonstrated.
Enantiomer-specific state transfer (ESST), which involves transferring enantiomers with different handedness of a chiral molecule into different-energy internal states, is a challenging yet significant task. Previous ESST methods are based on dynamic processes and thus require the preparation of initial states and precise control of microwave operation times. We propose a novel ESST approach, called enantiomer-specific pumping (ESP), which is based on a dissipative process and thereby eliminates the need for these two technical requirements. This approach utilizes a special microwave-induced dark state that appears exclusively for the enantiomer with a specific handedness. Specifically, in ESP, the enantiomer lacking the dark state can be pumped out of the subspace of relevant internal states, while the enantiomer with the dark state maintains a finite probability within this subspace, offering high efficiency in ESST. Notably, ESP facilitates enantiodetection without the need for enantiopure samples as reference.
Using a microwave-regime cyclic three-state configuration, enantiomer-selective state transfer (ESST) is carried out through two-path interference between a direct one-photon coupling and an effective two-photon coupling. A phase difference of $\ensuremath{\pi}$ in the one-photon process between the two enantiomers makes the interference constructive for one enantiomer but destructive for the other. Therefore only one enantiomer is excited into a higher rotational state, while the other remains in the ground state. The scheme allows flexibility in the pulse waveforms and the time order of the two paths. We simulate the scheme for a sample of cyclohexylmethanol (C7H14O{\mathrm{C}}_{7}{\mathrm{H}}_{14}\mathrm{O}C7​H14​O) molecules. The simulation results show that robust high-fidelity ESST can be obtained when experimental concerns are considered. Finally, we propose to employ the ESST scheme to implement enantioseparation and determine enantiomeric excesses.
Enantiospecific state transfer of chiral molecules is extremely important because enantiomers coexist in many biologically active compounds and play significantly different physiological, pharmacological, and biological roles. The inherently strong electric-dipole optical approaches based on the cyclic three-level model of chiral molecules have been extensively discussed. But, for the cases of large chiral molecules and/or chiral molecules of low asymmetry, the four-level model with two sub-loops is more realistic to describe the molecules. Based on the four-level model, we propose a pump-control approach to realize the highly efficient enantiospecific state transfer. In our approach, two pump pulses are applied to generate molecular coherence between the ground state and the first excited state of our working model. According to the coherence of the molecules, we adjust the phase and pulse area of the control pulse, then we obtain the highly efficient enantiospecific state transfer in the first excited working state. In addition, we further optimize the fraction of enantiopure samples by adjusting the area of the two pump pulses.
We propose a streamlined method of fast enantiomer-specific state transfer (ESST) of chiral molecules in cyclic three-level systems. Such three-level enantiomers are chirality-dependent systems driven by one of the three Rabi frequencies differing with a sign for the left- and right-handed chiral molecules. When the Hamiltonian of the three-level chiral molecules possesses the specific SU(2) algebraic structure, the populations transferred to the two excited states are shown to be exchanged between the left- and right-handed chiral molecules if they are initially prepared in their ground states. By employing unitary SU(2) transformation and inversely engineering time-dependent Hamiltonians with designed Rabi frequencies, we can make the left- and right-handed chiral molecules evolve respectively to different excited states from their initial ground states simultaneously. Thus a fast ESST is achieved.
We propose a simple dynamical method to realize fast enantio-specific state transfer (ESST) of chiral molecules. Driven by three external electromagenetic fields, the chiral molecules are modeled as cyclic three-level systems, where the overall phase differs by π for the left- and right-handed chiral molecules. We unveil that the ESST is allowed when the amplitudes of three Rabi frequencies in the cyclic three-level systems are equal. Our method is robust and highly efficient in the sense that the external fields can have arbitrary waveforms. This thus provides the opportunity of simplifying the experimental implementations of ESST through pulse design.
We derive a pulse-area theorem for a single-loop cyclic three-level system without applying the rotating-wave approximation while explicitly taking into account the time delays of control fields. This corresponds to an archetypal model for exploring enantioselective state transfer (ESST) in chiral molecules driven by three linearly polarized microwave pulses. By dividing the closed-loop excitation into two separate stages, we obtain both amplitude and phase conditions of three control fields to generate high fidelity of ESST. As a proof of principle, we apply this pulse-area theorem to cyclohexylmethanol molecules, for which three rotational states are connected by aaa-type, bbb-type, and ccc-type components of the transition dipole moments in both center-frequency-resonant and -detuned conditions. Our results show that two enantiomers with opposite handedness can be transferred to different target states by designing three microwave pulses that satisfy the amplitude and phase conditions at the transition frequencies. The corresponding control schemes are robust against the time delays between the two stages. We suggest that the two control fields used in the second stage should be applied simultaneously for practical applications. This work contributes an alternative pulse-area theorem to the field of quantum control, which has the potential to determine the chirality of enantiomers in a mixture.