Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.34803

General Photon Subtraction from a Gaussian Perspective

Niklas Budinger, Ulrik L. Andersen, Peter van Loock

quant-phSubmitted Sep 28, 2026• Announced Sep 29, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A near-deterministic source of non-Gaussianity is the missing piece to reach universal and fault-tolerant quantum computing with continuous-variable optics. Due to a lack of strong non-linearities, the probabilistic photon-subtracted Gaussian states remain the most promising contender. In combination with Gaussian measurements and single-mode feed-forward operations, they have been shown to provide sufficient non-Gaussianity at high rates. However, these existing breeding protocols lack the necessary loss tolerance to be experimentally feasible. In this work, we introduce a mathematical formalism based on the application of a Gaussian blur and filter on the measured Fock Wigner function to describe general photon-subtracted Gaussian states. Within our representation, the initial squeezing, Gaussian measurements, and photon loss can all be understood as contributions to the total blurring and interchanged accordingly. We find that this intuitive approach can be used to find improvements to cat, cubic phase, and GKP state generation by compromising between success rates, feed-forward compatibility, and loss tolerance. In the case of multiple photon subtractions, this is achieved by introducing a hybrid setup variant bridging the gap between protocols based on breeding and post-selection. Finally, we establish a general lower bound on the resources needed to generate a given target state near-deterministically by introducing the expected Wigner logarithmic negativity as an additive monotone of non-Gaussianity.

AI Summary

The paper studies how photon-number-conditioned Gaussian optical circuits can generate non-Gaussian resource states while balancing success probability, Gaussian feed-forward compatibility, and photon loss. It rewrites the conditional Wigner function exactly as a Gaussian convolution of the detected Fock-state Wigner functions, followed by an affine coordinate transformation and Gaussian filtering. The convolution covariance is a Schur complement of the initial Gaussian covariance matrix, allowing finite squeezing and loss to be analysed within the same representation. Performance is measured using expected Wigner logarithmic negativity, $\mathrm{xWLN}=\sum_{\vec n}P_{\vec n}\mathrm{WLN}(\rho_{\vec n})$. Additivity and Gaussian monotonicity give the resource-accounting bound $N\geq\mathrm{WLN}(\rho_{\rm target})/\mathrm{xWLN}$ for deterministic conversion from identical independent sources. Numerical single-detector scans identify Fock-like outputs as maximising this quantity, although their outcome-dependent negativity rings prevent useful Gaussian alignment. At 15 dB squeezing and 5% loss, modified cat-like and cubic-phase-like configurations increase xWLN by 21% and 226%, respectively, relative to the standard configurations considered. For multiple detectors, a tunable hybrid construction interpolates between compact post-selection circuits and breeding protocols. In a two-detector GKP-like example, selected-pattern xWLN increases from 0.041 for the compact setup to 0.052 for a hybrid setup, versus 0.034 at full added squeezing. The analysis combines Gaussian covariance identities with numerical Wigner integration. Limitations include heuristic feed-forward-compatibility measures rather than target-state fidelity guarantees, imperfect hybrid feed-forward, residual post-selection, and computationally prohibitive multimode optimisation. Extension of the single-detector maximum to a universal per-detector resource bound remains conjectural.

No sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsStrong assumptions

Error found: The universal optimal resource bound per detector or squeezing budget is not established, because the single-detector maximum is assessed numerically and the multi-detector extension remains conjectural. The stated minimum-copy ratio needs a success-probability qualification: exact preparation with probability p requires N·xWLN ≥ p·WLN(target), not necessarily N·xWLN ≥ WLN(target). The added vacuum projection has success probability sech²(ξ₀/2), rather than the stated sech(ξ₀/2), although its effect on the reported numerical results cannot be determined from the text.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
20 pages, 21 figures

Related papers

Boosting the generation rate of squeezed single-photon states by generalized photon subtraction

Hiroko Tomoda, Akihiro Machinaga, Kan Takase +9 more

In optical quantum information processing with continuous variables, optical non-Gaussian quantum states are essential for universal and fault-tolerant quantum computation. Experimentally, their most typical generation method is photon subtraction (PS), where single-photon detection by an on/off detector probabilistically heralds the generation of squeezed single-photon states. In PS, however, trying to avoid unwanted multiphoton detection inevitably limits the generation rate, hindering the application of squeezed single-photon states. Here, we theoretically show that generalized photon subtraction (GPS), a simple extension of PS, can improve the generation rate while maintaining the quality of the generated states. Furthermore, we experimentally demonstrate the generation rate improvement for 2-dB- and 4-dB-squeezed single-photon states compared to PS, by more than one order of magnitude, particularly for the case of 2 dB. Our results will accelerate the application of squeezed single-photon states to more advanced quantum information protocols.

arXiv:2404.19304•Physical Review A•Sep 23, 2024•16 citations

Mode-dependent-loss model for multimode photon-subtracted states

Mattia Walschaers, Young-Sik Ra, Nicolas Treps

Multimode photon subtraction provides an experimentally feasible option to construct large non-Gaussian quantum states in continuous variable quantum optics. The non-Gaussian features of the state can lead towards the more exotic aspects of quantum theory, such as negativity of the Wigner function. However, the payoff for states with such delicate quantum properties is their sensitivity to decoherence. In this paper, we present a general model that treats the most important source of decoherence in a purely optical setting: losses. We use the framework of open quantum systems and master equations to describe losses in $n$-photon-subtracted multimode states, where each photon can be subtracted in an arbitrary mode. As a main result, we find that mode-dependent losses and photon subtraction generally do not commute. In particular, the losses do not only reduce the purity of the state, they also change the modal structure of its non-Gaussian features. We then conduct a detailed study of single-photon subtraction from a multimode Gaussian state, which is a setting that lies within the reach of present-day experiments.

arXiv:1905.06755•Physical Review A•Aug 19, 2019•17 citations

Seeding Gaussian boson samplers with single photons for enhanced state generation

Valerio Crescimanna, Aaron Z. Goldberg, Khabat Heshami

Non-Gaussian quantum states are crucial to fault-tolerant quantum computation with continuous-variable systems. Usually, generation of such states involves trade-offs between success probability and quality of the resultant state. For example, injecting squeezed light into a multimode interferometer and postselecting on certain patterns of photon-number outputs in all but one mode, a fundamentally probabilistic task, can herald the creation of cat states, Gottesman-Kitaev-Preskill (GKP) states, and more. We consider the addition of a non-Gaussian resource state, particularly single photons, to this configuration and show how it improves the qualities and generation probabilities of desired states. With only two modes, adding a single-photon source improves GKP-state fidelity from 0.68 to 0.95 and adding a second then increases the success probability eightfold; for cat states with a fixed target fidelity, the probability of success can be improved by factors of up to four by adding single-photon sources. These demonstrate the usefulness of additional commonplace non-Gaussian resources for generating desirable states of light.

arXiv:2311.03432•Physical Review A•Feb 23, 2024•14 citations

Generation of optical Schrödinger cat states by generalized photon subtraction

Kan Takase, Jun–ichi Yoshikawa, Warit Asavanant +2 more

We propose a high-rate generation method of optical Schr\"odinger cat states. Thus far, photon subtraction from squeezed vacuum states has been a standard method in cat-state generation, but its constraints on experimental parameters limit the generation rate. In this paper, we consider the state generation by photon number measurement in one mode of two-mode Gaussian states, which is a generalization of conventional photon subtraction, and derive the conditions to generate high-fidelity and large-amplitude cat states. Our method relaxes the constraints on experimental parameters, allowing us to optimize them and attain a high generation rate. Supposing realistic experimental conditions, the generation rate of cat states with large amplitudes ($|\ensuremath{\alpha}|\ensuremath{\ge}2)$ can exceed megacounts per second, about ${10}^{3}$ to ${10}^{6}$ times better than typical rates of conventional photon subtraction. This rate would be improved further by the progress of related technologies. The ability to generate non-Gaussian states at a high rate is important in quantum computing using optical continuous variables, where scalability has been demonstrated but preparation of non-Gaussian states of light remains as a challenging task for universality and fault tolerance. Our proposal reduces the difficulty of the state preparation and opens a way for practical applications in quantum optics.

arXiv:2009.08580•Physical Review A•Jan 8, 2021•115 citations

Generation of non-Gaussian quantum photonic states with multimode input resources

Mohamed Faouzi Melalkia, Juliette Huynh, Sébastien Tanzilli +2 more

Non-Gaussian quantum states of light are important resources for implementing quantum information tasks, ranging from fault-tolerant optical quantum information processing to long distance quantum communication. These states can be generated by applying non-Gaussian operations, such as photon addition and subtraction, to an input Gaussian quantum state. Also, the use of Gaussian operations (like homodyne measurement) allows the transformation of non-Gaussian input quantum states while maintaining their non-Gaussianity. It has been shown that in such context, iterative tailoring of arbitrary quantum states is possible, by cascading elementary operation blocks. This invitably comes at the cost of increasing the protocol complexity. Spectral modes, on the other hand, can be used to handily carry multiple quantum states in a single spatial mode. Moreover, multimode states populating such modes are readily available in commonly exploited processes such as spontaneous parametric down conversion.In this work, we propose a protocol to generate non-Gaussian quantum states using spectral multiplexing of input states and Gaussian operations. We give the analytical expression of the output non-Gaussian state as a function of the number of input state, the Gaussian operation and the properties of spectral modes carrying the input quantum states. Taking as an example the cat breeding operation, we show that with a single mixing and measurement operation, we can obtain an amplified output cat state comparable to the one obtained using iterative breeding scheme with multiple mixing operations and measurements with the same number of input states. We show also that the generation of approximated GKP states is possible with this protocol. We believe that the proposed protocol will have a major impact on the field of non-Gaussian quantum states generation, and can be used to extend the study beyond the cases considered in our work.

•Nov 3, 2021•0 citations

All-optical Quantum State Engineering for Rotation-symmetric Bosonic States

Rajveer Nehra, Miller Eaton, Olivier Pfister +1 more

Continuous-variable quantum information processing through quantum optics offers a promising platform for building the next generation of scalable fault-tolerant information processors. To achieve quantum computational advantages and fault tolerance, non-Gaussian resources are essential. In this work, we propose and analyze a method to generate a variety of non-Gaussian states using coherent photon subtraction from a two-mode squeezed state followed by photon-number-resolving measurements. The proposed method offers a promising way to generate rotation-symmetric states conventionally used for quantum error correction with binomial codes and truncated Schrödinger cat codes. We consider the deleterious effects of experimental imperfections such as detection inefficiencies and losses in the state engineering protocol. Our method can be readily implemented with current quantum photonic technologies.

arXiv:2105.11035•May 23, 2021•4 citations
A near-deterministic source of non-Gaussianity is the missing piece to reach universal and fault-tolerant quantum computing with continuous-variable optics. Due to a lack of strong non-linearities, the probabilistic photon-subtracted Gaussian states remain the most promising contender. In combination with Gaussian measurements and single-mode feed-forward operations, they have been shown to provide sufficient non-Gaussianity at high rates. However, these existing breeding protocols lack the necessary loss tolerance to be experimentally feasible. In this work, we introduce a mathematical formalism based on the application of a Gaussian blur and filter on the measured Fock Wigner function to describe general photon-subtracted Gaussian states. Within our representation, the initial squeezing, Gaussian measurements, and photon loss can all be understood as contributions to the total blurring and interchanged accordingly. We find that this intuitive approach can be used to find improvements to cat, cubic phase, and GKP state generation by compromising between success rates, feed-forward compatibility, and loss tolerance. In the case of multiple photon subtractions, this is achieved by introducing a hybrid setup variant bridging the gap between protocols based on breeding and post-selection. Finally, we establish a general lower bound on the resources needed to generate a given target state near-deterministically by introducing the expected Wigner logarithmic negativity as an additive monotone of non-Gaussianity.
The paper studies how photon-number-conditioned Gaussian optical circuits can generate non-Gaussian resource states while balancing success probability, Gaussian feed-forward compatibility, and photon loss. It rewrites the conditional Wigner function exactly as a Gaussian convolution of the detected Fock-state Wigner functions, followed by an affine coordinate transformation and Gaussian filtering. The convolution covariance is a Schur complement of the initial Gaussian covariance matrix, allowing finite squeezing and loss to be analysed within the same representation.
Performance is measured using expected Wigner logarithmic negativity, xWLN=∑n⃗Pn⃗WLN(ρn⃗)\mathrm{xWLN}=\sum_{\vec n}P_{\vec n}\mathrm{WLN}(\rho_{\vec n})xWLN=∑n​Pn​WLN(ρn​). Additivity and Gaussian monotonicity give the resource-accounting bound N≥WLN(ρtarget)/xWLNN\geq\mathrm{WLN}(\rho_{\rm target})/\mathrm{xWLN}N≥WLN(ρtarget​)/xWLN for deterministic conversion from identical independent sources. Numerical single-detector scans identify Fock-like outputs as maximising this quantity, although their outcome-dependent negativity rings prevent useful Gaussian alignment. At 15 dB squeezing and 5% loss, modified cat-like and cubic-phase-like configurations increase xWLN by 21% and 226%, respectively, relative to the standard configurations considered.
For multiple detectors, a tunable hybrid construction interpolates between compact post-selection circuits and breeding protocols. In a two-detector GKP-like example, selected-pattern xWLN increases from 0.041 for the compact setup to 0.052 for a hybrid setup, versus 0.034 at full added squeezing.
The analysis combines Gaussian covariance identities with numerical Wigner integration. Limitations include heuristic feed-forward-compatibility measures rather than target-state fidelity guarantees, imperfect hybrid feed-forward, residual post-selection, and computationally prohibitive multimode optimisation. Extension of the single-detector maximum to a universal per-detector resource bound remains conjectural.
In optical quantum information processing with continuous variables, optical non-Gaussian quantum states are essential for universal and fault-tolerant quantum computation. Experimentally, their most typical generation method is photon subtraction (PS), where single-photon detection by an on/off detector probabilistically heralds the generation of squeezed single-photon states. In PS, however, trying to avoid unwanted multiphoton detection inevitably limits the generation rate, hindering the application of squeezed single-photon states. Here, we theoretically show that generalized photon subtraction (GPS), a simple extension of PS, can improve the generation rate while maintaining the quality of the generated states. Furthermore, we experimentally demonstrate the generation rate improvement for 2-dB- and 4-dB-squeezed single-photon states compared to PS, by more than one order of magnitude, particularly for the case of 2 dB. Our results will accelerate the application of squeezed single-photon states to more advanced quantum information protocols.
Multimode photon subtraction provides an experimentally feasible option to construct large non-Gaussian quantum states in continuous variable quantum optics. The non-Gaussian features of the state can lead towards the more exotic aspects of quantum theory, such as negativity of the Wigner function. However, the payoff for states with such delicate quantum properties is their sensitivity to decoherence. In this paper, we present a general model that treats the most important source of decoherence in a purely optical setting: losses. We use the framework of open quantum systems and master equations to describe losses in nnn-photon-subtracted multimode states, where each photon can be subtracted in an arbitrary mode. As a main result, we find that mode-dependent losses and photon subtraction generally do not commute. In particular, the losses do not only reduce the purity of the state, they also change the modal structure of its non-Gaussian features. We then conduct a detailed study of single-photon subtraction from a multimode Gaussian state, which is a setting that lies within the reach of present-day experiments.
Non-Gaussian quantum states are crucial to fault-tolerant quantum computation with continuous-variable systems. Usually, generation of such states involves trade-offs between success probability and quality of the resultant state. For example, injecting squeezed light into a multimode interferometer and postselecting on certain patterns of photon-number outputs in all but one mode, a fundamentally probabilistic task, can herald the creation of cat states, Gottesman-Kitaev-Preskill (GKP) states, and more. We consider the addition of a non-Gaussian resource state, particularly single photons, to this configuration and show how it improves the qualities and generation probabilities of desired states. With only two modes, adding a single-photon source improves GKP-state fidelity from 0.68 to 0.95 and adding a second then increases the success probability eightfold; for cat states with a fixed target fidelity, the probability of success can be improved by factors of up to four by adding single-photon sources. These demonstrate the usefulness of additional commonplace non-Gaussian resources for generating desirable states of light.
We propose a high-rate generation method of optical Schr\"odinger cat states. Thus far, photon subtraction from squeezed vacuum states has been a standard method in cat-state generation, but its constraints on experimental parameters limit the generation rate. In this paper, we consider the state generation by photon number measurement in one mode of two-mode Gaussian states, which is a generalization of conventional photon subtraction, and derive the conditions to generate high-fidelity and large-amplitude cat states. Our method relaxes the constraints on experimental parameters, allowing us to optimize them and attain a high generation rate. Supposing realistic experimental conditions, the generation rate of cat states with large amplitudes ($|\ensuremath{\alpha}|\ensuremath{\ge}2)$ can exceed megacounts per second, about 103{10}^{3}103 to 106{10}^{6}106 times better than typical rates of conventional photon subtraction. This rate would be improved further by the progress of related technologies. The ability to generate non-Gaussian states at a high rate is important in quantum computing using optical continuous variables, where scalability has been demonstrated but preparation of non-Gaussian states of light remains as a challenging task for universality and fault tolerance. Our proposal reduces the difficulty of the state preparation and opens a way for practical applications in quantum optics.
Non-Gaussian quantum states of light are important resources for implementing quantum information tasks, ranging from fault-tolerant optical quantum information processing to long distance quantum communication. These states can be generated by applying non-Gaussian operations, such as photon addition and subtraction, to an input Gaussian quantum state. Also, the use of Gaussian operations (like homodyne measurement) allows the transformation of non-Gaussian input quantum states while maintaining their non-Gaussianity. It has been shown that in such context, iterative tailoring of arbitrary quantum states is possible, by cascading elementary operation blocks. This invitably comes at the cost of increasing the protocol complexity. Spectral modes, on the other hand, can be used to handily carry multiple quantum states in a single spatial mode. Moreover, multimode states populating such modes are readily available in commonly exploited processes such as spontaneous parametric down conversion.In this work, we propose a protocol to generate non-Gaussian quantum states using spectral multiplexing of input states and Gaussian operations. We give the analytical expression of the output non-Gaussian state as a function of the number of input state, the Gaussian operation and the properties of spectral modes carrying the input quantum states. Taking as an example the cat breeding operation, we show that with a single mixing and measurement operation, we can obtain an amplified output cat state comparable to the one obtained using iterative breeding scheme with multiple mixing operations and measurements with the same number of input states. We show also that the generation of approximated GKP states is possible with this protocol. We believe that the proposed protocol will have a major impact on the field of non-Gaussian quantum states generation, and can be used to extend the study beyond the cases considered in our work.
Continuous-variable quantum information processing through quantum optics offers a promising platform for building the next generation of scalable fault-tolerant information processors. To achieve quantum computational advantages and fault tolerance, non-Gaussian resources are essential. In this work, we propose and analyze a method to generate a variety of non-Gaussian states using coherent photon subtraction from a two-mode squeezed state followed by photon-number-resolving measurements. The proposed method offers a promising way to generate rotation-symmetric states conventionally used for quantum error correction with binomial codes and truncated Schrödinger cat codes. We consider the deleterious effects of experimental imperfections such as detection inefficiencies and losses in the state engineering protocol. Our method can be readily implemented with current quantum photonic technologies.