arXiv:2609.34623
Trotterisation Thresholds and Dissipative Quantum Chaos in Open-System Digital Quantum Simulation
Angsar Manatuly, Lukas M. Sieberer, Cahit Kargi, Nathan K. Langford
Abstract
Digital quantum simulation (DQS) is one of the most promising applications of quantum computing. Trotterised DQS models quantum dynamics by decomposing the evolution into a sequence of gate-based Trotter steps. Using larger Trotter steps reduces the required gate count, but it is now understood that the Trotterisation step size cannot be increased beyond a certain threshold value, beyond which there is a sudden breakdown in simulation accuracy, due to the onset of quantum chaos. To date, this behaviour has only been studied for closed systems not subjected to the environmental noise and decoherence to which real-world quantum computers are highly sensitive. In this work, we study a range of experimentally relevant open-system quantum simulator models and show that Trotterisation thresholds persist even when open-system effects are included, even in the long-time, steady-state limit, once all coherence has been lost. We show that open DQS can accurately reproduce the dynamics of open target systems prior to the threshold, but still exhibits a sudden performance breakdown beyond it. We introduce new, statistical techniques to rigorously characterise the onset of quantum chaos beyond the Trotterisation threshold for both approximately unitary and genuine dissipative quantum chaos, based on random matrix theory (RMT), building on techniques developed for closed systems. Finally, we demonstrate that dissipative quantum chaos emerges when the dissipation is in balance with the presence of underlying unitary quantum chaos; the dissipation must be strong enough to induce genuinely dissipative behaviour, yet not so strong as to suppress the underlying chaotic structure.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether the chaos-associated Trotter-step threshold observed in closed-system digital quantum simulation survives Markovian dissipation, and how it relates to dissipative quantum chaos. It numerically studies Lindblad extensions of a kicked top ($j=10$), a nearest-neighbour Heisenberg chain ($N=5$), and a qubit–cavity Rabi model, varying the Trotter step $\tau$ and a common dissipation-rate multiplier $f_\gamma$. Across these models, local observables and simulation fidelities retain a sharp crossover from accurate to inaccurate digitised evolution, including in steady states. Over a broad dissipation range, its location approximately matches the closed-system threshold. Strong dissipation generally washes out the crossover; the Heisenberg implementation has different strong-dissipation behaviour because basis-rotation gates reorient its dissipative channels. Below threshold, fidelity to the corresponding open-system target can remain high even when fidelity to the closed-system target decays. Chaos is diagnosed through eigenvector-component statistics: the dominant canonical Kraus operator is compared with circular-ensemble predictions, and selected left and right eigenvectors of the full Floquet superoperator with Ginibre predictions, using chi-squared tests with 99% confidence regions. Ginibre agreement appears beyond approximately the same step-size threshold, within an intermediate window of total dissipation per step, proportional to $f_\gamma\tau$. The stated limitations include computationally restricted sizes, particularly a cavity dimension of four for RMT analysis versus twenty for dynamics. Not all superoperator eigenvectors show Ginibre statistics, and spectral filtering becomes difficult at extreme dissipation. The proposed generic behaviour is supported by these examples rather than a general theorem.
Error found: The claim that the steady-state threshold persists after all coherence has been lost is unsupported by the reported diagnostics, and the specified continuous kicked-top target necessarily retains coherence in the J_z basis at finite nonzero decay. The printed Rabi parity operator has an incorrect coefficient of σ_z and therefore lacks the commutation properties used in the text, although the corrected operator supplies the intended symmetry.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 20 pages, 8 figures