arXiv:2609.33574
Interactions Protect Periodically Driven Time Crystals Against Dephasing but Destabilise Multipolar-Driven Order
Karthikeya Machiraju, Kaustav Bhowmick
Abstract
We show that stronger interactions protect periodically driven time-crystal order against dephasing but destabilise order under random multipolar drives, and that coordination matters beyond the total interaction strength. We studied a disordered kicked Ising model of $N=12$ and $16$ spins with imperfect $π$ pulses and per-site dephasing by exact diagonalisation, comparing a periodic drive, random multipolar drives of order $n=0,1,2$ and the Thue-Morse sequence, and separated coupling strength from coordination by comparing a grid with a ring at equal total interaction strength $zJ$. For the periodic drive the coherence time scales approximately as $1/γ$, and stronger coupling reduces the transverse tilt on which dephasing acts. For multipolar drives of order $n\ge1$, doubling the coupling on a ring shortens the coherence time to $0.54$ ($n=1$), $0.37$ ($n=2$) and $0.44$ (Thue-Morse) at $N=16$, while random signs ($n=0$) are unaffected. A disorder scan supports a toggling-frame picture in which interactions spoil the block cancellation of the pulse error. At equal $zJ$ the grid outlives the ring by $2.15$ ($N=12$) and $2.78$ ($N=16$) for the periodic drive despite an identical transverse tilt, a coordination effect beyond this picture. All ratios hold under three definitions of the coherence time.
AI Summary
The paper asks how interaction strength and coordination affect subharmonic order under periodic versus structured aperiodic driving in an open spin system. It simulates a disordered kicked Ising model with imperfect $\pi$ pulses and local dephasing, primarily on $N=12,16$ rings and periodic grids, using state-vector evolution with quantum-jump trajectories. Comparing a grid at coupling $J$ with a ring at $2J$ holds the total interaction strength $zJ$ fixed. For periodic driving, coherence times scale approximately as $1/\gamma$, where $\gamma$ is the dephasing probability per step. Stronger interactions reduce the transverse spin component on which dephasing acts. Conversely, doubling the ring coupling reduces coherence times at $N=16$ to $0.54$, $0.37$, and $0.44$ of their original values for random multipolar orders $n=1,2$ and Thue–Morse driving, respectively; independent random signs show no resolved change. At equal $zJ$, periodic-drive coherence lasts $2.15$ times longer on the grid at $N=12$ and $2.78$ times longer at $N=16$, despite nearly identical transverse components. These conclusions survive three threshold-based lifetime definitions, with paired-bootstrap uncertainties. A heuristic toggling-frame calculation connects periodic protection to bounded transverse tilt and multipolar destabilisation to interaction-induced failure of pulse-error cancellation. A disorder scan supports its predicted distinction between $n=1$ and $n=2$. The calculation is uncontrolled at the studied parameters and fails for absolute $n=2$ lifetimes; it does not explain the coordination gain or Thue–Morse response. Other stated limits include small lattices, a fixed polarised initial state, restricted parameter and noise choices, and no thermodynamic extrapolation.
Error found: The abstract says that all ratios hold under three coherence-time definitions, although only their directions consistently survive: the N=16 n=2 ring-doubling ratio changes from 0.23 to 0.37 to 0.29. The multipolar mechanism section states T_c proportional to phi^(-2n) without restricting to zero disorder, whereas its residual formula gives phi^[-2(n-1)] at generic fixed nonzero disorder.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.