Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.33453

Local Many Worlds in Spacetime: Deutsch-Hayden Descriptors and Local Wavefunctions

Mordecai Waegell

quant-phgr-qchep-thSubmitted Sep 27, 2026• Announced Sep 29, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Bell's theorem establishes that a local and spatially separable physical theory with no superdeterminism or retrocausality must be a theory of many local worlds. The local many worlds formalism of quantum mechanics is a transparent separable physical theory in spacetime with a Lorentz covariant causal structure. Unlike the Everett many worlds interpretation, there is no nonseparable universal wavefunction in configuration space, but like Everett, there is only local unitary evolution which conserves probability (fluid) current, and no wavefunction collapse. Each event in spacetime has its own local wavefunction which is built up using only the local wavefunctions and local unitary evolution operators within its past light cone, and which is entirely disconnected from spacelike separated local wavefunctions. We call this the local Schrödinger picture. Local many worlds can also be described in the Heisenberg picture by ascribing Deutsch-Hayden (DH) descriptors to each individual system, each of which evolves under local unitary operations. Both the local wavefunctions and DH descriptors contain records of past interactions, and while the local wavefunctions provide a clear and intuitive physical narrative, the descriptors contain all of the same information in a much more compact form. Unfortunately, the compact form is also somewhat cryptic, which has made the local Heisenberg picture relatively inaccessible. The purpose of this article is to show that the local wavefunctions for any $N$-qubit system can always be constructed directly from the DH descriptors, allowing us to combine the benefits of both pictures.

AI Summary

The paper asks how event-associated “local wavefunctions” in a local-many-worlds interpretation can be reconstructed from Deutsch–Hayden (DH) descriptors carried by individual systems. It connects a local Schrödinger description, which retains initial-state data and the history of local unitaries inside an event’s past light cone, with a Heisenberg description that updates descriptors at local interactions. For $N$ qubits, the construction takes each system’s descriptor where its worldline intersects the past-light-cone surface. It forms descriptor products $Q_j$ corresponding to the $4^N-1$ nonidentity Pauli strings and computes $c_j=\langle0|^{\otimes N}Q_j|0\rangle^{\otimes N}$. These coefficients reconstruct $\rho=2^{-N}(I+\sum_j c_jP_j)$; when the state is pure, normalizing any nonzero column recovers its wavefunction up to global phase. The descriptors therefore replace the stored unitary history for state reconstruction, although the explicit procedure uses exponentially many coefficients. Worked singlet-state Bell scenarios, with measurement directions equal or separated by $120^\circ$, illustrate descriptor updates and the interpretation’s proposed local matching of observer records when observers reunite. The paper interprets this construction as a bridge between local wavefunctions and a Lorentz-covariant, separable ontology; its stronger conclusions about Bell’s theorem are interpretational claims. The treatment is restricted to qubits. Stated outstanding tasks include spatial degrees of freedom, bosons, indefinite particle number, and a relativistic fluid formulation. Formal mathematical equivalence to Tomonaga–Schwinger quantum field theory remains unestablished; quantum-gravity applications are presented as an outlook.

No sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsIncrementalUnclear noveltyPossible error

Error found: The abstract's claim that Bell's theorem requires many local worlds is not established by the paper's interpretive delayed-matching argument. The first Bell caption gives Alice's updated z descriptor with the wrong sign, producing a correlation opposite to that of its displayed wavefunction. Both displayed 120-degree Bell wavefunctions have squared norm 5/2 rather than 1 when the phi states are normalized. The printed x descriptor for qubit 2 after the 120-degree measurement does not square to the identity and therefore cannot result from unitary Pauli evolution.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
15 pages, 2 figures

Related papers

The ABC of Deutsch–Hayden Descriptors

Charles Alexandre Bédard

It has been more than 20 years since Deutsch and Hayden proved the locality of quantum theory, using the Heisenberg picture of quantum computational networks. Of course, locality holds even in the face of entanglement and Bell’s theorem. Today, most researchers in quantum foundations are still convinced not only that a local description of quantum systems has not yet been provided, but that it cannot exist. The main goal of this paper is to address this misconception by re-explaining the descriptor formalism in a hopefully accessible and self-contained way. It is a step-by-step guide to how and why descriptors work. Finally, superdense coding is revisited in the light of descriptors.

arXiv:2012.11189•Quantum Reports•Apr 27, 2021•23 citations

Restoring Locality: The Heisenberg Picture as a Separable Description of Quantum Theory

Sam Kuypers

Local realism has been the subject of much discussion in modern physics, partly because our deepest theories of physics appear to contradict one another in regard to whether reality is local. According to general relativity, it is, as physical quantities (perceptible or not) in two spacelike separated regions cannot affect one another. Yet, in quantum theory, it has traditionally been thought that local realism cannot hold and that such effects do occur. This apparent discrepancy between the two theories is resolved by Everettian quantum theory, as first proven by Deutsch & Hayden (2000). In this paper, I will explain how local realism is respected in quantum theory and review the advances in our understanding of locality since Deutsch & Hayden's work, including the concept of local branching and the more general analysis by Raymond-Robichaud (2021)

quant-pharXiv:2601.06522•Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 13, 2026•3 citations

Locality in the Heisenberg picture

Pickering, Phil

A growing body of literature supports Deutsch and Hayden’s (2000) claim that in the Heisenberg picture, quantum entanglement can be characterised locally using objects they call descriptors. I argue that their notion of locality rests, in part, on a qualified version of the principle of separability that I call spatial separability. I show that spatial separability is not sufficient for separability simpliciter, and that the more general version, spatiotemporal separability, reveals that their claim is false. Deutsch and Hayden’s approach also has a novel implication: if descriptors represent actual physical properties, they are non-qualitative properties, which are profoundly different from the qualitative properties we have come to expect from other branches of physics.

•Feb 24, 2025•0 citations

Local Quantum Theory with Fluids in Space-Time

Mordecai Waegell

In 1948, Schwinger developed a local Lorentz-covariant formulation of relativistic quantum electrodynamics in space-time which is fundamentally inconsistent with any delocalized interpretation of quantum mechanics. An interpretation compatible with Schwinger’s theory is presented, which reproduces all of the standard empirical predictions of conventional delocalized quantum theory in configuration space. This is an explicit, unambiguous, and Lorentz-covariant “local hidden variable theory” in space-time, whose existence proves definitively that such theories are possible. This does not conflict with Bell’s theorem because it is a local many-worlds theory. Each physical system is characterized by a wave-field, which is a set of indexed piece-wise single-particle wavefunctions in space-time, each with its own coefficient, along with a memory which contains the separate local Hilbert-space quantum state at each event in space-time. Each single-particle wavefunction of a fundamental system describes the motion of a portion of a conserved fluid in space-time, with the fluid decomposing into many classical point particles, each following a world-line and recording a local memory. Local interactions between two systems take the form of local boundary conditions between the differently indexed pieces of those systems’ wave-fields, with new indexes encoding each orthogonal outcome of the interaction. The general machinery is introduced, including the local mechanisms for entanglement and interference. The experience of collapse, Born rule probability, and environmental decoherence are discussed, and a number of illustrative examples are given.

arXiv:2107.06575•Quantum Reports•Feb 21, 2023•14 citations

The Laplacian Quantum Universe—A Single-World Alternative to Many-Worlds Interpretations

Arnold Neumaier, Thomas Stör

This paper shows how to treat quantum field theory as a modern, locally Lorentz covariant quantum version of the classical, mechanical universe suggested by Laplace over 200 years ago. The result is a fairly common-sense single-history, single-world alternative to decoherent histories (Gell-Mann and Hartle) and many-worlds interpretations (Everett, DeWitt). From the assumption that there is a single universal Heisenberg state whose N-point functions uniquely describe all physical details of our universe, everything is rigorously deduced in a way showing that the mathematical formalism is capable of yielding its own interpretation. Probabilities arise from the neglect of the environment in approximate models. By giving the collapse of the wave function at a double slit a natural unitary explanation, new light is shed on the quantum measurement problem and the origin of the Born rule.

•May 21, 2026•0 citations

Non-separability, locality and criteria of reality: a reply to Waegell and McQueen

Paolo Faglia

Using a 'reformulation of Bell's theorem', Waegell and McQueen, (2020) argue that any local theory which does not involve retro-causation or fine-tuning must be a many-worlds theory. Moreover they argue that non-separable many-worlds theories whose ontology is given by the wavefunction involve superluminal causation, as opposed to separable many-worlds theories (e.g. Waegell, 2021; Deutsch and Hayden 2000). I put forward three claims. (A) I challenge their argument for relying on a non-trivial, unquestioned assumption about elements of reality which allows Healey's approach (Healey, 2017b) to evade their claim. In an attempt to respond to (A), Waegell and McQueen may restrict their claim to theories which satisfy such an assumption, however, I also argue that (B) their argument fails to prove even the so weakened claim, as exemplified by theories that are both non-separable and local. Finally, (C) by arguing for the locality of the decoherence-based Everettian approach (Wallace, 2012) I refute Waegell and McQueen's claim that wavefunction-based ontologies, and more generally non-separable ontologies, involve superluminal causation. I close with some doubtful remarks about separable Everettian interpretations as compared to non-separable ones.

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A•Jun 18, 2024•9 citations
Bell's theorem establishes that a local and spatially separable physical theory with no superdeterminism or retrocausality must be a theory of many local worlds. The local many worlds formalism of quantum mechanics is a transparent separable physical theory in spacetime with a Lorentz covariant causal structure. Unlike the Everett many worlds interpretation, there is no nonseparable universal wavefunction in configuration space, but like Everett, there is only local unitary evolution which conserves probability (fluid) current, and no wavefunction collapse. Each event in spacetime has its own local wavefunction which is built up using only the local wavefunctions and local unitary evolution operators within its past light cone, and which is entirely disconnected from spacelike separated local wavefunctions. We call this the local Schrödinger picture. Local many worlds can also be described in the Heisenberg picture by ascribing Deutsch-Hayden (DH) descriptors to each individual system, each of which evolves under local unitary operations. Both the local wavefunctions and DH descriptors contain records of past interactions, and while the local wavefunctions provide a clear and intuitive physical narrative, the descriptors contain all of the same information in a much more compact form. Unfortunately, the compact form is also somewhat cryptic, which has made the local Heisenberg picture relatively inaccessible. The purpose of this article is to show that the local wavefunctions for any NNN-qubit system can always be constructed directly from the DH descriptors, allowing us to combine the benefits of both pictures.
The paper asks how event-associated “local wavefunctions” in a local-many-worlds interpretation can be reconstructed from Deutsch–Hayden (DH) descriptors carried by individual systems. It connects a local Schrödinger description, which retains initial-state data and the history of local unitaries inside an event’s past light cone, with a Heisenberg description that updates descriptors at local interactions.
For NNN qubits, the construction takes each system’s descriptor where its worldline intersects the past-light-cone surface. It forms descriptor products QjQ_jQj​ corresponding to the 4N−14^N-14N−1 nonidentity Pauli strings and computes cj=⟨0∣⊗NQj∣0⟩⊗Nc_j=\langle0|^{\otimes N}Q_j|0\rangle^{\otimes N}cj​=⟨0∣⊗NQj​∣0⟩⊗N. These coefficients reconstruct ρ=2−N(I+∑jcjPj)\rho=2^{-N}(I+\sum_j c_jP_j)ρ=2−N(I+∑j​cj​Pj​); when the state is pure, normalizing any nonzero column recovers its wavefunction up to global phase. The descriptors therefore replace the stored unitary history for state reconstruction, although the explicit procedure uses exponentially many coefficients. Worked singlet-state Bell scenarios, with measurement directions equal or separated by 120∘120^\circ120∘, illustrate descriptor updates and the interpretation’s proposed local matching of observer records when observers reunite.
The paper interprets this construction as a bridge between local wavefunctions and a Lorentz-covariant, separable ontology; its stronger conclusions about Bell’s theorem are interpretational claims. The treatment is restricted to qubits. Stated outstanding tasks include spatial degrees of freedom, bosons, indefinite particle number, and a relativistic fluid formulation. Formal mathematical equivalence to Tomonaga–Schwinger quantum field theory remains unestablished; quantum-gravity applications are presented as an outlook.
It has been more than 20 years since Deutsch and Hayden proved the locality of quantum theory, using the Heisenberg picture of quantum computational networks. Of course, locality holds even in the face of entanglement and Bell’s theorem. Today, most researchers in quantum foundations are still convinced not only that a local description of quantum systems has not yet been provided, but that it cannot exist. The main goal of this paper is to address this misconception by re-explaining the descriptor formalism in a hopefully accessible and self-contained way. It is a step-by-step guide to how and why descriptors work. Finally, superdense coding is revisited in the light of descriptors.
Local realism has been the subject of much discussion in modern physics, partly because our deepest theories of physics appear to contradict one another in regard to whether reality is local. According to general relativity, it is, as physical quantities (perceptible or not) in two spacelike separated regions cannot affect one another. Yet, in quantum theory, it has traditionally been thought that local realism cannot hold and that such effects do occur. This apparent discrepancy between the two theories is resolved by Everettian quantum theory, as first proven by Deutsch & Hayden (2000). In this paper, I will explain how local realism is respected in quantum theory and review the advances in our understanding of locality since Deutsch & Hayden's work, including the concept of local branching and the more general analysis by Raymond-Robichaud (2021)
A growing body of literature supports Deutsch and Hayden’s (2000) claim that in the Heisenberg picture, quantum entanglement can be characterised locally using objects they call descriptors. I argue that their notion of locality rests, in part, on a qualified version of the principle of separability that I call spatial separability. I show that spatial separability is not sufficient for separability simpliciter, and that the more general version, spatiotemporal separability, reveals that their claim is false. Deutsch and Hayden’s approach also has a novel implication: if descriptors represent actual physical properties, they are non-qualitative properties, which are profoundly different from the qualitative properties we have come to expect from other branches of physics.
In 1948, Schwinger developed a local Lorentz-covariant formulation of relativistic quantum electrodynamics in space-time which is fundamentally inconsistent with any delocalized interpretation of quantum mechanics. An interpretation compatible with Schwinger’s theory is presented, which reproduces all of the standard empirical predictions of conventional delocalized quantum theory in configuration space. This is an explicit, unambiguous, and Lorentz-covariant “local hidden variable theory” in space-time, whose existence proves definitively that such theories are possible. This does not conflict with Bell’s theorem because it is a local many-worlds theory. Each physical system is characterized by a wave-field, which is a set of indexed piece-wise single-particle wavefunctions in space-time, each with its own coefficient, along with a memory which contains the separate local Hilbert-space quantum state at each event in space-time. Each single-particle wavefunction of a fundamental system describes the motion of a portion of a conserved fluid in space-time, with the fluid decomposing into many classical point particles, each following a world-line and recording a local memory. Local interactions between two systems take the form of local boundary conditions between the differently indexed pieces of those systems’ wave-fields, with new indexes encoding each orthogonal outcome of the interaction. The general machinery is introduced, including the local mechanisms for entanglement and interference. The experience of collapse, Born rule probability, and environmental decoherence are discussed, and a number of illustrative examples are given.
This paper shows how to treat quantum field theory as a modern, locally Lorentz covariant quantum version of the classical, mechanical universe suggested by Laplace over 200 years ago. The result is a fairly common-sense single-history, single-world alternative to decoherent histories (Gell-Mann and Hartle) and many-worlds interpretations (Everett, DeWitt). From the assumption that there is a single universal Heisenberg state whose N-point functions uniquely describe all physical details of our universe, everything is rigorously deduced in a way showing that the mathematical formalism is capable of yielding its own interpretation. Probabilities arise from the neglect of the environment in approximate models. By giving the collapse of the wave function at a double slit a natural unitary explanation, new light is shed on the quantum measurement problem and the origin of the Born rule.
Using a 'reformulation of Bell's theorem', Waegell and McQueen, (2020) argue that any local theory which does not involve retro-causation or fine-tuning must be a many-worlds theory. Moreover they argue that non-separable many-worlds theories whose ontology is given by the wavefunction involve superluminal causation, as opposed to separable many-worlds theories (e.g. Waegell, 2021; Deutsch and Hayden 2000). I put forward three claims. (A) I challenge their argument for relying on a non-trivial, unquestioned assumption about elements of reality which allows Healey's approach (Healey, 2017b) to evade their claim. In an attempt to respond to (A), Waegell and McQueen may restrict their claim to theories which satisfy such an assumption, however, I also argue that (B) their argument fails to prove even the so weakened claim, as exemplified by theories that are both non-separable and local. Finally, (C) by arguing for the locality of the decoherence-based Everettian approach (Wallace, 2012) I refute Waegell and McQueen's claim that wavefunction-based ontologies, and more generally non-separable ontologies, involve superluminal causation. I close with some doubtful remarks about separable Everettian interpretations as compared to non-separable ones.