Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.33132

Quantum Monte Carlo Tree Search with Fixed Confidence

Mingjie Hu, Jian-Qiang Hu, Enlu Zhou

quant-phcs.AISubmitted Sep 27, 2026• Announced Sep 29, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Recent advances in quantum computing are opening new opportunities for computationally intensive decision problems. This paper studies how quantum computing can improve Monte Carlo tree search (MCTS) in the fixed-confidence setting, where the goal is to identify a near-optimal move in a given game tree with high probability while minimizing query complexity. We first formulate MCTS under a quantum oracle model. We then develop a quantum MCTS algorithm (QMCTS) that combines threshold-based elimination on the search tree with quantum Monte Carlo estimation to reduce the cost of evaluating stochastic leaf values. We establish an instance-dependent lower bound on the query complexity and derive a corresponding upper bound for QMCTS. The lower-bound analysis introduces a new quantum phase-testing result that may also be useful beyond MCTS. We validate the theoretical results through simulation experiments and further demonstrate the feasibility of QMCTS on real quantum hardware.

AI Summary

The paper studies fixed-confidence Monte Carlo tree search on a fixed MAX–MIN game tree with stochastic leaf rewards: identify an $\epsilon$-optimal root move with probability at least $1-\delta$, minimizing oracle queries. It assumes coherent access to leaf-sampling unitaries and their inverses, rather than only classical samples. QMCTS combines quantum mean estimation with geometrically decreasing precision and threshold-based subtree elimination. Each round estimates active leaves, propagates values through MAX–MIN backups, and removes empirically suboptimal children. Its high-probability query bound is $\widetilde O(\sum_\ell 1/d_{\ell,\epsilon})$, versus $\widetilde O(\sum_\ell 1/d_{\ell,\epsilon}^2)$ for its classical counterpart, where $d_{\ell,\epsilon}=\max\{\Delta_\ell,\Delta_\star,\epsilon\}$ combines the largest edge gap along a leaf’s path, the root gap, and target accuracy. Correctness follows from uniform estimation guarantees and preservation of optimal children during elimination. A conditional expected-query lower bound scales as $\Omega(\log(1/\delta)\sum_{\ell\in\mathcal L_{\mathrm{piv}}}1/d_{\ell,\epsilon})$ under bounded-size pivotal-block assumptions. Its proof reduces decision-changing perturbations to sequential phase testing, analyzed using trigonometric polynomials and a Remez inequality. Bounds match up to logarithmic factors when these blocks cover all leaves. Simulations include a 3,072-leaf chess-derived tree and a classical–quantum hybrid. A four-leaf IBM hardware test reports mean query counts of 68,352 quantum versus 306,444 classical over five runs. Stated limitations are the unresolved upper–lower-bound gap for general trees and the omission of gate complexity and hardware implementation costs from query accounting.

Little sign of AI-generated textIncrementalStrong assumptionsOverclaimsPossible error

Error found: The lower bound applies only under substantial pivotal-block assumptions, and the paper gives no explicit tree family verifying those assumptions, leaving its concrete scope undemonstrated. The structural lower-bound proof does not justify removing its additive negative term or replacing log(1/(4 delta)) with log(1/delta) over the full stated confidence range, although an amplification argument can repair this gap.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

Quantum-Enhanced Monte Carlo Tree Search

Jincheng Zhang

This paper investigates the potential of quantum computing to significantly enhance the efficiency of Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) algorithms. MCTS, a cornerstone of modern artificial intelligence, particularly in game playing, relies heavily on computationally intensive simulations to evaluate game states and guide the search process. We propose a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm that leverages quantum superposition and entanglement to achieve a parallel exploration of the vast search space inherent in MCTS. The core mechanism involves utilizing quantum computers for specific tasks within the MCTS workflow, primarily the evaluation of game states. We formulate the problem as a quantum optimization task, mapping the state evaluation to a quantum objective function. The algorithm employs a classical controller to manage the quantum computation, orchestrating the simulations and extracting information. Preliminary theoretical analysis suggests a potential exponential speedup in state evaluation compared to classical simulations, contingent on the quality of the quantum hardware and the effectiveness of the hybrid approach. This research contributes to the broader field of quantum-accelerated AI and provides a framework for future investigations into the practical application of quantum computing within complex decision-making algorithms.

•Sep 5, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Grover Adaptive Search for Discrete Simulation Optimization

Mingjie Hu, Jian-qiang Hu, Enlu Zhou

Quantum computing has advanced rapidly in recent years and has shown advantages in a variety of domains. In this paper, we investigate its potential for discrete simulation optimization in the fixed-confidence setting, a fundamental problem in the simulation literature. We first introduce a quantum simulation oracle that prepares a coherent superposition over all candidate solutions and provides the foundation for quantum algorithm design. Based on this oracle, we develop the first Grover-search-based quantum algorithm for discrete simulation optimization, called SOGAS. In particular, SOGAS uses a binary-search framework to progressively eliminate suboptimal solutions while carefully controlling the error probability, and eventually identifies a set of near-optimal solutions. We prove that SOGAS returns a near-optimal solution with probability at least the prescribed confidence level and achieves a quadratic speedup in the dependence of query complexity on the number of candidate solutions. Numerical experiments further show that SOGAS substantially outperforms classical benchmarks and provide empirical evidence for quantum advantage in discrete simulation optimization.

quant-pharXiv:2604.26277•Apr 30, 2026•3 citations

Quantum-Enhanced Monte Carlo Tree Search for Complex Optimization Problems

Jincheng Zhang

This paper explores the potential of quantum computing to revolutionize Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) algorithms, a cornerstone technique in reinforcement learning and game AI. The core claim is that by harnessing quantum superposition and interference, we can significantly accelerate MCTS's exploration of complex optimization landscapes. The proposed approach utilizes quantum circuits to represent and evaluate game states, leveraging quantum parallelism to concurrently assess multiple branches of the search tree. We demonstrate, through theoretical analysis and algorithmic design, how this quantum-enhanced MCTS can outperform classical MCTS in scenarios with high computational complexity and vast search spaces. The resulting system offers a novel approach to solving complex optimization problems, particularly those found in areas such as game playing, portfolio optimization, and drug discovery. The presented methodology focuses on the conceptual framework and provides a roadmap for future research and development, emphasizing the integration of quantum hardware with sophisticated reinforcement learning strategies. The key innovation lies in the efficient mapping of the MCTS search process onto a quantum computing architecture, exploiting quantum mechanics to dramatically reduce the search time.

•Aug 29, 2026•0 citations

How fast can a parent estimate the value of their children? A quantum algorithm for stochastic games

Marien Raat, Merlin Incerti-Medici, James R. Wootton +2 more

We give a quantum algorithm for stochastic $2$-player games. Their game trees are the expectiminimax trees of classical game search: $m$ adversarial layers alternate with $m$ chance layers, every node has $deg$ children, and the leaf values lie in an interval of length $N$. The algorithm estimates the value of the game to root mean square error $ε$ with \[ O\!\left( K^{D}\, deg^{\frac{D}{4}} \, \frac{N}ε \, D^{4D} \log\left( \frac{deg N}ε \right)^{4D} \right), \qquad D = 2m \] queries to the leaf values, where $K$ is an absolute constant. If we treat the depth $D$ as a constant as is sometimes done in the literature, the bound is $\widetilde O(deg^{m/2}ε^{-1})$ against the classical $\widetilde O(deg^{m}ε^{-2})$. So the quadratic speedup in the branching factor known for adversarial trees and the quadratic speedup in the accuracy known for a single expectation both survive when we nest one inside the other. We use a derandomised multilevel Monte Carlo estimator for chance layers and a coherent binary search for adversarial layers. The composition is done by introducing a conversion between root-mean-square and uniform error guarantees, and a composition to nest it with quantum mean estimation. We state the algorithm for stochastic games, but it is valid for the following conditions: the value of a parent is a Lipschitz function of the values of its children and the value at a chance vertex is linear in its children, however the speedup is preserved only if the deterministic step has a quantum subroutine with sublinear query complexity.

quant-pharXiv:2609.35511•Sep 29, 2026•0 citations

Quantum-enhanced Monte Carlo Tree Search framework for combinatorial optimization problems

Yohan Finet, Yves Bérubé-Lauzière, Victor Drouin-Touchette

Over the past decades, the operations research community has developed numerous effective optimization algorithms, yet quantum computing is emerging as a new computational paradigm with the potential to approach optimization problems more efficiently. Grover's algorithm offers a provable speedup for combinatorial optimization, but its circuit depth places it beyond current noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. A more accessible alternative is to reformulate the optimization problem as a quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) problem and apply quantum annealing; however, practical problem instances remain out of reach for existing hardware. We introduce AtomTreeSearch, a hybrid classical-quantum algorithm that integrates a quantum subroutine natively implementable on neutral-atom quantum computers within a Monte Carlo Tree Search framework. At each expansion step, a maximal weighted independent set of candidate actions provided by the quantum processor is selected, and these collective actions are performed to obtain a child node. We benchmark our method on the Traveling Salesman Problem, with instances of up to 60 cities on random Euclidean instances and up to 100 cities on TSPLIB instances. Our hybrid algorithm generally matches or outperforms both OR-Tools and simulated annealing on these instances, and we find that the quantum subroutine produces more diverse and higher-quality branches compared to classical alternate subroutines. These results suggest that carefully scoped quantum subroutines embedded in classical search frameworks represent a promising path toward near-term quantum utility in combinatorial optimization.

quant-pharXiv:2606.30415•Jun 30, 2026•1 citation

Monte Carlo Tree Search based Hybrid Optimization of Variational Quantum Circuits

Jiahao Yao, Haoya Li, Marin Bukov +2 more

Variational quantum algorithms stand at the forefront of simulations on near-term and future fault-tolerant quantum devices. While most variational quantum algorithms involve only continuous optimization variables, the representational power of the variational ansatz can sometimes be significantly enhanced by adding certain discrete optimization variables, as is exemplified by the generalized quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA). However, the hybrid discrete-continuous optimization problem in the generalized QAOA poses a challenge to the optimization. We propose a new algorithm called MCTS-QAOA, which combines a Monte Carlo tree search method with an improved natural policy gradient solver to optimize the discrete and continuous variables in the quantum circuit, respectively. We find that MCTS-QAOA has excellent noise-resilience properties and outperforms prior algorithms in challenging instances of the generalized QAOA.

arXiv:2203.16707•Mar 30, 2022•13 citations
Recent advances in quantum computing are opening new opportunities for computationally intensive decision problems. This paper studies how quantum computing can improve Monte Carlo tree search (MCTS) in the fixed-confidence setting, where the goal is to identify a near-optimal move in a given game tree with high probability while minimizing query complexity. We first formulate MCTS under a quantum oracle model. We then develop a quantum MCTS algorithm (QMCTS) that combines threshold-based elimination on the search tree with quantum Monte Carlo estimation to reduce the cost of evaluating stochastic leaf values. We establish an instance-dependent lower bound on the query complexity and derive a corresponding upper bound for QMCTS. The lower-bound analysis introduces a new quantum phase-testing result that may also be useful beyond MCTS. We validate the theoretical results through simulation experiments and further demonstrate the feasibility of QMCTS on real quantum hardware.
The paper studies fixed-confidence Monte Carlo tree search on a fixed MAX–MIN game tree with stochastic leaf rewards: identify an ϵ\epsilonϵ-optimal root move with probability at least 1−δ1-\delta1−δ, minimizing oracle queries. It assumes coherent access to leaf-sampling unitaries and their inverses, rather than only classical samples.
QMCTS combines quantum mean estimation with geometrically decreasing precision and threshold-based subtree elimination. Each round estimates active leaves, propagates values through MAX–MIN backups, and removes empirically suboptimal children. Its high-probability query bound is O~(∑ℓ1/dℓ,ϵ)\widetilde O(\sum_\ell 1/d_{\ell,\epsilon})O(∑ℓ​1/dℓ,ϵ​), versus O~(∑ℓ1/dℓ,ϵ2)\widetilde O(\sum_\ell 1/d_{\ell,\epsilon}^2)O(∑ℓ​1/dℓ,ϵ2​) for its classical counterpart, where dℓ,ϵ=max⁡{Δℓ,Δ⋆,ϵ}d_{\ell,\epsilon}=\max\{\Delta_\ell,\Delta_\star,\epsilon\}dℓ,ϵ​=max{Δℓ​,Δ⋆​,ϵ} combines the largest edge gap along a leaf’s path, the root gap, and target accuracy. Correctness follows from uniform estimation guarantees and preservation of optimal children during elimination.
A conditional expected-query lower bound scales as Ω(log⁡(1/δ)∑ℓ∈Lpiv1/dℓ,ϵ)\Omega(\log(1/\delta)\sum_{\ell\in\mathcal L_{\mathrm{piv}}}1/d_{\ell,\epsilon})Ω(log(1/δ)∑ℓ∈Lpiv​​1/dℓ,ϵ​) under bounded-size pivotal-block assumptions. Its proof reduces decision-changing perturbations to sequential phase testing, analyzed using trigonometric polynomials and a Remez inequality. Bounds match up to logarithmic factors when these blocks cover all leaves.
Simulations include a 3,072-leaf chess-derived tree and a classical–quantum hybrid. A four-leaf IBM hardware test reports mean query counts of 68,352 quantum versus 306,444 classical over five runs. Stated limitations are the unresolved upper–lower-bound gap for general trees and the omission of gate complexity and hardware implementation costs from query accounting.
This paper investigates the potential of quantum computing to significantly enhance the efficiency of Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) algorithms. MCTS, a cornerstone of modern artificial intelligence, particularly in game playing, relies heavily on computationally intensive simulations to evaluate game states and guide the search process. We propose a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm that leverages quantum superposition and entanglement to achieve a parallel exploration of the vast search space inherent in MCTS. The core mechanism involves utilizing quantum computers for specific tasks within the MCTS workflow, primarily the evaluation of game states. We formulate the problem as a quantum optimization task, mapping the state evaluation to a quantum objective function. The algorithm employs a classical controller to manage the quantum computation, orchestrating the simulations and extracting information. Preliminary theoretical analysis suggests a potential exponential speedup in state evaluation compared to classical simulations, contingent on the quality of the quantum hardware and the effectiveness of the hybrid approach. This research contributes to the broader field of quantum-accelerated AI and provides a framework for future investigations into the practical application of quantum computing within complex decision-making algorithms.
Quantum computing has advanced rapidly in recent years and has shown advantages in a variety of domains. In this paper, we investigate its potential for discrete simulation optimization in the fixed-confidence setting, a fundamental problem in the simulation literature. We first introduce a quantum simulation oracle that prepares a coherent superposition over all candidate solutions and provides the foundation for quantum algorithm design. Based on this oracle, we develop the first Grover-search-based quantum algorithm for discrete simulation optimization, called SOGAS. In particular, SOGAS uses a binary-search framework to progressively eliminate suboptimal solutions while carefully controlling the error probability, and eventually identifies a set of near-optimal solutions. We prove that SOGAS returns a near-optimal solution with probability at least the prescribed confidence level and achieves a quadratic speedup in the dependence of query complexity on the number of candidate solutions. Numerical experiments further show that SOGAS substantially outperforms classical benchmarks and provide empirical evidence for quantum advantage in discrete simulation optimization.
This paper explores the potential of quantum computing to revolutionize Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) algorithms, a cornerstone technique in reinforcement learning and game AI. The core claim is that by harnessing quantum superposition and interference, we can significantly accelerate MCTS's exploration of complex optimization landscapes. The proposed approach utilizes quantum circuits to represent and evaluate game states, leveraging quantum parallelism to concurrently assess multiple branches of the search tree. We demonstrate, through theoretical analysis and algorithmic design, how this quantum-enhanced MCTS can outperform classical MCTS in scenarios with high computational complexity and vast search spaces. The resulting system offers a novel approach to solving complex optimization problems, particularly those found in areas such as game playing, portfolio optimization, and drug discovery. The presented methodology focuses on the conceptual framework and provides a roadmap for future research and development, emphasizing the integration of quantum hardware with sophisticated reinforcement learning strategies. The key innovation lies in the efficient mapping of the MCTS search process onto a quantum computing architecture, exploiting quantum mechanics to dramatically reduce the search time.
We give a quantum algorithm for stochastic 222-player games. Their game trees are the expectiminimax trees of classical game search: mmm adversarial layers alternate with mmm chance layers, every node has degdegdeg children, and the leaf values lie in an interval of length NNN. The algorithm estimates the value of the game to root mean square error εεε with O ⁣(KD degD4 Nε D4Dlog⁡(degNε)4D),D=2m O\!\left( K^{D}\, deg^{\frac{D}{4}} \, \frac{N}ε \, D^{4D} \log\left( \frac{deg N}ε \right)^{4D} \right), \qquad D = 2m O(KDdeg4D​εN​D4Dlog(εdegN​)4D),D=2m queries to the leaf values, where KKK is an absolute constant. If we treat the depth DDD as a constant as is sometimes done in the literature, the bound is O~(degm/2ε−1)\widetilde O(deg^{m/2}ε^{-1})O(degm/2ε−1) against the classical O~(degmε−2)\widetilde O(deg^{m}ε^{-2})O(degmε−2). So the quadratic speedup in the branching factor known for adversarial trees and the quadratic speedup in the accuracy known for a single expectation both survive when we nest one inside the other. We use a derandomised multilevel Monte Carlo estimator for chance layers and a coherent binary search for adversarial layers. The composition is done by introducing a conversion between root-mean-square and uniform error guarantees, and a composition to nest it with quantum mean estimation. We state the algorithm for stochastic games, but it is valid for the following conditions: the value of a parent is a Lipschitz function of the values of its children and the value at a chance vertex is linear in its children, however the speedup is preserved only if the deterministic step has a quantum subroutine with sublinear query complexity.
Over the past decades, the operations research community has developed numerous effective optimization algorithms, yet quantum computing is emerging as a new computational paradigm with the potential to approach optimization problems more efficiently. Grover's algorithm offers a provable speedup for combinatorial optimization, but its circuit depth places it beyond current noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. A more accessible alternative is to reformulate the optimization problem as a quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) problem and apply quantum annealing; however, practical problem instances remain out of reach for existing hardware. We introduce AtomTreeSearch, a hybrid classical-quantum algorithm that integrates a quantum subroutine natively implementable on neutral-atom quantum computers within a Monte Carlo Tree Search framework. At each expansion step, a maximal weighted independent set of candidate actions provided by the quantum processor is selected, and these collective actions are performed to obtain a child node. We benchmark our method on the Traveling Salesman Problem, with instances of up to 60 cities on random Euclidean instances and up to 100 cities on TSPLIB instances. Our hybrid algorithm generally matches or outperforms both OR-Tools and simulated annealing on these instances, and we find that the quantum subroutine produces more diverse and higher-quality branches compared to classical alternate subroutines. These results suggest that carefully scoped quantum subroutines embedded in classical search frameworks represent a promising path toward near-term quantum utility in combinatorial optimization.
Variational quantum algorithms stand at the forefront of simulations on near-term and future fault-tolerant quantum devices. While most variational quantum algorithms involve only continuous optimization variables, the representational power of the variational ansatz can sometimes be significantly enhanced by adding certain discrete optimization variables, as is exemplified by the generalized quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA). However, the hybrid discrete-continuous optimization problem in the generalized QAOA poses a challenge to the optimization. We propose a new algorithm called MCTS-QAOA, which combines a Monte Carlo tree search method with an improved natural policy gradient solver to optimize the discrete and continuous variables in the quantum circuit, respectively. We find that MCTS-QAOA has excellent noise-resilience properties and outperforms prior algorithms in challenging instances of the generalized QAOA.