arXiv:2609.32348 · International Conference on Computational Intelligence and Communication Networks (CICN)
A Quantum Framework for K Coloring of Graphs
Lord Sen, Shyamapada Mukherjee
Abstract
Graph coloring is a well-known NP-complete problem with applications in scheduling, register allocation, frequency assignment, and network optimization. Quantum computing offers the potential for polynomial or even super-polynomial speedups in certain problem instances, yet practical quantum graph coloring methods must carefully balance qubit resources, circuit depth, and constraint enforcement. We proposed a solver agnostic quantum framework for $K$-coloring. Along with a novel encoding and efficient constraint implementation for its exact coloring exploiting Grover search and almost optimal coloring by the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm \emph{(QAOA)}, and \emph{Quantum Annealing}. Unlike using $O(NK)$ qubits as in \emph{SOTA}, we reduced the qubit requirements to $O(N \log_2 K)$, along with optimized comparator circuits enforcing adjacency constraints. Further symmetry-based graph reduction is incorporated as an optional preprocessing step to further reduce the instance size before quantum execution.
AI Summary
The paper addresses resource trade-offs in quantum $K$-coloring of graphs, focusing on color encoding and constraint enforcement across Grover search, QAOA, and quantum annealing. It presents a solver-selection pipeline with optional classical graph reduction, quantum execution, and classical validation or repair. Binary encoding uses $N\lceil\log_2K\rceil$ logical qubits rather than the $NK$ required by one-hot encoding. Grover oracles check adjacent-register equality and, in the fully quantum variant, out-of-range colors; a hybrid variant postpones range validation until measurement. The stated Grover iteration count is approximately $\frac{\pi}{4}\sqrt{2^{N\lceil\log_2K\rceil}/r}$, where $r$ counts valid colorings. The QAOA construction uses diagonal equality penalties and single-qubit $X$ mixers, with a stated $O(1)$ constraint-ancilla requirement. The annealing construction primarily uses a one-hot QUBO. Optional preprocessing includes symmetry-based vertex identification and decomposition at cut vertices. Evaluation consists of classical simulations of one small benchmark, $N=4$, $K=3$. Full-quantum Grover uses 25 qubits and reports valid-coloring fractions of 52.5%, 94.8%, and 90.3% after one, two, and three iterations. Binary QAOA uses eight qubits and reports 31.5%, 36.7%, and 55.3% validity at 5, 10, and 15 layers; hybrid Grover uses 14 qubits. The paper explicitly limits these results to qualitative illustrations: it provides no classical coloring baselines, broader graph-family evaluation, noisy-backend tests, or hardware experiments, and does not establish practical quantum advantage. Symmetry detection is treated as optional preprocessing without a general polynomial-time guarantee.
Central claim may not hold: The QAOA range penalty recognizes only the all-ones label, leaving some forbidden colors unpenalized for general K and penalizing a permitted color when K is a power of two. Collapsing arbitrary automorphism orbits and assigning each orbit one color does not preserve proper coloring, as shown by the two endpoints of a single edge. The claimed solver-wide O(N log₂ K) qubit reduction is not established for total resources, and the asserted O(log K)-ancilla sequential Grover construction lacks the reversible bookkeeping needed to justify its width/depth bounds. Result 4's qubit-saving formula is incorrect: under its stated register accounting, the saving is (min(a,c)−1)⌈log₂K⌉ rather than max(a,c)⌈log₂K⌉. The claim of almost-optimal coloring is unsupported by valid-fraction measurements on one four-vertex simulated instance.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.