Hegerfeldt's theorem shows that the localization of a particle (or field) is not possible under very general assumptions of quantum mechanics and special relativity. This theorem, and further developments and associated theorems force penetrating questions on the proper understanding of the theory and its use. In particular, the use of the collapse postulate is called into question. The existence of particles and even localized fields are called into question. And, this in turn challenges local measurements. It generally forces one to consider the profound problems and even wrong results that arise from the collapse postulate. We give a qualitatively new example of such a wrong result. Researchers and students alike are bothered by these fundamental issues. Students' ability to learn the material, and even their interest in physics, can be compromised by such disturbing conundra that seem to make physics, or at least QFT and its QM limit, seem incomprehensible and even inconsistent. This article resolves these issues in a way accessible to undergraduates, by applying the natural (minimal) interpretation of quantum mechanics (QM) (the ensemble interpretation) and explicating and clarifying the basic principles and premises used in QM and the Hegerfeldt theorem and its application to measurements.
AI Summary
The paper addresses the apparent tension between particle localization, relativistic causality, and quantum measurement associated with Hegerfeldt’s theorem and related results. It asks how these localization constraints should affect the interpretation of particles, localized fields, local measurements, and the collapse postulate.
The proposed approach is interpretational and pedagogical: it applies the ensemble interpretation of quantum mechanics and clarifies the principles and premises entering the localization theorems and their application to measurements. The abstract claims that this treatment resolves the associated conceptual difficulties without treating collapse as a necessary physical process. It also announces a qualitatively new example in which use of the collapse postulate gives a wrong result. The intended presentation is accessible to undergraduates, with an emphasis on explaining foundational issues rather than introducing a computational or experimental method.
Only the title and abstract are available. They do not specify the new example, the observable or prediction involved, or the argument establishing the claimed error. Nor do they give precise theorem hypotheses, quantitative bounds, or details sufficient to assess the scope of the proposed resolution. No explicit limitations are stated in the abstract. Consequently, the available material establishes the topic and proposed interpretational strategy, but not the technical content of the claimed resolution or counterexample.
No sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsUnclear noveltyMissing comparison
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the abstract only. Automated: it can be wrong.
Hegerfeldt's theorem shows that the localization of a particle (or field) is not possible under very general assumptions of quantum mechanics and special relativity. This theorem, and further developments and associated theorems force penetrating questions on the proper understanding of the theory and its use. In particular, the use of the collapse postulate is called into question. The existence of particles and even localized fields are called into question. And, this in turn challenges local measurements. It generally forces one to consider the profound problems and even wrong results that arise from the collapse postulate. We give a qualitatively new example of such a wrong result. Researchers and students alike are bothered by these fundamental issues. Students' ability to learn the material, and even their interest in physics, can be compromised by such disturbing conundra that seem to make physics, or at least QFT and its QM limit, seem incomprehensible and even inconsistent. This article resolves these issues in a way accessible to undergraduates, by applying the natural (minimal) interpretation of quantum mechanics (QM) (the ensemble interpretation) and explicating and clarifying the basic principles and premises used in QM and the Hegerfeldt theorem and its application to measurements.
The paper addresses the apparent tension between particle localization, relativistic causality, and quantum measurement associated with Hegerfeldt’s theorem and related results. It asks how these localization constraints should affect the interpretation of particles, localized fields, local measurements, and the collapse postulate.
The proposed approach is interpretational and pedagogical: it applies the ensemble interpretation of quantum mechanics and clarifies the principles and premises entering the localization theorems and their application to measurements. The abstract claims that this treatment resolves the associated conceptual difficulties without treating collapse as a necessary physical process. It also announces a qualitatively new example in which use of the collapse postulate gives a wrong result. The intended presentation is accessible to undergraduates, with an emphasis on explaining foundational issues rather than introducing a computational or experimental method.
Only the title and abstract are available. They do not specify the new example, the observable or prediction involved, or the argument establishing the claimed error. Nor do they give precise theorem hypotheses, quantitative bounds, or details sufficient to assess the scope of the proposed resolution. No explicit limitations are stated in the abstract. Consequently, the available material establishes the topic and proposed interpretational strategy, but not the technical content of the claimed resolution or counterexample.
The postulate of the collapse of the wave-function stands between the microscopic, quantum world, and the macroscopic world. Because of this intermediate position, the collapse process cannot be examined with the formalism of the quantum mechanics (QM), neither with that of classical mechanics. This fact makes some physicists propose interpretations of QM, which avoid this postulate. However, the common procedure used in that is making assumptions incompatible with the QM formalism. The present work discusses the most popular interpretations. It is shown that because of such assumptions those interpretations fail, i.e. predict for some experiments results which differ from the QM predictions. Despite that, special attention is called to a proposal of S. Gao, the only one which addresses and tries to solve an obvious and major contradiction. A couple of theorems are proved for showing that the collapse postulate is necessary in the QM. Although non-explainable with the quantum formalism, this postulate cannot be denied, otherwise one comes to conclusions which disagree with the QM. It is also proved here that the idea of “collapse at a distance” is problematic especially in relativistic cases, and is a misunderstanding. Namely, in an entanglement of two quantum systems, assuming that the measurement of one of the systems (accompanied by collapse of that system on one of its states) collapses the other systems, too without the second system being measured, which leads to a contradiction.
The problem of measurement in quantum mechanics is that the quantum particle in the course of evolution, as described by the linear Schrodinger equation, exists in all of its possible states, but in measuring, the particle is always detected in only one of its states. This property is called the "collapse of the wave function" and was formulated by Von Neumann as one of the postulates of quantum mechanics. However, it remains unclear at what point in time and under what laws this transition occurs. This article demonstrates that the collapse of the wave function may be due to the creation or annihilation of particles (quasi-particles). The processes of the creation or annihilation of particles play a key role in the measurements and are described on the basis of quantum field theory. The system of equations of quantum field theory of particles and fields is non-linear; as a result, the principle of superposition does not hold for the theory. The collapse of the wave function is a consequence of this non-linearity and occurs at the moment of creation (annihilation) of a particle. This result demonstrates that the wave function collapse can occur in both microscopic and macroscopic systems. Understanding the mechanisms of the collapse of the wave function can lead to the creation of microscopic devices involved in the calculations based on quantum computing.
This paper reviews the partial contents of our two manuscripts displayed on arXiv and the nine published papers in some journals, and offers some new expressions. These contents explore the interpretation or research of some concepts and quantum phenomena in quantum mechanics, including foundational or fundamental issues, which delve into deeper questions beneath the basic principles. In our research, we primarily focus on the absence of interaction, or restore the external field potential energy to the interaction energy and consider the related environment qualitatively. We offer a slightly more accessible explanation for several typical quantum phenomena explained using counterintuitive coherent superposition states, summarizing that the wave nature of a particle, i.e., coherent superposition, originates from the interaction of a particle with the environment. We try to propose adding a new postulate to the fundamental postulates or principles of quantum mechanics, which we call the zeroth postulate: any material particle is not free, meaning that the interaction between a particle with its environment cannot be zero. This provides a possible foundation for understanding the wave nature of microscopic particles in quantum mechanics, specifically the coherent superposition pure states. To put this into practice, we propose a new double-slit experiment, hoping that someone will conduct it and predicting that the experimental results will show interference patterns while also identifying which slit a particle has passed through, thus resolving the which-way dilemma. Additionally, we provide explanations for quantum measurements and conservation laws different from those in general books of quantum mechanics.
Abstract It is a widespread belief, at least within the physics community, that there is no relativistic quantum theory of (localizable) particles; and, thus, that the only relativistic quantum theory is a theory of fields. This belief has received much support in recent years in the form of rigorous nogo theorems by Malament (1996) and Hegerfeldt (1998a,b). In particular, Hegerfeldt shows that in a generic quantum theory (relativistic or nonrelativistic), if there are states with localized particles, and if there is a lower bound on the system’s energy, then superluminal spreading of the wavefunction must occur. Similarly, Malament shows the inconsistency of a few intuitive desiderata for a relativistic quantum mechanics of (localizable) par