arXiv:2609.31209
Bypassing no-go theorems on mixed classical-quantum systems: the (counter)example of hybrid van Hove theory
Marcel Reginatto, Andrés Darío Bermúdez Manjarres, Sebastian Ulbricht
Abstract
Motivated by models of mixed quantum-classical hybrid theories, we consider the representation of classical observables as Hilbert-space operators based on van Hove's unitary representation of contact transformations. This leads to a reformulation of classical mechanics where the phase space density satisfies the Liouville equation and, more importantly, classical observables are represented by van Hove operators that satisfy a commutation algebra isomorphic to the classical Poisson algebra of functions in phase space. Thus, this Hilbert space approach captures all the essential features of the phase space formulation of classical mechanics in that it reproduces its algebraic structure -- something that is not achieved by other approaches such as the Koopman-von Neumann theory. As an important feature, the definition of appropriate physical states in this formalism imposes certain natural requirements on the phase of the classical wave function, which ensure correct expectation values for the observables. Furthermore, we discuss how to extend the approach to the hybrid van Hove theory of mixed classical-quantum systems and illustrate its application with the example of interacting classical and quantum oscillators. Finally, we focus on the question of how hybrid van Hove theory evades no-go theorems on mixed classical-quantum systems and point to the various assumptions of the no-go theorems that do not apply to our approach. This demonstrates that these no-go theorems are not universally applicable, contrary to their original claims.
AI Summary
The paper examines whether no-go theorems for classical–quantum hybrid dynamics, including restrictions on entanglement generation through a classical mediator, apply to hybrid van Hove theory. It develops the classical Hilbert-space formulation underlying this previously introduced model and identifies assumptions of several no-go results that the model does not satisfy. Classical phase-space functions are represented by operators $\hat{\mathcal O}_F=F-p\partial_pF+i\hbar(\partial_qF\partial_p-\partial_pF\partial_q)$, satisfying $[\hat{\mathcal O}_F,\hat{\mathcal O}_G]=i\hbar\hat{\mathcal O}_{\{F,G\}}$. Evolution generated by $\hat{\mathcal O}_H$ yields the Liouville equation for the wavefunction modulus squared and an action equation for its phase. Trajectory-supported states, with phase constraints imposed along trajectories, are used to recover classical expectation values; general probability densities are represented through mixtures described by density matrices. For the hybrid extension, classical van Hove operators and quantum Schrödinger operators are coupled through product interaction terms. A bilinearly coupled classical–quantum oscillator example gives normal-mode frequencies $\Omega^{\pm}=\sqrt{\omega^2\pm\lambda/m}$ and reproduces the coupled-oscillator equations used as a consistency benchmark. The no-go discussion emphasizes that this formulation uses noncommuting classical observable operators and does not require their products to remain classical observables. Consequently, assumptions involving commuting classical observables, LOCC, particular generalized-probabilistic descriptions, or product-algebra closure do not apply. The paper accepts the mathematical correctness of the theorems but disputes their universal applicability. Its explicit dynamical example is quadratic; the corresponding quantum–classical Lie-algebra agreement does not extend to higher-degree polynomials. Consistency results and mediator-induced entanglement are cited from earlier work rather than established anew.
Central claim may not hold: The no-go comparison establishes non-applicability conditional on accepting the proposed framework, rather than independently establishing the consistent classical counterexample claimed. The claimed unchanged quadratic hybrid Lie algebra fails because commutators of hybrid interaction operators generate symmetrized products of van Hove operators rather than van Hove representatives of the corresponding classical products. The phase constraints required to recover classical expectation values do not follow from the single directional-derivative equation used to justify them.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 12 pages