Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.31075

On the applicability of Kolmogorov's theory of probability to the description of quantum phenomena. Part II: Bell inequalities

Maik Reddiger

quant-phmath-phSubmitted Sep 25, 2026• Announced Sep 28, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Among the various "no-go theorems" in the foundations of quantum mechanics, Bell inequalities are among the few, which do not implicitly rely on the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics. Instead, Bell inequalities are commonly understood to rest on Kolmogorov's theory of probability and a "locality" assumption. Physical evidence supporting their violation is hence taken as evidence against at least one of these two assumptions. This work provides a comprehensive analysis of the physical debate on Bell inequalities from the point of view of Kolmogorov's theory of probability, focusing on the Bell-Clauser-Horn-Shimony-Holt inequality (BCHSH inequality). The central contribution is the motivation and mathematical study of the notion of contextuality in Bell experiments: in so-called contextual Bell models the detectors themselves behave randomly and the distribution of the random detector parameters depends on the chosen detector settings. It is shown how even "classical" Bell experiments motivate such a description. The need to account for contextuality was pointed out before by de la Peña, Cetto, Brody, Lochak, Bohm, Hiley and others. A broad class of contextual models is proven to satisfy the BCHSH inequality, thereby generalizing a previous result by Gill and Lambare. Nonetheless, even under strong locality requirements, contextual Bell models may violate the BCHSH inequality: based on work by Popescu and Rohrlich, we consider a "proof of concept" example exhibiting the maximum possible violation. Contrary to the much debated "loopholes" in empirical tests of Bell inequalities, contextuality thus reveals a conceptual misunderstanding in the physical conclusions commonly drawn from Bell inequality violations.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether setting-dependent randomness in measurement devices can accommodate CHSH violations within Kolmogorov probability theory while satisfying specified locality conditions. It reviews Bell, CHSH and GHZ arguments, then introduces “contextual Bell models” with source/environment variables $\lambda_R$, detector variables $\lambda_A,\lambda_B$, and a joint measure $\mathbb{P}_{ab}$ depending on both settings. For these models, “strong locality” requires that the joint marginals of $(\lambda_R,\lambda_A)$ and $(\lambda_R,\lambda_B)$ depend only on the respective local setting, and that each output depends only on its local setting, local detector variable and $\lambda_R$. This implies no-signalling, but does not impose conditional independence between detector variables. A theorem establishes the CHSH bound $|S|\leq2$ when the joint measure factorizes into a setting-independent source distribution and two local stochastic kernels conditioned on $\lambda_R$. The proof integrates out detector variables, reducing the correlations to products of bounded local response averages. A finite construction reproduces Popescu–Rohrlich correlations and attains $S=4$, exceeding the quantum bound $2\sqrt{2}$, while satisfying the paper’s contextual strong-locality definition. Additional examples illustrate setting-dependent classical detector distributions and show that output correlation alone does not ensure a violation. The paper also discusses repeated-trial statistics using an independent, identically distributed model, a central-limit approximation and a Hoeffding bound. The stated limitation is that the violating construction specifies probabilities without a physical mechanism. A relativistic dynamical realization using only locally mediated interactions remains open; the discussion of how dynamics might generate suitable correlations is qualitative.

No sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsIncrementalUnclear noveltyPossible error

Central claim may not hold: The paper’s contextual “strong locality” conditions allow setting-dependent joint detector correlations without establishing that they can arise from physical local causality. The CHSH = 4 counterexample correctly reproduces a PR box, but assumes its joint correlations rather than deriving them from a locally causal mechanism. The abstract claims a conceptual correction to the physical interpretation of Bell violations even though the body explicitly leaves a locally mediated violating realization unestablished. The adapted central-limit theorem incorrectly asserts convergence for every Borel set and permits zero total variance, for which its standardization is undefined.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
44 pages + 15 pages of references, 2 figures; supplementary material in anc folder; Keywords: Bell's theorem, CHSH inequality, geometric quantum theory, contextuality, quantum nonlocality

Related papers

Bell's inequality: Physics meets Probability

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We remind the viewpoint that violation of Bell's inequality might be interpreted not only as an evidence of the alternative -- either nonlocality or ``death of reality'' (under the assumption the quantum mechanics is incomplete). Violation of Bell's type inequalities is a well known sufficient condition of incompatibility of random variables -- impossibility to realize them on a single probability space. Thus, in fact, we should take into account an additional interpretation of violation of Bell's inequality -- a few pairs of random variables (two dimensional vector variables) involved in the EPR-Bohm experiment are incompatible. They could not be realized on a single Kolmogorov probability space. Thus one can choose between: a) completeness of quantum mechanics; b) nonlocality; c) `` death of reality''; d) non-Kolmogorovness. In any event, violation of Bell's inequality has a variety of possible interpretations. Hence, it could not be used to derive the unique conclusion on the relation between quantum and classical models.

arXiv:0709.3909•Sep 25, 2007•50 citations

On the applicability of Kolmogorov’s theory of probability to the description of quantum phenomena. Part I: foundations

Maik Reddiger

Abstract By formulating the axioms of quantum mechanics, von Neumann also laid the foundations of a “quantum probability theory”. As such, it is regarded a generalization of the “classical probability theory” due to Kolmogorov. Outside of quantum physics, however, Kolmogorov’s axioms enjoy universal applicability. This raises the question of whether quantum physics indeed requires such a generalization of our conception of probability or if von Neumann’s axiomatization of quantum mechanics was contingent on the absence of a general theory of probability in the 1920s. This work argues in favor of the latter position. In particular, it shows how to construct a mathematically rigorous theory for non-relativistic N -body quantum systems subject to a time-independent scalar potential, which is based on Kolmogorov’s axioms and physically natural random variables. Though this theory is provably distinct from its quantum-mechanical analog, it nonetheless reproduces central predictions of the latter. Further work may make an empirical comparison possible. Moreover, the approach can in principle be adapted to other classes of quantum-mechanical models. Part II of this series discusses the empirical violation of Bell inequalities in the context of this approach. Part III addresses the projection postulate and the question of measurement.

arXiv:2405.05710•Quantum Studies Mathematics and Foundations•Oct 23, 2025•4 citations

Entanglement and quantum nonlocality demystified

Marian Kupczyński

Quantum nonlocality is presented often as the most remarkable and inexplicable phenomenon known to modern science. It has been known already for a long time that the probabilistic models used to prove Bell and Clauser-Horn-Shimony-Holt inequalities (BI-CHSH) for spin polarization correlation experiments (SPCE) are incompatible with the experimental protocols of SPCE. In particular these models use the same common probability space, joint probability distributions and/or conditional independence to describe coincidence experiments in incompatible experimental settings. Strangely enough these results are not known or simply neglected. This is why we will once again reanalyze Bell locality assumptions and show that they have nothing to do with the notion of Einsteinian locality therefore their violation should not be called quantum nonlocality but rather quantum non-Kolmogorovness or quantum contextuality. Moreover if local variables describing the measuring instruments are correctly taken into account then BI-CHSH can no longer be proven and one can easily construct non-signaling probabilistic models able to reproduce the predictions of QT. The violation of BI-CHSH is considered usually as a proof that a quantum state is entangled. Since BI-CHSH are violated also in some experiments from outside the domain of quantum physics therefore the entanglement is not exclusively a quantum phenomenon. In order to further demystify these notions we show that one can prepare two macroscopic systems in such a way that simple realizable local experiments on these systems violate BI. In view of these arguments the further testing of BI-CHSH inequalities in search for the loopholes does not seem to be necessary.

arXiv:1205.4636•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2012•31 citations

Detection probability "enhancement" and "unfair sampling" in Bell inequalities

David Rodríguez

On one side, so far a great part of the evidence accepted as proof of the alleged quantum non-locality relied on inhomogeneous Bell inequalities involving an additional assumption (no-enhancement) whose role had not been sufficiently examined (in contrast to homogeneous inequalities, where the role of low detection rates is well acknowledged). A first contribution of this paper is to provide explicit examples of how a model of hidden local variables (LHV) defying no-enhancement is able to produce a violation of an inhomogeneous inequality, a possibility that so far was pointed out only in qualitative terms. On the other hand, recent tests have attempted to overcome this reliance on supplementary assumptions, but still give rise to doubt, due to: (i) violations are extremely low, which points to some systematical error (the fact that alleged random errors of the detectors seem to conspire to interfere exactly at such narrow strip around the frontier with local-realism and not a different part of the spectrum that QM would theoretically produce can hardly be considered just coincidence); (ii) the correspondence between the observations and one or another quantum state is not clear either, as recent models cannot be really validated against the available data (they have equal or more parameters than restrictions). Following (ii), it would be convenient to verify a more significant set of quantum predictions, instead of just the few counting rates involved in a particular Bell inequality. Finally, another type of "no-go" tests (an instance of which we examine here) also present subtleties which call for serious examination.

arXiv:1111.4092•Nov 17, 2011•1 citation

Violation of Bell Inequalities: Mapping the Conceptual Implications

Brian Drummond

This short article concentrates on the conceptual aspects of the violation of Bell inequalities, and acts as a map to the 265 cited references. The article outlines (a) relevant characteristics of quantum mechanics, such as statistical balance and entanglement, (b) the thinking that led to the derivation of the original Bell inequality, and (c) the range of claimed implications, including realism, locality and others which attract less attention. The main conclusion is that violation of Bell inequalities appears to have some implications for the nature of physical reality, but that none of these are definite. The violations constrain possible prequantum (underlying) theories, but do not rule out the possibility that such theories might reconcile at least one understanding of locality and realism to quantum mechanical predictions. Violation might reflect, at least partly, failure to acknowledge the contextuality of quantum mechanics, or that data from different probability spaces have been inappropriately combined. Many claims that there are definite implications reflect one or more of (i) imprecise non-mathematical language, (ii) assumptions inappropriate in quantum mechanics, (iii) inadequate treatment of measurement statistics and (iv) underlying philosophical assumptions.

arXiv:2106.14767•Jun 28, 2021•3 citations

Estudo probabilístico de sistemas quânticos: relações entre desigualdades tipo Bell

Felipe Andrade Velozo

In 1964, John S. Bell publishes an article in response to the Einstein, \nPodolsky and Rosen paradox, in which he develops an inequality involving \nstatistical correlation, basing on the supposition that Quantum Mechanics is a \nstatistical theory. There should, therefore, exist a random variable related to the \nobservations, in which, if there was the possibility of knowing its value, the \nresult of the experiment would be completely predictable. Thus, the lack of \npredictability of the experiment would be due to the ignorance regarding the \nvalue that such variable assumes during the experiment. However, when using \nthe formula obtained by calculating the probabilities of the Quantum Mechanic \nexperiment, we find a set of values in which the inequality is violated. Thus, we \nconcluded that the Kolmogorov probability axioms are not enough to describe \nquantum phenomena. In 1969, J. F. Clauser, M. A. Horne, A. Shimony and R. \nA. Holt adapted Bell’s inequality for a viable experiment. In this dissertation, we \ncompared the violation regions of the Wigner and Bell inequalities, verifying \nthat they are equal and equivalent to the violation of one of the Kolmogorov \naxioms. We also verified that it is possible to create probability functions for \nquantum experiments that represent the Bell and Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt \ninequalities if compatible for changing a Kolmogorov axiom. The dissertation \naims at regarding a few incompatibilities of the Quantum Theory with the \nProbability Theory found in literature, statistically analyzing the formulas \nobtained.

•Jan 22, 2016•0 citations
Among the various "no-go theorems" in the foundations of quantum mechanics, Bell inequalities are among the few, which do not implicitly rely on the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics. Instead, Bell inequalities are commonly understood to rest on Kolmogorov's theory of probability and a "locality" assumption. Physical evidence supporting their violation is hence taken as evidence against at least one of these two assumptions.
This work provides a comprehensive analysis of the physical debate on Bell inequalities from the point of view of Kolmogorov's theory of probability, focusing on the Bell-Clauser-Horn-Shimony-Holt inequality (BCHSH inequality). The central contribution is the motivation and mathematical study of the notion of contextuality in Bell experiments: in so-called contextual Bell models the detectors themselves behave randomly and the distribution of the random detector parameters depends on the chosen detector settings. It is shown how even "classical" Bell experiments motivate such a description. The need to account for contextuality was pointed out before by de la Peña, Cetto, Brody, Lochak, Bohm, Hiley and others. A broad class of contextual models is proven to satisfy the BCHSH inequality, thereby generalizing a previous result by Gill and Lambare. Nonetheless, even under strong locality requirements, contextual Bell models may violate the BCHSH inequality: based on work by Popescu and Rohrlich, we consider a "proof of concept" example exhibiting the maximum possible violation.
Contrary to the much debated "loopholes" in empirical tests of Bell inequalities, contextuality thus reveals a conceptual misunderstanding in the physical conclusions commonly drawn from Bell inequality violations.
The paper asks whether setting-dependent randomness in measurement devices can accommodate CHSH violations within Kolmogorov probability theory while satisfying specified locality conditions. It reviews Bell, CHSH and GHZ arguments, then introduces “contextual Bell models” with source/environment variables λR\lambda_RλR​, detector variables λA,λB\lambda_A,\lambda_BλA​,λB​, and a joint measure Pab\mathbb{P}_{ab}Pab​ depending on both settings.
For these models, “strong locality” requires that the joint marginals of (λR,λA)(\lambda_R,\lambda_A)(λR​,λA​) and (λR,λB)(\lambda_R,\lambda_B)(λR​,λB​) depend only on the respective local setting, and that each output depends only on its local setting, local detector variable and λR\lambda_RλR​. This implies no-signalling, but does not impose conditional independence between detector variables. A theorem establishes the CHSH bound ∣S∣≤2|S|\leq2∣S∣≤2 when the joint measure factorizes into a setting-independent source distribution and two local stochastic kernels conditioned on λR\lambda_RλR​. The proof integrates out detector variables, reducing the correlations to products of bounded local response averages.
A finite construction reproduces Popescu–Rohrlich correlations and attains S=4S=4S=4, exceeding the quantum bound 222\sqrt{2}22​, while satisfying the paper’s contextual strong-locality definition. Additional examples illustrate setting-dependent classical detector distributions and show that output correlation alone does not ensure a violation. The paper also discusses repeated-trial statistics using an independent, identically distributed model, a central-limit approximation and a Hoeffding bound.
The stated limitation is that the violating construction specifies probabilities without a physical mechanism. A relativistic dynamical realization using only locally mediated interactions remains open; the discussion of how dynamics might generate suitable correlations is qualitative.
We remind the viewpoint that violation of Bell's inequality might be interpreted not only as an evidence of the alternative -- either nonlocality or ``death of reality'' (under the assumption the quantum mechanics is incomplete). Violation of Bell's type inequalities is a well known sufficient condition of incompatibility of random variables -- impossibility to realize them on a single probability space. Thus, in fact, we should take into account an additional interpretation of violation of Bell's inequality -- a few pairs of random variables (two dimensional vector variables) involved in the EPR-Bohm experiment are incompatible. They could not be realized on a single Kolmogorov probability space. Thus one can choose between: a) completeness of quantum mechanics; b) nonlocality; c) `` death of reality''; d) non-Kolmogorovness. In any event, violation of Bell's inequality has a variety of possible interpretations. Hence, it could not be used to derive the unique conclusion on the relation between quantum and classical models.
Abstract By formulating the axioms of quantum mechanics, von Neumann also laid the foundations of a “quantum probability theory”. As such, it is regarded a generalization of the “classical probability theory” due to Kolmogorov. Outside of quantum physics, however, Kolmogorov’s axioms enjoy universal applicability. This raises the question of whether quantum physics indeed requires such a generalization of our conception of probability or if von Neumann’s axiomatization of quantum mechanics was contingent on the absence of a general theory of probability in the 1920s. This work argues in favor of the latter position. In particular, it shows how to construct a mathematically rigorous theory for non-relativistic N -body quantum systems subject to a time-independent scalar potential, which is based on Kolmogorov’s axioms and physically natural random variables. Though this theory is provably distinct from its quantum-mechanical analog, it nonetheless reproduces central predictions of the latter. Further work may make an empirical comparison possible. Moreover, the approach can in principle be adapted to other classes of quantum-mechanical models. Part II of this series discusses the empirical violation of Bell inequalities in the context of this approach. Part III addresses the projection postulate and the question of measurement.
Quantum nonlocality is presented often as the most remarkable and inexplicable phenomenon known to modern science. It has been known already for a long time that the probabilistic models used to prove Bell and Clauser-Horn-Shimony-Holt inequalities (BI-CHSH) for spin polarization correlation experiments (SPCE) are incompatible with the experimental protocols of SPCE. In particular these models use the same common probability space, joint probability distributions and/or conditional independence to describe coincidence experiments in incompatible experimental settings. Strangely enough these results are not known or simply neglected. This is why we will once again reanalyze Bell locality assumptions and show that they have nothing to do with the notion of Einsteinian locality therefore their violation should not be called quantum nonlocality but rather quantum non-Kolmogorovness or quantum contextuality. Moreover if local variables describing the measuring instruments are correctly taken into account then BI-CHSH can no longer be proven and one can easily construct non-signaling probabilistic models able to reproduce the predictions of QT. The violation of BI-CHSH is considered usually as a proof that a quantum state is entangled. Since BI-CHSH are violated also in some experiments from outside the domain of quantum physics therefore the entanglement is not exclusively a quantum phenomenon. In order to further demystify these notions we show that one can prepare two macroscopic systems in such a way that simple realizable local experiments on these systems violate BI. In view of these arguments the further testing of BI-CHSH inequalities in search for the loopholes does not seem to be necessary.
On one side, so far a great part of the evidence accepted as proof of the alleged quantum non-locality relied on inhomogeneous Bell inequalities involving an additional assumption (no-enhancement) whose role had not been sufficiently examined (in contrast to homogeneous inequalities, where the role of low detection rates is well acknowledged). A first contribution of this paper is to provide explicit examples of how a model of hidden local variables (LHV) defying no-enhancement is able to produce a violation of an inhomogeneous inequality, a possibility that so far was pointed out only in qualitative terms. On the other hand, recent tests have attempted to overcome this reliance on supplementary assumptions, but still give rise to doubt, due to: (i) violations are extremely low, which points to some systematical error (the fact that alleged random errors of the detectors seem to conspire to interfere exactly at such narrow strip around the frontier with local-realism and not a different part of the spectrum that QM would theoretically produce can hardly be considered just coincidence); (ii) the correspondence between the observations and one or another quantum state is not clear either, as recent models cannot be really validated against the available data (they have equal or more parameters than restrictions). Following (ii), it would be convenient to verify a more significant set of quantum predictions, instead of just the few counting rates involved in a particular Bell inequality. Finally, another type of "no-go" tests (an instance of which we examine here) also present subtleties which call for serious examination.
This short article concentrates on the conceptual aspects of the violation of Bell inequalities, and acts as a map to the 265 cited references. The article outlines (a) relevant characteristics of quantum mechanics, such as statistical balance and entanglement, (b) the thinking that led to the derivation of the original Bell inequality, and (c) the range of claimed implications, including realism, locality and others which attract less attention. The main conclusion is that violation of Bell inequalities appears to have some implications for the nature of physical reality, but that none of these are definite. The violations constrain possible prequantum (underlying) theories, but do not rule out the possibility that such theories might reconcile at least one understanding of locality and realism to quantum mechanical predictions. Violation might reflect, at least partly, failure to acknowledge the contextuality of quantum mechanics, or that data from different probability spaces have been inappropriately combined. Many claims that there are definite implications reflect one or more of (i) imprecise non-mathematical language, (ii) assumptions inappropriate in quantum mechanics, (iii) inadequate treatment of measurement statistics and (iv) underlying philosophical assumptions.
In 1964, John S. Bell publishes an article in response to the Einstein, \nPodolsky and Rosen paradox, in which he develops an inequality involving \nstatistical correlation, basing on the supposition that Quantum Mechanics is a \nstatistical theory. There should, therefore, exist a random variable related to the \nobservations, in which, if there was the possibility of knowing its value, the \nresult of the experiment would be completely predictable. Thus, the lack of \npredictability of the experiment would be due to the ignorance regarding the \nvalue that such variable assumes during the experiment. However, when using \nthe formula obtained by calculating the probabilities of the Quantum Mechanic \nexperiment, we find a set of values in which the inequality is violated. Thus, we \nconcluded that the Kolmogorov probability axioms are not enough to describe \nquantum phenomena. In 1969, J. F. Clauser, M. A. Horne, A. Shimony and R. \nA. Holt adapted Bell’s inequality for a viable experiment. In this dissertation, we \ncompared the violation regions of the Wigner and Bell inequalities, verifying \nthat they are equal and equivalent to the violation of one of the Kolmogorov \naxioms. We also verified that it is possible to create probability functions for \nquantum experiments that represent the Bell and Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt \ninequalities if compatible for changing a Kolmogorov axiom. The dissertation \naims at regarding a few incompatibilities of the Quantum Theory with the \nProbability Theory found in literature, statistically analyzing the formulas \nobtained.