arXiv:2609.30363
Disentangling the Toric Code
Lei Gioia, Salvatore D. Pace, Ruben Verresen, Shu-Heng Shao, Ryan Thorngren
Abstract
Commuting-projector Hamiltonians with integer spectrum such as the 1+1d Ising ferromagnet and the 2+1d toric code may be regarded as the generators of non-on-site $U(1)$ symmetries. In this paper we study whether these symmetries can be made on-site in the presence of finite and infinite-dimensional ancillae. In the finite-dimensional case, we prove that the fractionalized excitations, such as domain walls and anyons, make it impossible to on-site these Hamiltonians. On the other hand, we show that when infinite dimensional ancillae (e.g., rotors) are allowed, both the 1+1d Ising ferromagnet and the 2+1d toric code can be disentangled, yielding on-site symmetries. This is not in contradiction with the non-trivial ground state order of these Hamiltonians, since the ancilla Hamiltonians are no longer bounded from below. Our results indicate agreement between lattice and quantum field theory anomalies in the presence of infinite-dimensional ancillae, while with finite-dimensional ancillae the obstruction to on-siteability may even be non-invertible.
AI Summary
The paper asks when the locality-preserving $U(1)$ symmetries generated by integer-spectrum commuting-projector Hamiltonians can be transformed into on-site actions by finite-depth circuits, and how the answer depends on ancillary Hilbert spaces and charge spectra. Its main examples are the 1D Ising ferromagnet and 2D toric code, normalized so domain walls and elementary anyons carry half-integer charge while total charges on periodic systems are integers. For ancilla generators bounded below or above, it proves obstructions using nonfactorizable operators in the ground-state algebra. Any disentangling QCA requires spread at least $L/8$ for the length-$L$ Ising ring, and at least $\max(L,L')/8$ for the toric code on an $L\times L'$ torus. The obstruction persists upon stacking with other gapped, semibounded generators, so it is non-invertible in this setting. Spectral-polynomial irreducibility gives stronger, unrestricted-unitary obstructions on selected power-of-two system sizes unless a local Hilbert-space dimension grows exponentially. With integer-charged rotor ancillae whose generators are unbounded in both directions, explicit finite-depth circuits instead make both symmetries on-site, including the toric code’s larger $U(1)_e\times U(1)_m$ symmetry. A general construction relates on-siteability with regular-representation ancillae to local factorization into commuting symmetry representations. SRE eigenstates and distinctions between on-siteability and blendability are also examined. These constructions do not trivialize the physical ground-state phases: the enlarged generators lack a lower energy bound. Extension to arbitrary commuting-projector models remains open, as does treatment of finite-range, integer-spectrum Hamiltonians with noncommuting terms.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 14+9 pages, 4 figures