Quantisation is considered as an action of classical point operators on field states at the Planck scale of the phase space. Emphasis is placed on the sequence of physical variables. A "state language/Dirac notation" for classical mechanics is introduced; in many cases, it replaces the principle of stationary action for conservative systems. Observed classical and quantum dynamics are considered as different vectorisations of the free semigroup contribution of time. There is a dream of describing classical dynamics as complex transformations of state vectors over such a free semigroup, rather than solving differential equations. The transition from the alphabet to states, from states to state functions, and from state functions to measurable quantities is managed by projectors. An attempt is made to provide a derivation of the Legendre transformation. The trivial multiplication of the potential energy by the wave function in the coordinate representation and its non-trivial operator action in the momentum representation are obtained without a Fourier transform nor the Planck scale. The quantisation procedure is divided into two stages: first, the action of point-like classical operators on field functions; and second, accounting for the physically finite scale of the Planck length against the backdrop of the possible infinitesimality in the classical phase space. The concept of an angle between states is introduced, defining the measure of "quantumness". The free semigroup time contribution is studied in the context of the Born rule.
AI Summary
The paper explores whether classical mechanics and nonrelativistic quantisation can be expressed through a common state notation built from a free semigroup representing ordered contributions of time. It assigns concatenated time symbols an additive squared length, then constructs trajectory states, field states, projectors, and differential operations. Within this notation, it recovers the Euler–Lagrange equation and presents a Legendre-transform construction using boundary maps on ordered tensor products, obtaining $H+L=p\dot q$.
Quantisation is separated into extending classical point operators to fields and introducing a finite phase-space scale. Projector manipulations express potential energy as multiplication in position space and as an operator in momentum space, without initially invoking a Fourier transform. A postulated minimum phase-space area $|dq\wedge dp|\approx\hbar$ motivates a hemisphere construction with solid angle $\Omega=\arctan[pq/(\sqrt{\hbar}\sqrt{\hbar+p^2+q^2})]$. Assuming the overlap is $A e^{i\Omega}$ gives $\langle q|p\rangle\approx A e^{ipq/\hbar}$ when $p^2+q^2\ll\hbar$; the opposite large-coordinate limit gives $\Omega\to\pi/2$.
The paper connects this overlap approximation to the standard phase-space path integral, emphasizing quadratic Hamiltonians and canonically rescaled coordinates. It also models repeated outcomes as Bernoulli thinning of time-symbol words. Identifying the expected surviving squared-length fraction with Hilbert-space norm scaling yields $p=|C|^2$, with almost-sure frequency convergence by the strong law.
The time construction is presented as a possible approximation, the phase-space cutoff is postulated, and the plane-wave recovery is restricted to a small-coordinate regime. Extension of the Born-rule argument to unequal generator lengths is stated as an expectation rather than established.
Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsUnclear noveltyStrong assumptionsPossible error
Central claim may not hold: The claimed momentum-space potential operator is left as an undefined expression U(⟨p|), obtained using a delta function that does not implement a position–momentum basis transformation.
The assigned solid-angle overlap does not provide the required delta-normalized basis transformation, and its locally valid plane-wave approximation is unjustifiably extended to unrestricted path integrals, whose free-particle momentum scale grows rather than shrinks in the short-time limit.
The abstract's physically finite Planck length is not established by the body's postulate of a phase-space area of order ℏ.
The Legendre-transform argument assigns generally nonclosed edges to H₁ and removes an arbitrary momentum-dependent term through an unsupported prohibition.
The Born-rule argument obtains p = |C_L|² by equating Bernoulli thinning with Hilbert-space scalar multiplication without independently justifying that identification.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
Quantisation is considered as an action of classical point operators on field states at the Planck scale of the phase space. Emphasis is placed on the sequence of physical variables. A "state language/Dirac notation" for classical mechanics is introduced; in many cases, it replaces the principle of stationary action for conservative systems. Observed classical and quantum dynamics are considered as different vectorisations of the free semigroup contribution of time. There is a dream of describing classical dynamics as complex transformations of state vectors over such a free semigroup, rather than solving differential equations. The transition from the alphabet to states, from states to state functions, and from state functions to measurable quantities is managed by projectors. An attempt is made to provide a derivation of the Legendre transformation. The trivial multiplication of the potential energy by the wave function in the coordinate representation and its non-trivial operator action in the momentum representation are obtained without a Fourier transform nor the Planck scale. The quantisation procedure is divided into two stages: first, the action of point-like classical operators on field functions; and second, accounting for the physically finite scale of the Planck length against the backdrop of the possible infinitesimality in the classical phase space. The concept of an angle between states is introduced, defining the measure of "quantumness". The free semigroup time contribution is studied in the context of the Born rule.
The paper explores whether classical mechanics and nonrelativistic quantisation can be expressed through a common state notation built from a free semigroup representing ordered contributions of time. It assigns concatenated time symbols an additive squared length, then constructs trajectory states, field states, projectors, and differential operations. Within this notation, it recovers the Euler–Lagrange equation and presents a Legendre-transform construction using boundary maps on ordered tensor products, obtaining H+L=pq˙.
Quantisation is separated into extending classical point operators to fields and introducing a finite phase-space scale. Projector manipulations express potential energy as multiplication in position space and as an operator in momentum space, without initially invoking a Fourier transform. A postulated minimum phase-space area ∣dq∧dp∣≈ℏ motivates a hemisphere construction with solid angle Ω=arctan[pq/(ℏℏ+p2+q2)]. Assuming the overlap is AeiΩ gives ⟨q∣p⟩≈Aeipq/ℏ when p2+q2≪ℏ; the opposite large-coordinate limit gives Ω→π/2.
The paper connects this overlap approximation to the standard phase-space path integral, emphasizing quadratic Hamiltonians and canonically rescaled coordinates. It also models repeated outcomes as Bernoulli thinning of time-symbol words. Identifying the expected surviving squared-length fraction with Hilbert-space norm scaling yields p=∣C∣2, with almost-sure frequency convergence by the strong law.
The time construction is presented as a possible approximation, the phase-space cutoff is postulated, and the plane-wave recovery is restricted to a small-coordinate regime. Extension of the Born-rule argument to unequal generator lengths is stated as an expectation rather than established.
A quantum mechanical representation suitable for studying the time evolution of quantum densities in phase space is proposed and examined in detail. This representation on ℒ2 (2) phase space is based on definitions of the operators P̂ and Q̂ in phase space that satisfy various correspondences for the Liouville equation in classical and quantum phase space, as well as quantum position and momentum ℒ2 (1) spaces. The definitions presented here, P̂=p/2−iℏ∂/∂q and Q̂=q/2+iℏ∂/∂p, are related to definitions that have been recently proposed [J. Chem. Phys. 93, 8862 (1990)]. The resulting quantum phase space representation shares many of the mathematical properties of usual representations in coordinate and momentum spaces. Within this representation, time evolution equations for complex-valued functions (wave functions) and their square magnitudes (distribution functions) are derived, and it is shown that the coordinate and momentum space time evolution equations can be recovered by a simple Fourier projection. The phase space quantum probability conservation equation obtained is a good illustration of the quantization rule that requires one to replace the classical Poisson bracket between the Hamiltonian and the probability density with the quantum commutator between the corresponding operators. The possible classical analogs to quantum probabilities densities are also considered and some of the present results are illustrated for the dynamics of the coherent state.
Abstract In many texts, the transition from classical mechanics to quantum mechanics is achieved by substituting the action for the phase angle. The paper presents a different approach to show some connections between classical and quantum mechanics for a single particle for an audience at graduate and postgraduate levels. Firstly, it is shown that a wave equation of action can be derived under the free particle condition and the Legendre transform. The wave-like solutions of the action, Hamiltonian and momentum of the free particle are presented. Using the discrete approximation, the equation of motion of a single particle, in scalar potential field, is obtained in a similar form to Schrödinger’s equation. The rest of the paper discusses the propagation, superposition of the wave-like dynamic variables and their connections to quantum mechanics. The superposition of the variables of a particle is generally distinct from the superposition of classical waves (e.g. acoustics). The quantum superposition provides a self-consistent interpretation of the wave-like solutions of the variables. Connections between the classical and quantum relations for corresponding variables are observed from the one-to-one comparisons.
The conventional correspondence basis for quantum dynamics is here replaced by a self-contained quantum dynamical principle from which the equations of motion and the commutation relations can be deduced. The theory is developed in terms of the model supplied by localizable fields. A short review is first presented of the general quantum-mechanical scheme of operators and eigenvectors, in which emphasis is placed on the differential characterization of representatives and transformation functions by means of infinitesimal unitary transformations. The fundamental dynamical principle is stated as a variational equation for the transformation function connecting eigenvectors associated with different spacelike surfaces, which describes the temporal development of the system. The generator of the infinitesimal transformation is the variation of the action integral operator, the space-time volume integral of the invariant lagrange function operator. The invariance of the lagrange function preserves the form of the dynamical principle under coordinate transformations, with the exception of those transformations which include a reversal in the positive sense of time, where a separate discussion is necessary. It will be shown in Sec. III that the requirement of invariance under time reflection imposes a restriction upon the operator properties of fields, which is simply the connection between the spin and statistics of particles. For a given dynamical system, changes in the transformation function arise only from alterations of the eigenvectors associated with the two surfaces, as generated by operators constructed from field variables attached to those surfaces. This yields the operator principle of stationary action, from which the equations of motion are obtained. Commutation relations are derived from the generating operator associated with a given surface. In particular, canonical commutation relations are obtained for those field components that are not restricted by equations of constraint. The surface generating operator also leads to generalized Schrödinger equations for the representative of an arbitrary state. Action integral variations which correspond to changing the dynamical system are discussed briefly. A method for constructing the transformation function is described, in a form appropriate to an integral spin field, which involves solving Hamilton-Jacobi equations for ordered operators. In Sec. III, the exceptional nature of time reflection is indicated by the remark that the charge and the energy-momentum vector behave as a pseudoscalar and pseudovector, respectively, for time reflection transformations. This shows, incidentally, that positive and negative charge must occur symmetrically in a completely covariant theory. The contrast between the pseudo energy-momentum vector and the proper displacement vector then indicates that time reflection cannot be described within the unitary transformation framework. This appears most fundamentally in the basic dynamical principle. It is important to recognize here that the contributions to the lagrange function of half-integral spin fields behave like pseudoscalars with respect to time reflection. The non-unitary transformation required to represent time reflection is found to be the replacement of a state vector by its dual, or complex conjugate vector, together with the transposition of all operators. The fundamental dynamical principle is then invariant under time reflection if inverting the order of all operators in the lagrange function leaves an integral spin contribution unaltered, and reverses the sign of a half-integral spin contribution. This implies the essential commutativity, or anti-commutativity, of integral and half-integral field components, respectively, which is the connection between spin and statistics.
For the case of the quantization of the usual non-relativistic classical Lagrangian function quadratic in the velocity the validity is demonstrated of the non-canonical space-time formulation of quantum mechanics proposed recently by the author, which aims to evaluate, without appealing to the Schrödinger equation, the transformation function K(x,t′;y,t′) in the space representation on the basis of the composition rule K(x, t″; y, t′) = ∫K(x, t″; z, t)dzK(z, t; y, t′) (1) coupled with the supposition that it is approximated to zeroth order in the quantum of action h by the so-called semi-classical kernel Ko(x, t″; y, t′) = [(i/h)∂2S/∂x∂y]1/2 exp [(i/ℏ) S(x,t″; y, t′] (2) written in terms of the classical action S(x, t″; y, t′) alone. In the first place the action function corresponding to the above Lagrangian is expanded in power of the interval of time T = t″ − t′. Then the deviation of the semi-classical kernel (2) from the unitary transformation function is shown to be of the third order in T, and the corresponding correction term is evaluated by solving the integral equation (1). It is also shown that the semi-classical kernel is unitary for a free motion of a particle with its mass being a function in the space coordinate.
A quantization of a fixed classical mechanical system is firstly an association between quantum mechanical observables (preferably self-adjoint operators on Hilbert space) and classical mechanical observables (i.e. real-valued functions on phase space). Secondly, a quantization should permit an interpretation of the correspondence principle that ‘classical mechanics is the limit of quantum mechanics as Planck's constant approaches zero'. With these two underlying precepts, Section 2 states the four basic requirements, I to IV, of a quantization along with an additional requirement V that characterizes the subclass of special quantizations.
The conventional correspondence basis for quantum dynamics is here replaced by a self-contained quantum dynamical principle from which the equations of motion and the commutation relations can be deduced. The theory is developed in terms of the model supplied by localizable fields. A short review is first presented of the general quantum-mechanical scheme of operators and eigenvectors, in which emphasis is placed on the differential characterization of representatives and transformation functions by means of infinitesimal unitary transformations. The fundamental dynamical principle is stated as a variational equation for the transformation function connecting eigenvectors associated with different spacelike surfaces, which describes the temporal development of the system. The generator of the infinitesimal transformation is the variation of the action integral operator, the spacetime volume integral of the invariant lagrange function operator. The invariance of the lagrange function preserves the form of the dynamical principle under coordinate transformations, with the exception of those transformations which include a reversal in the positive sense of time, where a separate discussion is necessary. It will be shown in Sec. III that the requirement of invariance under time reflection imposes a restriction upon the operator properties of fields, which is simply the connection between the spin and statistics of particles. For a given dynamical system, changes in the transformation function arise only from alterations of the eigenvectors associated with the two surfaces, as generated by operators constructed from field variables attached to those surfaces. This yields the operator principle of stationary action, from which the equations of motion are obtained. Commutation relations are derived from the generating operator associated with a given surface. In particular, canonical commutation relations are obtained for those field components that are not restricted by equations of constraint. The surface generating operator also leads to generalized Schr\"odinger equations for the representative of an arbitrary state. Action integral variations which correspond to changing the dynamical system are discussed briefly. A method for constructing the transformation function is described, in a form appropriate to an integral spin field, which involves solving Hamilton-Jacobi equations for ordered operators. In Sec. III, the exceptional nature of time reflection is indicated by the remark that the charge and the energy-momentum vector behave as a pseudoscalar and pseudovector, respectively, for time reflection transformations. This shows, incidentally, that positive and negative charge must occur symmetrically in a completely covariant theory. The contrast between the pseudo energy-momentum vector and the proper displacement vector then indicates that time reflection cannot be described within the unitary transformation framework. This appears most fundamentally in the basic dynamical principle. It is important to recognize here that the contributions to the lagrange function of half-integral spin fields behave like pseudoscalars with respect to time reflection. The non-unitary transformation required to represent time reflection is found to be the replacement of a state vector by its dual, or complex conjugate vector, together with the transposition of all operators. The fundamental dynamical principle is then invariant under time reflection if inverting the order of all operators in the lagrange function leaves an integral spin contribution unaltered, and reverses the sign of a half-integral spin contribution. This implies the essential commutativity, or anti-commutativity, of integral and half-integral field components, respectively, which is the connection between spin and statistics.