Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.25861

Universal Fidelity Law for Linear-Optical Entangling Gates

Haim Nakav, Ofer Firstenberg

quant-phphysics.atom-phphysics.opticsSubmitted Sep 22, 2026• Announced Sep 23, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Imperfect photon sources degrade the performance of interference-based linear-optical entangling gates. We derive a universal fidelity law for these gates in terms of two standard source metrics: Hong-Ou-Mandel visibility and second-order coherence. We model the multiphoton component as an arbitrary overlap between noise and signal photons. While different values of the signal-noise overlap produce different error structures, associated with different physical platforms, all result in the same fidelity law. We test the model on our actively synchronized CNOT-gate experiment and against published results across different platforms, with no free parameters. This framework turns source characterization into a unified benchmark for photonic quantum computing.

AI Summary

The paper asks how photon indistinguishability and multiphoton emission jointly limit post-selected linear-optical CNOT performance, and whether standard source measurements suffice to compare different platforms. It analyzes a three-PPBS CNOT, using Bell-state output fidelity rather than process fidelity, with time-integrated, polarization-resolved coincidence detection. The model retains two- and three-photon input events, including coincidences where one photon exits an unmonitored port. A signal–noise mode overlap interpolates between identical and distinguishable extra photons. At fixed intrinsic indistinguishability $\eta$, the first-order multiphoton error depends on this overlap: at unit delivered brightness and $\eta=1$, its coefficient is $2g^{(2)}(0)$ for identical noise versus $3.5g^{(2)}(0)$ for distinguishable noise. Expressing the result through raw two-source HOM visibility $V$ cancels the noise-overlap dependence. For equal delivered brightness and small mean autocorrelation $g^{(2)}$, the resulting law is $F\simeq(1+V)/(4-2V)-g^{(2)}/[2(2-V)]$, common to all four Bell-state preparations. Delivered brightness also cancels to this order. Comparisons use measurements from a synchronized CNOT and published results across source platforms, without fitted parameters. Four operating points spanning a 3.5-fold change in $g^{(2)}$ show a mean residual infidelity of $0.023\pm0.015$, attributed to circuit imperfections. The stated scope assumes low multiphoton probability, truncates contributions beyond three total photons, and represents noise by a single effective mode shared across multiphoton events. The compact law assumes equal input brightness and matching measurement windows; for non-PPBS architectures it is presented only as an indicative baseline.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsIncrementalStrong assumptions

Central claim may not hold: The claimed generality exceeds the derivation, which concerns Bell-state preparation fidelities of a particular post-selected PPBS CNOT rather than arbitrary linear-optical entangling gates. The dependence on only measured visibility and second-order coherence is correctly derived only to first order under equal delivered brightness and the paper's restricted emission and noise-mode assumptions. The experimental residuals do not independently establish the paper's attribution of all remaining infidelity to circuit imperfections. The detection equations count photon pairs rather than general non-number-resolving detector coincidences, requiring an unstated low-efficiency limit or different measurement protocol and undermining the law's claimed applicability at finite detection efficiency.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
13 pages, 4 figures, 4 tables

Related papers

Hong-Ou-Mandel Interference with Imperfect Single Photon Sources

H. Ollivier, Sarah E. Thomas, Stephen C. Wein +12 more

Hong-Ou-Mandel interference is a cornerstone of optical quantum technologies. We explore both theoretically and experimentally how unwanted multiphoton components of single-photon sources affect the interference visibility, and find that the overlap between the single photons and the noise photons significantly impacts the interference. We apply our approach to quantum dot single-photon sources to access the mean wave packet overlap of the single-photon component. This study provides a consistent platform with which to diagnose the limitations of current single-photon sources on the route towards the ideal device.

arXiv:2005.01743•Physical Review Letters•Feb 12, 2021•101 citations

Quantum interferences and gates with emitter-based coherent photon sources

Ilse Maillette de Buy Wenniger, Stephen C. Wein, Dario Fioretto +10 more

Quantum emitters such as quantum dots, defects in diamond or in silicon have emerged as efficient single-photon sources that are progressively exploited in quantum technologies. In 2019, it was shown that the emitted single-photon states often include coherence with the vacuum component. Here we investigate how such photon-number coherence alters quantum interference experiments that are routinely implemented both for characterizing or exploiting the generated photons. We show that it strongly modifies intensity correlation measurements in a Hong–Ou–Mandel experiment and leads to errors in indistinguishability estimations. It also results in additional entanglement when performing partial measurements. We illustrate the impact on quantum protocols by evidencing modifications in heralding efficiency and fidelity of two-qubit gates.

arXiv:2401.01187•Optica Quantum•Oct 10, 2024•8 citations

Detector imperfections in photon-pair source characterization

Pavel Sekatski, Nicolas Sangouard, Félix Bussières +3 more

We analyse how imperfections in single-photon detectors impact the characterization of photon-pair sources. We perform exact calculations to reveal the effects of multi-pair emissions and of noisy, non-unit efficiency, nonphoton-number resolving detections on the Cauchy–Schwarz parameter, on the second-order auto-correlation and cross-correlation functions, and on the visibilities of both Hong–Ou–Mandel and Bell-like interferences. We consider sources producing either two-mode squeezed states or states with a Poissonian photon distribution. The proposed formulas are useful in practice to determine the impacts of multi-pair emissions and dark counts in standard tests used in quantum optics.

arXiv:1109.0194•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Jun 8, 2012•65 citations

Quantum cnot Gate with Actively Synchronized Photon Pairs

Haim Nakav, Tanim Firdoshi, Omri Davidson +2 more

Controlling the synchronization of photons from probabilistic quantum sources plays a pivotal role in advancing efficient quantum information processing. We report the realization of a probabilistic entangling gate operating on actively synchronized photon pairs, using a quantum memory based on warm atomic vapor. We achieve a truth-table fidelity exceeding 85% and demonstrate Bell-inequality violation for all four Bell states. The reduction in visibility of the Hong-Ou-Mandel interference introduced by the storage process is identified as a primary factor limiting the gate fidelity. We derive an exact quantitative relation between Hong-Ou-Mandel visibility and gate fidelity for pure single photons, which applies to all photonic gates relying on interference, regardless of the physical platform.

arXiv:2505.03960•Physical Review Letters•Nov 25, 2025•4 citations

Parametric downconversion and optical quantum gates: two's company, four's a crowd

Marco Barbieri, Till J. Weinhold, B. P. Lanyon +4 more

We show that the primary cause of errors in a broad class of optical quantum-logic gates are due to the higher-order photon terms in parametric downconversion sources. A model describing real-life imperfections in these entangling gates is presented and tested in an experiment where we entangle dependent photons from the same downconversion source using a controlled-z gate, and measure the state tomographically. We find good agreement between the modelled and measured results. Our investigations demonstrate that, although small, these noise terms are amplified by the intrinsic non-determinism of the gates. It is worth considering alternative schemes based on weak nonlinearities to see if they are more resilient to this degradation.

Journal of Modern Optics•Jan 20, 2009•22 citations

A Quantum Model of Linear Optical Devices for Quantum Computing

Yuan Heng Jiang, Rebecca Jiang

Extending an existing quantum optic model for beamsplitters, a comprehensive model is developed from the first principles of quantum physics to describe photons traversing linear optical devices of arbitrary number of ports and even a circuit of devices, which are essential components of photonic quantum computing gates and circuits. The model derives the quantum operators and states of the photons at the egress ports of a device, gate or circuit from those at the ingress ports. As an application and validation, it is used to model the experiment that discovered the Hong-Ou-Mandel (HOM) effect and to explain the effect without the notion of quantum interference. The experiment is not only a landmark in the research of quantum optics but also important to photonic quantum computing design.

•Nov 1, 2020•0 citations
Imperfect photon sources degrade the performance of interference-based linear-optical entangling gates. We derive a universal fidelity law for these gates in terms of two standard source metrics: Hong-Ou-Mandel visibility and second-order coherence. We model the multiphoton component as an arbitrary overlap between noise and signal photons. While different values of the signal-noise overlap produce different error structures, associated with different physical platforms, all result in the same fidelity law. We test the model on our actively synchronized CNOT-gate experiment and against published results across different platforms, with no free parameters. This framework turns source characterization into a unified benchmark for photonic quantum computing.
The paper asks how photon indistinguishability and multiphoton emission jointly limit post-selected linear-optical CNOT performance, and whether standard source measurements suffice to compare different platforms. It analyzes a three-PPBS CNOT, using Bell-state output fidelity rather than process fidelity, with time-integrated, polarization-resolved coincidence detection.
The model retains two- and three-photon input events, including coincidences where one photon exits an unmonitored port. A signal–noise mode overlap interpolates between identical and distinguishable extra photons. At fixed intrinsic indistinguishability η\etaη, the first-order multiphoton error depends on this overlap: at unit delivered brightness and η=1\eta=1η=1, its coefficient is 2g(2)(0)2g^{(2)}(0)2g(2)(0) for identical noise versus 3.5g(2)(0)3.5g^{(2)}(0)3.5g(2)(0) for distinguishable noise.
Expressing the result through raw two-source HOM visibility VVV cancels the noise-overlap dependence. For equal delivered brightness and small mean autocorrelation g(2)g^{(2)}g(2), the resulting law is F≃(1+V)/(4−2V)−g(2)/[2(2−V)]F\simeq(1+V)/(4-2V)-g^{(2)}/[2(2-V)]F≃(1+V)/(4−2V)−g(2)/[2(2−V)], common to all four Bell-state preparations. Delivered brightness also cancels to this order. Comparisons use measurements from a synchronized CNOT and published results across source platforms, without fitted parameters. Four operating points spanning a 3.5-fold change in g(2)g^{(2)}g(2) show a mean residual infidelity of 0.023±0.0150.023\pm0.0150.023±0.015, attributed to circuit imperfections.
The stated scope assumes low multiphoton probability, truncates contributions beyond three total photons, and represents noise by a single effective mode shared across multiphoton events. The compact law assumes equal input brightness and matching measurement windows; for non-PPBS architectures it is presented only as an indicative baseline.
Hong-Ou-Mandel interference is a cornerstone of optical quantum technologies. We explore both theoretically and experimentally how unwanted multiphoton components of single-photon sources affect the interference visibility, and find that the overlap between the single photons and the noise photons significantly impacts the interference. We apply our approach to quantum dot single-photon sources to access the mean wave packet overlap of the single-photon component. This study provides a consistent platform with which to diagnose the limitations of current single-photon sources on the route towards the ideal device.
Quantum emitters such as quantum dots, defects in diamond or in silicon have emerged as efficient single-photon sources that are progressively exploited in quantum technologies. In 2019, it was shown that the emitted single-photon states often include coherence with the vacuum component. Here we investigate how such photon-number coherence alters quantum interference experiments that are routinely implemented both for characterizing or exploiting the generated photons. We show that it strongly modifies intensity correlation measurements in a Hong–Ou–Mandel experiment and leads to errors in indistinguishability estimations. It also results in additional entanglement when performing partial measurements. We illustrate the impact on quantum protocols by evidencing modifications in heralding efficiency and fidelity of two-qubit gates.
We analyse how imperfections in single-photon detectors impact the characterization of photon-pair sources. We perform exact calculations to reveal the effects of multi-pair emissions and of noisy, non-unit efficiency, nonphoton-number resolving detections on the Cauchy–Schwarz parameter, on the second-order auto-correlation and cross-correlation functions, and on the visibilities of both Hong–Ou–Mandel and Bell-like interferences. We consider sources producing either two-mode squeezed states or states with a Poissonian photon distribution. The proposed formulas are useful in practice to determine the impacts of multi-pair emissions and dark counts in standard tests used in quantum optics.
Controlling the synchronization of photons from probabilistic quantum sources plays a pivotal role in advancing efficient quantum information processing. We report the realization of a probabilistic entangling gate operating on actively synchronized photon pairs, using a quantum memory based on warm atomic vapor. We achieve a truth-table fidelity exceeding 85% and demonstrate Bell-inequality violation for all four Bell states. The reduction in visibility of the Hong-Ou-Mandel interference introduced by the storage process is identified as a primary factor limiting the gate fidelity. We derive an exact quantitative relation between Hong-Ou-Mandel visibility and gate fidelity for pure single photons, which applies to all photonic gates relying on interference, regardless of the physical platform.
We show that the primary cause of errors in a broad class of optical quantum-logic gates are due to the higher-order photon terms in parametric downconversion sources. A model describing real-life imperfections in these entangling gates is presented and tested in an experiment where we entangle dependent photons from the same downconversion source using a controlled-z gate, and measure the state tomographically. We find good agreement between the modelled and measured results. Our investigations demonstrate that, although small, these noise terms are amplified by the intrinsic non-determinism of the gates. It is worth considering alternative schemes based on weak nonlinearities to see if they are more resilient to this degradation.
Extending an existing quantum optic model for beamsplitters, a comprehensive model is developed from the first principles of quantum physics to describe photons traversing linear optical devices of arbitrary number of ports and even a circuit of devices, which are essential components of photonic quantum computing gates and circuits. The model derives the quantum operators and states of the photons at the egress ports of a device, gate or circuit from those at the ingress ports. As an application and validation, it is used to model the experiment that discovered the Hong-Ou-Mandel (HOM) effect and to explain the effect without the notion of quantum interference. The experiment is not only a landmark in the research of quantum optics but also important to photonic quantum computing design.