arXiv:2609.25360
Operator-Level Quantum-Classical Correspondence in Relativistic Quantum Theory and Curved Spacetime
Pankaj Sheoran, Gopal Kashyap, Sanjay Siwach
Abstract
In a recent work \cite{Shaikh:2026nsi}, it was shown that for a non-relativistic particle, the operator equations of motion can be cast in the same differential form as Newton's equation of motion. This establishes a correspondence between quantum operator dynamics and classical mechanics at the level of the equations of motion. In this work, we investigate whether this correspondence extends to quantum field theory and linearized gravity. We explicitly show that the Heisenberg equations of motion for quantum field operators reproduce the corresponding classical equations of motion for a broad class of field theories. The Klein-Gordon equation, Maxwell's equations, Yang-Mills equations, and linearized Einstein equations are shown to arise at the operator level without taking the limit $\hbar\rightarrow0$. We then extend the analysis to curved spacetime and show that the quantum field operators satisfy the corresponding covariant field equations at the operator level. In the weak-field approximation, we show that the Heisenberg evolution of the metric-perturbations reproduces the linearized Einstein equations at the operator level. For a quantum particle in curved spacetime, the Heisenberg equations for position and momentum reproduce classical geodesic motion in the semiclassical limit, thereby extending the operator-level quantum-classical correspondence from fields to particle dynamics.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether Heisenberg-picture operator equations retain the differential form of classical equations for relativistic fields, fields on curved backgrounds, and weak gravitational perturbations, without taking $\hbar\to0$. It distinguishes this formal correspondence from classical behavior of expectation values: observables remain noncommuting, and predictions still depend on the quantum state. Starting from classical Lagrangians, it constructs Hamiltonians, promotes canonical variables to operators, and evaluates Heisenberg equations using equal-time canonical commutators or anticommutators. The calculations recover operator Klein–Gordon equations for free and quartically interacting scalar fields, Dirac equations for free fermions and fermions coupled to scalar, electromagnetic, and non-Abelian gauge fields, and covariant scalar, Dirac, and source-free Maxwell equations on curved backgrounds. Cancellation of the canonical $\hbar$ factor against the Heisenberg prefactor is explicit, although mass and interaction terms can retain $\hbar$ through the chosen normalization. For gravity, the paper discusses the semiclassical Einstein equation with a renormalized stress-tensor expectation value and derives the vacuum linearized wave equation $\Box\hat h_{\mu\nu}=0$ in harmonic gauge. A separate particle calculation uses a Laplace–Beltrami Hamiltonian, including an optional curvature coupling, to obtain geodesic-form motion at leading semiclassical order. The gravitational analysis is restricted to weak fields and a gauge-fixed dynamical sector; a complete constrained canonical treatment is not supplied. The particle result neglects ordering corrections of order $\hbar$ and higher. No classical-state approximation is invoked for the field-operator calculations, whereas recovering classical particle motion explicitly uses a semiclassical approximation.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract claims a derivation of the Yang–Mills equations, but the non-Abelian calculation derives only the Dirac matter equation and omits the gauge-field dynamics. The displayed linearized-gravity evolution is not equivalent to the covariant equation subsequently asserted, and its trace does not yield the claimed wave equation. The curved-spacetime Dirac derivation uses an incompatible flat-normalized anticommutator and incorrectly treats curved γ^0 as its own inverse, invalidating its claimed general-background derivation. The electromagnetic momentum definition and displayed evolution imply a relative minus sign between temporal and spatial derivatives, contradicting the Maxwell equation subsequently asserted.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 15 pages, including 1 appendix