Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.25336

Thermalization and dephasing in an isolated system of coupled qubits

Jukka P. Pekola, Bayan Karimi

quant-phcond-mat.mes-hallSubmitted Sep 21, 2026• Announced Sep 23, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A system evolving unitarily does not dephase or thermalize by definition. Yet, if one considers a part of a unitary system, situation is different. Here we analyze an isolated set of coupled qubits taking one qubit at a time as a subsystem, and writing self-consistently a weak-coupling master equation for it. Weakly anharmonic oscillators and ideal qubits (two-level systems) demonstrate dephasing, i.e. the diagonal elements of the density matrix reach a steady-state in the long-time limit, and the off-diagonal elements of ideal qubits decay exponentially. For the linear coupling between the qubits, only the degenerate ones interact, and the system does not reach thermal distribution. However, non-linearity, in our analysis in form of three-wave mixing, ensures a thermal distribution in the long time limit, where the temperature is determined uniquely by the energy in the initial non-thermal state. Finally, we present a potential experimental scheme based on a superconducting quantum circuit.

AI Summary

The paper studies when individual qubits in an isolated, unitarily evolving ensemble lose coherence and approach thermal populations. It considers all-to-all coupled weakly anharmonic oscillators and ideal two-level systems, comparing excitation-conserving exchange coupling with excitation-nonconserving three-wave mixing. The analysis treats each element as a subsystem coupled to the remaining elements and closes weak-coupling master equations self-consistently using their evolving populations. Numerical solutions, including oscillator ensembles with $N=100$ and two-level ensembles with up to $N=300$, approach Gibbs populations under three-wave mixing for the tested initial conditions and coupling profiles. The final temperature is obtained from conservation of the initial excitation energy. For equally spaced frequencies $\Omega_k=k\Delta\Omega$, integral approximations give $\beta\hbar\Delta\Omega\approx\pi/\sqrt{6\Delta\varepsilon}$ for oscillators and $\pi/\sqrt{12\Delta\varepsilon}$ for two-level systems in the regimes considered, where $\Delta\varepsilon=\Delta E/(\hbar\Delta\Omega)$. Single-qubit coherences decay in the master-equation dynamics. For exchange coupling, strict weak-coupling resonance conditions restrict energy transfer to degenerate elements, preventing thermal redistribution in this description. A separate single-excitation analysis with level broadening yields nonthermal Lorentzian population profiles. A superconducting circuit using asymmetric Josephson loops and inductive coupling is proposed as a possible implementation. The stated limitations include weak coupling, perturbative treatment of oscillator anharmonicity, and the assumed uniform frequency distribution. Convergence to a unique thermal state is supported numerically rather than proved analytically; possible fragmentation or localization for nonuniform spectra is discussed. The thermalization simulations solve the closed master equations rather than the full many-body unitary dynamics.

No sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsStrong assumptionsMissing comparisonUnclear novelty

Central claim may not hold: The numerical evidence establishes convergence of approximate self-consistent rate equations, rather than thermalization of the corresponding isolated many-body unitary system. Nonzero all-to-all coupling does not ensure thermalization under the stated equations because their strict energy-conservation delta functions forbid all three-wave transitions when additive frequency resonances are absent. Supplemental Fig. S2 reports redistribution from the unique number state at excitation energy ℏΔΩ, although no energy-conserving three-wave transition can leave that state. The rate equations incorrectly factorize repeated-mode correlations, allowing two-quanta absorption from a singly occupied oscillator and analogous forbidden processes for ideal qubits.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

Dephasing of entangled qubits

P. Nalbach

We investigate the influence of nearby two-level systems on the dynamics of a qubit. The intrinsic decoherence is given by a coupling of both the qubit and the two-level systems to a heat bath. Assuming weak interactions between the qubit and the two-level systems we show that the dephasing of the qubit follows a multi-exponential decay. For a flat distribution of energy splittings of the two-level systems the multi-exponential behavior simplifies to a good approximation to a single exponential decay. The rate is given by the sum of the dephasing rate of the isolated qubit plus all relaxation rates for the two-level systems out of their present state. This latter contribution sums up to a rate approximately given by the mean coupling between the qubit and the two-level systems times the number of thermally active neighbors.

arXiv:cond-mat/0107156•Jul 6, 2001•2 citations

A novel scheme for modelling dissipation (gain) and thermalization in open quantum systems

Fardin Kheirandish, Elmira Bolandhemmat, Narges Cheraghpour +2 more

Abstract In this letter, we introduce a novel method for investigating dissipation (gain) and thermalization in an open quantum system. In this method, the quantum system is coupled linearly with a copy of itself or with another system described by a finite number of bosonic operators. The time-dependent coupling functions play a fundamental role in this scheme. To demonstrate the efficiency and significance of the method, we apply it to some ubiquitous open quantum systems. Firstly, we investigate a quantum oscillator in the presence of a thermal bath at the inverse temperature β, obtaining the reduced density matrix, the Husimi distribution function, and the quantum heat distribution function accurately. The results are consistent with existing literature by appropriate choices for the time-dependent coupling function. To illustrate the generalizability of this method to systems interacting with multiple thermal baths, we study the interaction of a quantum oscillator with two thermal baths at different temperatures and obtain compatible results. Subsequently, we analyze a two-level atom with energy or phase dissipation and derive the spontaneous emission and the pure dephasing processes consistently using the new method. Finally, we investigate the Markovianity in a dissipative two-level system.

arXiv:2404.10286•Physica Scripta•Nov 27, 2024•2 citations

Long-Time Relaxation of a Finite Spin Bath Linearly Coupled to a Qubit

Jukka P Pekola, Bayan Karimi, Marco Cattaneo +1 more

We discuss the long-time relaxation of a qubit linearly coupled to a finite bath of [Formula: see text] spins (two-level systems, TLSs), with the interaction Hamiltonian in rotating wave approximation. We focus on the regime [Formula: see text], assuming that the qubit–bath coupling is weak, that the range of spin frequencies is sufficiently broad, and that all the spins are initialized in the ground state. Despite the model being perfectly integrable, we make two interesting observations about the effective system relaxation. First, as one would expect, the qubit relaxes exponentially towards its zero-temperature state at a well characterized rate. Second, the bath spins, even when mutually coupled, do not relax towards a thermal distribution, but rather form a Lorentzian distribution peaked at the frequency of the initially excited qubit. This behaviour is captured by an analytical approximation that makes use of the property [Formula: see text] to treat the TLS frequencies as a continuum and is confirmed by our numerical simulations.

arXiv:2305.08692•Open Systems & Information Dynamics•Jun 1, 2023•6 citations

Decoherence in an anharmonic oscillator coupled to a thermal environment: A semiclassical forward-backward approach

Yossi Elran, Paul W. Brumer

The decoherence of an anharmonic oscillator in a thermal harmonic bath is examined via a semiclassical approach. A computational strategy is presented and exploited to calculate the time dependence of the purity and the decay of individual matrix elements in the energy representation for a variety of initial states. The time dependence of the decoherence is found to depend on the temperature of the bath, the coupling strength, the initial state of the oscillator, and the choice of quantity measuring the decoherence. Recurrences in the purity and in the off-diagonal matrix elements are observed, as well as the collapse of these matrix elements to the diagonal, providing evidence for the retention of quantum coherence for time scales longer than that indicated by the purity. The results are used to analyze the utility of the Caldeira-Leggett and Redfield models of decoherence and to assess the dependence of dephasing rates on the degree of structure in phase space. In several cases we find that the dephasing dynamics can be described as an initial Zeno-effect regime, followed by a Caldeira-Leggett region, followed by recurrences.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 23, 2004•33 citations

Nonequilibrium thermal entanglement for simple qubit systems

Ilya Sinayskiy, N. Pumulo, Francesco Petruccione

The dynamics of simple qubit systems in a chain configuration coupled at both ends to separate bosonic baths at different temperatures is studied. An exact analytical solution of the master equation in the Born-Markov approximation for the reduced density matrix of the qubit system is constructed. The unique non-equilibrium stationary state for the long time behavior of the reduced density matrix in obtained. Dynamical and steady state properties of the concurrence between the first and the last spin are studied.

arXiv:1401.2306•Jan 10, 2014•1 citation

Partial decoherence and thermalization through time-domain ergodicity

R. Englman, Asher Yahalom A

An approach, differing from two commonly used methods (the stochastic Schr\"odinger equation and the master equation) but entrenched in the traditional density matrix formalism, is developed in a semiclassical setting in order to go from the solutions of the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation to decohering and thermalized states. This is achieved by utilizing the time ergodicity, rather than the sampling (or ensemble) ergodicity, of physical systems. We introduce the formalism through a study of the Rabi model (a two-level system coupled to an oscillator) and show that our semiclassical version exhibits, both qualitatively and quantitatively, many features of state truncation and equilibration. We then study the time evolution of two qubits in interaction with a bosonic environment, such that the energy scale of one qubit is much larger and that of the other is much smaller than the environment's energy scale. The low-energy qubit decoheres to a mixture, while the high-energy qubit is protected through the adiabatic theorem. However, an interqubit coupling generates an overall decoherence and leads, for some values of the coupling, to long-term revivals in the state occupations.

arXiv:1306.4220•Physical Review A•May 17, 2013•2 citations
A system evolving unitarily does not dephase or thermalize by definition. Yet, if one considers a part of a unitary system, situation is different. Here we analyze an isolated set of coupled qubits taking one qubit at a time as a subsystem, and writing self-consistently a weak-coupling master equation for it. Weakly anharmonic oscillators and ideal qubits (two-level systems) demonstrate dephasing, i.e. the diagonal elements of the density matrix reach a steady-state in the long-time limit, and the off-diagonal elements of ideal qubits decay exponentially. For the linear coupling between the qubits, only the degenerate ones interact, and the system does not reach thermal distribution. However, non-linearity, in our analysis in form of three-wave mixing, ensures a thermal distribution in the long time limit, where the temperature is determined uniquely by the energy in the initial non-thermal state. Finally, we present a potential experimental scheme based on a superconducting quantum circuit.
The paper studies when individual qubits in an isolated, unitarily evolving ensemble lose coherence and approach thermal populations. It considers all-to-all coupled weakly anharmonic oscillators and ideal two-level systems, comparing excitation-conserving exchange coupling with excitation-nonconserving three-wave mixing.
The analysis treats each element as a subsystem coupled to the remaining elements and closes weak-coupling master equations self-consistently using their evolving populations. Numerical solutions, including oscillator ensembles with N=100N=100N=100 and two-level ensembles with up to N=300N=300N=300, approach Gibbs populations under three-wave mixing for the tested initial conditions and coupling profiles. The final temperature is obtained from conservation of the initial excitation energy. For equally spaced frequencies Ωk=kΔΩ\Omega_k=k\Delta\OmegaΩk​=kΔΩ, integral approximations give βℏΔΩ≈π/6Δε\beta\hbar\Delta\Omega\approx\pi/\sqrt{6\Delta\varepsilon}βℏΔΩ≈π/6Δε​ for oscillators and π/12Δε\pi/\sqrt{12\Delta\varepsilon}π/12Δε​ for two-level systems in the regimes considered, where Δε=ΔE/(ℏΔΩ)\Delta\varepsilon=\Delta E/(\hbar\Delta\Omega)Δε=ΔE/(ℏΔΩ). Single-qubit coherences decay in the master-equation dynamics.
For exchange coupling, strict weak-coupling resonance conditions restrict energy transfer to degenerate elements, preventing thermal redistribution in this description. A separate single-excitation analysis with level broadening yields nonthermal Lorentzian population profiles. A superconducting circuit using asymmetric Josephson loops and inductive coupling is proposed as a possible implementation.
The stated limitations include weak coupling, perturbative treatment of oscillator anharmonicity, and the assumed uniform frequency distribution. Convergence to a unique thermal state is supported numerically rather than proved analytically; possible fragmentation or localization for nonuniform spectra is discussed. The thermalization simulations solve the closed master equations rather than the full many-body unitary dynamics.
We investigate the influence of nearby two-level systems on the dynamics of a qubit. The intrinsic decoherence is given by a coupling of both the qubit and the two-level systems to a heat bath. Assuming weak interactions between the qubit and the two-level systems we show that the dephasing of the qubit follows a multi-exponential decay. For a flat distribution of energy splittings of the two-level systems the multi-exponential behavior simplifies to a good approximation to a single exponential decay. The rate is given by the sum of the dephasing rate of the isolated qubit plus all relaxation rates for the two-level systems out of their present state. This latter contribution sums up to a rate approximately given by the mean coupling between the qubit and the two-level systems times the number of thermally active neighbors.
Abstract In this letter, we introduce a novel method for investigating dissipation (gain) and thermalization in an open quantum system. In this method, the quantum system is coupled linearly with a copy of itself or with another system described by a finite number of bosonic operators. The time-dependent coupling functions play a fundamental role in this scheme. To demonstrate the efficiency and significance of the method, we apply it to some ubiquitous open quantum systems. Firstly, we investigate a quantum oscillator in the presence of a thermal bath at the inverse temperature β, obtaining the reduced density matrix, the Husimi distribution function, and the quantum heat distribution function accurately. The results are consistent with existing literature by appropriate choices for the time-dependent coupling function. To illustrate the generalizability of this method to systems interacting with multiple thermal baths, we study the interaction of a quantum oscillator with two thermal baths at different temperatures and obtain compatible results. Subsequently, we analyze a two-level atom with energy or phase dissipation and derive the spontaneous emission and the pure dephasing processes consistently using the new method. Finally, we investigate the Markovianity in a dissipative two-level system.
We discuss the long-time relaxation of a qubit linearly coupled to a finite bath of [Formula: see text] spins (two-level systems, TLSs), with the interaction Hamiltonian in rotating wave approximation. We focus on the regime [Formula: see text], assuming that the qubit–bath coupling is weak, that the range of spin frequencies is sufficiently broad, and that all the spins are initialized in the ground state. Despite the model being perfectly integrable, we make two interesting observations about the effective system relaxation. First, as one would expect, the qubit relaxes exponentially towards its zero-temperature state at a well characterized rate. Second, the bath spins, even when mutually coupled, do not relax towards a thermal distribution, but rather form a Lorentzian distribution peaked at the frequency of the initially excited qubit. This behaviour is captured by an analytical approximation that makes use of the property [Formula: see text] to treat the TLS frequencies as a continuum and is confirmed by our numerical simulations.
The decoherence of an anharmonic oscillator in a thermal harmonic bath is examined via a semiclassical approach. A computational strategy is presented and exploited to calculate the time dependence of the purity and the decay of individual matrix elements in the energy representation for a variety of initial states. The time dependence of the decoherence is found to depend on the temperature of the bath, the coupling strength, the initial state of the oscillator, and the choice of quantity measuring the decoherence. Recurrences in the purity and in the off-diagonal matrix elements are observed, as well as the collapse of these matrix elements to the diagonal, providing evidence for the retention of quantum coherence for time scales longer than that indicated by the purity. The results are used to analyze the utility of the Caldeira-Leggett and Redfield models of decoherence and to assess the dependence of dephasing rates on the degree of structure in phase space. In several cases we find that the dephasing dynamics can be described as an initial Zeno-effect regime, followed by a Caldeira-Leggett region, followed by recurrences.
The dynamics of simple qubit systems in a chain configuration coupled at both ends to separate bosonic baths at different temperatures is studied. An exact analytical solution of the master equation in the Born-Markov approximation for the reduced density matrix of the qubit system is constructed. The unique non-equilibrium stationary state for the long time behavior of the reduced density matrix in obtained. Dynamical and steady state properties of the concurrence between the first and the last spin are studied.
An approach, differing from two commonly used methods (the stochastic Schr\"odinger equation and the master equation) but entrenched in the traditional density matrix formalism, is developed in a semiclassical setting in order to go from the solutions of the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation to decohering and thermalized states. This is achieved by utilizing the time ergodicity, rather than the sampling (or ensemble) ergodicity, of physical systems. We introduce the formalism through a study of the Rabi model (a two-level system coupled to an oscillator) and show that our semiclassical version exhibits, both qualitatively and quantitatively, many features of state truncation and equilibration. We then study the time evolution of two qubits in interaction with a bosonic environment, such that the energy scale of one qubit is much larger and that of the other is much smaller than the environment's energy scale. The low-energy qubit decoheres to a mixture, while the high-energy qubit is protected through the adiabatic theorem. However, an interqubit coupling generates an overall decoherence and leads, for some values of the coupling, to long-term revivals in the state occupations.