arXiv:2609.25243
Extended symmetric quantum phase in a honeycomb Heisenberg model with sublattice-selective interactions
Nai Chao Hu, Xing-Yu Zhang, Yuchi He, Nick Bultinck
Abstract
Motivated by two-dimensional bilayer systems we numerically study an anti-ferromagnetic spin-$1/2$ Heisenberg model on the honeycomb lattice with a nearest-neighbour exchange coupling $J_1$, and a next-nearest-neighbour exchange coupling $J_2'$ for the B sublattice sites only. Using infinite Projected Entangled-Pair States (iPEPS), variational uniform matrix-product states on cylinders, and exact diagonalization, we find an extended symmetric regime $0.4\lesssim J'_2/J_1\lesssim0.6$, in which local observables show no magnetic, valence-bond, or chiral spin order. At $J'_2/J_1=0.5$, the PEPS correlation length grows systematically with bond dimension, and an inverse-correlation-length extrapolation favors a vanishing limit. We also find that various observables scale algebraically with the finite bond-dimension-induced correlation length, which points to a gapless spin liquid ground state. We propose a $\mathbb{Z}_2$ Dirac spin liquid parton state, with Dirac points that are protected by translation, time-reversal and three-fold rotation symmetry, as a promising candidate state to explain the numerical results. We also discuss the possibility that the symmetric ground state is a featureless, short-range entangled state with a small gap.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether sublattice-selective frustration can stabilize a symmetric quantum phase in a simple spin-$1/2$ honeycomb Heisenberg model. It considers antiferromagnetic nearest-neighbour exchange $J_1$ and next-nearest-neighbour exchange $J'_2$ acting only on the $B$ sublattice. The exchange matrix has an exactly flat lowest band at $J'_2/J_1=1/\sqrt{3}$. Combining infinite PEPS, SU(2)-symmetric cylinder VUMPS, and 24-site exact diagonalization, it identifies a quantum-disordered regime around $0.4\lesssim J'_2/J_1\lesssim0.6$. Magnetization extrapolations indicate loss of Néel order near $0.4$; comparisons with plaquette-VBS ansätze, bond correlations, and chirality measurements find no magnetic, valence-bond, or chiral order in the intermediate regime. Finite-momentum correlations become dominant near $0.6$, although the ensuing phase remains unresolved. A unique PEPS transfer-matrix fixed point and return to the initial cylinder state after $2\pi$ spin-flux insertion are presented as evidence against gapped topological order. At $J'_2/J_1=0.5$, the PEPS correlation length grows from $0.94$ to $2.18$ as bond dimension increases from $4$ to $10$. Extrapolation is compatible with divergence, and energy scaling is compatible with a $z=1$ gapless state. A candidate $\mathbb{Z}_2$ Dirac spin liquid has nodes protected by translation, time reversal, and threefold rotation without inversion symmetry. However, correlation lengths remain short, extrapolations depend on the fitted bond dimensions, and scaling exponents are unresolved. A featureless short-range-entangled state with a small gap cannot be excluded. A possible moiré-TMD realization is also discussed.
Error found: The paper claims to rule out gapped topological order, although returning to the initial state after spin-flux insertion and finding a unique transfer-matrix fixed point in a finite-bond-dimension variational state do not generally exclude topological order in the exact ground state.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 20 pages, 22 figures