Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.24169

No violation on a generalisation of Leggett-Garg inequality and Bell-CHSH inequality with extended probability

Sirawit Kajonsombat, Pongwit Srisangyingcharoen

quant-phSubmitted Sep 21, 2026• Announced Sep 22, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A generalisation of the Leggett-Garg inequality (LGI) and the Bell-CHSH inequality is proposed in this work, by replacing a classical probability notion with an extended probability notion. The extended probability serves as an underlying layer of reality to the classical probability. Within the consistent history framework, the underlying layer is so-called a non-settleable history. Hence, the bounds of the LGIs and Bell-CHSH inequalities are extended. The resulting generalised inequalities are satisfied without violation for arbitrary measurement settings. Furthermore, generalised Macro- realism and generalised Local realism are introduced and analysed within the extended probability framework without relying on an explicit measurement. This opens up further possibilities on one of the great pursuits in physics, understanding on how a quantum system can possess classical properties.

AI Summary

The paper asks how Leggett–Garg and Bell–CHSH bounds change when nonnegative joint probabilities are replaced by signed quasiprobabilities, and whether the resulting description supports generalised notions of macrorealism and local realism. It uses the consistent-history expression $q(\alpha)=\operatorname{Re}\operatorname{Tr}(C_\alpha\rho)$, where $C_\alpha$ is a product of projectors. For four-variable histories, it defines an “extended unity” $\mathscr{I}_4=\sum_\alpha|q(\alpha)|\geq1$. Marginalisation and the triangle inequality give $|K_4|\leq2\mathscr{I}_4$ and $|B_4|\leq2\mathscr{I}_4$: each deterministic Leggett–Garg or CHSH combination has magnitude two. The correlations themselves retain their usual values; the bounds change. These inequalities therefore hold for any settings admitting the specified signed joint representation. Nonnegative histories recover $\mathscr{I}_4=1$ and the standard bound of two. Explicit spin-projector expressions and numerical angle sweeps illustrate the construction for a single spin and a two-spin singlet. The paper also examines reduction from four to three variables. Identical adjacent sharp projectors preserve the corresponding total-variation norm, whereas unsharp effects can yield $\mathscr{I}_{4\rightarrow3}\geq\mathscr{I}_3$ without equality. Interpretively, it proposes generalised macrorealism and local realism formulated using extended probabilities rather than actual measurements. The stated caveats concern interpretation: extended probabilities need not represent observable histories, counterfactual assignments across incompatible consistent-history frameworks require additional choices, and no generalised Fine theorem is established. Consequently, a local-hidden-variable interpretation is not generally guaranteed by satisfaction of the new inequalities.

No sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsUnclear noveltyStrong assumptionsPossible error

Error found: The displayed singlet quasiprobability has incorrect cross-party quadratic signs and an incorrect quartic coefficient, and disagrees with its defining projector expression even when all measurement directions coincide. Satisfaction of the signed-probability bounds does not establish the generalised macrorealism or local realism that the paper infers from it. The quasiprobability's marginal consistency does not imply the independence between times required by the paper's definition of non-invasive extended probability.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
9 pages, 4 figures

Related papers

Condition for macroscopic realism beyond the Leggett-Garg inequalities

Johannes Kofler, Časlav Brukner

In 1985, Leggett and Garg put forward the concept of macroscopic realism (macrorealism) and, in analogy to Bell's theorem, derived a necessary condition in terms of inequalities, which are now known as the Leggett-Garg inequalities. In this paper, we discuss another necessary condition called no-signaling in time. It solely bases on comparing the probability distribution for a macrovariable at some time for the cases where previously a measurement has or has not been performed. Although the concept is analogous to the no-signaling condition in the case of Bell tests, it can be violated according to quantum mechanical predictions even in situations where no violation of Leggett-Garg inequalities is possible.

arXiv:1207.3666•Physical Review A•May 13, 2013•209 citations

The Leggett-Garg Inequalities and Non-Invasive Measurability

JM Yearsley

The Leggett-Garg inequalities are a set of inequalities obeyed by classical systems but violated in quantum theory. Their violation has been taken as evidence that quantum theory lacks a `realistic' formulation. However in addition to realism the derivation of the Leggett-Garg inequalities relies on another, more obscure assumption of `non-invasive measurability.' The significance of this assumption and the consequences for the interpretation of violations of the Leggett-Garg inequalities have been hotly debated. In this paper we present a pedagogical introduction to the issues, focussing on the significance of non-invasive measurability. We give a simple derivation of the Leggett-Garg inequalities paying particular attention to where and when the two assumptions are used, and we give an example of a realist but not non-invasively measurable hidden variable theory which violates them. We also discuss recent attempts to experimentally implement non-invasive measurements via so called `undetectable measurements' and we show that even undetectable measurements are not necessarily non-invasive.

arXiv:1310.2149•Oct 8, 2013•14 citations

Modeling Leggett-Garg-inequality violation

Saulo V. Moreira, Arne Keller, T. Coudreau +1 more

The Leggett-Garg inequality is a widely used test of the ``quantumness'' of a system and involves correlations between measurements realized at different times. According to its widespread interpretation, a violation of the Leggett-Garg inequality disproves macroscopic realism and noninvasiveness. Nevertheless, recent results point out that macroscopic realism is a model-dependent notion and that one should always be able to attribute to invasiveness a violation of a Leggett-Garg inequality. This opens some natural questions: How do we provide such an attribution in a systematic way? How can apparent macroscopic realism violation be recast into a dimensional-independent invasiveness model? The present work answers these questions by introducing an operational model where the effects of invasiveness are controllable through a parameter associated with what is called the measurability of the physical system. Such a parameter leads to different generalized measurements that can be associated with the dimensionality of a system, to measurement errors, or to back action.

arXiv:1506.04993•Physical Review A•Dec 30, 2015•28 citations

Hidden nonmacrorealism: Reviving the Leggett-Garg inequality with stochastic operations

Huan-Yu Ku, Hao‐Cheng Weng, Yen-An Shih +5 more

The Leggett-Garg inequality (LGI) distinguishes nonmacrorealistic channels from macrorealistic ones by constraining the experimental outcomes of the underlying system. In this work, we propose a class of channels which, initially, cannot violate the LGI (in the form of the temporal Bell inequality) but can violate it after the application of stochastic pre- and post-operations (SPPOs). As a proof-of-principle experiment, we demonstrate the stochastic pre- and post-operations in an amplitude-damping channel with photonic qubits. We denote the above phenomenon as hidden nonmacrorealistic channels. We also discuss the relationship between these hidden nonmacrorealistic channels [in terms of the temporal Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality] and the strongly nonlocality-breaking channel, which breaks the hidden spatial CHSH nonlocality for arbitrary states. In general, if the channel satisfies hidden nonmacrorealism, it is not a strongly CHSH nonlocality-breaking channel.

arXiv:2105.08273•Physical Review Research•Oct 29, 2021•9 citations

A Probability Model for the Bell Experiment

Kees van Hee, Kees van Berkel, J. de Graaf

The Bell inequality constrains the outcomes of measurements on pairs of distant entangled particles. The Bell contradiction states that the Bell inequality is inconsistent with the calculated outcomes of these quantum experiments. This contradiction led many to question the underlying assumptions, viz. so-called realism and locality. The probability model underlying the Bell inequality is generally left implicit. We propose an explicit probability model for the CHSH version of the Bell experiment. This model has only two simultaneously observable detector settings per measurement, and therefore does not assume realism. The quantum expectation now becomes a conditional expectation, given the two detector settings. This probability model is in full agreement with both quantum mechanics and experiments. As a result, the model satisfies the Bell inequality; there are no so-called violations. We extend this model to include a hidden variable. This extended model is not Bell-separable. This non-separability implies that the model is non-deterministic or non-local (or both).

arXiv:2302.05174•Quantum Reports•Feb 14, 2026•1 citation

About what can be witnessed by a Leggett—Garg inequality test: modeling its violation

Saulo V. Moreira, Arne Keller, T. Coudreau +1 more

The Leggett-Garg inequality is a widely used test of the "quantumness" of a system, and involves correlations between measurements realized at different times. According to its widespread interpretation, a violation of the Legget-Garg inequality disproves macroscopic realism and non-invasiveness. Nevertheless, recent results point out that macroscopic realism is a model dependent notion and that one should always be able to attribute to invasiveness a violation of a Legget-Garg inequality. This opens some natural questions: how to provide such an attribution in a systematic way? How can apparent macroscopic realism violation be recast into a dimensional independent invasiveness model? The present work answers these questions by introducing an operational model where the effects of invasiveness are controllable through a parameter associated with what is called the measurability of the physical system. Such a parameter leads to different generalized measurements that can be associated with the dimensionality of a system, to measurement errors or to back action.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Mar 1, 2016•1 citation
A generalisation of the Leggett-Garg inequality (LGI) and the Bell-CHSH inequality is proposed in this work, by replacing a classical probability notion with an extended probability notion. The extended probability serves as an underlying layer of reality to the classical probability. Within the consistent history framework, the underlying layer is so-called a non-settleable history. Hence, the bounds of the LGIs and Bell-CHSH inequalities are extended. The resulting generalised inequalities are satisfied without violation for arbitrary measurement settings. Furthermore, generalised Macro- realism and generalised Local realism are introduced and analysed within the extended probability framework without relying on an explicit measurement. This opens up further possibilities on one of the great pursuits in physics, understanding on how a quantum system can possess classical properties.
The paper asks how Leggett–Garg and Bell–CHSH bounds change when nonnegative joint probabilities are replaced by signed quasiprobabilities, and whether the resulting description supports generalised notions of macrorealism and local realism. It uses the consistent-history expression q(α)=Re⁡Tr⁡(Cαρ)q(\alpha)=\operatorname{Re}\operatorname{Tr}(C_\alpha\rho)q(α)=ReTr(Cα​ρ), where CαC_\alphaCα​ is a product of projectors.
For four-variable histories, it defines an “extended unity” I4=∑α∣q(α)∣≥1\mathscr{I}_4=\sum_\alpha|q(\alpha)|\geq1I4​=∑α​∣q(α)∣≥1. Marginalisation and the triangle inequality give ∣K4∣≤2I4|K_4|\leq2\mathscr{I}_4∣K4​∣≤2I4​ and ∣B4∣≤2I4|B_4|\leq2\mathscr{I}_4∣B4​∣≤2I4​: each deterministic Leggett–Garg or CHSH combination has magnitude two. The correlations themselves retain their usual values; the bounds change. These inequalities therefore hold for any settings admitting the specified signed joint representation. Nonnegative histories recover I4=1\mathscr{I}_4=1I4​=1 and the standard bound of two. Explicit spin-projector expressions and numerical angle sweeps illustrate the construction for a single spin and a two-spin singlet.
The paper also examines reduction from four to three variables. Identical adjacent sharp projectors preserve the corresponding total-variation norm, whereas unsharp effects can yield I4→3≥I3\mathscr{I}_{4\rightarrow3}\geq\mathscr{I}_3I4→3​≥I3​ without equality. Interpretively, it proposes generalised macrorealism and local realism formulated using extended probabilities rather than actual measurements.
The stated caveats concern interpretation: extended probabilities need not represent observable histories, counterfactual assignments across incompatible consistent-history frameworks require additional choices, and no generalised Fine theorem is established. Consequently, a local-hidden-variable interpretation is not generally guaranteed by satisfaction of the new inequalities.
In 1985, Leggett and Garg put forward the concept of macroscopic realism (macrorealism) and, in analogy to Bell's theorem, derived a necessary condition in terms of inequalities, which are now known as the Leggett-Garg inequalities. In this paper, we discuss another necessary condition called no-signaling in time. It solely bases on comparing the probability distribution for a macrovariable at some time for the cases where previously a measurement has or has not been performed. Although the concept is analogous to the no-signaling condition in the case of Bell tests, it can be violated according to quantum mechanical predictions even in situations where no violation of Leggett-Garg inequalities is possible.
The Leggett-Garg inequalities are a set of inequalities obeyed by classical systems but violated in quantum theory. Their violation has been taken as evidence that quantum theory lacks a `realistic' formulation. However in addition to realism the derivation of the Leggett-Garg inequalities relies on another, more obscure assumption of `non-invasive measurability.' The significance of this assumption and the consequences for the interpretation of violations of the Leggett-Garg inequalities have been hotly debated. In this paper we present a pedagogical introduction to the issues, focussing on the significance of non-invasive measurability. We give a simple derivation of the Leggett-Garg inequalities paying particular attention to where and when the two assumptions are used, and we give an example of a realist but not non-invasively measurable hidden variable theory which violates them. We also discuss recent attempts to experimentally implement non-invasive measurements via so called `undetectable measurements' and we show that even undetectable measurements are not necessarily non-invasive.
The Leggett-Garg inequality is a widely used test of the ``quantumness'' of a system and involves correlations between measurements realized at different times. According to its widespread interpretation, a violation of the Leggett-Garg inequality disproves macroscopic realism and noninvasiveness. Nevertheless, recent results point out that macroscopic realism is a model-dependent notion and that one should always be able to attribute to invasiveness a violation of a Leggett-Garg inequality. This opens some natural questions: How do we provide such an attribution in a systematic way? How can apparent macroscopic realism violation be recast into a dimensional-independent invasiveness model? The present work answers these questions by introducing an operational model where the effects of invasiveness are controllable through a parameter associated with what is called the measurability of the physical system. Such a parameter leads to different generalized measurements that can be associated with the dimensionality of a system, to measurement errors, or to back action.
The Leggett-Garg inequality (LGI) distinguishes nonmacrorealistic channels from macrorealistic ones by constraining the experimental outcomes of the underlying system. In this work, we propose a class of channels which, initially, cannot violate the LGI (in the form of the temporal Bell inequality) but can violate it after the application of stochastic pre- and post-operations (SPPOs). As a proof-of-principle experiment, we demonstrate the stochastic pre- and post-operations in an amplitude-damping channel with photonic qubits. We denote the above phenomenon as hidden nonmacrorealistic channels. We also discuss the relationship between these hidden nonmacrorealistic channels [in terms of the temporal Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality] and the strongly nonlocality-breaking channel, which breaks the hidden spatial CHSH nonlocality for arbitrary states. In general, if the channel satisfies hidden nonmacrorealism, it is not a strongly CHSH nonlocality-breaking channel.
The Bell inequality constrains the outcomes of measurements on pairs of distant entangled particles. The Bell contradiction states that the Bell inequality is inconsistent with the calculated outcomes of these quantum experiments. This contradiction led many to question the underlying assumptions, viz. so-called realism and locality. The probability model underlying the Bell inequality is generally left implicit. We propose an explicit probability model for the CHSH version of the Bell experiment. This model has only two simultaneously observable detector settings per measurement, and therefore does not assume realism. The quantum expectation now becomes a conditional expectation, given the two detector settings. This probability model is in full agreement with both quantum mechanics and experiments. As a result, the model satisfies the Bell inequality; there are no so-called violations. We extend this model to include a hidden variable. This extended model is not Bell-separable. This non-separability implies that the model is non-deterministic or non-local (or both).
The Leggett-Garg inequality is a widely used test of the "quantumness" of a system, and involves correlations between measurements realized at different times. According to its widespread interpretation, a violation of the Legget-Garg inequality disproves macroscopic realism and non-invasiveness. Nevertheless, recent results point out that macroscopic realism is a model dependent notion and that one should always be able to attribute to invasiveness a violation of a Legget-Garg inequality. This opens some natural questions: how to provide such an attribution in a systematic way? How can apparent macroscopic realism violation be recast into a dimensional independent invasiveness model? The present work answers these questions by introducing an operational model where the effects of invasiveness are controllable through a parameter associated with what is called the measurability of the physical system. Such a parameter leads to different generalized measurements that can be associated with the dimensionality of a system, to measurement errors or to back action.