Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.20755

Engineering Weak Universality with Quantum Dots

Warre Missiaen, Michael Wimmer, Natalia Chepiga

cond-mat.str-elcond-mat.mes-hallquant-phSubmitted Sep 17, 2026• Announced Sep 18, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum critical theories with continuously varying critical exponents remain challenging to access experimentally. Here, we propose quantum-dot architectures for realizing the quantum Ashkin-Teller and XYZ/eight-vertex models using resonator-mediated and direct Coulomb interactions, respectively. We focus on the Ashkin-Teller and eight-vertex critical lines, which are connected by a non-local duality relating local order parameters to topological string operators. The resulting platforms provide microscopic control over the parameters explicitly controlling critical exponents, with the Coulomb-based implementation enabling stronger interaction regimes. We demonstrate that continuously varying critical behavior can already be resolved in short chains. For experimentally realistic parameters, the accessible interaction range is expected to produce changes in the critical exponents of order $10\%$ for the Ashkin-Teller model and substantially larger changes for the eight-vertex model. In both cases, the predicted variations lie well above the estimated measurement uncertainties.

AI Summary

The paper proposes quantum-dot realizations of continuously varying critical behavior along the quantum Ashkin–Teller (AT) and XYZ/eight-vertex critical lines. The goal is to tune the interactions controlling critical exponents, rather than access only an isolated critical point. For AT, two quantum-dot Kitaev chains are coupled through site and link resonators that modulate chemical potentials and hopping/pairing amplitudes. Perturbatively eliminating high-frequency resonators generates the required four-Majorana interactions, with strength $\lambda_{\rm eff}\simeq2g^2/\omega_r$. Quoted resonator frequencies of $10$–$12\,\mathrm{GHz}$ and couplings of $1$–$1.5\,\mathrm{GHz}$ give $\lambda_{\rm eff}/t\simeq0.07$–$0.19$ for $t=10\,\mu\mathrm{eV}$, corresponding to approximately $10\%$ variation in the polarization scaling dimension. For XYZ, nearest-neighbor Coulomb interactions supply the density–density coupling; the eight-vertex condition is $t+\Delta=-V/2$. Charging energies of $20$–$30\,\mu\mathrm{eV}$ reported in related devices motivate access to stronger interactions and larger exponent variations. DMRG finite-size fits for $L=8,10,12,14$, compared with exact critical predictions and $L=70$–$100$ calculations, demonstrate parameter-dependent scaling in short chains. Proposed observables are charge-derived parity strings for AT and local-density Friedel oscillations for XYZ. This is a theoretical proposal, not an experimental demonstration. Stated limitations include demanding resonator couplings, mode crowding and crosstalk, parameter disorder, calibration of the critical manifold, unwanted longer-range Coulomb terms, and finite-size corrections. Reported fit uncertainties are regression errors, not experimental measurement uncertainties. Electron temperatures of $30$–$50\,\mathrm{mK}$ are argued not to limit the short systems considered.

Little sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptionsOverclaims

Central claim may not hold: The abstract claims that predicted exponent variations exceed estimated measurement uncertainties, but the paper supplies numerical fit regression errors rather than an experimental uncertainty estimate. The conclusion's thermal-suppression claim is not justified by the unrestricted decoupled AT excitation gaps, which are comparable to or smaller than kBT at the stated temperatures; a parity-restricted thermal analysis is absent. The short-chain XYZ exponent at Jy/Jx=0.8 has a 15.45% finite-size bias, substantially exceeding its regression error, so those errors cannot represent total extraction uncertainty despite the paper's acknowledgment of finite-size drift.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

Universality and non-universality in the Ashkin-Teller model

Alessandro Giuliani

The Ashkin-Teller model can be formulated as a pair of 2D Ising models, interacting via a four-spin interaction. I consider the case of weak anisotropy (slight a-symmetry between the two Ising layers) and weak coupling. I show that the system admits two critical temperatures whose difference varies continuously with the strength of the coupling, scaling with an anomalous exponent as one let the a-symmetry parameter go to zero. The specific heat diverges logarithmically at the critical points (as for Ising) but the constant in front of the logarithm is renormalized by an anomalous critical exponent. The logarithmic divergence of the specific heat dominates only in an exponentially small interval around the critical temperatures and outside it is modified into an anomalous power law behaviour. The proof is based on an exact mapping of Ashkin-Teller into a model of (1+1)D interacting fermions and on the implementation of constructive Renormalization group methods on the fermionic system. This PhD thesis includes: (1) a review of the exact solution of 2D Ising in terms of Grassmann functional integrals; (2) a review of the Grassmann representation for a class of interacting Ising models, including Ashkin-Teller and the 8 vertex model; (3) a detailed discussion of the multiscale analysis of the Ashkin-Teller model, based on fermionic Renormalization Group methods, including the study of the flow of the effective coupling constants (in particular a proof of vanishing of the beta function for this and similar Luttinger-like models, based on modified approximate Ward identities, is included). This thesis is based on joint work with V. Mastropietro.

arXiv:cond-mat/0412176•Dec 7, 2004•1 citation

Stacked quantum Ising systems and quantum Ashkin-Teller model

Davide Rossini, Ettore Vicari

We analyze the quantum states of an isolated composite system consisting of two stacked quantum Ising (SQI) subsystems, coupled by a local Hamiltonian term that preserves the $Z_2$ symmetry of each subsystem. The coupling strength is controlled by an intercoupling parameter $w$, with $w=0$ corresponding to decoupled quantum Ising systems. We focus on the quantum correlations of one of the two SQI subsystems, $S$, in the ground state of the global system, and study their dependence on both the state of the weakly-coupled complementary part $E$ and the intercoupling strength. We concentrate on regimes in which $S$ develops critical long-range correlations. The most interesting physical scenario arises when both SQI subsystems are critical. In particular, for identical SQI subsystems, the global system is equivalent to the quantum Ashkin-Teller model, characterized by an additional $Z_2$ interchange symmetry between the two subsystem operators. In this limit, one-dimensional SQI systems exhibit a peculiar critical line along which the length-scale critical exponent $ν$ varies continuously with $w$, while two-dimensional systems develop quantum multicritical behaviors characterized by an effective enlargement of the symmetry of the critical modes, from the actual $Z_2\oplus Z_2$ symmetry to a continuous O(2) symmetry.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2601.18922•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 28, 2026•1 citation

The off-critical integrable Ashkin-Teller model

Paul A. Pearce, Katherine Seaton

The exact solution of an Ashkin-Teller model, with layer and spatial anisotropy and Z 2 *Z 2 symmetry, is presented. The model is related to the eight-vertex model by a sublattice or orbifold duality and it has the same free energy and magnetisation. The exact solution manifold is a three-dimensional submanifold of the full six-dimensional thermodynamic space. It admits a Z 3 symmetry relating three regimes each exhibiting different partial order. In the spatially isotropic case, these regimes are separated by three lines of continuously varying critical behaviour which coalesce at the four-state Potts critical point. The magnetisations and polarisation are derived using corner transfer matrices giving rise to the appearance of chiral and Virasoro characters. The associated critical exponents confirm the known values. In particular, one obtains the value x sigma =1/8 for the magnetic scaling dimension and identify the next-to-leading thermal field.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Apr 7, 1990•6 citations

Random-matrix and quantum-critical crossovers for interacting electrons in quantum dots

Ganpathy N. Murthy

Quantum dots with a large Thouless number $g$ embody a regime where both disorder and interactions can be treated nonperturbatively using large-$N$ techniques (with $N=g$) and quantum phase transitions can be studied. Here we focus on dots where the noninteracting Hamiltonian is drawn from a crossover ensemble between two symmetry classes, where the crossover parameter introduces a tunable energy scale independent of and much smaller than the Thouless energy. We show that the quantum critical regime, dominated by collective critical fluctuations, can be accessed at this energy scale. The nonperturbative physics of this regime can only be described by the large-$N$ approach, as we illustrate with two experimentally relevant examples.

arXiv:cond-mat/0406029•Physical Review B•Oct 15, 2004•10 citations

Topological quantum gates with quantum dots

Jiannis K. Pachos, Vlatko Vedral

We present an idealized model involving interacting quantum dots that can support both the dynamical and geometrical forms of quantum computation. We show that by employing a structure similar to the one used in the Aharonov-Bohm effect we can construct a topological two-qubit phase-gate that is to a large degree independent of the exact values of the control parameters and therefore resilient to control errors. The main components of the setup are realizable with present technology.

arXiv:quant-ph/0302077•Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Oct 16, 2003•5 citations

Critical behavior of the random-bond Ashkin-Teller model: A Monte Carlo study

Shai Wiseman, Eytan Domany

The critical behavior of a bond-disordered Ashkin-Teller model on a square lattice is investigated by intensive Monte Carlo simulations. A duality transformation is used to locate a critical plane of the disordered model. This critical plane corresponds to the line of critical points of the pure model, along which critical exponents vary continuously. Along this line the scaling exponent corresponding to randomness \ensuremath{\varphi}=(\ensuremath{\alpha}/\ensuremath{\nu}) varies continuously and is positive so that the randomness is relevant, and different critical behavior is expected for the disordered model. We use a cluster algorithm for the Monte Carlo simulations based on the Wolff embedding idea, and perform a finite size scaling study of several critical models, extrapolating between the critical bond-disordered Ising and bond-disordered four-state Potts models. The critical behavior of the disordered model is compared with the critical behavior of an anisotropic Ashkin-Teller model, which is used as a reference pure model. We find no essential change in the order parameters' critical exponents with respect to those of the pure model. The divergence of the specific heat C is changed dramatically. Our results favor a logarithmic type divergence at ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$, C\ensuremath{\sim}lnL for the random-bond Ashkin-Teller and four-state Potts models and C\ensuremath{\sim}ln lnL for the random-bond Ising model.

arXiv:cond-mat/9411046•Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Apr 1, 1995•68 citations
Quantum critical theories with continuously varying critical exponents remain challenging to access experimentally. Here, we propose quantum-dot architectures for realizing the quantum Ashkin-Teller and XYZ/eight-vertex models using resonator-mediated and direct Coulomb interactions, respectively. We focus on the Ashkin-Teller and eight-vertex critical lines, which are connected by a non-local duality relating local order parameters to topological string operators. The resulting platforms provide microscopic control over the parameters explicitly controlling critical exponents, with the Coulomb-based implementation enabling stronger interaction regimes. We demonstrate that continuously varying critical behavior can already be resolved in short chains. For experimentally realistic parameters, the accessible interaction range is expected to produce changes in the critical exponents of order 10%10\%10% for the Ashkin-Teller model and substantially larger changes for the eight-vertex model. In both cases, the predicted variations lie well above the estimated measurement uncertainties.
The paper proposes quantum-dot realizations of continuously varying critical behavior along the quantum Ashkin–Teller (AT) and XYZ/eight-vertex critical lines. The goal is to tune the interactions controlling critical exponents, rather than access only an isolated critical point.
For AT, two quantum-dot Kitaev chains are coupled through site and link resonators that modulate chemical potentials and hopping/pairing amplitudes. Perturbatively eliminating high-frequency resonators generates the required four-Majorana interactions, with strength λeff≃2g2/ωr\lambda_{\rm eff}\simeq2g^2/\omega_rλeff​≃2g2/ωr​. Quoted resonator frequencies of 101010–12 GHz12\,\mathrm{GHz}12GHz and couplings of 111–1.5 GHz1.5\,\mathrm{GHz}1.5GHz give λeff/t≃0.07\lambda_{\rm eff}/t\simeq0.07λeff​/t≃0.07–0.190.190.19 for t=10 μeVt=10\,\mu\mathrm{eV}t=10μeV, corresponding to approximately 10%10\%10% variation in the polarization scaling dimension. For XYZ, nearest-neighbor Coulomb interactions supply the density–density coupling; the eight-vertex condition is t+Δ=−V/2t+\Delta=-V/2t+Δ=−V/2. Charging energies of 202020–30 μeV30\,\mu\mathrm{eV}30μeV reported in related devices motivate access to stronger interactions and larger exponent variations.
DMRG finite-size fits for L=8,10,12,14L=8,10,12,14L=8,10,12,14, compared with exact critical predictions and L=70L=70L=70–100100100 calculations, demonstrate parameter-dependent scaling in short chains. Proposed observables are charge-derived parity strings for AT and local-density Friedel oscillations for XYZ.
This is a theoretical proposal, not an experimental demonstration. Stated limitations include demanding resonator couplings, mode crowding and crosstalk, parameter disorder, calibration of the critical manifold, unwanted longer-range Coulomb terms, and finite-size corrections. Reported fit uncertainties are regression errors, not experimental measurement uncertainties. Electron temperatures of 303030–50 mK50\,\mathrm{mK}50mK are argued not to limit the short systems considered.
The Ashkin-Teller model can be formulated as a pair of 2D Ising models, interacting via a four-spin interaction. I consider the case of weak anisotropy (slight a-symmetry between the two Ising layers) and weak coupling. I show that the system admits two critical temperatures whose difference varies continuously with the strength of the coupling, scaling with an anomalous exponent as one let the a-symmetry parameter go to zero. The specific heat diverges logarithmically at the critical points (as for Ising) but the constant in front of the logarithm is renormalized by an anomalous critical exponent. The logarithmic divergence of the specific heat dominates only in an exponentially small interval around the critical temperatures and outside it is modified into an anomalous power law behaviour. The proof is based on an exact mapping of Ashkin-Teller into a model of (1+1)D interacting fermions and on the implementation of constructive Renormalization group methods on the fermionic system. This PhD thesis includes: (1) a review of the exact solution of 2D Ising in terms of Grassmann functional integrals; (2) a review of the Grassmann representation for a class of interacting Ising models, including Ashkin-Teller and the 8 vertex model; (3) a detailed discussion of the multiscale analysis of the Ashkin-Teller model, based on fermionic Renormalization Group methods, including the study of the flow of the effective coupling constants (in particular a proof of vanishing of the beta function for this and similar Luttinger-like models, based on modified approximate Ward identities, is included). This thesis is based on joint work with V. Mastropietro.
We analyze the quantum states of an isolated composite system consisting of two stacked quantum Ising (SQI) subsystems, coupled by a local Hamiltonian term that preserves the Z2Z_2Z2​ symmetry of each subsystem. The coupling strength is controlled by an intercoupling parameter www, with w=0w=0w=0 corresponding to decoupled quantum Ising systems. We focus on the quantum correlations of one of the two SQI subsystems, SSS, in the ground state of the global system, and study their dependence on both the state of the weakly-coupled complementary part EEE and the intercoupling strength. We concentrate on regimes in which SSS develops critical long-range correlations. The most interesting physical scenario arises when both SQI subsystems are critical. In particular, for identical SQI subsystems, the global system is equivalent to the quantum Ashkin-Teller model, characterized by an additional Z2Z_2Z2​ interchange symmetry between the two subsystem operators. In this limit, one-dimensional SQI systems exhibit a peculiar critical line along which the length-scale critical exponent ννν varies continuously with www, while two-dimensional systems develop quantum multicritical behaviors characterized by an effective enlargement of the symmetry of the critical modes, from the actual Z2⊕Z2Z_2\oplus Z_2Z2​⊕Z2​ symmetry to a continuous O(2) symmetry.
The exact solution of an Ashkin-Teller model, with layer and spatial anisotropy and Z 2 *Z 2 symmetry, is presented. The model is related to the eight-vertex model by a sublattice or orbifold duality and it has the same free energy and magnetisation. The exact solution manifold is a three-dimensional submanifold of the full six-dimensional thermodynamic space. It admits a Z 3 symmetry relating three regimes each exhibiting different partial order. In the spatially isotropic case, these regimes are separated by three lines of continuously varying critical behaviour which coalesce at the four-state Potts critical point. The magnetisations and polarisation are derived using corner transfer matrices giving rise to the appearance of chiral and Virasoro characters. The associated critical exponents confirm the known values. In particular, one obtains the value x sigma =1/8 for the magnetic scaling dimension and identify the next-to-leading thermal field.
Quantum dots with a large Thouless number ggg embody a regime where both disorder and interactions can be treated nonperturbatively using large-NNN techniques (with N=gN=gN=g) and quantum phase transitions can be studied. Here we focus on dots where the noninteracting Hamiltonian is drawn from a crossover ensemble between two symmetry classes, where the crossover parameter introduces a tunable energy scale independent of and much smaller than the Thouless energy. We show that the quantum critical regime, dominated by collective critical fluctuations, can be accessed at this energy scale. The nonperturbative physics of this regime can only be described by the large-NNN approach, as we illustrate with two experimentally relevant examples.
The critical behavior of a bond-disordered Ashkin-Teller model on a square lattice is investigated by intensive Monte Carlo simulations. A duality transformation is used to locate a critical plane of the disordered model. This critical plane corresponds to the line of critical points of the pure model, along which critical exponents vary continuously. Along this line the scaling exponent corresponding to randomness \ensuremath{\varphi}=(\ensuremath{\alpha}/\ensuremath{\nu}) varies continuously and is positive so that the randomness is relevant, and different critical behavior is expected for the disordered model. We use a cluster algorithm for the Monte Carlo simulations based on the Wolff embedding idea, and perform a finite size scaling study of several critical models, extrapolating between the critical bond-disordered Ising and bond-disordered four-state Potts models. The critical behavior of the disordered model is compared with the critical behavior of an anisotropic Ashkin-Teller model, which is used as a reference pure model. We find no essential change in the order parameters' critical exponents with respect to those of the pure model. The divergence of the specific heat C is changed dramatically. Our results favor a logarithmic type divergence at Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​, C\ensuremath{\sim}lnL for the random-bond Ashkin-Teller and four-state Potts models and C\ensuremath{\sim}ln lnL for the random-bond Ising model.