arXiv:2609.20728
-fold unbiased measurements and maximal incompatibility
Sébastien Designolle, Máté Farkas
Abstract
Mutually unbiased bases capture perfect complementarity between two quantum measurements. Extensions beyond pairwise unbiasedness have been proposed, but essentially no non-trivial higher-order constructions are known. We introduce $k$-fold unbiased measurements ($k$-UMs), extending the $k$-fold unbiased bases notion of [arXiv:1706.04446] from rank-one basis measurements to arbitrary-rank projective measurements, and show that this higher-rank setting supports a much richer theory. We develop the notions of algebraic and spectral $k$-UMs and prove that they coincide for rank-one measurements and triples of measurements (3-UMs). We establish strong no-go results for higher-order rank-one constructions and three-outcome 3-UMs, but obtain infinitely many higher-rank triples using Hadamard matrices and Clifford algebras. We then give these structures an exact operational interpretation in terms of measurement incompatibility. For 3-UMs with any number of outcomes, we determine their generalised incompatibility robustness exactly and construct an explicit joint measurement for their noisy versions at the compatibility threshold. Finally, we implement the symmetry reduction of the sum-of-squares hierarchy recently introduced in [New J. Phys. 28, 064509 (2026)] and give numerical evidence that the noise thresholds arising from the $k$-UM analysis may characterise the asymptotic behaviour of this hierarchy. In particular, with very high precision, we numerically show that our constructed four-outcome 3-UMs are among the most incompatible triples of four-outcome measurements.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether higher-order mutual unbiasedness becomes realisable beyond rank-one bases, and whether the resulting measurements maximise incompatibility. It introduces algebraic $k$-fold unbiased measurements ($k$-UMs), defined by symmetrised projection-product identities, and spectral $k$-UMs, whose selected sums have characteristic polynomial $\mu_{k,n}(t)^r$, where $\mu_{k,n}(t)=(1-n^{-1}\mathrm d/\mathrm dt)^kt^n$ and $r$ is the outcome rank. The definitions coincide at rank one, for pairs and triples, and for binary measurements. Rank-one constructions are ruled out for $k\geq3$ except $(k,n)=(3,2)$; three-outcome triples are impossible at any finite rank. Conversely, real Hadamard matrices and Clifford representations yield infinitely many higher-rank triples. The smallest nonbinary example has four outcomes, rank two, and dimension eight. For every $n$-outcome 3-UM, matching SDP bounds establish generalised incompatibility visibility $\eta^{\mathrm g}=\lambda_{3,n}/3$, where $\lambda_{k,n}$ is the largest root of $\mu_{k,n}$. An explicit parent measurement uses maximal-eigenvalue projectors of selected sums. The four-outcome example gives $[1+\cos(\pi/9)]/3\approx0.64656$. A harmonic-mean argument also proves that 3-UMs uniquely minimise the selected-sum norm bound among projective triples. Global maximal incompatibility remains unproved: symmetry-reduced sum-of-squares computations give a universal lower bound matching the four-outcome value to approximately $3\times10^{-25}$, without an exact certificate. General hierarchy convergence is conjectured. Equivalence of the definitions beyond the established regimes and nonbinary constructions with $k>3$ remain open; the Hadamard–Clifford construction requires rank growing exponentially with outcome number.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 10+14 pages, 3 tables. Comments are welcome!