Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.20549

Scalable logical qubits

Matthias Troyer, Chetan Nayak, John Martinis

quant-phSubmitted Sep 17, 2026• Announced Sep 18, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Utility-scale quantum computing will require executing long, complex algorithms with end-to-end error rates far below what physical qubits can support directly. Error-corrected logical qubits are needed to achieve this goal. To make the progress on logical qubits measurable and comparable we introduce the definition of scalable logical qubits: logical qubits preserved for long computations by repeated quantum error correction, capable of fault-tolerant universal operations with low-latency real-time decoding and feedback, and replicable to the hundreds or thousands, as required by applications. We characterize these scalable logical qubits along four coupled dimensions: reliability, scale, capability, and performance, and discuss trade-offs among these dimensions.

AI Summary

The paper addresses how progress toward application-scale, error-corrected quantum computing should be defined and compared. It proposes the term “scalable logical qubits” to distinguish logical-qubit demonstrations from systems intended to support long computations with end-to-end error rates substantially below those achievable with physical qubits alone. The proposed definition combines several requirements: preservation through repeated quantum error correction; support for fault-tolerant universal operations; low-latency, real-time decoding and feedback; and the ability to replicate logical qubits into systems containing hundreds or thousands of them. The abstract organizes their characterization along four coupled dimensions—reliability, scale, capability, and performance—and states that trade-offs among these dimensions are discussed. The contribution described is therefore a definition and assessment framework, rather than a reported logical-qubit experiment, code construction, or threshold theorem. Only the title and abstract are available, so the specific metrics, quantitative criteria, examples, and arguments supporting the framework cannot be assessed. The abstract gives no numerical error-rate targets, decoding-latency bounds, resource-overhead estimates, or experimental benchmarks; “hundreds or thousands” specifies an intended scale rather than a demonstrated result. It also states no explicit limitations or conditions under which the proposed definition applies. Whether the full paper provides operational tests for satisfying each requirement is not established by the available material.

No sign of AI-generated textUnclear noveltyMissing comparison

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the abstract only. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

Hybrid Optimization-Driven Performance Benchmarking of Logical Qubits for Reliable Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computing

P. Nirupama, Seeniappan Kaliappan, M. Muthukannan +1 more

Recent developments in quantum computation have motivated the search for scalable logical qubit architectures that may strongly suppress errors under hardware constraints and realistic noise conditions. Although the field of QEC codes and decoders achieved substantial progress, previous work either focuses on individual solutions that are disconnected from each other or proposed specific benchmarking setups without a common framework to evaluate them; criteria used may include hardware abstraction level, decoding latency, hybrid optimization heuristic etc., as well as application-level performance metrics. Towards this end, we propose a complete end-to-end benchmarking suite tailored to assess the efficacy of logical quantum computing within a wide variety of quantum settings such as superconducting qubits, trapped ions, neutral atoms and photonic systems. It is mainly to find out the best configuration that keeps a tradeoff between logical reliability and physical resource overhead as well as operation real time requirement. The framework includes surface codes, qLDPC codes, and bosonic encoding schemes as well as hybrid-adaptive code-distance optimization to study trade-offs between logical error rates and physical qubit costs. Numerical results also demonstrate that the proposed hybrid adaptive schemes significantly increase the probability of successful task release and reduce the total cost of resource compared with fixed-distance-based ones. Simulation results demonstrate lower logical failure probability and favorable effective throughput performance in presence of practical decoder latency constraints. The proposed approach provides a standardized benchmarking methodology for scalable quantum systems and the ability to effectively benchmark near-term quantum workloads, cloud-based quantum services and future fault-tolerant quantum applications.

•Sep 1, 2026•0 citations

Advances in Logical Qubits and Quantum Error Correction: Progress Toward Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computing

Mirza Adnan Mohtashim

Quantum computing has reached a pivotal inflection point with the recent demonstration ofbelow-threshold quantum error correction and the emergence of logical qubits that outperformtheir physical counterparts. This review synthesizes the remarkable progress achieved between2024 and 2026 across multiple quantum hardware platforms, including superconducting circuits,trapped ions, and neutral atom arrays. We examine the theoretical foundations of quantumerror correction codes, with particular emphasis on surface codes and the rapidly advancingquantum low-density parity-check (qLDPC) codes. Key experimental milestones are analyzed,including Google’s Willow chip demonstration of exponential error suppression, IBM’s modularfault-tolerant roadmap culminating in the Starling system, IonQ’s achievement of 48 logicalqubits with a 2:1 encoding ratio, and QuEra’s record-efficiency neutral atom error correctionapproaching the Teraquop regime. The review further explores critical enabling technologiessuch as real-time decoding architectures, magic state distillation protocols, and fault-tolerant gateimplementations. We discuss the remaining challenges in scaling to hundreds of logical qubits,achieving practical logical error rates of 10−10 to 10−15, and realizing end-to-end fault-tolerantalgorithms. By synthesizing these developments, this article provides a comprehensive assessmentof the field’s trajectory toward practical fault-tolerant quantum computing and identifies the keymilestones that will define the next phase of progress.

•May 12, 2026•0 citations

Toward Scalable Quantum Computing with Superconducting Circuits

Michael Kerschbaum

Quantum computing holds the promise of solving problems that are intractable for classical computers, with applications ranging from optimization and materials simulation to cryptography. It achieves this by leveraging the exponentially scaling dimensionality of the space encoding quantum information and by executing algorithms on quantum registers in superposition states – a feature often referred to as quantum parallelism. However, while encoding information in computational units capable of exploring a continuous set of quantum states enables exponential scaling of computational power with system size, quantum systems are also more susceptible to errors than their classical counterparts. These errors take the form of both control errors, where miscalibration of the control pulses causes coherent errors on the qubit states, as well as incoherent errors due to energy relaxation and dephasing. Scaling quantum systems to run useful algorithms involving hundreds or thousands of logical qubits will require quantum error correction. In this approach, quantum information is redundantly encoded across an entangled state of many physical qubits. This has enabled experimental demonstrations across various platforms – including ion traps, superconducting circuits, and neutral atoms – showing that encoded quantum states can be preserved beyond the coherence times of the constituting physical qubits. However, quantum state preservation is only one component needed for scalable quantum computing. To execute algorithms, it is also necessary to implement quantum gates on and between encoded qubits, in a way that maintains fault tolerance by preserving the ability to correct errors as they occur during the computation. In the first part of this thesis, we demonstrate the implementation of an error-corrected quantum operation that entangles two logical qubits. This is achieved by performing lattice surgery on a distance-three surface code qubit, resulting in a logical Bell state encoded in distance-three repetition codes, which enable the correction of single bit-flip errors. We further introduce techniques to benchmark and characterize the performance of logical operations, including applying the protocol to arbitrary logical input states and performing logical quantum process tomography. Together, these results constitute one of the first realizations of error-corrected lattice surgery in superconducting circuits. While quantum error correction can correct errors provided they occur with sufficiently low frequency, it may fail when many qubits experience errors simultaneously. In the second part of this thesis, we therefore shift focus to a specific error mechanism known to cause correlated errors in superconducting circuits – quasiparticle-induced decoherence. In this case, various forms of energy deposition on the quantum device can break Cooper pairs into quasiparticles, which may subsequently diffuse to the tunnel junction and interact with the qubit state, thereby causing decoherence. In this thesis, we investigate the impact of quasiparticle tunneling on qubit performance, with a focus on infrared-induced quasiparticles. We compare the sensitivity of niobium-based qubits to those made from tantalum – a material that has gained interest in recent years following demonstrations of qubits with improved coherence times based on this material. Using a thermal radiator source, we show that the performance of tantalum qubits may be limited by infrared-induced quasiparticles in typical superconducting circuit experimental setups. By employing both ambient and in-line infrared filters, we investigate the effectiveness of different filtering strategies and develop best practices for engineering cryogenic environments for superconducting quantum processors. The results presented in this thesis contribute to the advancement of quantum computing based on superconducting circuits by implementing and characterizing quantum error-corrected operations, and by investigating quasiparticles as a source of decoherence, along with strategies to improve infrared filtering and signal conditioning in cryogenic environments for future fault-tolerant quantum computing.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Demonstration of logical qubits and repeated error correction with better-than-physical error rates

Paetznick, A., Marcus Palmer Da Silva, Ciarán Ryan-Anderson +29 more

The promise of quantum computers hinges on the ability to scale to large system sizes, e.g., to run quantum computations consisting of more than 100 million operations fault-tolerantly. This in turn requires suppressing errors to levels inversely proportional to the size of the computation. As a step towards this ambitious goal, we present experiments on a trapped-ion QCCD processor where, through the use of fault-tolerant encoding and error correction, we are able to suppress logical error rates to levels below the physical error rates. In particular, we entangled logical qubits encoded in the [[7,1,3]] code with error rates 9.8 times to 500 times lower than at the physical level, and entangled logical qubits encoded in a [[12,2,4]] code based on Knill's C4/C6 scheme with error rates 4.7 times to 800 times lower than at the physical level, depending on the judicious use of post-selection. Moreover, we demonstrate repeated error correction with the [[12,2,4]] code, with logical error rates below physical circuit baselines corresponding to repeated CNOTs, and show evidence that the error rate per error correction cycle, which consists of over 100 physical CNOTs, approaches the error rate of two physical CNOTs. These results signify a transition from noisy intermediate scale quantum computing to reliable quantum computing, and demonstrate advanced capabilities toward large-scale fault-tolerant quantum computing.

arXiv:2404.02280•Apr 2, 2024•304 citations

Low-overhead fault-tolerant quantum computing using long-range connectivity

Lawrence Z. Cohen, Isaac H. Kim, Stephen D. Bartlett +1 more

Vast numbers of qubits will be needed for large-scale quantum computing because of the overheads associated with error correction. We present a scheme for low-overhead fault-tolerant quantum computation based on quantum low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes, where long-range interactions enable many logical qubits to be encoded with a modest number of physical qubits. In our approach, logic gates operate via logical Pauli measurements that preserve both the protection of the LDPC codes and the low overheads in terms of the required number of additional qubits. Compared with surface codes with the same code distance, we estimate order-of-magnitude improvements in the overheads for processing around 100 logical qubits using this approach. Given the high thresholds demonstrated by LDPC codes, our estimates suggest that fault-tolerant quantum computation at this scale may be achievable with a few thousand physical qubits at comparable error rates to what is needed for current approaches.

arXiv:2110.10794•Science Advances•May 20, 2022•160 citations

Fault-tolerant execution of error-corrected quantum algorithms

Michael A. Perlin, Zichang He, Anthony Alexiades Armenakas +9 more

Scaling up quantum algorithms to tackle high-impact problems in science and industry requires quantum error correction and fault tolerance. While progress has been made in experimentally realizing error-corrected primitives, the end-to-end execution of logical quantum algorithms using only fault-tolerant (FT) components has remained out of reach. We demonstrate the FT and error-corrected execution of two quantum algorithms, the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) and the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm applied to the Poisson equation, on Quantinuum H2 and Helios trapped-ion quantum processors using the $[[7,1,3]]$ Steane code. For QAOA circuits on 5 and 6 logical qubits, we show performance improvements from increasing the number of QAOA layers and the number of $T$ gates used to approximate logical rotations, despite increased physical circuit complexity. We further show that QAOA circuits with up to 8 logical qubits and 9 logical $T$ gates perform similarly to unencoded circuits. For the largest QAOA circuits we run, with 12 logical (97 physical) qubits and 2132 physical two-qubit gates, we still observe better-than-random performance. Finally, we show that adding active QEC cycles and increasing the repeat-until-success limit of state preparation subroutines can improve the performance of a quantum algorithm, thereby demonstrating critical capabilities of scalable FT quantum computation. Our results are enabled by an FT logical $T$ gate implementation with an infidelity of $\sim 2.6(4)\times10^{-3}$ and dynamic circuits with measurement-dependent feedback. Our work demonstrates near-break-even performance of complex, error-corrected algorithmic quantum circuits using only FT components.

quant-pharXiv:2603.04584•Physical Review X•Mar 6, 2026•20 citations
Utility-scale quantum computing will require executing long, complex algorithms with end-to-end error rates far below what physical qubits can support directly. Error-corrected logical qubits are needed to achieve this goal. To make the progress on logical qubits measurable and comparable we introduce the definition of scalable logical qubits: logical qubits preserved for long computations by repeated quantum error correction, capable of fault-tolerant universal operations with low-latency real-time decoding and feedback, and replicable to the hundreds or thousands, as required by applications. We characterize these scalable logical qubits along four coupled dimensions: reliability, scale, capability, and performance, and discuss trade-offs among these dimensions.
The paper addresses how progress toward application-scale, error-corrected quantum computing should be defined and compared. It proposes the term “scalable logical qubits” to distinguish logical-qubit demonstrations from systems intended to support long computations with end-to-end error rates substantially below those achievable with physical qubits alone.
The proposed definition combines several requirements: preservation through repeated quantum error correction; support for fault-tolerant universal operations; low-latency, real-time decoding and feedback; and the ability to replicate logical qubits into systems containing hundreds or thousands of them. The abstract organizes their characterization along four coupled dimensions—reliability, scale, capability, and performance—and states that trade-offs among these dimensions are discussed. The contribution described is therefore a definition and assessment framework, rather than a reported logical-qubit experiment, code construction, or threshold theorem.
Only the title and abstract are available, so the specific metrics, quantitative criteria, examples, and arguments supporting the framework cannot be assessed. The abstract gives no numerical error-rate targets, decoding-latency bounds, resource-overhead estimates, or experimental benchmarks; “hundreds or thousands” specifies an intended scale rather than a demonstrated result. It also states no explicit limitations or conditions under which the proposed definition applies. Whether the full paper provides operational tests for satisfying each requirement is not established by the available material.
Recent developments in quantum computation have motivated the search for scalable logical qubit architectures that may strongly suppress errors under hardware constraints and realistic noise conditions. Although the field of QEC codes and decoders achieved substantial progress, previous work either focuses on individual solutions that are disconnected from each other or proposed specific benchmarking setups without a common framework to evaluate them; criteria used may include hardware abstraction level, decoding latency, hybrid optimization heuristic etc., as well as application-level performance metrics. Towards this end, we propose a complete end-to-end benchmarking suite tailored to assess the efficacy of logical quantum computing within a wide variety of quantum settings such as superconducting qubits, trapped ions, neutral atoms and photonic systems. It is mainly to find out the best configuration that keeps a tradeoff between logical reliability and physical resource overhead as well as operation real time requirement. The framework includes surface codes, qLDPC codes, and bosonic encoding schemes as well as hybrid-adaptive code-distance optimization to study trade-offs between logical error rates and physical qubit costs. Numerical results also demonstrate that the proposed hybrid adaptive schemes significantly increase the probability of successful task release and reduce the total cost of resource compared with fixed-distance-based ones. Simulation results demonstrate lower logical failure probability and favorable effective throughput performance in presence of practical decoder latency constraints. The proposed approach provides a standardized benchmarking methodology for scalable quantum systems and the ability to effectively benchmark near-term quantum workloads, cloud-based quantum services and future fault-tolerant quantum applications.
Quantum computing has reached a pivotal inflection point with the recent demonstration ofbelow-threshold quantum error correction and the emergence of logical qubits that outperformtheir physical counterparts. This review synthesizes the remarkable progress achieved between2024 and 2026 across multiple quantum hardware platforms, including superconducting circuits,trapped ions, and neutral atom arrays. We examine the theoretical foundations of quantumerror correction codes, with particular emphasis on surface codes and the rapidly advancingquantum low-density parity-check (qLDPC) codes. Key experimental milestones are analyzed,including Google’s Willow chip demonstration of exponential error suppression, IBM’s modularfault-tolerant roadmap culminating in the Starling system, IonQ’s achievement of 48 logicalqubits with a 2:1 encoding ratio, and QuEra’s record-efficiency neutral atom error correctionapproaching the Teraquop regime. The review further explores critical enabling technologiessuch as real-time decoding architectures, magic state distillation protocols, and fault-tolerant gateimplementations. We discuss the remaining challenges in scaling to hundreds of logical qubits,achieving practical logical error rates of 10−10 to 10−15, and realizing end-to-end fault-tolerantalgorithms. By synthesizing these developments, this article provides a comprehensive assessmentof the field’s trajectory toward practical fault-tolerant quantum computing and identifies the keymilestones that will define the next phase of progress.
Quantum computing holds the promise of solving problems that are intractable for classical computers, with applications ranging from optimization and materials simulation to cryptography. It achieves this by leveraging the exponentially scaling dimensionality of the space encoding quantum information and by executing algorithms on quantum registers in superposition states – a feature often referred to as quantum parallelism. However, while encoding information in computational units capable of exploring a continuous set of quantum states enables exponential scaling of computational power with system size, quantum systems are also more susceptible to errors than their classical counterparts. These errors take the form of both control errors, where miscalibration of the control pulses causes coherent errors on the qubit states, as well as incoherent errors due to energy relaxation and dephasing. Scaling quantum systems to run useful algorithms involving hundreds or thousands of logical qubits will require quantum error correction. In this approach, quantum information is redundantly encoded across an entangled state of many physical qubits. This has enabled experimental demonstrations across various platforms – including ion traps, superconducting circuits, and neutral atoms – showing that encoded quantum states can be preserved beyond the coherence times of the constituting physical qubits. However, quantum state preservation is only one component needed for scalable quantum computing. To execute algorithms, it is also necessary to implement quantum gates on and between encoded qubits, in a way that maintains fault tolerance by preserving the ability to correct errors as they occur during the computation. In the first part of this thesis, we demonstrate the implementation of an error-corrected quantum operation that entangles two logical qubits. This is achieved by performing lattice surgery on a distance-three surface code qubit, resulting in a logical Bell state encoded in distance-three repetition codes, which enable the correction of single bit-flip errors. We further introduce techniques to benchmark and characterize the performance of logical operations, including applying the protocol to arbitrary logical input states and performing logical quantum process tomography. Together, these results constitute one of the first realizations of error-corrected lattice surgery in superconducting circuits. While quantum error correction can correct errors provided they occur with sufficiently low frequency, it may fail when many qubits experience errors simultaneously. In the second part of this thesis, we therefore shift focus to a specific error mechanism known to cause correlated errors in superconducting circuits – quasiparticle-induced decoherence. In this case, various forms of energy deposition on the quantum device can break Cooper pairs into quasiparticles, which may subsequently diffuse to the tunnel junction and interact with the qubit state, thereby causing decoherence. In this thesis, we investigate the impact of quasiparticle tunneling on qubit performance, with a focus on infrared-induced quasiparticles. We compare the sensitivity of niobium-based qubits to those made from tantalum – a material that has gained interest in recent years following demonstrations of qubits with improved coherence times based on this material. Using a thermal radiator source, we show that the performance of tantalum qubits may be limited by infrared-induced quasiparticles in typical superconducting circuit experimental setups. By employing both ambient and in-line infrared filters, we investigate the effectiveness of different filtering strategies and develop best practices for engineering cryogenic environments for superconducting quantum processors. The results presented in this thesis contribute to the advancement of quantum computing based on superconducting circuits by implementing and characterizing quantum error-corrected operations, and by investigating quasiparticles as a source of decoherence, along with strategies to improve infrared filtering and signal conditioning in cryogenic environments for future fault-tolerant quantum computing.
The promise of quantum computers hinges on the ability to scale to large system sizes, e.g., to run quantum computations consisting of more than 100 million operations fault-tolerantly. This in turn requires suppressing errors to levels inversely proportional to the size of the computation. As a step towards this ambitious goal, we present experiments on a trapped-ion QCCD processor where, through the use of fault-tolerant encoding and error correction, we are able to suppress logical error rates to levels below the physical error rates. In particular, we entangled logical qubits encoded in the [[7,1,3]] code with error rates 9.8 times to 500 times lower than at the physical level, and entangled logical qubits encoded in a [[12,2,4]] code based on Knill's C4/C6 scheme with error rates 4.7 times to 800 times lower than at the physical level, depending on the judicious use of post-selection. Moreover, we demonstrate repeated error correction with the [[12,2,4]] code, with logical error rates below physical circuit baselines corresponding to repeated CNOTs, and show evidence that the error rate per error correction cycle, which consists of over 100 physical CNOTs, approaches the error rate of two physical CNOTs. These results signify a transition from noisy intermediate scale quantum computing to reliable quantum computing, and demonstrate advanced capabilities toward large-scale fault-tolerant quantum computing.
Vast numbers of qubits will be needed for large-scale quantum computing because of the overheads associated with error correction. We present a scheme for low-overhead fault-tolerant quantum computation based on quantum low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes, where long-range interactions enable many logical qubits to be encoded with a modest number of physical qubits. In our approach, logic gates operate via logical Pauli measurements that preserve both the protection of the LDPC codes and the low overheads in terms of the required number of additional qubits. Compared with surface codes with the same code distance, we estimate order-of-magnitude improvements in the overheads for processing around 100 logical qubits using this approach. Given the high thresholds demonstrated by LDPC codes, our estimates suggest that fault-tolerant quantum computation at this scale may be achievable with a few thousand physical qubits at comparable error rates to what is needed for current approaches.
Scaling up quantum algorithms to tackle high-impact problems in science and industry requires quantum error correction and fault tolerance. While progress has been made in experimentally realizing error-corrected primitives, the end-to-end execution of logical quantum algorithms using only fault-tolerant (FT) components has remained out of reach. We demonstrate the FT and error-corrected execution of two quantum algorithms, the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) and the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm applied to the Poisson equation, on Quantinuum H2 and Helios trapped-ion quantum processors using the [[7,1,3]][[7,1,3]][[7,1,3]] Steane code. For QAOA circuits on 5 and 6 logical qubits, we show performance improvements from increasing the number of QAOA layers and the number of TTT gates used to approximate logical rotations, despite increased physical circuit complexity. We further show that QAOA circuits with up to 8 logical qubits and 9 logical TTT gates perform similarly to unencoded circuits. For the largest QAOA circuits we run, with 12 logical (97 physical) qubits and 2132 physical two-qubit gates, we still observe better-than-random performance. Finally, we show that adding active QEC cycles and increasing the repeat-until-success limit of state preparation subroutines can improve the performance of a quantum algorithm, thereby demonstrating critical capabilities of scalable FT quantum computation. Our results are enabled by an FT logical TTT gate implementation with an infidelity of ∼2.6(4)×10−3\sim 2.6(4)\times10^{-3}∼2.6(4)×10−3 and dynamic circuits with measurement-dependent feedback. Our work demonstrates near-break-even performance of complex, error-corrected algorithmic quantum circuits using only FT components.