arXiv:2609.20052
Semiclassical scaling of eigenstate thermalization in single-particle chaotic systems
Yaoqi Ye, Xiao Wang
Abstract
We study the off-diagonal matrix elements of real-space observables in time-reversal-invariant single-particle chaotic systems. By analyzing the semiclassical expression for the off-diagonal variance derived from Berry's conjecture, we show that the banded structure of the observable matrix emerges naturally. For local observables, we identify a characteristic bandwidth associated with a late-time timescale inversely proportional to the particle velocity. We further show that, for systems with steep-wall confinement, the predicted magnitude follows the entropy scaling of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH), multiplied by an additional kinetic-energy-dependent factor that is independent of spatial dimension and is not captured by conventional many-body ETH. We illustrate these results through a case study of quantum billiards and verify the semiclassical scaling numerically in a generalized quarter-Sinai billiard. Our results elucidate the dynamical implications of Berry's conjecture and provide a comparison between single-particle eigenstate thermalization and many-body ETH.
AI Summary
The paper asks how off-diagonal matrix elements of position-dependent observables scale in time-reversal-invariant, single-particle chaotic systems, and how this scaling compares with many-body ETH. Starting from a semiclassical variance expression based on Berry’s conjecture, it analyzes products of eigenfunction Bessel correlations. Their dephasing with increasing energy separation produces a banded observable matrix. For observables supported away from classical turning boundaries, with spatial extent large compared with the local wavelength, the characteristic energy bandwidth scales as $\omega_b\sim\hbar v/\ell$, where $v$ is the particle speed and $\ell$ is the relevant spatial scale. For steep-wall confinement, the ETH envelope has the scaling $|f_O(E,\omega)|^2\sim\hbar^{-1}E_k^{-1/2}g_O^2(\omega/(\hbar\sqrt{E_k}))$, with fixed geometric and mass factors suppressed. Thus the variance contains an additional, dimension-independent kinetic-energy factor beyond the entropy prefactor. In billiards, the associated time scale is the classical traversal time. Numerical tests use the position observable $q_x$ in a generalized quarter-Sinai billiard. At fixed scaled separation $u=|\omega|/\sqrt{\bar E}$, variances follow the predicted $\bar E^{-1/2}$ scaling over approximately $10^4<\bar E<10^7$ for $u=2,3,4$. Normalized matrix elements approach Gaussian statistics near $\bar E\simeq9\times10^6$. The stated limitations include unexplained poorer agreement at smaller $u$ and finite-energy non-Gaussian statistics. More importantly, the predicted variance retains a systematic quantitative discrepancy with numerics up to $\bar E\simeq1.6\times10^7$, without a clear convergence trend. Correlations between distinct eigenstates omitted by the Berry-based treatment are suggested as a possible cause.
Central claim may not hold: The additional kinetic-energy dependence is compatible with the paper’s stated ETH ansatz because its envelope f_O(E,omega) already permits energy dependence. The general off-diagonal variance formula predicts nonzero matrix elements for the identity observable and is not invariant under adding a constant to an observable, demonstrating that it omits correlations essential to the claimed general envelope.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 6 pages, 3 figures; Supplemental Material: 3 pages, 1 figure