arXiv:2609.19884
Odd/Even or Half ? Entanglement Anomaly in the Bose-Hubbard model
Humberto E. López-Hernández, Santiago F. Caballero-Benitez
Abstract
The area law relates the bipartite entanglement entropy of a quantum many-body ground state to the size of the boundary between the subsystems, but the geometry of this boundary is rarely discussed. We inspect this in the 1D Bose-Hubbard model at fixed density by comparing four spatial bipartitions of the periodic lattice: first half, second half, even sites, and odd sites; sharing the same number of sites but differing in how the boundary is arranged. We find analytical limits with perturbation theory: in the Mott insulator the contiguous cut obeys the area lay while the alternating cut obeys a volume law $S\propto N_s$, in this sense an anomaly, and for the superfluid both cuts colapse to the binomial saturation due to delocalization of the state. We formulate these limits as a statement about the many-body problem using a generalized slave-boson approach based on mean-field with quantum fluctuations while verifying with Exact Diagonalization (ED) for small lattice sizes and Densitiy Matrix Renormalization Group (DMRG) simulations for $N_s\gg 1$. The slave-boson Gaussian ground state allows to compute the entanglement entropy from a reduced correlation matrix for any desired bipartition consistent with ED and DMRG results. Using slave bosons the computational cost is set by the local cutoff $n_{\max}$ rather than the Hilbert space dimension, so we can reach lattice sizes far beyond ED. Our method is capable of establishing the partition-dependent scaling laws as a many-body feature, not only a finite-size effect, in great agreement with the ED for $N_s\in[4,10]$ and DMRG for larger lattice sizes.
AI Summary
The paper studies how ground-state entanglement in the periodic, unit-filled 1D Bose–Hubbard model depends on bipartition geometry, comparing contiguous half-chain and alternating odd/even partitions. Complementarity equates the two halves and the odd/even entropies separately; lattice symmetries do not relate contiguous and alternating cuts. Strong-coupling perturbation theory gives $S_{\mathrm{half}}=4\varepsilon^2[1+\ln(1/\varepsilon^2)]$ to leading order, with $\varepsilon=\sqrt{2}t/U$. The alternating entropy instead scales as $N_s$, reflecting its $N_s$ crossing bonds rather than the half-chain’s two. The calculation expresses geometry-dependent corrections through a boundary-matrix spectrum. At exactly $U=0$, the fixed-number condensate gives $S_A=H[\mathrm{Bin}(N,|A|/N_s)]$, independent of geometry; equal-size cuts therefore coincide, with entropy asymptotically $\tfrac12\ln(\pi eN_s/2)$. A two-sublattice slave-boson mean-field construction with Gaussian fluctuations computes either entropy from restricted correlation matrices. Comparisons use exact diagonalization through $N_s=10$ and DMRG through $N_s=64$. Deep-Mott ratios agree closely across methods: at $t/U=10^{-3}$ and $N_s=64$, $S_{\mathrm{odd}}/S_{\mathrm{half}}$ is approximately $29.73$. The stated limitation is that mean field places the transition at $t/U\approx0.086$, versus the accepted $0.305$, making its critical-region description qualitative. The claimed superfluid agreement also has qualifications in the reported tables: at $N_s=8$, $t/U=100$, slave-boson half-chain entropy is $2.6589$, versus $1.7572$ from exact diagonalization. At the same coupling, the alternating-to-half ratio increases with size, reaching $1.54$ in slave bosons and $1.62$ in DMRG at $N_s=64$, rather than remaining near unity.
Central claim may not hold: The paper extends its correct U=0 binomial entropy result to interacting-superfluid large-system scaling without justification, while its fixed-t/U=100 size-scaling table shows the two cut entropies separating rather than collapsing. The supplementary deep-superfluid table reports slave-boson entropies approximately 51% and 61% above ED for the half and alternating cuts, contradicting the claimed quantitative agreement. At N_s=N=8 and t/U=100, the reported absolute slave-boson entropies imply an alternating/half ratio of approximately 1.0651, whereas the scaling table reports 1.0097. The claimed full-range slave-boson agreement is contradicted by a 34% entropy-ratio error within the physical Mott phase near the explicitly acknowledged, incorrectly located mean-field transition.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 7 pages, 2 tables, 3 figures and supplemental material with 9 pages, 3 tables and 4 Figures