Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.19798

Variational Solution of Non-Hermitian Quantum Field Theory in Two Dimensions

Paul Romatschke

hep-thhep-latquant-phSubmitted Sep 17, 2026• Announced Sep 18, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This work describes a variational technique to solve non-Hermitian quantum systems, in particular those with negative coupling quartic self-interaction. Differences of applying variational methods from standard quantum mechanics to non-Hermitian quantum mechanics -- including potential pitfalls -- are highlighted. A successful implementation of the variational approach for the non-Hermitian case is presented. The technique is used to analyze scalar quantum field theory in d=2 with negative quartic self-interaction in the Hamiltonian formulation in lattice discretization.

AI Summary

The paper studies whether Hamiltonian basis truncation can compute nonperturbative spectra and observables of $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric scalar field theory with negative quartic interaction in $1+1$ dimensions, where conventional Monte Carlo sampling encounters a sign problem. The construction uses contour-normalized, $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric polynomial basis functions multiplied by a cubic exponential, then diagonalizes the truncated non-Hermitian Hamiltonian. Because ordinary variational energy minimization can fail, the basis parameter is selected by minimizing the change in the ground-state energy between successive truncations. For the massless wrong-sign quartic oscillator, eight basis states give $E_0/g^{1/3}\simeq0.930546$, with reported relative error $10^{-6}$. Massive-oscillator spectra are also compared with an isospectral Hermitian formulation. For the spatially discretized field theory, calculations mainly at $ga^2=0.05$ find two regimes distinguished by an imaginary field expectation value, separated by a finite-volume crossover. The correlation-length peak grows and narrows between three and seven sites. Low-lying eigenvalues become real as the basis is enlarged; no spontaneous $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetry breaking is observed for the parameters examined. Ground-state energies and observables are compared with saddle-point approximations. Finite-temperature pressure and entropy show no clear transition, while the field expectation value changes with temperature. The stated main limitation is exponential basis growth: approximately $10^3$, $10^4$, and $10^5$ states are required for three, five, and seven sites. These volumes do not permit a large-volume extrapolation, and finite-temperature conclusions remain inconclusive. A permutation-symmetrized basis is proposed as a route to larger systems.

No sign of AI-generated textIncrementalSmall numerics onlyMissing comparisonPossible error

Error found: Minimizing changes between successive truncations is presented as a ground-state selection principle without a justification establishing convergence or accuracy. The contour-defined Hamiltonian matrix requires a generalized eigenproblem with the indefinite overlap metric, which is absent from the displayed spectral equations even though an implicitly corrected implementation remains possible. The stated identity between a bare-mass second derivative of the ground-state energy and the inverse squared mass gap fails even for a free single-site oscillator. The proposed permutation-symmetric basis does not generally span the zero-momentum sector of a nearest-neighbor lattice Hamiltonian. The appendix's finite-temperature entropy formula equals T² times the derivative of its stated free pressure rather than the correct entropy.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
26 pages, 11 figures

Related papers

A Variational Approach to Quantum Field Theory

Martí Rovira, Robert J. Perry, A. Parreño

In strongly coupled field theories, perturbation theory cannot be employed to study the low-energy spectrum. Thus, non-perturbative techniques are required. We employ the variational method, a rigorous, non-perturbative approach which provides variational upper bounds on the energy eigenstates of the theory. An essential step in the variational method is the choice of trial wave function. In this work, we study the viability of employing a neural network as our variational ansatz. As a first step towards phenomenologically interesting strongly coupled theories like quantum chromodynamics, we study scalar field theories with quartic couplings.

arXiv:2409.17887•International Conference on Quarks and Nuclear Physics (QNP)•Feb 7, 2025•3 citations

Variational Matrix Product State Approach for Non-Hermitian System Based on a Companion Hermitian Hamiltonian

Zhen Guo, Zheng-Tao Xu, Meng Li +2 more

Non-Hermitian systems exhibiting topological properties are attracting growing interest. In this work, we propose an algorithm for solving the ground state of a non-Hermitian system in the matrix product state (MPS) formalism based on a companion Hermitian Hamiltonian. If the eigenvalues of the non-Hermitian system are known, the companion Hermitian Hamiltonian can be directly constructed and solved using Hermitian variational methods. When the eigenvalues are unknown, a gradient descent along with the companion Hermitian Hamiltonian yields both the ground state eigenenergy and the eigenstate. With the variational principle as a solid foundation, our algorithm ensures convergence and provides results in excellent agreement with the exact solutions of the non-Hermitian Su-Schrieffer-Heeger (nH-SSH) model as well as its interacting extension. The approach we present avoids solving any non-Hermitian matrix and overcomes numerical instabilities commonly encountered in large non-Hermitian systems.

arXiv:2210.14858•Oct 26, 2022•14 citations

Quantum field theories on a lattice: Variational methods for arbitrary coupling strengths and the Ising model in a transverse magnetic field

Sidney D. Drell, Marvin Weinstein, Shimon Yankielowicz B

This paper continues our studies of quantum field theories on a lattice. We develop techniques for computing the low-lying spectrum of a lattice Hamiltonian using a variational approach, without recourse either to weak- or strong-coupling expansions. Our variational methods, which are relatively simple and straightforward, are applied to the Ising model in a transverse magnetic field as well as to a free spinless field theory. We demonstrate their accuracy in the vicinity of a phase transition for the Ising model by comparing with known exact solutions.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Sep 15, 1977•107 citations

Towards Nonperturbative Solution of Quantum Dynamics : A Hamiltonian Mean Field Approximation Scheme with Perturbation Theory for Arbitray Strength of Interaction

B. P. Mahapatra

We introduce a non perturbative general approximation scheme (NGAS) that can handle interactions of any strength in quantum theory. This approach starts with an input Hamiltonian that can be solved exactly. The interaction effects are then built into this Hamiltonian through nonlinear feedback enforced by self consistency conditions. While the method itself is nonperturbative it can be systematically improved using a new perturbation method called 'mean field perturbation theory' which does not involve power series expansion in any small parameter. We put this scheme to the test on one dimensional anharmonic interactions using the harmonic approximation. The results are consistently accurate across various cases including quartic, sextic, and octic anharmonic oscillators, as well as the quartic double well oscillator (QDWO) even when the coupling strength varies widely. The flexibility of the method is demonstrated when we swap the input Hamiltonian for that of an infinite square well and still achieve comparable accuracy. When applied to the λϕ4 quantum field theory this approach aligns with the Gaussian effective potential method under the harmonic approximation. Beyond that it reveals the condensate structure of the effective vacuum and highlights the instability of the perturbative ground state. Notably, our ground-state energy results for the QDWO stand in stark contrast to those from standard perturbation theory where Borel summation fails regardless of coupling strength.

arXiv:1909.12508•Sep 27, 2019•0 citations

Some progress on the use of the variational method in quantum field theory

Antoine Tilloy

Strongly coupled quantum field theories in $(1+1)$ dimensions are notoriously hard to solve non-perturbatively. Variational methods, despite their success for quantum many-body physics on the lattice, have long lacked a natural ansatz adapted to the relativistic setting. This monograph explains the intuition behind relativistic continuous matrix product states (RCMPS), a variational ansatz tailored to $(1+1)$-dimensional QFT, and reports on several years of progress in developing and applying this approach. Using Riemannian optimization on the manifold of RCMPS, we obtain competitive non-perturbative approximations to ground state energies and local observables in the $φ^4$, Sine-Gordon, and Sinh-Gordon models, including in strongly coupled regimes where perturbation theory fails. We then describe extensions to models with several interacting fields. Beyond energy density and local observables, we show how the framework can be used to evaluate non-local observables (defects) and, through an original linear programming approach, to extract spectral data such as particle masses. We close by discussing the current limitations of the method and the most promising directions for future work.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2604.10284•Apr 14, 2026•1 citation

Comparison of mass renormalization schemes for simple model systems

E V Stefanovich, R E Wagner, Q Su +1 more

We discuss an alternative method to mass renormalize a quantum field Hamiltonian based on a requirement that the vacuum and single-particle sectors are not self-scattering. We illustrate the feasibility of this method for the concrete example of bosonic quadratic and also quartic interactions. The results are compared with those obtained by the standard renormalization technique based on a spectral analysis of the usual field-based propagators. We also discuss a potential method for renormalizing a quantum field theory in a non-perturbative way using computational methods.

arXiv:1308.3198•Laser Physics•Feb 7, 2013•5 citations
This work describes a variational technique to solve non-Hermitian quantum systems, in particular those with negative coupling quartic self-interaction. Differences of applying variational methods from standard quantum mechanics to non-Hermitian quantum mechanics -- including potential pitfalls -- are highlighted. A successful implementation of the variational approach for the non-Hermitian case is presented. The technique is used to analyze scalar quantum field theory in d=2 with negative quartic self-interaction in the Hamiltonian formulation in lattice discretization.
The paper studies whether Hamiltonian basis truncation can compute nonperturbative spectra and observables of PT\mathcal{PT}PT-symmetric scalar field theory with negative quartic interaction in 1+11+11+1 dimensions, where conventional Monte Carlo sampling encounters a sign problem.
The construction uses contour-normalized, PT\mathcal{PT}PT-symmetric polynomial basis functions multiplied by a cubic exponential, then diagonalizes the truncated non-Hermitian Hamiltonian. Because ordinary variational energy minimization can fail, the basis parameter is selected by minimizing the change in the ground-state energy between successive truncations. For the massless wrong-sign quartic oscillator, eight basis states give E0/g1/3≃0.930546E_0/g^{1/3}\simeq0.930546E0​/g1/3≃0.930546, with reported relative error 10−610^{-6}10−6. Massive-oscillator spectra are also compared with an isospectral Hermitian formulation.
For the spatially discretized field theory, calculations mainly at ga2=0.05ga^2=0.05ga2=0.05 find two regimes distinguished by an imaginary field expectation value, separated by a finite-volume crossover. The correlation-length peak grows and narrows between three and seven sites. Low-lying eigenvalues become real as the basis is enlarged; no spontaneous PT\mathcal{PT}PT-symmetry breaking is observed for the parameters examined. Ground-state energies and observables are compared with saddle-point approximations. Finite-temperature pressure and entropy show no clear transition, while the field expectation value changes with temperature.
The stated main limitation is exponential basis growth: approximately 10310^3103, 10410^4104, and 10510^5105 states are required for three, five, and seven sites. These volumes do not permit a large-volume extrapolation, and finite-temperature conclusions remain inconclusive. A permutation-symmetrized basis is proposed as a route to larger systems.
In strongly coupled field theories, perturbation theory cannot be employed to study the low-energy spectrum. Thus, non-perturbative techniques are required. We employ the variational method, a rigorous, non-perturbative approach which provides variational upper bounds on the energy eigenstates of the theory. An essential step in the variational method is the choice of trial wave function. In this work, we study the viability of employing a neural network as our variational ansatz. As a first step towards phenomenologically interesting strongly coupled theories like quantum chromodynamics, we study scalar field theories with quartic couplings.
Non-Hermitian systems exhibiting topological properties are attracting growing interest. In this work, we propose an algorithm for solving the ground state of a non-Hermitian system in the matrix product state (MPS) formalism based on a companion Hermitian Hamiltonian. If the eigenvalues of the non-Hermitian system are known, the companion Hermitian Hamiltonian can be directly constructed and solved using Hermitian variational methods. When the eigenvalues are unknown, a gradient descent along with the companion Hermitian Hamiltonian yields both the ground state eigenenergy and the eigenstate. With the variational principle as a solid foundation, our algorithm ensures convergence and provides results in excellent agreement with the exact solutions of the non-Hermitian Su-Schrieffer-Heeger (nH-SSH) model as well as its interacting extension. The approach we present avoids solving any non-Hermitian matrix and overcomes numerical instabilities commonly encountered in large non-Hermitian systems.
This paper continues our studies of quantum field theories on a lattice. We develop techniques for computing the low-lying spectrum of a lattice Hamiltonian using a variational approach, without recourse either to weak- or strong-coupling expansions. Our variational methods, which are relatively simple and straightforward, are applied to the Ising model in a transverse magnetic field as well as to a free spinless field theory. We demonstrate their accuracy in the vicinity of a phase transition for the Ising model by comparing with known exact solutions.
We introduce a non perturbative general approximation scheme (NGAS) that can handle interactions of any strength in quantum theory. This approach starts with an input Hamiltonian that can be solved exactly. The interaction effects are then built into this Hamiltonian through nonlinear feedback enforced by self consistency conditions. While the method itself is nonperturbative it can be systematically improved using a new perturbation method called 'mean field perturbation theory' which does not involve power series expansion in any small parameter. We put this scheme to the test on one dimensional anharmonic interactions using the harmonic approximation. The results are consistently accurate across various cases including quartic, sextic, and octic anharmonic oscillators, as well as the quartic double well oscillator (QDWO) even when the coupling strength varies widely. The flexibility of the method is demonstrated when we swap the input Hamiltonian for that of an infinite square well and still achieve comparable accuracy. When applied to the λϕ4 quantum field theory this approach aligns with the Gaussian effective potential method under the harmonic approximation. Beyond that it reveals the condensate structure of the effective vacuum and highlights the instability of the perturbative ground state. Notably, our ground-state energy results for the QDWO stand in stark contrast to those from standard perturbation theory where Borel summation fails regardless of coupling strength.
Strongly coupled quantum field theories in (1+1)(1+1)(1+1) dimensions are notoriously hard to solve non-perturbatively. Variational methods, despite their success for quantum many-body physics on the lattice, have long lacked a natural ansatz adapted to the relativistic setting. This monograph explains the intuition behind relativistic continuous matrix product states (RCMPS), a variational ansatz tailored to (1+1)(1+1)(1+1)-dimensional QFT, and reports on several years of progress in developing and applying this approach. Using Riemannian optimization on the manifold of RCMPS, we obtain competitive non-perturbative approximations to ground state energies and local observables in the φ4φ^4φ4, Sine-Gordon, and Sinh-Gordon models, including in strongly coupled regimes where perturbation theory fails. We then describe extensions to models with several interacting fields. Beyond energy density and local observables, we show how the framework can be used to evaluate non-local observables (defects) and, through an original linear programming approach, to extract spectral data such as particle masses. We close by discussing the current limitations of the method and the most promising directions for future work.
We discuss an alternative method to mass renormalize a quantum field Hamiltonian based on a requirement that the vacuum and single-particle sectors are not self-scattering. We illustrate the feasibility of this method for the concrete example of bosonic quadratic and also quartic interactions. The results are compared with those obtained by the standard renormalization technique based on a spectral analysis of the usual field-based propagators. We also discuss a potential method for renormalizing a quantum field theory in a non-perturbative way using computational methods.