arXiv:2609.19625 · Physical Review A
Experimental certification of the nonlocal advantages of quantum imaginarity
Jian-Hao Wu, Kai-Yu Yuan, Yun-Xiang Tian, Hao-Ran Tan, Yan-Xin Rong, Zhen Shang, Yong-Jian Gu, Ya Xiao
Abstract
Quantum imaginarity is a distinct resource in quantum information theory, yet its nonlocal properties have not been fully explored. Here, we report an experimental study of the nonlocal advantage of quantum imaginarity (NAQI), in which local measurements on one subsystem can steer the average imaginarity of the conditional states of the other subsystem beyond the corresponding classical bound. The $l_1$-norm of imaginarity inequality is adopted as an experimentally accessible witness. A hybrid optimization algorithm that combines a genetic algorithm with sequential quadratic programming is developed to avoid local optima and accelerate the search for optimal measurement settings. Using polarization-encoded photonic qubits, we prepare two classes of two-qubit Bell-diagonal states and experimentally characterize the imaginarity of the conditional states following local measurements. Clear violations of the $l_1$-norm of imaginarity inequality are observed, providing an experimental certification of NAQI. We further investigate the relationship among NAQI, the nonlocal advantage of quantum coherence (NAQC), and Bell nonlocality based on their respective inequality criteria. For the two-qubit Werner states considered in this work, the regions of states that violate the respective criteria satisfy $\mathcal{D}_{\rm NAQC}\subset\mathcal{D}_{\rm NAQI}\subset\mathcal{D}_{\rm BN}$. Our work provides an experimental realization of NAQI and a comparison of different forms of quantum nonclassicality in a photonic platform.
AI Summary
The paper investigates whether local measurements on one qubit can steer the conditional states of another qubit to exhibit an average quantum imaginarity exceeding a single-qubit complementarity bound. This nonlocal advantage of quantum imaginarity (NAQI) is a steering-like criterion, distinct from Bell nonlocality, and is evaluated using the basis-dependent $l_1$-norm of imaginarity. The experiment uses polarization-entangled photon pairs generated by spontaneous parametric down-conversion. Incoherent optical mixing prepares binary mixtures of two Bell states and Werner states $\rho_W(p)=p|\phi^+\rangle\langle\phi^+|+(1-p)I/4$. Projective measurements characterize Bob’s conditional states, with measurement settings selected numerically using a genetic algorithm followed by sequential quadratic programming (GA–SQP). NAQI is certified when the optimized witness exceeds $\sqrt{5}$. Average preparation fidelities are $0.9760\pm0.0013$ for the Bell mixtures and $0.9890\pm0.0006$ for the Werner states. Violations occur at every tested Bell-mixture parameter except $p=0.5$, and at $p=0.8$ and $1$ in the initial Werner-state measurements. Additional Werner-state measurements compare NAQI, nonlocal advantage of coherence (NAQC), and CHSH violation. Their detected regions satisfy $\mathcal D_{\rm NAQC}\subset\mathcal D_{\rm NAQI}\subset\mathcal D_{\rm BN}$; the coherence and CHSH bounds are $\sqrt{6}$ and $2$, respectively. This inclusion is explicitly restricted to the Werner family and the chosen criteria, not asserted as a general hierarchy. Optimization benchmarks find GA–SQP and multistart SQP values agreeing within $10^{-10}$, with shorter GA–SQP runtimes on the tested two-qubit problems; higher-dimensional and multipartite applications remain prospective.
Central claim may not hold: The unrestricted sum defining the NAQI witness in Eq. (l1_norm) reaches at least 6 on an uncorrelated product state with valid MUBs, contradicting its claimed classical bound √5. Equation (M1) gives nonorthogonal vectors at angles used in the reported optimal settings, and Eq. (M2) then gives unnormalized vectors, invalidating the stated MUB construction.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Journal reference
- Phys. Rev. A 114, 032439 (2026)
- DOI
- 10.1103/7jcn-yq29
- Comments
- [10] pages, [6] figures. Accepted by Physical Review A. DOI: 10.1103/7jcn-yq29