arXiv:2609.19247
Topological entanglement entropy in 3D gravity
Vijay Balasubramanian, Charlie Cummings
Abstract
We derive an entropy formula for a recently proposed tensor network model of states in 3D gravity which satisfy the constraint equations of diffeomorphism invariance, and including the effects of matter. After accounting for the invertibility of the spacetime metric, we argue that this formula matches the quantum extremal surface formula (for small but finite $G_N$), and is not restricted to time symmetric spacetimes. We derive the result via canonical quantization without relying on path integrals, and discuss an extension to compact bulk subregions.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether the quantum extremal surface (QES) entropy formula can emerge from canonical, diffeomorphism-invariant states rather than a gravitational path integral. It extends a previously introduced topological tensor-network model, defined for transformable gauge groups, to include matter and discusses its relation to AdS$_3$ gravity. For a fixed cut $\gamma$ assigning matter legs to either side, an extended-Hilbert-space construction gives $S_R[\gamma]=H[p^\gamma]+\langle\hat A_\gamma\rangle+S_{\mathrm{bulk}}$, where $H$ is differential entropy over representation sectors and the area spectrum is $\ln\mu(\pi)$, with $\mu$ a ratio of representation-space measures. Edge modes and renormalized algebraic traces handle divergences for noncompact groups. Gaussian averaging over matter states produces an approximate minimum of this expression over cuts, assuming replica symmetry and a dominant saddle. A proposed quantum-group replacement incorporating metric invertibility yields an area spectrum matching $\ell/(4G_N)$ at leading order. Examples include time-symmetric geometries and rotating BTZ black holes, where the spectrum matches $2\pi r_+/(4G_N)$. Content-defined compact bulk regions give either their own generalized entropy or a minimum over enclosing regions, depending on whether exterior matter is fixed or averaged. The gravitational interpretation remains conditional: the required quantum-group network is not explicitly constructed, the randomness assumption lacks a settled gravitational justification, and a mapping-class-group quotient is still needed, with positivity unresolved. Factorization along closed bulk cuts is also left open. Absolute entropy retains a state-independent normalization ambiguity; entropy differences do not.
Central claim may not hold: The identification with metric-invertible 3D gravity at small but finite Newton's constant depends on a quantum-group extension that the paper does not construct. The QES-like minimization is established only approximately for Gaussian-random matter under concentration, replica-symmetry and dominant-saddle assumptions, rather than for general fixed matter states. Even the proposed quantum-group model still requires a mapping-class-group quotient to match the full gravitational phase space, and the paper does not establish positivity of the resulting physical inner product.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 71+6 pages, 12 figures