Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.18735

All coherent measurements provide observational ergotropic advantage

Soumik Mahanti, Rakesh Saini, Alexei Gilchrist, Arindam Mitra

quant-phSubmitted Sep 16, 2026• Announced Sep 17, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The use of quantum resources in the work extraction from a quantum system is an emerging research topic. Recently, [arXiv:2602.22893] established the necessity of measurement coherence for obtaining advantage in work extraction from an unknown isolated quantum system. However, a quantitative relation between the magnitude of this advantage and established measures of measurement coherence is missing. Here, we establish such a connection by introducing a faithful operational quantifier of the work advantage provided by a measurement. We show that measurement coherence is necessary and sufficient for a positive advantage, and derive upper and lower bounds in terms of the robustness of measurement coherence and an $l_{\infty}$ norm based coherence measure respectively. Finally, we examine this quantifier of advantage from the resource theoretic perspective. Our results provide an operational characterisation of measurement coherence as a resource for work extraction and reveal a nontrivial relation between its resource content and thermodynamic value.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether every measurement with coherence in the energy eigenbasis can improve observational ergotropy over incoherent measurements, and how that improvement relates to measurement-coherence measures. It uses the coarse-grained state $\Lambda_M^{\rm cg}(\rho)=\sum_\mu\operatorname{Tr}[\rho M(\mu)]M(\mu)/\operatorname{Tr}M(\mu)$ and defines the measurement’s advantage as $A_M^H=\max_\rho[P_H(\Delta\rho)-P_H(\Lambda_M^{\rm cg}(\rho))]$, where $P_H$ is passive energy. A difference replaces a ratio because the incoherent-work benchmark can vanish, making ratio-based advantages divergent. For nondegenerate Hamiltonians, the main result is $A_M^H>0$ if and only if $M$ is coherent. The quantitative bounds are $\delta_{\min}C_{l_\infty}(M)^2/d^2\leq A_M^H\leq[(d-1)/d](E_{d-1}-E_0)R_C(M)$, with $\delta_{\min}$ the smallest adjacent energy gap. Both bounds have saturating qubit families: rank-one projective measurements attain the upper bound, while equatorial trine POVMs with visibility $c$ have $A_M^H=Ec^2/4$, attaining the lower bound. A separate ceiling, $A_M^H\leq\operatorname{Tr}(H)/d-E_0$, is accompanied by a characterization of measurements attaining it. The proofs use perturbations around the maximally mixed state, variational formulas for sums of largest eigenvalues, and robustness decompositions. Explicit examples show that greater coherence robustness need not yield greater advantage; a qutrit construction also shows failure of monotonicity under physically incoherent preprocessing. Thus the advantage is not itself a coherence monotone under the operations considered. Degenerate Hamiltonians and a resource theory making the advantage monotonic are left for future investigation.

Little sign of AI-generated textIncrementalPossible error

Error found: The unconditional coherence-sufficiency theorem fails for the explicitly permitted constant Hamiltonian H=cI, because every measurement then has zero observational ergotropic advantage. The sufficiency proof falsely asserts that the coarse-graining channel maps its chosen off-diagonal operator to an operator with zero diagonal, although a positive quadratic-form argument repairs the proof. The appendix omits the population-optimization bound needed to establish its asserted global maxima, although independent optimization confirms both maxima and the claimed PIO monotonicity violation.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
15 pages

Related papers

Robustness as a thermodynamic currency: work advantages and preparation costs of nonclassical states

Luis Pedro Garcıa-Pintos, Tanmoy Biswas, Chandan Datta

Understanding whether uniquely quantum features can provide concrete advantages in thermodynamic processes is a central objective of quantum thermodynamics. A key challenge is quantifying how different forms of non-classicality can be systematically harnessed to enhance thermodynamic tasks. In light of this, we prove that any form of non-classicality can serve as a thermodynamic resource. In particular, any system that possesses quantum magic, coherence, or non-classical correlations can be leveraged to extract higher amounts of work than if the system does not possess such resources. The quantum thermodynamic advantages--quantified by the ratio between work extractable from a resource state and work extractable in its absence--increase with the resource robustness. We show that for any convex quantum resource theory, any resourceful state can yield a work-extraction advantage over all free states via a cyclic quench/thermalization protocol whose Hamiltonian is engineered from an optimal robustness witness. We illustrate concrete examples in which the robustness measures increase with the system's dimension, yielding quantum thermodynamic advantages that scale with it. In contrast, we also show that preparing a resource state (e.g., one with magic, coherence, or non-classical correlations) can be significantly more thermodynamically costly than preparing any state without such a resource. Concretely, there always exists a protocol that can prepare any non-resourceful state at significantly less work than it takes to prepare a resourceful state. Overall, our results provide operational meaning to robustness measures of quantum resources in terms of their thermodynamic costs and advantages.

quant-pharXiv:2603.04618•Mar 6, 2026•1 citation

Information and coherence as resources for work extraction from unknown quantum state and providing quantum advantages

Tanmoy Biswas

The amount of extractable work from a physical system is fundamentally connected to the information available about its state, as illustrated by Maxwell's demon and the Gibbs paradox. In standard thermodynamic protocols involving system--bath interactions, the maximum work is given by the free-energy difference between the initial state and the corresponding Gibbs state at the bath temperature. This motivates a natural question: does information also limit work extraction in closed quantum systems that do not involve a heat bath and where work is obtained through unitary operations generated by a time-dependent Hamiltonian? While ergotropy quantifies the maximum work extractable via unitary operations, it assumes complete knowledge of the quantum state, typically requiring full state tomography. In realistic scenarios, however, only partial information is accessible. In this case, the relevant figure of merit is observational ergotropy, which depends explicitly on the measurement used to probe the system. We show that observational ergotropy decreases under classical post-processing of measurement outcomes, implying that fine-grained measurements allow greater work extraction than coarse-grained ones. Moreover, maximizing observational ergotropy over all possible measurements recovers standard ergotropy, which decomposes into incoherent (classical) and coherent (quantum) contributions. Our results demonstrate that coherence in the measurement projectors constitutes the key resource, enabling work extraction beyond the incoherent limit and establishing coherence as the origin of quantum advantage in observational ergotropy extraction.

quant-pharXiv:2602.22893•Feb 27, 2026•3 citations

Quantifying coherence of quantum measurements

Kyunghyun Baek, Adel Sohbi, Jaehak Lee +2 more

Abstract In this work we investigate how to quantify the coherence of quantum measurements. First, we establish a resource theoretical framework to address the coherence of measurement and show that any statistical distance can be adopted to define a coherence monotone of measurement. For instance, the relative entropy fulfills all the required properties as a proper monotone. We specifically introduce a coherence monotone of measurement in terms of off-diagonal elements of positive-operator-valued measure components. This quantification provides a lower bound on the robustness of measurement-coherence that has an operational meaning as the maximal advantage over all incoherent measurements in state discrimination tasks. Finally, we propose an experimental scheme to assess our quantification of measurement-coherence and demonstrate it by performing an experiment using a single qubit on IBM Q processor.

arXiv:2008.03999•New Journal of Physics•Aug 7, 2020•27 citations

A note on the monotonicity of observational ergotropic advantage

Debanjan Dey Sarkar, Mallika Mondal, Preeti Parashar

Very recently, Mahanti et al. (arXiv:2609.18735) introduced the observational ergotropic advantage, which gives the maximum value of extra work that a measurement can obtain with respect to all incoherent measurements. However, the above quantity does not show monotonic behaviour under the resource theory of measurement coherence. So, the search for a resource theory in which it is a monotone was open. We derive the monotonicity of this quantity using energy-preserving channels and passive resets as free operations and energy-incoherent measurements as free objects. We show the monotonicity property of the measure as a necessary criterion of measurement transformation, but it turns out not to be a sufficient condition. It is further established that the measure is not convex. A short analysis of bounds and tightness of the measure using a degenerate Hamiltonian is also given.

quant-pharXiv:2610.32585•Oct 26, 2026•0 citations

Works with quantum resource of coherence

Yuhan Ma, Liu, C. L., C. P. Sun

We study the modification of the second law of thermodynamics for a quantum system interacting with a reservoir regarding quantum coherence. The whole system is isolated so that neither energy nor information is lost. It is discovered that the coherence of the reservoir can serves as a useful resource allowing the system extract more energy from the reservoir; among the coherence measures, only is the relative entropy of coherence feasible to quantitatively characterize energy exchange. We demonstrate that a thermodynamic cycle between two coherent reservoirs can output more work than its classical counterpart. The efficiency of such cycle surpasses the Carnot efficiency, which is the upper bound of heat engine efficiency in classical regime.

arXiv:2110.04550•Oct 9, 2021•12 citations

Robustness of Quantum Memories: An Operational Resource-Theoretic Approach

Xiao Yuan, Yunchao Liu, Qi Zhao +3 more

Quantum memory -- the capacity to store and faithfully recover unknown quantum states -- is essential for any quantum technology to exhibit operational advantage. There is thus great value in identifying physically meaningful means to benchmark candidate quantum memories against each other across diverse operational settings. Here we introduce the robustness of quantum memory, and prove that it satisfies all the mathematical properties we expect of a bona-fide resource-theoretic measure of a system's capacity to retain non-classical information. We demonstrate its operational meaning as a resource in three different settings: (1) the resource cost of synthesising the memory with idealised qubit memories, (2) the resource cost of simulating the memory's observational statistics with classical resources, and (3) the performance of the memory in discriminating different input states. We illustrate an efficient semi-definite program to estimate the robustness of quantum memory, and show that it can be lower bounded with a single witness or purity measurement. Our results thus provide an experimentally accessible and operationally meaningful quantifier of the resources behind preserving quantum information.

•Jul 4, 2019•7 citations
The use of quantum resources in the work extraction from a quantum system is an emerging research topic. Recently, [arXiv:2602.22893] established the necessity of measurement coherence for obtaining advantage in work extraction from an unknown isolated quantum system. However, a quantitative relation between the magnitude of this advantage and established measures of measurement coherence is missing. Here, we establish such a connection by introducing a faithful operational quantifier of the work advantage provided by a measurement. We show that measurement coherence is necessary and sufficient for a positive advantage, and derive upper and lower bounds in terms of the robustness of measurement coherence and an l∞l_{\infty}l∞​ norm based coherence measure respectively. Finally, we examine this quantifier of advantage from the resource theoretic perspective. Our results provide an operational characterisation of measurement coherence as a resource for work extraction and reveal a nontrivial relation between its resource content and thermodynamic value.
The paper asks whether every measurement with coherence in the energy eigenbasis can improve observational ergotropy over incoherent measurements, and how that improvement relates to measurement-coherence measures. It uses the coarse-grained state ΛMcg(ρ)=∑μTr⁡[ρM(μ)]M(μ)/Tr⁡M(μ)\Lambda_M^{\rm cg}(\rho)=\sum_\mu\operatorname{Tr}[\rho M(\mu)]M(\mu)/\operatorname{Tr}M(\mu)ΛMcg​(ρ)=∑μ​Tr[ρM(μ)]M(μ)/TrM(μ) and defines the measurement’s advantage as AMH=max⁡ρ[PH(Δρ)−PH(ΛMcg(ρ))]A_M^H=\max_\rho[P_H(\Delta\rho)-P_H(\Lambda_M^{\rm cg}(\rho))]AMH​=maxρ​[PH​(Δρ)−PH​(ΛMcg​(ρ))], where PHP_HPH​ is passive energy. A difference replaces a ratio because the incoherent-work benchmark can vanish, making ratio-based advantages divergent.
For nondegenerate Hamiltonians, the main result is AMH>0A_M^H>0AMH​>0 if and only if MMM is coherent. The quantitative bounds are δmin⁡Cl∞(M)2/d2≤AMH≤[(d−1)/d](Ed−1−E0)RC(M)\delta_{\min}C_{l_\infty}(M)^2/d^2\leq A_M^H\leq[(d-1)/d](E_{d-1}-E_0)R_C(M)δmin​Cl∞​​(M)2/d2≤AMH​≤[(d−1)/d](Ed−1​−E0​)RC​(M), with δmin⁡\delta_{\min}δmin​ the smallest adjacent energy gap. Both bounds have saturating qubit families: rank-one projective measurements attain the upper bound, while equatorial trine POVMs with visibility ccc have AMH=Ec2/4A_M^H=Ec^2/4AMH​=Ec2/4, attaining the lower bound. A separate ceiling, AMH≤Tr⁡(H)/d−E0A_M^H\leq\operatorname{Tr}(H)/d-E_0AMH​≤Tr(H)/d−E0​, is accompanied by a characterization of measurements attaining it.
The proofs use perturbations around the maximally mixed state, variational formulas for sums of largest eigenvalues, and robustness decompositions. Explicit examples show that greater coherence robustness need not yield greater advantage; a qutrit construction also shows failure of monotonicity under physically incoherent preprocessing. Thus the advantage is not itself a coherence monotone under the operations considered. Degenerate Hamiltonians and a resource theory making the advantage monotonic are left for future investigation.
Understanding whether uniquely quantum features can provide concrete advantages in thermodynamic processes is a central objective of quantum thermodynamics. A key challenge is quantifying how different forms of non-classicality can be systematically harnessed to enhance thermodynamic tasks. In light of this, we prove that any form of non-classicality can serve as a thermodynamic resource. In particular, any system that possesses quantum magic, coherence, or non-classical correlations can be leveraged to extract higher amounts of work than if the system does not possess such resources. The quantum thermodynamic advantages--quantified by the ratio between work extractable from a resource state and work extractable in its absence--increase with the resource robustness. We show that for any convex quantum resource theory, any resourceful state can yield a work-extraction advantage over all free states via a cyclic quench/thermalization protocol whose Hamiltonian is engineered from an optimal robustness witness. We illustrate concrete examples in which the robustness measures increase with the system's dimension, yielding quantum thermodynamic advantages that scale with it. In contrast, we also show that preparing a resource state (e.g., one with magic, coherence, or non-classical correlations) can be significantly more thermodynamically costly than preparing any state without such a resource. Concretely, there always exists a protocol that can prepare any non-resourceful state at significantly less work than it takes to prepare a resourceful state. Overall, our results provide operational meaning to robustness measures of quantum resources in terms of their thermodynamic costs and advantages.
The amount of extractable work from a physical system is fundamentally connected to the information available about its state, as illustrated by Maxwell's demon and the Gibbs paradox. In standard thermodynamic protocols involving system--bath interactions, the maximum work is given by the free-energy difference between the initial state and the corresponding Gibbs state at the bath temperature. This motivates a natural question: does information also limit work extraction in closed quantum systems that do not involve a heat bath and where work is obtained through unitary operations generated by a time-dependent Hamiltonian? While ergotropy quantifies the maximum work extractable via unitary operations, it assumes complete knowledge of the quantum state, typically requiring full state tomography. In realistic scenarios, however, only partial information is accessible. In this case, the relevant figure of merit is observational ergotropy, which depends explicitly on the measurement used to probe the system. We show that observational ergotropy decreases under classical post-processing of measurement outcomes, implying that fine-grained measurements allow greater work extraction than coarse-grained ones. Moreover, maximizing observational ergotropy over all possible measurements recovers standard ergotropy, which decomposes into incoherent (classical) and coherent (quantum) contributions. Our results demonstrate that coherence in the measurement projectors constitutes the key resource, enabling work extraction beyond the incoherent limit and establishing coherence as the origin of quantum advantage in observational ergotropy extraction.
Abstract In this work we investigate how to quantify the coherence of quantum measurements. First, we establish a resource theoretical framework to address the coherence of measurement and show that any statistical distance can be adopted to define a coherence monotone of measurement. For instance, the relative entropy fulfills all the required properties as a proper monotone. We specifically introduce a coherence monotone of measurement in terms of off-diagonal elements of positive-operator-valued measure components. This quantification provides a lower bound on the robustness of measurement-coherence that has an operational meaning as the maximal advantage over all incoherent measurements in state discrimination tasks. Finally, we propose an experimental scheme to assess our quantification of measurement-coherence and demonstrate it by performing an experiment using a single qubit on IBM Q processor.
Very recently, Mahanti et al. (arXiv:2609.18735) introduced the observational ergotropic advantage, which gives the maximum value of extra work that a measurement can obtain with respect to all incoherent measurements. However, the above quantity does not show monotonic behaviour under the resource theory of measurement coherence. So, the search for a resource theory in which it is a monotone was open. We derive the monotonicity of this quantity using energy-preserving channels and passive resets as free operations and energy-incoherent measurements as free objects. We show the monotonicity property of the measure as a necessary criterion of measurement transformation, but it turns out not to be a sufficient condition. It is further established that the measure is not convex. A short analysis of bounds and tightness of the measure using a degenerate Hamiltonian is also given.
We study the modification of the second law of thermodynamics for a quantum system interacting with a reservoir regarding quantum coherence. The whole system is isolated so that neither energy nor information is lost. It is discovered that the coherence of the reservoir can serves as a useful resource allowing the system extract more energy from the reservoir; among the coherence measures, only is the relative entropy of coherence feasible to quantitatively characterize energy exchange. We demonstrate that a thermodynamic cycle between two coherent reservoirs can output more work than its classical counterpart. The efficiency of such cycle surpasses the Carnot efficiency, which is the upper bound of heat engine efficiency in classical regime.
Quantum memory -- the capacity to store and faithfully recover unknown quantum states -- is essential for any quantum technology to exhibit operational advantage. There is thus great value in identifying physically meaningful means to benchmark candidate quantum memories against each other across diverse operational settings. Here we introduce the robustness of quantum memory, and prove that it satisfies all the mathematical properties we expect of a bona-fide resource-theoretic measure of a system's capacity to retain non-classical information. We demonstrate its operational meaning as a resource in three different settings: (1) the resource cost of synthesising the memory with idealised qubit memories, (2) the resource cost of simulating the memory's observational statistics with classical resources, and (3) the performance of the memory in discriminating different input states. We illustrate an efficient semi-definite program to estimate the robustness of quantum memory, and show that it can be lower bounded with a single witness or purity measurement. Our results thus provide an experimentally accessible and operationally meaningful quantifier of the resources behind preserving quantum information.