arXiv:2609.18735
All coherent measurements provide observational ergotropic advantage
Soumik Mahanti, Rakesh Saini, Alexei Gilchrist, Arindam Mitra
Abstract
The use of quantum resources in the work extraction from a quantum system is an emerging research topic. Recently, [arXiv:2602.22893] established the necessity of measurement coherence for obtaining advantage in work extraction from an unknown isolated quantum system. However, a quantitative relation between the magnitude of this advantage and established measures of measurement coherence is missing. Here, we establish such a connection by introducing a faithful operational quantifier of the work advantage provided by a measurement. We show that measurement coherence is necessary and sufficient for a positive advantage, and derive upper and lower bounds in terms of the robustness of measurement coherence and an $l_{\infty}$ norm based coherence measure respectively. Finally, we examine this quantifier of advantage from the resource theoretic perspective. Our results provide an operational characterisation of measurement coherence as a resource for work extraction and reveal a nontrivial relation between its resource content and thermodynamic value.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether every measurement with coherence in the energy eigenbasis can improve observational ergotropy over incoherent measurements, and how that improvement relates to measurement-coherence measures. It uses the coarse-grained state $\Lambda_M^{\rm cg}(\rho)=\sum_\mu\operatorname{Tr}[\rho M(\mu)]M(\mu)/\operatorname{Tr}M(\mu)$ and defines the measurement’s advantage as $A_M^H=\max_\rho[P_H(\Delta\rho)-P_H(\Lambda_M^{\rm cg}(\rho))]$, where $P_H$ is passive energy. A difference replaces a ratio because the incoherent-work benchmark can vanish, making ratio-based advantages divergent. For nondegenerate Hamiltonians, the main result is $A_M^H>0$ if and only if $M$ is coherent. The quantitative bounds are $\delta_{\min}C_{l_\infty}(M)^2/d^2\leq A_M^H\leq[(d-1)/d](E_{d-1}-E_0)R_C(M)$, with $\delta_{\min}$ the smallest adjacent energy gap. Both bounds have saturating qubit families: rank-one projective measurements attain the upper bound, while equatorial trine POVMs with visibility $c$ have $A_M^H=Ec^2/4$, attaining the lower bound. A separate ceiling, $A_M^H\leq\operatorname{Tr}(H)/d-E_0$, is accompanied by a characterization of measurements attaining it. The proofs use perturbations around the maximally mixed state, variational formulas for sums of largest eigenvalues, and robustness decompositions. Explicit examples show that greater coherence robustness need not yield greater advantage; a qutrit construction also shows failure of monotonicity under physically incoherent preprocessing. Thus the advantage is not itself a coherence monotone under the operations considered. Degenerate Hamiltonians and a resource theory making the advantage monotonic are left for future investigation.
Error found: The unconditional coherence-sufficiency theorem fails for the explicitly permitted constant Hamiltonian H=cI, because every measurement then has zero observational ergotropic advantage. The sufficiency proof falsely asserts that the coarse-graining channel maps its chosen off-diagonal operator to an operator with zero diagonal, although a positive quadratic-form argument repairs the proof. The appendix omits the population-optimization bound needed to establish its asserted global maxima, although independent optimization confirms both maxima and the claimed PIO monotonicity violation.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 15 pages