Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.18671

Theory-agnostic nonclassicality certification in an integrated photonic circuit

Vinicius P. Rossi, Emanuele Polino, Beatrice Polacchi, Valeria Cimini, David Schmid, John H. Selby, Giacomo Corrielli, Andrea Crespi, Roberto Osellame, Fabio Sciarrino, Ana Belén Sainz

quant-phSubmitted Sep 16, 2026• Announced Sep 17, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Certifying nonclassicality without assuming any particular underlying physical theory constitutes both a foundational challenge and a requirement for device-independent protocols. Realizing such theory-independent certification in scalable architectures is essential for connecting fundamental tests with emerging quantum technologies. Integrated photonic circuits are a leading platform for scalable quantum information processing, motivating the development of rigorous methods to certify the nonclassical resources underpinning quantum advantage. In this paper, we report a theory-independent certification of generalized contextuality on a three-mode integrated photonic circuit. Our approach combines theory-agnostic tomography with simplex-embeddability certification---a framework that requires no assumptions about the underlying physical theory---and applies it to experimental data from a three-mode photonic circuit seeded by single photons. An independently constructed quantum model of the experiment provides a consistency check on the observed nonclassicality, without entering the certification as a theoretical assumption. The method rules out simplex-embeddability for our experimental data, providing robust, theory-independent evidence that our photonic circuit exhibits nonclassicality.

AI Summary

Can generalized contextuality be certified in an integrated photonic circuit without assuming a quantum model? This paper applies an existing pipeline of theory-agnostic tomography and simplex-embeddability testing to single-photon prepare-and-measure statistics from a three-mode chip. Independently controlled voltages define preparation and measurement settings, with three output outcomes and approximately $3500$ detected coincidences per setting pair. A constrained low-rank factorization reconstructs generalized-probabilistic-theory (GPT) states and effects from the measured frequencies. Rank selection uses training and cross-table prediction errors across the original table and nine multinomially resampled tables. Both experimental data and a separately fitted quantum model select effective rank $k=7$, rather than the full qutrit GPT dimension of $9$. Linear-programming tests find depolarizing-noise robustness $r=0.200\pm0.005$ for the experimental reconstruction and $0.261\pm0.001$ for the model reconstruction. A simulated fully dephased classical counterpart returns zero robustness at comparable count levels. The certification concerns the reconstructed GPT fragment: its robustness is not a noise threshold for the raw experimental probabilities. The paper explicitly acknowledges the tomographic-completeness loophole: reconstructed fragments can be GPT “shadows” whose failure of simplex embeddability need not establish contextuality of the underlying system. The measurements and preparations are not mutually tomographically complete in the quantum model, and the consistency checks do not close this loophole. The prepare-and-measure causal decomposition also requires justification. No operational advantage or fully device-independent security protocol is demonstrated.

Little sign of AI-generated textIncrementalOverclaimsStrong assumptions

Central claim may not hold: The abstract and conclusions overstate the physical certification: non-simplex-embeddability of the reconstructed GPT shadow establishes contextuality only with additional tomographic justification that the paper explicitly leaves unresolved. The classical dephasing control is insufficiently specified: mode-basis dephasing of the supplied preparation and measurement model produces an ideal rank-one table, so reproducing the reported rank-three control requires a different, explicitly specified channel or basis. The consistency-check prose reports classical-control rank three at all tested count values, contradicting the figure caption's rank-two results at N=10^2 and N=10^3.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
22 pages, 7 figures. A Github repository accompanies the publication. Comments are welcome!

Related papers

Randomness certification in a quantum network with independent sources

Giorgio Minati, Giovanni Rodari, Emanuele Polino +5 more

Randomness certification is a foundational and practical aspect of quantum information science, essential for securing quantum communication protocols. Traditionally, these protocols have been implemented and validated with a single entanglement source, as in the paradigmatic Bell scenario. However, advancing these protocols to support more complex configurations involving multiple entanglement sources is key to building robust architectures and realizing large-scale quantum networks. Here, we show how to certify randomness in an entanglement-teleportation experiment, the building block of a quantum repeater displaying two independent sources of entanglement. Using the scalar extension method, we address the challenge posed by the nonconvexity of the correlation set, providing effective bounds on an eavesdropper's knowledge of the shared secret bits. Our theoretical model characterizes the certifiable randomness within the network and is validated through the analysis of experimental data from a photonic quantum network.

arXiv:2502.14658•Science Advances•Jan 23, 2026•7 citations

Observation of quantum nonclassicality without freedom of choice in a minimal causal network

Ya Xiao, Yan-Xin Rong, Ran He +6 more

Quantum causal networks enable tests of nonclassicality beyond Bell nonlocality while relaxing some physically unwarranted assumptions. By relaxing the freedom-of-choice and spacelike-separation assumptions, the unrelated-confounders causal networks provide a simple and robust route to certify quantum nonclassicality. Here, we implement the minimal three-node unrelated-confounders network in an optical experiment using two independent polarization-entangled photon sources and an intervention at the central node, experimentally achieved with a high-fidelity entangling measurement. We employ a causal data-fusion protocol that combines observational and interventional data to significantly improve the protocol's noise tolerance, and observe a violation of the corresponding hybrid causal inequality by more than three standard deviations. Our results provide deeper insights into quantum nonlocality in networks and highlight the UC network as a compact, experimentally accessible platform for device-independent quantum protocols that do not require actively chosen measurement settings.

quant-pharXiv:2608.03552•Aug 5, 2026•0 citations

Integrated photonic circuits for contextuality tests via sequential measurements in three-level quantum systems

Patrick Lima, Wilder R. Cardoso, Sebastião Pádua

In this paper, we present a protocol to obtain photonic circuits that can be used in the implementation of contextuality tests on qutrit systems. The use of photonic integrated circuits offers several advantages for performing this type of task. These include scalability, accuracy, robustness, high-speed and efficient quantum measurements, precise control over the phase properties of photons by using electrically driven heaters to induce a thermo-optic phase shift and resistance to noise. We relate the average values that appear in the inequalities with the probability of photon counting in the circuit outputs and present a realizable configuration for the desired device, taking into account state-dependent and state-independent contextuality tests.

Optics Express•Dec 28, 2023•3 citations

Connecting Quantum Contextuality and Nonlocality

Jianqi Sheng, Dongkai Zhang, Lixiang Chen

Quantum theory departs from classical physics in its treatment of correlations, most prominently through the phenomena of contextuality and nonlocality. Once regarded primarily as foundational curiosities, these effects are now understood as key operational resources for quantum computation, communication, and simulation. Although traditionally investigated in distinct settings, recent theoretical and experimental advances have revealed deep conceptual, mathematical, and operational connections between them. This review presents a unified perspective on these developments based on sheaf-theoretic and graph-theoretic frameworks, which provide theory-independent characterizations of statistical correlations. These approaches clarify the structural relationship between contextuality and nonlocality, facilitate the formulation of experimentally testable inequalities, and guide implementations in realistic physical platforms, with particular emphasis on photonic systems. By bridging abstract theoretical structures and concrete experimental realizations, this review sheds light on the nonclassical foundations of quantum correlations and their emerging role in quantum technologies.

quant-pharXiv:2602.23221•Feb 27, 2026•0 citations

Robust certification of high-dimensional quantum devices

Javier Fernández, Albert Rico, David Viedma +6 more

Certifying quantum behavior from classically accessible data is essential for secure communication and scalable quantum technologies. While powerful certification methods such as Bell nonlocality and quantum steering exist, their implementation typically requires entanglement or additional assumptions, and experimental demonstrations mainly focus on low-dimensional systems. In minimal prepare-and-measure scenarios, where a sender encodes information into quantum states and a receiver performs a single measurement, robust certification becomes particularly challenging, especially in the presence of noise and in higher-dimensional Hilbert spaces. Here, we propose, design, and experimentally implement a protocol that certifies quantumness between two distant parties without the need for preshared resources or measurement incompatibility. The experiments are carried out using the orbital angular momentum degrees of freedom of single photons, chosen for providing increased dimensionality that is scalable. We demonstrate the robustness of the protocol through rank-stability analysis of the observed correlations, which enables the certification of non-classicality even in the presence of noise. Our results provide a practical route to validate high-dimensional quantum communication systems and open new possibilities for secure and dimension-efficient quantum information processing.

quant-pharXiv:2605.04338•May 7, 2026•0 citations

Theory-independent monitoring of the decoherence of a superconducting qubit with generalized contextuality

Albert Aloy, Matteo Fadel, Thomas D. Galley +2 more

Characterizing the nonclassicality of quantum systems under minimal assumptions is an important challenge for quantum foundations and technology. Here we introduce a theory-independent method of process tomography and perform it on a superconducting qubit. We demonstrate its decoherence without assuming quantum theory or trusting the devices by modelling the system as a general probabilistic theory. We show that the superconducting system is initially well-described as a quantum bit, but that its realized state space contracts over time, which in quantum terminology indicates its loss of coherence. The system is initially nonclassical in the sense of generalized contextuality: it does not admit of a hidden-variable model where statistically indistinguishable preparations are represented by identical hidden-variable distributions. In finite time, the system becomes noncontextual and hence loses its nonclassicality. Moreover, we demonstrate in a theory-independent way that the system undergoes non-Markovian evolution at late times. Our results extend theory-independent tomography to time-evolving systems, and show how important dynamical physical phenomena can be experimentally monitored without assuming quantum theory.

arXiv:2411.13421•Nature Communications•Feb 7, 2026•2 citations
Certifying nonclassicality without assuming any particular underlying physical theory constitutes both a foundational challenge and a requirement for device-independent protocols. Realizing such theory-independent certification in scalable architectures is essential for connecting fundamental tests with emerging quantum technologies. Integrated photonic circuits are a leading platform for scalable quantum information processing, motivating the development of rigorous methods to certify the nonclassical resources underpinning quantum advantage. In this paper, we report a theory-independent certification of generalized contextuality on a three-mode integrated photonic circuit. Our approach combines theory-agnostic tomography with simplex-embeddability certification---a framework that requires no assumptions about the underlying physical theory---and applies it to experimental data from a three-mode photonic circuit seeded by single photons. An independently constructed quantum model of the experiment provides a consistency check on the observed nonclassicality, without entering the certification as a theoretical assumption. The method rules out simplex-embeddability for our experimental data, providing robust, theory-independent evidence that our photonic circuit exhibits nonclassicality.
Can generalized contextuality be certified in an integrated photonic circuit without assuming a quantum model? This paper applies an existing pipeline of theory-agnostic tomography and simplex-embeddability testing to single-photon prepare-and-measure statistics from a three-mode chip. Independently controlled voltages define preparation and measurement settings, with three output outcomes and approximately 350035003500 detected coincidences per setting pair.
A constrained low-rank factorization reconstructs generalized-probabilistic-theory (GPT) states and effects from the measured frequencies. Rank selection uses training and cross-table prediction errors across the original table and nine multinomially resampled tables. Both experimental data and a separately fitted quantum model select effective rank k=7k=7k=7, rather than the full qutrit GPT dimension of 999. Linear-programming tests find depolarizing-noise robustness r=0.200±0.005r=0.200\pm0.005r=0.200±0.005 for the experimental reconstruction and 0.261±0.0010.261\pm0.0010.261±0.001 for the model reconstruction. A simulated fully dephased classical counterpart returns zero robustness at comparable count levels.
The certification concerns the reconstructed GPT fragment: its robustness is not a noise threshold for the raw experimental probabilities. The paper explicitly acknowledges the tomographic-completeness loophole: reconstructed fragments can be GPT “shadows” whose failure of simplex embeddability need not establish contextuality of the underlying system. The measurements and preparations are not mutually tomographically complete in the quantum model, and the consistency checks do not close this loophole. The prepare-and-measure causal decomposition also requires justification. No operational advantage or fully device-independent security protocol is demonstrated.
Randomness certification is a foundational and practical aspect of quantum information science, essential for securing quantum communication protocols. Traditionally, these protocols have been implemented and validated with a single entanglement source, as in the paradigmatic Bell scenario. However, advancing these protocols to support more complex configurations involving multiple entanglement sources is key to building robust architectures and realizing large-scale quantum networks. Here, we show how to certify randomness in an entanglement-teleportation experiment, the building block of a quantum repeater displaying two independent sources of entanglement. Using the scalar extension method, we address the challenge posed by the nonconvexity of the correlation set, providing effective bounds on an eavesdropper's knowledge of the shared secret bits. Our theoretical model characterizes the certifiable randomness within the network and is validated through the analysis of experimental data from a photonic quantum network.
Quantum causal networks enable tests of nonclassicality beyond Bell nonlocality while relaxing some physically unwarranted assumptions. By relaxing the freedom-of-choice and spacelike-separation assumptions, the unrelated-confounders causal networks provide a simple and robust route to certify quantum nonclassicality. Here, we implement the minimal three-node unrelated-confounders network in an optical experiment using two independent polarization-entangled photon sources and an intervention at the central node, experimentally achieved with a high-fidelity entangling measurement. We employ a causal data-fusion protocol that combines observational and interventional data to significantly improve the protocol's noise tolerance, and observe a violation of the corresponding hybrid causal inequality by more than three standard deviations. Our results provide deeper insights into quantum nonlocality in networks and highlight the UC network as a compact, experimentally accessible platform for device-independent quantum protocols that do not require actively chosen measurement settings.
In this paper, we present a protocol to obtain photonic circuits that can be used in the implementation of contextuality tests on qutrit systems. The use of photonic integrated circuits offers several advantages for performing this type of task. These include scalability, accuracy, robustness, high-speed and efficient quantum measurements, precise control over the phase properties of photons by using electrically driven heaters to induce a thermo-optic phase shift and resistance to noise. We relate the average values that appear in the inequalities with the probability of photon counting in the circuit outputs and present a realizable configuration for the desired device, taking into account state-dependent and state-independent contextuality tests.
Quantum theory departs from classical physics in its treatment of correlations, most prominently through the phenomena of contextuality and nonlocality. Once regarded primarily as foundational curiosities, these effects are now understood as key operational resources for quantum computation, communication, and simulation. Although traditionally investigated in distinct settings, recent theoretical and experimental advances have revealed deep conceptual, mathematical, and operational connections between them. This review presents a unified perspective on these developments based on sheaf-theoretic and graph-theoretic frameworks, which provide theory-independent characterizations of statistical correlations. These approaches clarify the structural relationship between contextuality and nonlocality, facilitate the formulation of experimentally testable inequalities, and guide implementations in realistic physical platforms, with particular emphasis on photonic systems. By bridging abstract theoretical structures and concrete experimental realizations, this review sheds light on the nonclassical foundations of quantum correlations and their emerging role in quantum technologies.
Certifying quantum behavior from classically accessible data is essential for secure communication and scalable quantum technologies. While powerful certification methods such as Bell nonlocality and quantum steering exist, their implementation typically requires entanglement or additional assumptions, and experimental demonstrations mainly focus on low-dimensional systems. In minimal prepare-and-measure scenarios, where a sender encodes information into quantum states and a receiver performs a single measurement, robust certification becomes particularly challenging, especially in the presence of noise and in higher-dimensional Hilbert spaces. Here, we propose, design, and experimentally implement a protocol that certifies quantumness between two distant parties without the need for preshared resources or measurement incompatibility. The experiments are carried out using the orbital angular momentum degrees of freedom of single photons, chosen for providing increased dimensionality that is scalable. We demonstrate the robustness of the protocol through rank-stability analysis of the observed correlations, which enables the certification of non-classicality even in the presence of noise. Our results provide a practical route to validate high-dimensional quantum communication systems and open new possibilities for secure and dimension-efficient quantum information processing.
Characterizing the nonclassicality of quantum systems under minimal assumptions is an important challenge for quantum foundations and technology. Here we introduce a theory-independent method of process tomography and perform it on a superconducting qubit. We demonstrate its decoherence without assuming quantum theory or trusting the devices by modelling the system as a general probabilistic theory. We show that the superconducting system is initially well-described as a quantum bit, but that its realized state space contracts over time, which in quantum terminology indicates its loss of coherence. The system is initially nonclassical in the sense of generalized contextuality: it does not admit of a hidden-variable model where statistically indistinguishable preparations are represented by identical hidden-variable distributions. In finite time, the system becomes noncontextual and hence loses its nonclassicality. Moreover, we demonstrate in a theory-independent way that the system undergoes non-Markovian evolution at late times. Our results extend theory-independent tomography to time-evolving systems, and show how important dynamical physical phenomena can be experimentally monitored without assuming quantum theory.