Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.18666

Impact of a CSS quantum error correction code in underwater quantum key distribution

Juliette Florin, Nicolas Le Josse, Arnaud Coatanhay, Gilles Burel

quant-phSubmitted Sep 16, 2026• Announced Sep 17, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum key distribution (QKD) enables secure underwater communications essential for maritime infrastructure. Underwater optical channels introduce substantial photon loss (erasures) and ambient noise that degrade QKD performance. This paper investigates whether two four-qubit Calderbank-Shor-Steane (CSS) quantum error correction codes (QECC) mitigate these impairments in vertical underwater communication BB84 QKD protocol. After developing a comprehensive stochastic channel model incorporating photon loss, geometric spreading, and solar noise, we assess the viability of QECC through the analytical study of the quantum bit error rate (QBER) and the secure key rate (SKR) with and without security depending on the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) validated against Monte Carlo simulations. The standard four-qubit CSS code achieves a 3 dB SNR gain at the QBER 11% security threshold; the discard code variant achieves 4.5 dB. However, QECC includes an encoding overhead that reduces the SKR. We demonstrate a crucial relationship between the SKR and the probability of arrival of the sent photon. Analysis shows that QECC is beneficial exclusively in marginal SNR regimes; at high SNR, raw BB84 dominates. For an ocean Type III Jerlov water scenario with sunlight coming from the sun located at the top of the atmosphere, we identify operational depth-range windows where QECC enables communication otherwise infeasible. This analysis establishes that error correction deployment must be scenario-dependent: extend operational range at the cost of throughput when SNR is marginal, or prioritize key generation rates at high SNR.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether four-qubit CSS encoding improves vertical underwater BB84 QKD when photon loss and ambient solar photons dominate. It combines a stochastic optical-channel model incorporating geometric spreading, exponential attenuation, and independent Poisson signal/background arrivals with an erasure-plus-depolarization channel. Two existing $[[4,1,2]]$ code variants are evaluated: one corrects a single known erasure and rejects detected errors; the other discards any block containing an erasure. Analytical error-pattern enumeration is compared with Monte Carlo simulations. At the assumed $11\%$ QBER security threshold, the standard and discard variants reduce the required SNR by approximately $3$ and $4.5$ dB, respectively. These gains incur substantial throughput penalties beyond the four-to-one encoding overhead. With physical survival probability $s\ll1$ and negligible background, the key-rate scalings are $\xi s$ without encoding, $\xi s^3$ for the standard code, and $\xi s^4/4$ for the discard variant. For the specified Jerlov type-III water and solar-background scenario, encoding reduces minimum operating depth by roughly $6$–$8$ m or extends range by $6.5$–$9.3$ m. Benefits occur near the security threshold; unencoded BB84 gives higher rates at high SNR. The analysis assumes ideal gates, quantum memories, QND photon-number detection, synchronization, and homogeneous water. It omits propagation-induced phase errors and uses a simplified angular solar-radiance model. Stated extensions include finite-fidelity hardware, alternative receiver orientations, experimental validation, and further security analysis accounting for an adversary’s knowledge of the code structure, including coherent attacks.

Some signs of AI-generated textIncrementalStrong assumptionsMissing comparisonPossible error

Central claim may not hold: The positive rates labelled secure are not justified for the stated Poissonian source: in some explicitly studied loss regimes, photon-number splitting can reproduce the raw-BB84 detections without errors while revealing the entire key. The solar-noise model extrapolates solar-disk radiance across the receiver's hemispherical field of view without a supporting angular model, undermining the claimed operational depth windows. Table 3's high-SNR rate ratios disagree with the paper's own noise-free formulas and μ=0.1, contradicting its claimed numerical agreement.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
37 pages, 13 figures

Related papers

The security analysis of the BB84 protocol in the case of Calderbank–Shor–Steane code leakage

Ming Fang, Yaping Li, Li Fei

Quantum key distribution (QKD) allows authenticated parties to share secure keys. Its security comes from quantum physics rather than computational complexity. The previous work has been able to demonstrate the security of the BB84 protocol based on the uncertainty principle, entanglement purification and information theory. In the security proof method based on entanglement purification, it is assumed that the information of Calderbank–Shor–Steane (CSS) error correction code cannot be leaked, otherwise, it is insecure. However, there is no quantitative analysis of the relationship between the parameter of CSS code and the amount of information leaked. In the attack and defense strategy of the actual quantum key distribution system, especially in the application of the device that is easy to lose or out of control, it is necessary to assess the impact of the parameter leakage. In this paper, we derive the relationship between the leaked parameter of CSS code and the amount of the final key leakage based on the BB84 protocol. Based on this formula, we simulated the impact of different CSS code parameter leaks on the final key amount. Through the analysis of simulation results, the security of the BB84 protocol is inversely proportional to the value of [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] in the case of the CSS code leak.

International Journal of Quantum Information•Jan 6, 2022•0 citations

Performance Analysis of Quantum Key Distribution in Underwater Channels

Amir Hossein Fahim Raouf

The current literature on quantum key distribution (QKD) is mainly limited to the transmissions over fiber optic, atmospheric or satellite links and are not directly applicable to underwater environments with different channel characteristics. Absorption, scattering, and turbulence experienced in underwater channels severely limit the range of quantum communication links. In the first part of this thesis, we analyze the quantum bit error rate (QBER) and secret key rate (SKR) performance of the well-known BB84 protocol in underwater channels. As path loss model, we consider a modified version of Beer-Lambert formula which takes into account the effect of scattering. We derive a closed-form expression for the wave structure function to determine the average power transfer over turbulent underwater path and use this to obtain an upper bound on QBER as well as a lower bound on SKR. In the second part of this thesis, as a potential solution to overcome range limitations, we investigate a multi-hop underwater QKD where intermediate nodes between the source and destination nodes help the key distribution. We consider the deployment of passive relays which simply redirect the qubits to the next relay node or the receiver without any measurement. Based on the near-field analysis, we present the performance of relay-assisted QKD scheme in terms of QBER and SKR in different water types and turbulence conditions. In the last part of this thesis, we investigate the fundamental performance limits of decoy BB84 protocol over turbulent underwater channels and provide a comprehensive performance characterization. Based on near field analysis, we utilize the wave structure function to determine the average power transfer over turbulent underwater path and use this to obtain a lower bound on key generation rate. Based on this bound, we present the performance of decoy BB84 protocol in different water type.

arXiv:2208.11493•Aug 20, 2022•7 citations

Fault-Tolerant Quantum Communication Systems Using Clifford Hierarchy-based CSS Codes

Mahendra Kumar Das, Payal Bhardwaj, Bishnu Kumar +2 more

Abstract Recent advances in quantum communication demand the development of a robust quantum infrastructure for secure data transmission across multimodal networks. Quantum communication transmits information using quantum states (qubits), which act as fundamental units and are vulnerable to noise, decoherence, and hardware imperfections in optical networks. This paper presents a fault-tolerant framework for quantum communication. It integrates Clifford hierarchy-based diagonal gates with Calderbank-Shor-Steane (CSS) codes to ensure error-resilient operation. The proposed scheme uses recursive algebraic structures, including transversal Clifford gates (T, CZ, CCZ). It also employs concatenated Reed-Muller code families to build logical operators that maintain fault tolerance under realistic channel conditions. The recursive algebraic structure of the Clifford hierarchy and the application of quantum Reed-Muller code families in this study provide reliable fault tolerant links and quantum key distribution (QKD) mechanisms for effective noise mitigation. Channel modeling is performed for both fiber-based and free-space optical links, incorporating depolarizing noise, photon loss, and detector dark counts to evaluate system reliability. The Steane and Reed-Muller codes effectively depolarize noise and minimize the logical error rate to an optimum level. Simulation results demonstrate that the proposed coding scheme reduces logical error rates by nearly an order of magnitude compared to unencoded qubits, maintains state fidelity above 0.9 under moderate loss conditions, and achieves secure key rates well beyond the 7% QBER threshold of the conventional BB84 protocol. The results extend the operational noise tolerance of QKD systems under realistic fiber-based conditions and highlight the framework’s adaptability to free-space optical channels. Overall, the developed framework bridges the gap between mathematical fault-tolerant code design and practical quantum communication architectures.

•Feb 24, 2026•0 citations

Performance Analysis of Underwater Quantum Key Distribution Protocols: BB84, SARG04, and BBM92

Nour Rizk, Angélique Drémeau, Arnaud Coatanhay

This study compares the quantum bit error rate (QBER) performance of BB84, SARG04, and the entanglement-based BBM92 protocol in non-turbulent underwater optical channels. Clear, coastal, and turbid water types are considered under different background-illumination and receiver configurations. For BB84 and SARG04, channel attenuation and background-induced detections determine the quantum gain and QBER. For BBM92, photon loss is included through the two arm detection efficiencies, whereas the polarization state conditioned on two-photon detection is described by local depolarizing Kraus channels. The BBM92 QBER is obtained from the correlations in both measurement bases and from an exact partition of recorded events into true and false coincidences. Stochastic numerical estimates provide consistency checks of the analytical implementation. The results show that water turbidity and optical background reduce the distance below the adopted QBER threshold. They also show that a low conditional BBM92 QBER may coexist with a very small coincidence probability; therefore, the QBER-threshold distance alone does not represent a complete operational or secret-key-rate bound.

quant-pharXiv:2605.29513•May 29, 2026•2 citations

Quantum key distribution protocol based on CSS error correcting codes

Wei Jia, Feng Bao, Hao Cheng Yu +1 more

In the quantum key distribution (QKD) process, the presence of noise in the quantum channel reduces the efficiency of QKD with low transmission reliability. Quantum error correcting codes (QECCs) can weaken the impact of noise on the final result due to its flexibility in code length and rate selection. In this paper, QECCs is used to overcome the adverse effects of quantum channel noise, and a QKD protocol based on quantum CSS error correcting codes is proposed. Firstly, we construct the corresponding quantum CSS codes based on classical linear code, then modify and simplify some steps of BB84 protocol by using the characteristics of error correcting codes to design the new protocol. Through theoretical deduction, our QKD protocol based on quantum CSS codes improves the security of key transmission, and the confidentiality of transmission in the noisy quantum channel is also enhanced.

ACM Turing Celebration Conference - China (ACM TURC)•May 17, 2019•3 citations

QKD BB84 Under water With Quantum Error Correction

Juliette Florin, Nicolas Le Josse, Gilles Burel +1 more

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) in underwater environments presents unique challenges due to the inherent properties of water as a quantum channel. This work contributes to the broader study of underwater quantum communication, with a focus on enhancing the robustness of QKD protocols through quantum error correction (QEC). This study models the underwater quantum channel to assess the feasibility of performing QKD in such conditions. This research aims to enhance the performance of the QKD through additional QEC that should mitigate errors introduced by the underwater channel. We employ an erasure and noise model to simulate the underwater environment inspired by the prior work of Rizk et al. (2025), excluding depolarisation effects, to evaluate the channel’s impact on quantum communication. The findings aim to offer valuable insights into implementing secure quantum communication underwater and demonstrate how QEC can influence the implementation of QKD protocols in such settings.

•Aug 17, 2026•0 citations
Quantum key distribution (QKD) enables secure underwater communications essential for maritime infrastructure. Underwater optical channels introduce substantial photon loss (erasures) and ambient noise that degrade QKD performance. This paper investigates whether two four-qubit Calderbank-Shor-Steane (CSS) quantum error correction codes (QECC) mitigate these impairments in vertical underwater communication BB84 QKD protocol. After developing a comprehensive stochastic channel model incorporating photon loss, geometric spreading, and solar noise, we assess the viability of QECC through the analytical study of the quantum bit error rate (QBER) and the secure key rate (SKR) with and without security depending on the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) validated against Monte Carlo simulations. The standard four-qubit CSS code achieves a 3 dB SNR gain at the QBER 11% security threshold; the discard code variant achieves 4.5 dB. However, QECC includes an encoding overhead that reduces the SKR. We demonstrate a crucial relationship between the SKR and the probability of arrival of the sent photon. Analysis shows that QECC is beneficial exclusively in marginal SNR regimes; at high SNR, raw BB84 dominates. For an ocean Type III Jerlov water scenario with sunlight coming from the sun located at the top of the atmosphere, we identify operational depth-range windows where QECC enables communication otherwise infeasible. This analysis establishes that error correction deployment must be scenario-dependent: extend operational range at the cost of throughput when SNR is marginal, or prioritize key generation rates at high SNR.
The paper asks whether four-qubit CSS encoding improves vertical underwater BB84 QKD when photon loss and ambient solar photons dominate. It combines a stochastic optical-channel model incorporating geometric spreading, exponential attenuation, and independent Poisson signal/background arrivals with an erasure-plus-depolarization channel. Two existing [[4,1,2]][[4,1,2]][[4,1,2]] code variants are evaluated: one corrects a single known erasure and rejects detected errors; the other discards any block containing an erasure. Analytical error-pattern enumeration is compared with Monte Carlo simulations.
At the assumed 11%11\%11% QBER security threshold, the standard and discard variants reduce the required SNR by approximately 333 and 4.54.54.5 dB, respectively. These gains incur substantial throughput penalties beyond the four-to-one encoding overhead. With physical survival probability s≪1s\ll1s≪1 and negligible background, the key-rate scalings are ξs\xi sξs without encoding, ξs3\xi s^3ξs3 for the standard code, and ξs4/4\xi s^4/4ξs4/4 for the discard variant. For the specified Jerlov type-III water and solar-background scenario, encoding reduces minimum operating depth by roughly 666–888 m or extends range by 6.56.56.5–9.39.39.3 m. Benefits occur near the security threshold; unencoded BB84 gives higher rates at high SNR.
The analysis assumes ideal gates, quantum memories, QND photon-number detection, synchronization, and homogeneous water. It omits propagation-induced phase errors and uses a simplified angular solar-radiance model. Stated extensions include finite-fidelity hardware, alternative receiver orientations, experimental validation, and further security analysis accounting for an adversary’s knowledge of the code structure, including coherent attacks.
Quantum key distribution (QKD) allows authenticated parties to share secure keys. Its security comes from quantum physics rather than computational complexity. The previous work has been able to demonstrate the security of the BB84 protocol based on the uncertainty principle, entanglement purification and information theory. In the security proof method based on entanglement purification, it is assumed that the information of Calderbank–Shor–Steane (CSS) error correction code cannot be leaked, otherwise, it is insecure. However, there is no quantitative analysis of the relationship between the parameter of CSS code and the amount of information leaked. In the attack and defense strategy of the actual quantum key distribution system, especially in the application of the device that is easy to lose or out of control, it is necessary to assess the impact of the parameter leakage. In this paper, we derive the relationship between the leaked parameter of CSS code and the amount of the final key leakage based on the BB84 protocol. Based on this formula, we simulated the impact of different CSS code parameter leaks on the final key amount. Through the analysis of simulation results, the security of the BB84 protocol is inversely proportional to the value of [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] in the case of the CSS code leak.
The current literature on quantum key distribution (QKD) is mainly limited to the transmissions over fiber optic, atmospheric or satellite links and are not directly applicable to underwater environments with different channel characteristics. Absorption, scattering, and turbulence experienced in underwater channels severely limit the range of quantum communication links. In the first part of this thesis, we analyze the quantum bit error rate (QBER) and secret key rate (SKR) performance of the well-known BB84 protocol in underwater channels. As path loss model, we consider a modified version of Beer-Lambert formula which takes into account the effect of scattering. We derive a closed-form expression for the wave structure function to determine the average power transfer over turbulent underwater path and use this to obtain an upper bound on QBER as well as a lower bound on SKR. In the second part of this thesis, as a potential solution to overcome range limitations, we investigate a multi-hop underwater QKD where intermediate nodes between the source and destination nodes help the key distribution. We consider the deployment of passive relays which simply redirect the qubits to the next relay node or the receiver without any measurement. Based on the near-field analysis, we present the performance of relay-assisted QKD scheme in terms of QBER and SKR in different water types and turbulence conditions. In the last part of this thesis, we investigate the fundamental performance limits of decoy BB84 protocol over turbulent underwater channels and provide a comprehensive performance characterization. Based on near field analysis, we utilize the wave structure function to determine the average power transfer over turbulent underwater path and use this to obtain a lower bound on key generation rate. Based on this bound, we present the performance of decoy BB84 protocol in different water type.
Abstract Recent advances in quantum communication demand the development of a robust quantum infrastructure for secure data transmission across multimodal networks. Quantum communication transmits information using quantum states (qubits), which act as fundamental units and are vulnerable to noise, decoherence, and hardware imperfections in optical networks. This paper presents a fault-tolerant framework for quantum communication. It integrates Clifford hierarchy-based diagonal gates with Calderbank-Shor-Steane (CSS) codes to ensure error-resilient operation. The proposed scheme uses recursive algebraic structures, including transversal Clifford gates (T, CZ, CCZ). It also employs concatenated Reed-Muller code families to build logical operators that maintain fault tolerance under realistic channel conditions. The recursive algebraic structure of the Clifford hierarchy and the application of quantum Reed-Muller code families in this study provide reliable fault tolerant links and quantum key distribution (QKD) mechanisms for effective noise mitigation. Channel modeling is performed for both fiber-based and free-space optical links, incorporating depolarizing noise, photon loss, and detector dark counts to evaluate system reliability. The Steane and Reed-Muller codes effectively depolarize noise and minimize the logical error rate to an optimum level. Simulation results demonstrate that the proposed coding scheme reduces logical error rates by nearly an order of magnitude compared to unencoded qubits, maintains state fidelity above 0.9 under moderate loss conditions, and achieves secure key rates well beyond the 7% QBER threshold of the conventional BB84 protocol. The results extend the operational noise tolerance of QKD systems under realistic fiber-based conditions and highlight the framework’s adaptability to free-space optical channels. Overall, the developed framework bridges the gap between mathematical fault-tolerant code design and practical quantum communication architectures.
This study compares the quantum bit error rate (QBER) performance of BB84, SARG04, and the entanglement-based BBM92 protocol in non-turbulent underwater optical channels. Clear, coastal, and turbid water types are considered under different background-illumination and receiver configurations. For BB84 and SARG04, channel attenuation and background-induced detections determine the quantum gain and QBER. For BBM92, photon loss is included through the two arm detection efficiencies, whereas the polarization state conditioned on two-photon detection is described by local depolarizing Kraus channels. The BBM92 QBER is obtained from the correlations in both measurement bases and from an exact partition of recorded events into true and false coincidences. Stochastic numerical estimates provide consistency checks of the analytical implementation. The results show that water turbidity and optical background reduce the distance below the adopted QBER threshold. They also show that a low conditional BBM92 QBER may coexist with a very small coincidence probability; therefore, the QBER-threshold distance alone does not represent a complete operational or secret-key-rate bound.
In the quantum key distribution (QKD) process, the presence of noise in the quantum channel reduces the efficiency of QKD with low transmission reliability. Quantum error correcting codes (QECCs) can weaken the impact of noise on the final result due to its flexibility in code length and rate selection. In this paper, QECCs is used to overcome the adverse effects of quantum channel noise, and a QKD protocol based on quantum CSS error correcting codes is proposed. Firstly, we construct the corresponding quantum CSS codes based on classical linear code, then modify and simplify some steps of BB84 protocol by using the characteristics of error correcting codes to design the new protocol. Through theoretical deduction, our QKD protocol based on quantum CSS codes improves the security of key transmission, and the confidentiality of transmission in the noisy quantum channel is also enhanced.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) in underwater environments presents unique challenges due to the inherent properties of water as a quantum channel. This work contributes to the broader study of underwater quantum communication, with a focus on enhancing the robustness of QKD protocols through quantum error correction (QEC). This study models the underwater quantum channel to assess the feasibility of performing QKD in such conditions. This research aims to enhance the performance of the QKD through additional QEC that should mitigate errors introduced by the underwater channel. We employ an erasure and noise model to simulate the underwater environment inspired by the prior work of Rizk et al. (2025), excluding depolarisation effects, to evaluate the channel’s impact on quantum communication. The findings aim to offer valuable insights into implementing secure quantum communication underwater and demonstrate how QEC can influence the implementation of QKD protocols in such settings.