Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.18412 · Laser Physics Letters

Measuring correlations in quantum and statistical systems

V. I. Yukalov, E. P. Yukalova

quant-phcond-mat.stat-mechSubmitted Sep 16, 2026• Announced Sep 17, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The survey discusses the problem of measuring correlations in composite quantum and statistical systems. After briefly recalling the standard methods of describing correlations, the emphasis is on the method of correlation indices. The latter method for quantifying the strength of correlations in composite physical systems is sufficiently general allowing for measuring in a unique way the correlation strength in both quantum and statistical systems, for static as well as for dynamic processes. The correlation indices, can be defined for correlation operators, reduced density matrices, and other operators containing information on correlations in the studied composite systems. The correlation indices measure all types of correlations, quantum correlations, such as entanglement, as well as classical correlations. They are applicable for characterizing static as well as dynamical processes. Examples are given of correlation indices for several quantum states and for spin and pseudospin systems. The quantification of correlations in a nonequilibrium system is exemplified by calculating the correlation index for a trapped Bose-Einstein condensate subject to the action of an alternating field.

AI Summary

This survey addresses how to assign a scalar correlation strength to composite quantum and classical statistical systems, including time-dependent and multipartite settings. Its focus is the correlation index $\varkappa(A)=\ln[\|A\|/\|A^\otimes\|]$, where $A^\otimes$ is the normalized tensor product of partial traces of $A$. The construction is applied to correlation operators, density matrices, and spin observables, with the stated aim of including both classical and quantum correlations. The examples use explicit partial traces and norm calculations. For classically correlated mixtures of orthogonal product states, the index depends on the largest mode population. For coherent states $\sum_m c_m|m\cdots m\rangle$, the reported expression is $(1-N)\ln\max_m|c_m|^2$, with maximum $(N-1)\ln M$ for $M$ equally populated modes. A mean-field spin calculation gives $\varkappa=\ln[(6+6Ns^2+N^2s^4)/(1+Ns^2)^2]$, approaching $\ln6$ at zero polarization and zero for $Ns^2\to\infty$. A driven two-mode condensate example obtains oscillating indices by integrating nonlinear population-and-phase equations. The scope is illustrative rather than an axiomatic characterization of a correlation measure. The paper states that calculating the index requires correlation functions or reduced density matrices; mean-field approximations are used for the spin example, while other systems may require refined approximations or numerical methods. There are also inconsistencies between the stated spectral norm and several worked examples: normalized pure-state projectors have spectral norm one, whereas the entangled-state calculations use the largest mode population. Consequently, the reported pure-state formulas do not follow from the norm definition as written.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsUnclear noveltyMissing comparisonPossible error

Central claim may not hold: The correlation index in Eq. (29) can vanish for a nonproduct classical distribution and can be negative for a valid density operator, undermining its claimed general interpretation as total correlation strength. The EPR, generalized Bell, and Hartree–Fock calculations assign incorrect operator norms to normalized pure-state projectors, and Eq. (62) also gives an incorrect single-site partial trace. Equation (35) omits a logarithm, the equal-population amplitudes preceding Eq. (69) are incorrectly normalized, and Eq. (100) reverses the population difference defined in Eq. (99). For independent unpolarized spins, the stated operator-norm definition yields the spin correlation index ln N, contradicting Eq. (90) and the claimed maximum ln 6. The driven-condensate example assumes a Bell state that synchronous local driving of initially independent wells does not generate, without specifying an entangling preparation mechanism.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Journal reference
Laser Phys. Lett. 23 (2026) 023001
Comments
Ltex file, 19 pages, 3 figures

Related papers

Correlation measure for statistical systems

V. I. Yukalov, E. P. Yukalova

A measure of correlations for statistical systems is advanced, called correlation index. The measure is general, being applicable to quantum and classical, equilibrium and nonequilibrium statistical systems. After formulating the general notion of correlation indices for arbitrary trace-class operators, the calculation of the correlation indices are illustrated by several examples of density operators and reduced density matrices. The computation of the correlation indices for equilibrium systems is exemplified for bosonic systems with the Bose-Einstein condensate, superconducting systems, and for spin systems. Correlation indices for nonequilibrium systems are considered for nonlinear dynamics of spin and pseudospin systems.

quant-pharXiv:2609.34859•Journal of Statistical Physics•Sep 29, 2026•1 citation

When are correlations quantum?—verification and quantification of entanglement by simple measurements

K M R Audenaert, Martin Bodo Plenio

The verification and quantification of experimentally created entanglement by simple measurements, especially between distant particles, is an important basic task in quantum processing. When composite systems are subjected to local measurements the measurement data will exhibit correlations, whether these systems are classical or quantum. Therefore, the observation of correlations in the classical measurement record does not automatically imply the presence of quantum correlations in the system under investigation. In this study, we explore the question of when correlations, or other measurement data, are sufficient to guarantee the existence of a certain amount of quantum correlations in the system and when additional information, such as the degree of purity of the system, is needed to do so. Various measurement settings are discussed, both numerically and analytically. Exact results and lower bounds on the least entanglement consistent with the observations are presented. The approach is suitable both for the bi-partite and the multi-partite setting.

arXiv:quant-ph/0608067•New Journal of Physics•Nov 8, 2006•113 citations

Experimental quantification of spatial correlations in quantum dynamics

Lukas Postler, Ángel Rivas, Philipp Schindler +6 more

Correlations between different partitions of quantum systems play a central role in a variety of many-body quantum systems, and they have been studied exhaustively in experimental and theoretical research. Here, we investigate dynamical correlations in the time evolution of multiple parts of a composite quantum system. A rigorous measure to quantify correlations in quantum dynamics based on a full tomographic reconstruction of the quantum process has been introduced recently [Á. Rivas et al., New Journal of Physics, 17(6) 062001 (2015).]. In this work, we derive a lower bound for this correlation measure, which does not require full knowledge of the quantum dynamics. Furthermore we also extend the correlation measure to multipartite systems. We directly apply the developed methods to a trapped ion quantum information processor to experimentally characterize the correlations in quantum dynamics for two- and four-qubit systems. The method proposed and demonstrated in this work is scalable, platform-independent and applicable to other composite quantum systems and quantum information processing architectures. We apply the method to estimate spatial correlations in environmental noise processes, which are crucial for the performance of quantum error correction procedures.

arXiv:1806.08088•Quantum•Sep 3, 2018•18 citations

Entanglement Measure for Composite Systems

Vyacheslav I. Yukalov

A general description of entanglement is suggested as an action realized by an arbitrary operator over given disentangled states. The related entanglement measure is defined. Because of its generality, this definition can be employed for any physical systems, pure or mixed, equilibrium or nonequilibrium, and characterized by any type of operators, whether these are statistical operators, field operators, spin operators, or anything else. Entanglement of any number of parts from their total ensemble forming a multiparticle composite system can be determined. Interplay between entanglement and ordering, occurring under phase transitions, is analyzed by invoking the concept of operator order indices.

arXiv:quant-ph/0309015•Physical Review Letters•Apr 24, 2003•39 citations

Quantification of Correlations in Quantum Many-Particle Systems

Krzysztof Byczuk, J. Kuneš, Walter Hofstetter +1 more

We introduce a well-defined and unbiased measure of the strength of correlations in quantum many-particle systems which is based on the relative von Neumann entropy computed from the density operator of correlated and uncorrelated states. The usefulness of this general concept is demonstrated by quantifying correlations of interacting electrons in the Hubbard model and in a series of transition-metal oxides using dynamical mean-field theory.

arXiv:1110.3214•Physical Review Letters•Feb 23, 2012•29 citations

Measures and applications of quantum correlations

Gerardo Adesso, Thomas R Bromley, Marco Cianciaruso

Abstract Quantum information theory is built upon the realisation that quantum resources like coherence and entanglement can be exploited for novel or enhanced ways of transmitting and manipulating information, such as quantum cryptography, teleportation, and quantum computing. We now know that there is potentially much more than entanglement behind the power of quantum information processing. There exist more general forms of non-classical correlations, stemming from fundamental principles such as the necessary disturbance induced by a local measurement, or the persistence of quantum coherence in all possible local bases. These signatures can be identified and are resilient in almost all quantum states, and have been linked to the enhanced performance of certain quantum protocols over classical ones in noisy conditions. Their presence represents, among other things, one of the most essential manifestations of quantumness in cooperative systems, from the subatomic to the macroscopic domain. In this work we give an overview of the current quest for a proper understanding and characterisation of the frontier between classical and quantum correlations (QCs) in composite states. We focus on various approaches to define and quantify general QCs, based on different yet interlinked physical perspectives, and comment on the operational significance of the ensuing measures for quantum technology tasks such as information encoding, distribution, discrimination and metrology. We then provide a broader outlook of a few applications in which quantumness beyond entanglement looks fit to play a key role.

arXiv:1605.00806•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Nov 3, 2016•431 citations
The survey discusses the problem of measuring correlations in composite quantum and statistical systems. After briefly recalling the standard methods of describing correlations, the emphasis is on the method of correlation indices. The latter method for quantifying the strength of correlations in composite physical systems is sufficiently general allowing for measuring in a unique way the correlation strength in both quantum and statistical systems, for static as well as for dynamic processes. The correlation indices, can be defined for correlation operators, reduced density matrices, and other operators containing information on correlations in the studied composite systems. The correlation indices measure all types of correlations, quantum correlations, such as entanglement, as well as classical correlations. They are applicable for characterizing static as well as dynamical processes. Examples are given of correlation indices for several quantum states and for spin and pseudospin systems. The quantification of correlations in a nonequilibrium system is exemplified by calculating the correlation index for a trapped Bose-Einstein condensate subject to the action of an alternating field.
This survey addresses how to assign a scalar correlation strength to composite quantum and classical statistical systems, including time-dependent and multipartite settings. Its focus is the correlation index ϰ(A)=ln⁡[∥A∥/∥A⊗∥]\varkappa(A)=\ln[\|A\|/\|A^\otimes\|]ϰ(A)=ln[∥A∥/∥A⊗∥], where A⊗A^\otimesA⊗ is the normalized tensor product of partial traces of AAA. The construction is applied to correlation operators, density matrices, and spin observables, with the stated aim of including both classical and quantum correlations.
The examples use explicit partial traces and norm calculations. For classically correlated mixtures of orthogonal product states, the index depends on the largest mode population. For coherent states ∑mcm∣m⋯m⟩\sum_m c_m|m\cdots m\rangle∑m​cm​∣m⋯m⟩, the reported expression is (1−N)ln⁡max⁡m∣cm∣2(1-N)\ln\max_m|c_m|^2(1−N)lnmaxm​∣cm​∣2, with maximum (N−1)ln⁡M(N-1)\ln M(N−1)lnM for MMM equally populated modes. A mean-field spin calculation gives ϰ=ln⁡[(6+6Ns2+N2s4)/(1+Ns2)2]\varkappa=\ln[(6+6Ns^2+N^2s^4)/(1+Ns^2)^2]ϰ=ln[(6+6Ns2+N2s4)/(1+Ns2)2], approaching ln⁡6\ln6ln6 at zero polarization and zero for Ns2→∞Ns^2\to\inftyNs2→∞. A driven two-mode condensate example obtains oscillating indices by integrating nonlinear population-and-phase equations.
The scope is illustrative rather than an axiomatic characterization of a correlation measure. The paper states that calculating the index requires correlation functions or reduced density matrices; mean-field approximations are used for the spin example, while other systems may require refined approximations or numerical methods. There are also inconsistencies between the stated spectral norm and several worked examples: normalized pure-state projectors have spectral norm one, whereas the entangled-state calculations use the largest mode population. Consequently, the reported pure-state formulas do not follow from the norm definition as written.
A measure of correlations for statistical systems is advanced, called correlation index. The measure is general, being applicable to quantum and classical, equilibrium and nonequilibrium statistical systems. After formulating the general notion of correlation indices for arbitrary trace-class operators, the calculation of the correlation indices are illustrated by several examples of density operators and reduced density matrices. The computation of the correlation indices for equilibrium systems is exemplified for bosonic systems with the Bose-Einstein condensate, superconducting systems, and for spin systems. Correlation indices for nonequilibrium systems are considered for nonlinear dynamics of spin and pseudospin systems.
The verification and quantification of experimentally created entanglement by simple measurements, especially between distant particles, is an important basic task in quantum processing. When composite systems are subjected to local measurements the measurement data will exhibit correlations, whether these systems are classical or quantum. Therefore, the observation of correlations in the classical measurement record does not automatically imply the presence of quantum correlations in the system under investigation. In this study, we explore the question of when correlations, or other measurement data, are sufficient to guarantee the existence of a certain amount of quantum correlations in the system and when additional information, such as the degree of purity of the system, is needed to do so. Various measurement settings are discussed, both numerically and analytically. Exact results and lower bounds on the least entanglement consistent with the observations are presented. The approach is suitable both for the bi-partite and the multi-partite setting.
Correlations between different partitions of quantum systems play a central role in a variety of many-body quantum systems, and they have been studied exhaustively in experimental and theoretical research. Here, we investigate dynamical correlations in the time evolution of multiple parts of a composite quantum system. A rigorous measure to quantify correlations in quantum dynamics based on a full tomographic reconstruction of the quantum process has been introduced recently [Á. Rivas et al., New Journal of Physics, 17(6) 062001 (2015).]. In this work, we derive a lower bound for this correlation measure, which does not require full knowledge of the quantum dynamics. Furthermore we also extend the correlation measure to multipartite systems. We directly apply the developed methods to a trapped ion quantum information processor to experimentally characterize the correlations in quantum dynamics for two- and four-qubit systems. The method proposed and demonstrated in this work is scalable, platform-independent and applicable to other composite quantum systems and quantum information processing architectures. We apply the method to estimate spatial correlations in environmental noise processes, which are crucial for the performance of quantum error correction procedures.
A general description of entanglement is suggested as an action realized by an arbitrary operator over given disentangled states. The related entanglement measure is defined. Because of its generality, this definition can be employed for any physical systems, pure or mixed, equilibrium or nonequilibrium, and characterized by any type of operators, whether these are statistical operators, field operators, spin operators, or anything else. Entanglement of any number of parts from their total ensemble forming a multiparticle composite system can be determined. Interplay between entanglement and ordering, occurring under phase transitions, is analyzed by invoking the concept of operator order indices.
Abstract Quantum information theory is built upon the realisation that quantum resources like coherence and entanglement can be exploited for novel or enhanced ways of transmitting and manipulating information, such as quantum cryptography, teleportation, and quantum computing. We now know that there is potentially much more than entanglement behind the power of quantum information processing. There exist more general forms of non-classical correlations, stemming from fundamental principles such as the necessary disturbance induced by a local measurement, or the persistence of quantum coherence in all possible local bases. These signatures can be identified and are resilient in almost all quantum states, and have been linked to the enhanced performance of certain quantum protocols over classical ones in noisy conditions. Their presence represents, among other things, one of the most essential manifestations of quantumness in cooperative systems, from the subatomic to the macroscopic domain. In this work we give an overview of the current quest for a proper understanding and characterisation of the frontier between classical and quantum correlations (QCs) in composite states. We focus on various approaches to define and quantify general QCs, based on different yet interlinked physical perspectives, and comment on the operational significance of the ensuing measures for quantum technology tasks such as information encoding, distribution, discrimination and metrology. We then provide a broader outlook of a few applications in which quantumness beyond entanglement looks fit to play a key role.