arXiv:2609.18412 · Laser Physics Letters
Measuring correlations in quantum and statistical systems
V. I. Yukalov, E. P. Yukalova
Abstract
The survey discusses the problem of measuring correlations in composite quantum and statistical systems. After briefly recalling the standard methods of describing correlations, the emphasis is on the method of correlation indices. The latter method for quantifying the strength of correlations in composite physical systems is sufficiently general allowing for measuring in a unique way the correlation strength in both quantum and statistical systems, for static as well as for dynamic processes. The correlation indices, can be defined for correlation operators, reduced density matrices, and other operators containing information on correlations in the studied composite systems. The correlation indices measure all types of correlations, quantum correlations, such as entanglement, as well as classical correlations. They are applicable for characterizing static as well as dynamical processes. Examples are given of correlation indices for several quantum states and for spin and pseudospin systems. The quantification of correlations in a nonequilibrium system is exemplified by calculating the correlation index for a trapped Bose-Einstein condensate subject to the action of an alternating field.
AI Summary
This survey addresses how to assign a scalar correlation strength to composite quantum and classical statistical systems, including time-dependent and multipartite settings. Its focus is the correlation index $\varkappa(A)=\ln[\|A\|/\|A^\otimes\|]$, where $A^\otimes$ is the normalized tensor product of partial traces of $A$. The construction is applied to correlation operators, density matrices, and spin observables, with the stated aim of including both classical and quantum correlations. The examples use explicit partial traces and norm calculations. For classically correlated mixtures of orthogonal product states, the index depends on the largest mode population. For coherent states $\sum_m c_m|m\cdots m\rangle$, the reported expression is $(1-N)\ln\max_m|c_m|^2$, with maximum $(N-1)\ln M$ for $M$ equally populated modes. A mean-field spin calculation gives $\varkappa=\ln[(6+6Ns^2+N^2s^4)/(1+Ns^2)^2]$, approaching $\ln6$ at zero polarization and zero for $Ns^2\to\infty$. A driven two-mode condensate example obtains oscillating indices by integrating nonlinear population-and-phase equations. The scope is illustrative rather than an axiomatic characterization of a correlation measure. The paper states that calculating the index requires correlation functions or reduced density matrices; mean-field approximations are used for the spin example, while other systems may require refined approximations or numerical methods. There are also inconsistencies between the stated spectral norm and several worked examples: normalized pure-state projectors have spectral norm one, whereas the entangled-state calculations use the largest mode population. Consequently, the reported pure-state formulas do not follow from the norm definition as written.
Central claim may not hold: The correlation index in Eq. (29) can vanish for a nonproduct classical distribution and can be negative for a valid density operator, undermining its claimed general interpretation as total correlation strength. The EPR, generalized Bell, and Hartree–Fock calculations assign incorrect operator norms to normalized pure-state projectors, and Eq. (62) also gives an incorrect single-site partial trace. Equation (35) omits a logarithm, the equal-population amplitudes preceding Eq. (69) are incorrectly normalized, and Eq. (100) reverses the population difference defined in Eq. (99). For independent unpolarized spins, the stated operator-norm definition yields the spin correlation index ln N, contradicting Eq. (90) and the claimed maximum ln 6. The driven-condensate example assumes a Bell state that synchronous local driving of initially independent wells does not generate, without specifying an entangling preparation mechanism.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Journal reference
- Laser Phys. Lett. 23 (2026) 023001
- Comments
- Ltex file, 19 pages, 3 figures