Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.18211

Proof of Heisenberg's Error-Disturbance Relation for Individual Measurements

Seiji Kosugi

quant-phSubmitted Sep 16, 2026• Announced Sep 17, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Heisenberg originally envisioned the error-disturbance relation under the premise that the state after measurement must remain consistent with the Kennard-Robertson uncertainty relation. This implies that the measurement error must be formulated via a posterior observable $\hat{x}_t$, rather than a prior observable $\hat{x}_0$, because the posterior measurement error determines the post-measurement uncertainty of the electron. Building upon the preliminary conceptual foundation reported in arXiv:1504.03779, this paper presents a rigorous derivation of the error-disturbance principle formulated from the unitary transformation equations of observables. Each readout $X$ of a posterior probe observable $\hat{X}_t$ completes a single measurement event, producing a specific conditional object state. The Kennard-Robertson uncertainty relation must hold for these states. Specifically, we show that the uncertainty relation between the error $ε_{X}(\hat{x}_t)$ and the disturbance $η_{X}(\hat{p}_0)$ holds strictly at the level of individual measurements, characterized by the specific readout $X$. We also verify that conventional error-disturbance relations, where the errors are evaluated by averaging over the unconditioned state, hold true. Our results provide a refined theoretical basis for understanding the fundamental trade-off in individual measurement outcomes.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether a Heisenberg-type error–disturbance relation can hold for individual measurement outcomes when error refers to estimating a post-interaction observable, rather than its pre-interaction value. It models an object–probe interaction by a unitary $U$, followed by a precise probe readout $X$, and defines error and disturbance in the corresponding conditional state. The conditional mean minimizes the posterior mean-square estimation error, giving $\epsilon_X(\sigma_t)\geq\sigma_X(\sigma_0)$, where the latter variance is evaluated in the conditional post-interaction state. Applying a Robertson inequality to this error and the disturbance operator, the paper derives the claimed bound $\epsilon_X(\sigma_t)\eta_X(y_0)\geq\tfrac12|\langle[\sigma_0,y_0]\rangle_X|$. For position and momentum, the right-hand side is $\hbar/2$. Separate treatments cover continuous, mixed continuous–discrete, and fully discrete spectra. An unconditioned analogue is derived using an unbiasedness argument and Appleby’s lemma. A von Neumann position-measurement interaction illustrates the construction. The derivation represents the interaction as mapping product eigenvectors to product eigenvectors and eliminates a cross-commutator using an assumed single-valued correspondence from the initial probe eigenvalue and final readout to the posterior object eigenvalue. The paper explicitly defers a proof that this correspondence holds under arbitrary unitary measurement dynamics to a forthcoming publication. Its error concerns a posterior observable, so the claimed relations differ from conventional prior-observable error–disturbance inequalities; they do not establish the latter. The treatment assumes an initially pure product state and an ideal probe readout without further object interaction.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsStrong assumptionsPossible errorUnclear novelty

Central claim may not hold: Section 2 incorrectly infers from unitarity that inverse images of product eigenvectors form a local product eigenbasis. The essential commutator cancellation assumes that the initial probe label and final readout uniquely determine the final object eigenvalue, which general indirect measurements do not require. Section 6 applies an all-input unbiasedness argument to a posterior-mean estimator that generally changes with the input state. The final von Neumann example asserts an exact product of ℏ/2 without establishing zero mean disturbance or saturation of the uncertainty bound. An informative two-qubit measurement explicitly violates both the claimed outcome-conditioned inequality and its unconditioned counterpart under the paper's definitions.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
This paper builds upon the preliminary framework presented in arXiv:1504.03779

Related papers

A Universal Formulation of Uncertainty Relation for Error and Disturbance

Jaeha Lee, Izumi Tsutsui

We present a universal formulation of uncertainty relation valid for any conceivable quantum measurement and the resultant observation (observer) effect of statistical nature. Owing to its simplicity and operational tangibility, our general relation is also experimentally verifiable. Our relation violates the traditional na{ï}ve bound $\hbar/2$ for the position-momentum measurement while respecting Heisenberg's original philosophy of the uncertainty principle. Our error-disturbance relation admits a parallel formulation to our relation for errors, which also embraces the standard Kennard--Robertson (Schr{ö}dinger) relation as a special case; this attains a unified picture of the three orthodox realms of uncertainty regarding quantum indeterminacy, measurement, and observation effect within a single framework.

arXiv:2004.06099•Apr 13, 2020•2 citations

Proof of Heisenberg's error-disturbance principle

Seiji Kosugi

In Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation for electron position measurement, the measurement error must be the one that determines the uncertainty in the electron position just after the measurement. It is the resolution $ε(x_t)$ i.e., the measurement error of the post-measurement observable $\hat{x}_t$, not the precision $ε(x_0)$ i.e., that of the pre-measurement observable $\hat{x}_0$ that determines the uncertainty of the observable $\hat{x}_t$. Therefore, Heisenberg's relation must be interpreted as one between the resolution $ε(x_t)$ and the disturbance $η(y_0)$. The magnitude of the disturbance $η(y_0)$ is independent of the definition of the measurement value of the observable $\hat{x}_t$. Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation is proven to hold true in general, when the measurement value of $\hat{x}_t$ is defined in order to minimize the resolution $ε(x_t)$.

arXiv:1504.03779•Apr 15, 2015•2 citations

Uncertainty Relations for Accurate Measurements

Seiji Kosugi

Our investigation of the results of the neutron spin experiment by Ehhart et al. demonstrates that their results cannot be understood in accordance with common sense. For example, their results obtained with different measurement errors are equal to each other for a same neutron state. This is because their measurement values have a large systematic error due to adopting an incorrect measurement-value operator, which is the operator that gives the measurement values of the measured observable. They asserted that their results confirmed the validity of a universally valid uncertainty relation proposed by Ozawa. Therefore, their results demonstrate unexpectedly that Ozawa's uncertainty relation holds true for incorrect measurements. In addition, we have proved this fact theoretically. The measurement-value operator must be defined in order that the systematic error of measurement values predicted by the operator is zero. Such a measurement is called an accurate measurement. Two kind of uncertainty relations are derived for accurate measurements of a pre-measurement observable $\hat{x}_0$. In addition, we have presented an uncertainty relation for accurate measurements of a post-measurement observable $\hat{x}_t$. Heisenberg's original uncertainty relation for measurement processes should be interpreted as this relation between the resolution, that is, the measurement error of the post-measurement observable $\hat{x}_t$ and the disturbance of an object observable $\hat{y}_0$.

arXiv:1309.1966•Sep 8, 2013•0 citations

Error-tradeoff and error-disturbance relations for incompatible quantum measurements

Cyril Branciard

Heisenberg's uncertainty principle is one of the main tenets of quantum theory. Nevertheless, and despite its fundamental importance for our understanding of quantum foundations, there has been some confusion in its interpretation: Although Heisenberg's first argument was that the measurement of one observable on a quantum state necessarily disturbs another incompatible observable, standard uncertainty relations typically bound the indeterminacy of the outcomes when either one or the other observable is measured. In this paper, we quantify precisely Heisenberg's intuition. Even if two incompatible observables cannot be measured together, one can still approximate their joint measurement, at the price of introducing some errors with respect to the ideal measurement of each of them. We present a tight relation characterizing the optimal tradeoff between the error on one observable vs. the error on the other. As a particular case, our approach allows us to characterize the disturbance of an observable induced by the approximate measurement of another one; we also derive a stronger error-disturbance relation for this scenario.

arXiv:1304.2071•Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Apr 5, 2013•144 citations

Universally valid Heisenberg uncertainty relation

Kazuo Fujikawa

A universally valid Heisenberg uncertainty relation is proposed by combining the universally valid error-disturbance uncertainty relation of Ozawa with the relation of Robertson. This form of the uncertainty relation, which is defined with the same mathematical rigor as the relations of Kennard and Robertson, incorporates both the intrinsic quantum fluctuations and measurement effects.

arXiv:1205.1360•Physical Review A•Jun 22, 2012•34 citations

Proof of Heisenberg’s Error-Disturbance Relation

Paul Busch, PEKKA J. LAHTI, Reinhard F. Werner

While the slogan "no measurement without disturbance" has established itself under the name of the Heisenberg effect in the consciousness of the scientifically interested public, a precise statement of this fundamental feature of the quantum world has remained elusive, and serious attempts at rigorous formulations of it as a consequence of quantum theory have led to seemingly conflicting preliminary results. Here we show that despite recent claims to the contrary [L. Rozema et al, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 100404 (2012)], Heisenberg-type inequalities can be proven that describe a tradeoff between the precision of a position measurement and the necessary resulting disturbance of momentum (and vice versa). More generally, these inequalities are instances of an uncertainty relation for the imprecisions of any joint measurement of position and momentum. Measures of error and disturbance are here defined as figures of merit characteristic of measuring devices. As such they are state independent, each giving worst-case estimates across all states, in contrast to previous work that is concerned with the relationship between error and disturbance in an individual state.

arXiv:1306.1565•Physical Review Letters•Oct 17, 2013•243 citations
Heisenberg originally envisioned the error-disturbance relation under the premise that the state after measurement must remain consistent with the Kennard-Robertson uncertainty relation. This implies that the measurement error must be formulated via a posterior observable x^t\hat{x}_tx^t​, rather than a prior observable x^0\hat{x}_0x^0​, because the posterior measurement error determines the post-measurement uncertainty of the electron. Building upon the preliminary conceptual foundation reported in arXiv:1504.03779, this paper presents a rigorous derivation of the error-disturbance principle formulated from the unitary transformation equations of observables. Each readout XXX of a posterior probe observable X^t\hat{X}_tX^t​ completes a single measurement event, producing a specific conditional object state. The Kennard-Robertson uncertainty relation must hold for these states. Specifically, we show that the uncertainty relation between the error εX(x^t)ε_{X}(\hat{x}_t)εX​(x^t​) and the disturbance ηX(p^0)η_{X}(\hat{p}_0)ηX​(p^​0​) holds strictly at the level of individual measurements, characterized by the specific readout XXX. We also verify that conventional error-disturbance relations, where the errors are evaluated by averaging over the unconditioned state, hold true. Our results provide a refined theoretical basis for understanding the fundamental trade-off in individual measurement outcomes.
The paper asks whether a Heisenberg-type error–disturbance relation can hold for individual measurement outcomes when error refers to estimating a post-interaction observable, rather than its pre-interaction value. It models an object–probe interaction by a unitary UUU, followed by a precise probe readout XXX, and defines error and disturbance in the corresponding conditional state.
The conditional mean minimizes the posterior mean-square estimation error, giving ϵX(σt)≥σX(σ0)\epsilon_X(\sigma_t)\geq\sigma_X(\sigma_0)ϵX​(σt​)≥σX​(σ0​), where the latter variance is evaluated in the conditional post-interaction state. Applying a Robertson inequality to this error and the disturbance operator, the paper derives the claimed bound ϵX(σt)ηX(y0)≥12∣⟨[σ0,y0]⟩X∣\epsilon_X(\sigma_t)\eta_X(y_0)\geq\tfrac12|\langle[\sigma_0,y_0]\rangle_X|ϵX​(σt​)ηX​(y0​)≥21​∣⟨[σ0​,y0​]⟩X​∣. For position and momentum, the right-hand side is ℏ/2\hbar/2ℏ/2. Separate treatments cover continuous, mixed continuous–discrete, and fully discrete spectra. An unconditioned analogue is derived using an unbiasedness argument and Appleby’s lemma. A von Neumann position-measurement interaction illustrates the construction.
The derivation represents the interaction as mapping product eigenvectors to product eigenvectors and eliminates a cross-commutator using an assumed single-valued correspondence from the initial probe eigenvalue and final readout to the posterior object eigenvalue. The paper explicitly defers a proof that this correspondence holds under arbitrary unitary measurement dynamics to a forthcoming publication. Its error concerns a posterior observable, so the claimed relations differ from conventional prior-observable error–disturbance inequalities; they do not establish the latter. The treatment assumes an initially pure product state and an ideal probe readout without further object interaction.
We present a universal formulation of uncertainty relation valid for any conceivable quantum measurement and the resultant observation (observer) effect of statistical nature. Owing to its simplicity and operational tangibility, our general relation is also experimentally verifiable. Our relation violates the traditional na{ï}ve bound ℏ/2\hbar/2ℏ/2 for the position-momentum measurement while respecting Heisenberg's original philosophy of the uncertainty principle. Our error-disturbance relation admits a parallel formulation to our relation for errors, which also embraces the standard Kennard--Robertson (Schr{ö}dinger) relation as a special case; this attains a unified picture of the three orthodox realms of uncertainty regarding quantum indeterminacy, measurement, and observation effect within a single framework.
In Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation for electron position measurement, the measurement error must be the one that determines the uncertainty in the electron position just after the measurement. It is the resolution ε(xt)ε(x_t)ε(xt​) i.e., the measurement error of the post-measurement observable x^t\hat{x}_tx^t​, not the precision ε(x0)ε(x_0)ε(x0​) i.e., that of the pre-measurement observable x^0\hat{x}_0x^0​ that determines the uncertainty of the observable x^t\hat{x}_tx^t​. Therefore, Heisenberg's relation must be interpreted as one between the resolution ε(xt)ε(x_t)ε(xt​) and the disturbance η(y0)η(y_0)η(y0​). The magnitude of the disturbance η(y0)η(y_0)η(y0​) is independent of the definition of the measurement value of the observable x^t\hat{x}_tx^t​. Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation is proven to hold true in general, when the measurement value of x^t\hat{x}_tx^t​ is defined in order to minimize the resolution ε(xt)ε(x_t)ε(xt​).
Our investigation of the results of the neutron spin experiment by Ehhart et al. demonstrates that their results cannot be understood in accordance with common sense. For example, their results obtained with different measurement errors are equal to each other for a same neutron state. This is because their measurement values have a large systematic error due to adopting an incorrect measurement-value operator, which is the operator that gives the measurement values of the measured observable. They asserted that their results confirmed the validity of a universally valid uncertainty relation proposed by Ozawa. Therefore, their results demonstrate unexpectedly that Ozawa's uncertainty relation holds true for incorrect measurements. In addition, we have proved this fact theoretically. The measurement-value operator must be defined in order that the systematic error of measurement values predicted by the operator is zero. Such a measurement is called an accurate measurement. Two kind of uncertainty relations are derived for accurate measurements of a pre-measurement observable x^0\hat{x}_0x^0​. In addition, we have presented an uncertainty relation for accurate measurements of a post-measurement observable x^t\hat{x}_tx^t​. Heisenberg's original uncertainty relation for measurement processes should be interpreted as this relation between the resolution, that is, the measurement error of the post-measurement observable x^t\hat{x}_tx^t​ and the disturbance of an object observable y^0\hat{y}_0y^​0​.
Heisenberg's uncertainty principle is one of the main tenets of quantum theory. Nevertheless, and despite its fundamental importance for our understanding of quantum foundations, there has been some confusion in its interpretation: Although Heisenberg's first argument was that the measurement of one observable on a quantum state necessarily disturbs another incompatible observable, standard uncertainty relations typically bound the indeterminacy of the outcomes when either one or the other observable is measured. In this paper, we quantify precisely Heisenberg's intuition. Even if two incompatible observables cannot be measured together, one can still approximate their joint measurement, at the price of introducing some errors with respect to the ideal measurement of each of them. We present a tight relation characterizing the optimal tradeoff between the error on one observable vs. the error on the other. As a particular case, our approach allows us to characterize the disturbance of an observable induced by the approximate measurement of another one; we also derive a stronger error-disturbance relation for this scenario.
While the slogan "no measurement without disturbance" has established itself under the name of the Heisenberg effect in the consciousness of the scientifically interested public, a precise statement of this fundamental feature of the quantum world has remained elusive, and serious attempts at rigorous formulations of it as a consequence of quantum theory have led to seemingly conflicting preliminary results. Here we show that despite recent claims to the contrary [L. Rozema et al, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 100404 (2012)], Heisenberg-type inequalities can be proven that describe a tradeoff between the precision of a position measurement and the necessary resulting disturbance of momentum (and vice versa). More generally, these inequalities are instances of an uncertainty relation for the imprecisions of any joint measurement of position and momentum. Measures of error and disturbance are here defined as figures of merit characteristic of measuring devices. As such they are state independent, each giving worst-case estimates across all states, in contrast to previous work that is concerned with the relationship between error and disturbance in an individual state.