Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.17166

Numerical Study of Stability of Clean Critical Points across Aperiodic, Topological, and Uncorrelated Disorder

Shuhao Fan, Lu Liu, Wenan Guo

Published Sep 15, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Using the two-dimensional Ashkin-Teller (AT) model, we compare criticality on three non-periodic lattices: the Smith-hat aperiodic tiling, Voronoi-Delaunay (VD) random triangulations, and uncorrelated diluted square lattices. The decay of the block-averaged coordination fluctuation $σ_Q$ with exponent $α$ is used to describe the connectivity disorder. The first two lattices share the same exponent $α$, which differs from that of the third. We consider the regime where the correlation-length exponent $ν<1$, where randomness is relevant according to the Harris criterion $d ν\le 2$, but should be irrelevant in cases of the Smith-hat tiling and VD triangulations, where $αν>1$, according to the Harris--Barghathi--Vojta (HBV) criterion. For the diluted lattice, we indeed find that the clean universality behavior breaks down along the entire critical line, indicating a crossover to a fixed line dominated by disorder, in line with both the Harris criterion and the HBV criterion. In contrast, both VD and Smith-hat lattices display critical exponents consistent with the clean AT universality class, as validated by a Coulomb-gas self-consistency check, violating the Harris criterion while conforming to the HBV criterion.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2609.17166

Related papers

Phase Transitions on Random Lattices: How Random is Topological Disorder?

Hatem Barghathi, Thomas Vojta

We study the effects of topological (connectivity) disorder on phase transitions. We identify a broad class of random lattices whose disorder fluctuations decay much faster with increasing length scale than those of generic random systems, yielding a wandering exponent of ω=(d-1)/(2d) in d dimensions. The stability of clean critical points is thus governed by the criterion (d+1)ν>2 rather than the usual Harris criterion dν>2, making topological disorder less relevant than generic randomness. The Imry-Ma criterion is also modified, allowing first-order transitions to survive in all dimensions d>1. These results explain a host of puzzling violations of the original criteria for equilibrium and nonequilibrium phase transitions on random lattices. We discuss applications, and we illustrate our theory by computer simulations of random Voronoi and other lattices.

arXiv:1402.4425•Physical Review Letters•Sep 19, 2014•39 citations

Universality of continuous phase transitions on random Voronoi graphs

Manuel Schrauth, Jefferson S. E. Portela

The Voronoi construction is ubiquitous across the natural sciences and engineering. In statistical mechanics, however, only its dual, the Delaunay triangulation, has been considered in the investigation of critical phenomena. In this paper we set to fill this gap by studying three prominent systems of classical statistical mechanics, the equilibrium spin-1/2 Ising model, the nonequilibrium contact process, and the conserved stochastic sandpile model on two-dimensional random Voronoi graphs. Particular motivation comes from the fact that these graphs have vertices of constant coordination number, making it possible to isolate topological effects of quenched disorder from node-intrinsic coordination number disorder. Using large-scale numerical simulations and finite-size scaling techniques, we are able to demonstrate that all three systems belong to their respective clean universality classes. Therefore, quenched disorder introduced by the randomness of the lattice is irrelevant and does not influence the character of the phase transitions. We report the critical points to considerable precision and, for the Ising model, also the first correction-to-scaling exponent.

arXiv:1907.12494•Physical review. E•Dec 16, 2019•3 citations

Two-dimensional Ising model on random lattices with constant coordination number

Manuel Schrauth, Julian A. J. Richter, Jefferson S. E. Portela

We study the two-dimensional Ising model on networks with quenched topological (connectivity) disorder. In particular, we construct random lattices of constant coordination number and perform large-scale Monte Carlo simulations in order to obtain critical exponents using finite-size scaling relations. We find disorder-dependent effective critical exponents, similar to diluted models, showing thus no clear universal behavior. Considering the very recent results for the two-dimensional Ising model on proximity graphs and the coordination number correlation analysis suggested by Barghathi and Vojta [Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 120602 (2014)PRLTAO0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.113.120602], our results indicate that the planarity and connectedness of the lattice play an important role on deciding whether the phase transition is stable against quenched topological disorder.

arXiv:1711.07981•Physical review. E•Feb 28, 2018•10 citations

Self-averaging, distribution of pseudocritical temperatures, and finite size scaling in critical disordered systems

Shai Wiseman, Eytan Domany

We evaluate by Monte Carlo simulations various singular thermodynamic quantities $X$ for ensembles of quenched random Ising and Ashkin-Teller models. The measurements are taken at ${T}_{c}$ and we study how the distributions $P(X)$ (and, in particular, their relative squared width, ${R}_{X})$ over the ensemble depend on the system size $l.$ The Ashkin-Teller model was studied in the regime where bond randomness is irrelevant and we found weak self-averaging; ${R}_{X}\ensuremath{\sim}{l}^{\ensuremath{\alpha}/\ensuremath{\nu}}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0,$ where $\ensuremath{\alpha}<0$ and $\ensuremath{\nu}$ are the exponents (of the pure model fixed point) governing the transition. For the site-dilute Ising model on a cubic lattice, known to be governed by a random fixed point, we find that ${R}_{X}$ tends to a constant, as predicted by Aharony and Harris. We tested whether this constant is universal. However, this constant is different for canonical and grand canonical disorder. We identify the pseudocritical temperature of each sample $i,$ ${T}_{c}(i,l),$ as the temperature at which the susceptibility reaches its maximal value ${\ensuremath{\chi}}^{\mathrm{max}}.$ The distribution of these sample dependent ${T}_{c}(i,l)$ was investigated; we found that its variance scales as $[\ensuremath{\delta}{T}_{c}(l){]}^{2}\ensuremath{\sim}{l}^{\ensuremath{-}2/\ensuremath{\nu}}.$ Our previously proposed finite size scaling ansatz for disordered systems was tested and found to hold. We did observe deviations from a single function, which imply that sample dependent scaling functions are needed. These deviations are, however, relatively small and hence to obtain a fixed statistical error it may be more computationally efficient to measure ${\ensuremath{\chi}}^{\mathrm{max}}$ than the commonly used $\ensuremath{\chi}{(T}_{c}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}).$

arXiv:cond-mat/9802102•Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Sep 1, 1998•125 citations

Lack of self-averaging in critical disordered systems

Shai Wiseman, Eytan Domany

We consider the sample to sample fluctuations that occur in the value of a thermodynamic quantity $P$ in an ensemble of finite systems with quenched disorder, at equilibrium. The variance of $P$, ${V}_{P}$, which characterizes these fluctuations is calculated as a function of the systems' linear size $l$, focusing on the behavior at the critical point. The specific model considered is the bond-disordered Ashkin-Teller model on a square lattice [Phys. Rev. 64, 178 (1943)]. Using extensive Monte Carlo simulations, several bond-disordered Ashkin-Teller models were examined, including the bond-disordered Ising model and the bond-disordered four-state Potts model. It was found that far from criticality all thermodynamic quantities which were examined (energy, magnetization, specific heat, susceptibility) are strongly self-averaging, that is ${V}_{P}\ensuremath{\sim}{l}^{\ensuremath{-}d}$ (where $d=2$ is the dimension). At criticality though, the results indicate that the magnetization $M$ and the susceptibility $\ensuremath{\chi}$ are non-self-averaging, i.e., $\frac{{V}_{\ensuremath{\chi}}}{{\ensuremath{\chi}}^{2}}, \frac{{V}_{M}}{{M}^{2}}\ensuremath{\nrightarrow}0$. The energy $E$ at criticality is clearly weakly self-averaging, that is ${V}_{E}\ensuremath{\sim}{l}^{\ensuremath{-}{y}_{v}}$ with $0<{y}_{v}<d$. Less conclusively, and possibly only as a transient behavior, the specific heat too is found to be weakly self-averaging. A phenomenological theory of finite size scaling for disordered systems is developed, based on physical considerations similar to those leading to the Harris criterion. Its main prediction is that when the specific heat exponent $\ensuremath{\alpha}<0$ ($\ensuremath{\alpha}$ of the disordered model) then, for a quantity $P$ which scales as ${l}^{\ensuremath{\rho}}$ at criticality, its variance ${V}_{P}$ will scale asymptotically as ${l}^{2\ensuremath{\rho}+\frac{\ensuremath{\alpha}}{\ensuremath{\nu}}}$. The theory is not applicable in the asymptotic limit ($l\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$) to the bond-disordered Ashkin-Teller model where $\frac{\ensuremath{\alpha}}{\ensuremath{\nu}}={0}_{+}$. Nonetheless in the accessible range of lattice sizes we found very good agreement between the theory and the data for ${V}_{\ensuremath{\chi}}$ and ${V}_{E}$. The theory may also be compatible with the data for the variance of the magnetization ${V}_{M}$ and the variance of the specific heat ${V}_{C}$, but evidence for this is less convincing.

arXiv:cond-mat/9506101•Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Oct 1, 1995•132 citations

Critical behavior of the spin-1 Blume-Capel model on two-dimensional Voronoi-Delaunay random lattices

Francivaldo Pinheiro Fernandes, Douglas F. de Albuquerque, F. W. S. Lima +1 more

The critical properties of the spin-1 Blume-Capel model in two dimensions is studied on Voronoi-Delaunay random lattices with quenched connectivity disorder. The system is treated by applying Monte Carlo simulations using the heat-bath update algorithm together with single histograms re-weighting techniques. We calculate the critical temperature as well as the critical exponents as a function of the crystal field $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$. It is found that this disordered system exhibits phase transitions of first- and second-order types that depend on the value of the crystal field. For values of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\le}3$, where the nearest-neighbor exchange interaction $J$ has been set to unity, the disordered system presents a second-order phase transition. The results suggest that the corresponding exponent ratio belongs to the same universality class as the regular two-dimensional ferromagnetic model. There exists a tricritical point close to ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{t}=3.05(4)$ with different critical exponents. For ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{t}\ensuremath{\le}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}<3.4$ this model undergoes a first-order phase transition. Finally, for $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\ge}3.4$ the system is always in the paramagnetic phase.

Physical Review E•Aug 26, 2015•9 citations
Using the two-dimensional Ashkin-Teller (AT) model, we compare criticality on three non-periodic lattices: the Smith-hat aperiodic tiling, Voronoi-Delaunay (VD) random triangulations, and uncorrelated diluted square lattices. The decay of the block-averaged coordination fluctuation σQσ_QσQ​ with exponent ααα is used to describe the connectivity disorder. The first two lattices share the same exponent ααα, which differs from that of the third. We consider the regime where the correlation-length exponent ν<1ν<1ν<1, where randomness is relevant according to the Harris criterion dν≤2d ν\le 2dν≤2, but should be irrelevant in cases of the Smith-hat tiling and VD triangulations, where αν>1αν>1αν>1, according to the Harris--Barghathi--Vojta (HBV) criterion. For the diluted lattice, we indeed find that the clean universality behavior breaks down along the entire critical line, indicating a crossover to a fixed line dominated by disorder, in line with both the Harris criterion and the HBV criterion. In contrast, both VD and Smith-hat lattices display critical exponents consistent with the clean AT universality class, as validated by a Coulomb-gas self-consistency check, violating the Harris criterion while conforming to the HBV criterion.
We study the effects of topological (connectivity) disorder on phase transitions. We identify a broad class of random lattices whose disorder fluctuations decay much faster with increasing length scale than those of generic random systems, yielding a wandering exponent of ω=(d-1)/(2d) in d dimensions. The stability of clean critical points is thus governed by the criterion (d+1)ν>2 rather than the usual Harris criterion dν>2, making topological disorder less relevant than generic randomness. The Imry-Ma criterion is also modified, allowing first-order transitions to survive in all dimensions d>1. These results explain a host of puzzling violations of the original criteria for equilibrium and nonequilibrium phase transitions on random lattices. We discuss applications, and we illustrate our theory by computer simulations of random Voronoi and other lattices.
The Voronoi construction is ubiquitous across the natural sciences and engineering. In statistical mechanics, however, only its dual, the Delaunay triangulation, has been considered in the investigation of critical phenomena. In this paper we set to fill this gap by studying three prominent systems of classical statistical mechanics, the equilibrium spin-1/2 Ising model, the nonequilibrium contact process, and the conserved stochastic sandpile model on two-dimensional random Voronoi graphs. Particular motivation comes from the fact that these graphs have vertices of constant coordination number, making it possible to isolate topological effects of quenched disorder from node-intrinsic coordination number disorder. Using large-scale numerical simulations and finite-size scaling techniques, we are able to demonstrate that all three systems belong to their respective clean universality classes. Therefore, quenched disorder introduced by the randomness of the lattice is irrelevant and does not influence the character of the phase transitions. We report the critical points to considerable precision and, for the Ising model, also the first correction-to-scaling exponent.
We study the two-dimensional Ising model on networks with quenched topological (connectivity) disorder. In particular, we construct random lattices of constant coordination number and perform large-scale Monte Carlo simulations in order to obtain critical exponents using finite-size scaling relations. We find disorder-dependent effective critical exponents, similar to diluted models, showing thus no clear universal behavior. Considering the very recent results for the two-dimensional Ising model on proximity graphs and the coordination number correlation analysis suggested by Barghathi and Vojta [Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 120602 (2014)PRLTAO0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.113.120602], our results indicate that the planarity and connectedness of the lattice play an important role on deciding whether the phase transition is stable against quenched topological disorder.
We evaluate by Monte Carlo simulations various singular thermodynamic quantities XXX for ensembles of quenched random Ising and Ashkin-Teller models. The measurements are taken at Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ and we study how the distributions P(X)P(X)P(X) (and, in particular, their relative squared width, RX){R}_{X})RX​) over the ensemble depend on the system size l.l.l. The Ashkin-Teller model was studied in the regime where bond randomness is irrelevant and we found weak self-averaging; ${R}_{X}\ensuremath{\sim}{l}^{\ensuremath{\alpha}/\ensuremath{\nu}}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0,$ where $\ensuremath{\alpha}<0$ and $\ensuremath{\nu}$ are the exponents (of the pure model fixed point) governing the transition. For the site-dilute Ising model on a cubic lattice, known to be governed by a random fixed point, we find that RX{R}_{X}RX​ tends to a constant, as predicted by Aharony and Harris. We tested whether this constant is universal. However, this constant is different for canonical and grand canonical disorder. We identify the pseudocritical temperature of each sample i,i,i, Tc(i,l),{T}_{c}(i,l),Tc​(i,l), as the temperature at which the susceptibility reaches its maximal value ${\ensuremath{\chi}}^{\mathrm{max}}.$ The distribution of these sample dependent Tc(i,l){T}_{c}(i,l)Tc​(i,l) was investigated; we found that its variance scales as $[\ensuremath{\delta}{T}_{c}(l){]}^{2}\ensuremath{\sim}{l}^{\ensuremath{-}2/\ensuremath{\nu}}.$ Our previously proposed finite size scaling ansatz for disordered systems was tested and found to hold. We did observe deviations from a single function, which imply that sample dependent scaling functions are needed. These deviations are, however, relatively small and hence to obtain a fixed statistical error it may be more computationally efficient to measure ${\ensuremath{\chi}}^{\mathrm{max}}$ than the commonly used $\ensuremath{\chi}{(T}_{c}^{\ensuremath{\infty}}).$
We consider the sample to sample fluctuations that occur in the value of a thermodynamic quantity PPP in an ensemble of finite systems with quenched disorder, at equilibrium. The variance of PPP, VP{V}_{P}VP​, which characterizes these fluctuations is calculated as a function of the systems' linear size lll, focusing on the behavior at the critical point. The specific model considered is the bond-disordered Ashkin-Teller model on a square lattice [Phys. Rev. 64, 178 (1943)]. Using extensive Monte Carlo simulations, several bond-disordered Ashkin-Teller models were examined, including the bond-disordered Ising model and the bond-disordered four-state Potts model. It was found that far from criticality all thermodynamic quantities which were examined (energy, magnetization, specific heat, susceptibility) are strongly self-averaging, that is ${V}_{P}\ensuremath{\sim}{l}^{\ensuremath{-}d}$ (where d=2d=2d=2 is the dimension). At criticality though, the results indicate that the magnetization MMM and the susceptibility $\ensuremath{\chi}$ are non-self-averaging, i.e., $\frac{{V}_{\ensuremath{\chi}}}{{\ensuremath{\chi}}^{2}}, \frac{{V}_{M}}{{M}^{2}}\ensuremath{\nrightarrow}0$. The energy EEE at criticality is clearly weakly self-averaging, that is ${V}_{E}\ensuremath{\sim}{l}^{\ensuremath{-}{y}_{v}}$ with 0<yv<d0<{y}_{v}<d0<yv​<d. Less conclusively, and possibly only as a transient behavior, the specific heat too is found to be weakly self-averaging. A phenomenological theory of finite size scaling for disordered systems is developed, based on physical considerations similar to those leading to the Harris criterion. Its main prediction is that when the specific heat exponent $\ensuremath{\alpha}<0$ ($\ensuremath{\alpha}$ of the disordered model) then, for a quantity PPP which scales as ${l}^{\ensuremath{\rho}}$ at criticality, its variance VP{V}_{P}VP​ will scale asymptotically as ${l}^{2\ensuremath{\rho}+\frac{\ensuremath{\alpha}}{\ensuremath{\nu}}}$. The theory is not applicable in the asymptotic limit ($l\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$) to the bond-disordered Ashkin-Teller model where $\frac{\ensuremath{\alpha}}{\ensuremath{\nu}}={0}_{+}$. Nonetheless in the accessible range of lattice sizes we found very good agreement between the theory and the data for ${V}_{\ensuremath{\chi}}$ and VE{V}_{E}VE​. The theory may also be compatible with the data for the variance of the magnetization VM{V}_{M}VM​ and the variance of the specific heat VC{V}_{C}VC​, but evidence for this is less convincing.
The critical properties of the spin-1 Blume-Capel model in two dimensions is studied on Voronoi-Delaunay random lattices with quenched connectivity disorder. The system is treated by applying Monte Carlo simulations using the heat-bath update algorithm together with single histograms re-weighting techniques. We calculate the critical temperature as well as the critical exponents as a function of the crystal field $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$. It is found that this disordered system exhibits phase transitions of first- and second-order types that depend on the value of the crystal field. For values of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\le}3$, where the nearest-neighbor exchange interaction JJJ has been set to unity, the disordered system presents a second-order phase transition. The results suggest that the corresponding exponent ratio belongs to the same universality class as the regular two-dimensional ferromagnetic model. There exists a tricritical point close to ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{t}=3.05(4)$ with different critical exponents. For ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{t}\ensuremath{\le}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}<3.4$ this model undergoes a first-order phase transition. Finally, for $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\ge}3.4$ the system is always in the paramagnetic phase.