Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.11903

The generalised semi-Clifford conjecture is false

Nadish de Silva, Oscar Lautsch

quant-phmath-phmath.QASubmitted Sep 10, 2026• Announced Sep 11, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Clifford hierarchy is a nested sequence of sets of quantum gates that can be fault-tolerantly performed using gate teleportation within standard quantum error correction schemes. The importance of these gates has motivated numerous studies of their structure. Zeng-Chen-Chuang conjectured in 2007 that all hierarchy gates are generalised semi-Clifford, i.e. take the form $C_1 ΠD C_2$ for Clifford gates $C_1, C_2$, a permutation gate $Π$, and a diagonal gate $D$; Beigi-Shor proved in 2008 that this holds for all third-level gates. We construct a five-qubit gate that is in the fifth level of the Clifford hierarchy but is not generalised semi-Clifford. Rather than simply present and verify our counterexample to the generalised semi-Clifford conjecture, we show how its form can be deduced. Our counterexample also demonstrates that the Clifford hierarchy is not closed under inverses.

Comments
Preliminary draft. Improved exposition forthcoming

Related papers

The Generalized Semi-Clifford Conjecture Holds at Level 4

Maxwell Marcus, Sathyawageeswar Subramanian, Marcel Dall'Agnol

The Clifford hierarchy $\mathsf{C}_1 \subset \mathsf{C}_2 \subset \cdots$ was introduced by Gottesman and Chuang (arXiv:quant-ph/9908010) to characterize gates that admit fault-tolerant implementation by gate teleportation. Yet, despite its rich mathematical structure and the attention it has received in recent years, little is known about $\mathsf{C}_k$ for $k > 3$. Most progress has focused on identifying structural properties of restrictions of the hierarchy, such as diagonal gates and gates on systems of small dimension $d$ or with few qudits. The generalized semi-Clifford conjecture, proposed by Zeng et al. (arXiv:0712.2084), states that every gate in $\cup_k \mathsf{C}_k$ is, up to multiplication by Cliffords, the product of a permutation and a diagonal matrix. Beigi and Shor proved the case $d=2$, $k=3$ (arXiv:0810.5108) and Pllaha et al. found an alternative proof by exploiting fixed points of the conjugation map induced by (a Clifford correction of) $U \in \mathsf{C}_3$ on the span of maximal stabilizer subgroups (arXiv:2006.14040). By extending their fixed-point arguments to the group $Γ_1(U)$ generated by $U \mathsf{P} U^\dagger$ and beyond, we prove the conjecture for $k \leq 4$ and any prime dimension $d$. Our proof centers on conjugation groups $Γ_1(U), Γ_2(U), \ldots$ of $U \in \mathsf{C}_k$, which we expect to be a useful tool in the study of the Clifford hierarchy more generally. We also show a natural sufficient condition on such groups for gates in higher levels to be generalized semi-Clifford.

quant-pharXiv:2609.38751•Oct 1, 2026•1 citation

When is the Clifford hierarchy generalized semi-Clifford?

Rongbiao Thomas Wang, Bobby Zixuan Zhang

We study semi-Clifford and generalized semi-Clifford structures in the Clifford hierarchy as a function of hierarchy level $k$ and qubit number $n$. We show that $\mathcal{C}_k(n)$ is semi-Clifford if and only if $k\le2$, $n\le2$, or $k=3$ and $n\le6$. We also establish that $\mathcal{C}_k(n)$ is generalized semi-Clifford when $k\le4$ or $n\le3$ and construct counterexamples when $k,n \geq 5$. For $n=4$ and $k\ge5$, we show that every gate defined over $\mathbb{Q}(i)$ up to a scalar is generalized semi-Clifford, reduce the general case to a single level, and propose a strategy to prove our conjecture that $\mathcal{C}_k(n)$ is generalized semi-Clifford if and only if $k\le4$ or $n\le4$. Lastly, we go beyond this structure by introducing $n_c$-generalized semi-Clifford gates, which we show are exactly the gates of the form $\sum_x|π(x)\rangle\langle x|\otimes V_x$ up to Clifford gates on both sides, where $π$ permutes the computational basis states of $n_c$ control qubits. We conjecture that for $k\ge3$ every gate in $\mathcal{C}_k(n)$ has this form for some $n_c\ge1$ with every $V_x\in\mathcal{C}_{k-3}(n-n_c)$, refining the conjecture of Zeng, Chen, and Chuang.

quant-pharXiv:2610.06402•Oct 6, 2026•0 citations

The Clifford hierarchy for one qubit or qudit

Nadish de Silva, Oscar Lautsch

The Clifford hierarchy is a nested sequence of sets of quantum gates that can be fault-tolerantly performed using gate teleportation within standard quantum error correction schemes. The groups of Pauli and Clifford gates constitute the first and second ‘levels’, respectively. Non-Clifford gates from the third level or higher, such as the T gate, are necessary for achieving fault-tolerant universal quantum computation. Since it was defined 26 years ago by Gottesman–Chuang, two questions have been studied by numerous researchers. First, precisely which gates constitute the Clifford hierarchy? Second, which subset of the hierarchy gates admit efficient gate teleportation protocols? We completely solve both questions in the practically relevant case of the Clifford hierarchy for gates of one qubit or one qudit of prime dimension. We express every such hierarchy gate uniquely as a product of three simple gates, yielding also a formula for the size of every level. These results are a consequence of our finding that all such hierarchy gates can be expressed in a certain form that guarantees efficient gate teleportation. Our decomposition of Clifford gates as a unique product of three elementary Clifford gates is of broad applicability.

arXiv:2501.07939•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Oct 1, 2025•14 citations

Semi-Cliffordness of the Clifford hierarchy for a single qudit in composite dimensions

Yifei Qi, Rahul Sarkar

An important question in quantum information theory asks whether every gate in the Clifford hierarchy is semi-Clifford or not, as such gates admit resource-efficient implementations via gate teleportation. Extending recent results for prime dimensions~\cite{silva_clifford_2025}, we prove that every hierarchy gate on a single qudit of dimension \(d\) is semi-Clifford, if and only if \(d\) is square-free. In composite dimensions, \(\mathbb{Z}_d^2\) is a symplectic module rather than a vector space, motivating a distinction between four types of gates. Semi-Clifford gates ($\mathcal{SC}$) are the ones that become diagonal under left and right multiplication by Clifford gates, while a broader class $\mathcal{N}$ admits a permutation diagonal form, under left and right multiplication by Cliffords. Lagrangian semi-Clifford gates ($\mathcal{LSC}$) conjugate some maximal abelian Pauli subgroup to another, whereas generalized semi-Clifford gates ($\mathcal{GSC}$) map some maximal abelian Pauli subalgebra to another under conjugation. In square-free dimensions, we have \(\mathcal{SC}=\mathcal{LSC}\) and \(\mathcal{N}=\mathcal{GSC}\), but when \(d\) is not square-free, these equivalences can fail, as Lagrangian submodules can become non-free. We also show that every third-level gate of the one-qudit Clifford hierarchy is a generalized semi-Clifford in arbitrary dimensions.

quant-pharXiv:2610.06836•Oct 6, 2026•0 citations

Efficient quantum gate teleportation in higher dimensions

Nadish de Silva

The Clifford hierarchy is a nested sequence of sets of quantum gates critical to achieving fault-tolerant quantum computation. Diagonal gates of the Clifford hierarchy and ‘nearly diagonal’ semi-Clifford gates are particularly important: they admit efficient gate teleportation protocols that implement these gates with fewer ancillary quantum resources such as magic states. Despite the practical importance of these sets of gates, many questions about their structure remain open; this is especially true in the higher-dimensional qudit setting. Our contribution is to leverage the discrete Stone–von Neumann theorem and the symplectic formalism of qudit stabilizer theory towards extending the results of Zeng et al . (2008) and Beigi & Shor (2010) to higher dimensions in a uniform manner. We further give a simple algorithm for recursively enumerating all gates of the Clifford hierarchy, a simple algorithm for recognizing and diagonalizing semi-Clifford gates, and a concise proof of the classification of the diagonal Clifford hierarchy gates due to Cui et al . (2016) for the single-qudit case. We generalize the efficient gate teleportation protocols of semi-Clifford gates to the qudit setting and prove that every third-level gate of one qudit (of any prime dimension) and of two qutrits can be implemented efficiently. Numerical evidence gathered via the aforementioned algorithms supports the conjecture that higher-level gates can be implemented efficiently.

arXiv:2011.00127•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Jul 1, 2021•20 citations

C_3, semi-Clifford and genralized semi-Clifford operations

Salman Beigi, Peter W. Shor

Fault-tolerant quantum computation is a basic problem in quantum computation, and teleportation is one of the main techniques in this theory. Using teleportation on stabilizer codes, the most well-known quantum codes, Pauli gates and Clifford operators can be applied fault-tolerantly. Indeed, this technique can be generalized for an extended set of gates, the so called ${\mathcal{C}}_k$ hierarchy gates, introduced by Gottesman and Chuang (Nature, 402, 390-392). ${\mathcal{C}}_k$ gates are a generalization of Clifford operators, but our knowledge of these sets is not as rich as our knowledge of Clifford gates. Zeng et al. in (Phys. Rev. A 77, 042313) raise the question of the relation between ${\mathcal{C}}_k$ hierarchy and the set of semi-Clifford and generalized semi-Clifford operators. They conjecture that any ${\mathcal{C}}_k$ gate is a generalized semi-Clifford operator. In this paper, we prove this conjecture for $k=3$. Using the techniques that we develop, we obtain more insight on how to characterize ${\mathcal{C}}_3$ gates. Indeed, the more we understand ${\mathcal{C}}_3$, the more intuition we have on ${\mathcal{C}}_k$, $k\geq 4$, and then we have a way of attacking the conjecture for larger $k$.

arXiv:0810.5108•Quantum Information and Computation•Jan 1, 2010•18 citations
The Clifford hierarchy is a nested sequence of sets of quantum gates that can be fault-tolerantly performed using gate teleportation within standard quantum error correction schemes. The importance of these gates has motivated numerous studies of their structure. Zeng-Chen-Chuang conjectured in 2007 that all hierarchy gates are generalised semi-Clifford, i.e. take the form C1ΠDC2C_1 ΠD C_2C1​ΠDC2​ for Clifford gates C1,C2C_1, C_2C1​,C2​, a permutation gate ΠΠΠ, and a diagonal gate DDD; Beigi-Shor proved in 2008 that this holds for all third-level gates.
We construct a five-qubit gate that is in the fifth level of the Clifford hierarchy but is not generalised semi-Clifford. Rather than simply present and verify our counterexample to the generalised semi-Clifford conjecture, we show how its form can be deduced. Our counterexample also demonstrates that the Clifford hierarchy is not closed under inverses.
The Clifford hierarchy C1⊂C2⊂⋯\mathsf{C}_1 \subset \mathsf{C}_2 \subset \cdotsC1​⊂C2​⊂⋯ was introduced by Gottesman and Chuang (arXiv:quant-ph/9908010) to characterize gates that admit fault-tolerant implementation by gate teleportation. Yet, despite its rich mathematical structure and the attention it has received in recent years, little is known about Ck\mathsf{C}_kCk​ for k>3k > 3k>3. Most progress has focused on identifying structural properties of restrictions of the hierarchy, such as diagonal gates and gates on systems of small dimension ddd or with few qudits. The generalized semi-Clifford conjecture, proposed by Zeng et al. (arXiv:0712.2084), states that every gate in ∪kCk\cup_k \mathsf{C}_k∪k​Ck​ is, up to multiplication by Cliffords, the product of a permutation and a diagonal matrix. Beigi and Shor proved the case d=2d=2d=2, k=3k=3k=3 (arXiv:0810.5108) and Pllaha et al. found an alternative proof by exploiting fixed points of the conjugation map induced by (a Clifford correction of) U∈C3U \in \mathsf{C}_3U∈C3​ on the span of maximal stabilizer subgroups (arXiv:2006.14040). By extending their fixed-point arguments to the group Γ1(U)Γ_1(U)Γ1​(U) generated by UPU†U \mathsf{P} U^\daggerUPU† and beyond, we prove the conjecture for k≤4k \leq 4k≤4 and any prime dimension ddd. Our proof centers on conjugation groups Γ1(U),Γ2(U),…Γ_1(U), Γ_2(U), \ldotsΓ1​(U),Γ2​(U),… of U∈CkU \in \mathsf{C}_kU∈Ck​, which we expect to be a useful tool in the study of the Clifford hierarchy more generally. We also show a natural sufficient condition on such groups for gates in higher levels to be generalized semi-Clifford.
We study semi-Clifford and generalized semi-Clifford structures in the Clifford hierarchy as a function of hierarchy level kkk and qubit number nnn. We show that Ck(n)\mathcal{C}_k(n)Ck​(n) is semi-Clifford if and only if k≤2k\le2k≤2, n≤2n\le2n≤2, or k=3k=3k=3 and n≤6n\le6n≤6. We also establish that Ck(n)\mathcal{C}_k(n)Ck​(n) is generalized semi-Clifford when k≤4k\le4k≤4 or n≤3n\le3n≤3 and construct counterexamples when k,n≥5k,n \geq 5k,n≥5. For n=4n=4n=4 and k≥5k\ge5k≥5, we show that every gate defined over Q(i)\mathbb{Q}(i)Q(i) up to a scalar is generalized semi-Clifford, reduce the general case to a single level, and propose a strategy to prove our conjecture that Ck(n)\mathcal{C}_k(n)Ck​(n) is generalized semi-Clifford if and only if k≤4k\le4k≤4 or n≤4n\le4n≤4. Lastly, we go beyond this structure by introducing ncn_cnc​-generalized semi-Clifford gates, which we show are exactly the gates of the form ∑x∣π(x)⟩⟨x∣⊗Vx\sum_x|π(x)\rangle\langle x|\otimes V_x∑x​∣π(x)⟩⟨x∣⊗Vx​ up to Clifford gates on both sides, where πππ permutes the computational basis states of ncn_cnc​ control qubits. We conjecture that for k≥3k\ge3k≥3 every gate in Ck(n)\mathcal{C}_k(n)Ck​(n) has this form for some nc≥1n_c\ge1nc​≥1 with every Vx∈Ck−3(n−nc)V_x\in\mathcal{C}_{k-3}(n-n_c)Vx​∈Ck−3​(n−nc​), refining the conjecture of Zeng, Chen, and Chuang.
The Clifford hierarchy is a nested sequence of sets of quantum gates that can be fault-tolerantly performed using gate teleportation within standard quantum error correction schemes. The groups of Pauli and Clifford gates constitute the first and second ‘levels’, respectively. Non-Clifford gates from the third level or higher, such as the T gate, are necessary for achieving fault-tolerant universal quantum computation. Since it was defined 26 years ago by Gottesman–Chuang, two questions have been studied by numerous researchers. First, precisely which gates constitute the Clifford hierarchy? Second, which subset of the hierarchy gates admit efficient gate teleportation protocols? We completely solve both questions in the practically relevant case of the Clifford hierarchy for gates of one qubit or one qudit of prime dimension. We express every such hierarchy gate uniquely as a product of three simple gates, yielding also a formula for the size of every level. These results are a consequence of our finding that all such hierarchy gates can be expressed in a certain form that guarantees efficient gate teleportation. Our decomposition of Clifford gates as a unique product of three elementary Clifford gates is of broad applicability.
An important question in quantum information theory asks whether every gate in the Clifford hierarchy is semi-Clifford or not, as such gates admit resource-efficient implementations via gate teleportation. Extending recent results for prime dimensions~\cite{silva_clifford_2025}, we prove that every hierarchy gate on a single qudit of dimension ddd is semi-Clifford, if and only if ddd is square-free. In composite dimensions, Zd2\mathbb{Z}_d^2Zd2​ is a symplectic module rather than a vector space, motivating a distinction between four types of gates. Semi-Clifford gates (SC\mathcal{SC}SC) are the ones that become diagonal under left and right multiplication by Clifford gates, while a broader class N\mathcal{N}N admits a permutation diagonal form, under left and right multiplication by Cliffords. Lagrangian semi-Clifford gates (LSC\mathcal{LSC}LSC) conjugate some maximal abelian Pauli subgroup to another, whereas generalized semi-Clifford gates (GSC\mathcal{GSC}GSC) map some maximal abelian Pauli subalgebra to another under conjugation. In square-free dimensions, we have SC=LSC\mathcal{SC}=\mathcal{LSC}SC=LSC and N=GSC\mathcal{N}=\mathcal{GSC}N=GSC, but when ddd is not square-free, these equivalences can fail, as Lagrangian submodules can become non-free. We also show that every third-level gate of the one-qudit Clifford hierarchy is a generalized semi-Clifford in arbitrary dimensions.
The Clifford hierarchy is a nested sequence of sets of quantum gates critical to achieving fault-tolerant quantum computation. Diagonal gates of the Clifford hierarchy and ‘nearly diagonal’ semi-Clifford gates are particularly important: they admit efficient gate teleportation protocols that implement these gates with fewer ancillary quantum resources such as magic states. Despite the practical importance of these sets of gates, many questions about their structure remain open; this is especially true in the higher-dimensional qudit setting. Our contribution is to leverage the discrete Stone–von Neumann theorem and the symplectic formalism of qudit stabilizer theory towards extending the results of Zeng et al . (2008) and Beigi & Shor (2010) to higher dimensions in a uniform manner. We further give a simple algorithm for recursively enumerating all gates of the Clifford hierarchy, a simple algorithm for recognizing and diagonalizing semi-Clifford gates, and a concise proof of the classification of the diagonal Clifford hierarchy gates due to Cui et al . (2016) for the single-qudit case. We generalize the efficient gate teleportation protocols of semi-Clifford gates to the qudit setting and prove that every third-level gate of one qudit (of any prime dimension) and of two qutrits can be implemented efficiently. Numerical evidence gathered via the aforementioned algorithms supports the conjecture that higher-level gates can be implemented efficiently.
Fault-tolerant quantum computation is a basic problem in quantum computation, and teleportation is one of the main techniques in this theory. Using teleportation on stabilizer codes, the most well-known quantum codes, Pauli gates and Clifford operators can be applied fault-tolerantly. Indeed, this technique can be generalized for an extended set of gates, the so called Ck{\mathcal{C}}_kCk​ hierarchy gates, introduced by Gottesman and Chuang (Nature, 402, 390-392). Ck{\mathcal{C}}_kCk​ gates are a generalization of Clifford operators, but our knowledge of these sets is not as rich as our knowledge of Clifford gates. Zeng et al. in (Phys. Rev. A 77, 042313) raise the question of the relation between Ck{\mathcal{C}}_kCk​ hierarchy and the set of semi-Clifford and generalized semi-Clifford operators. They conjecture that any Ck{\mathcal{C}}_kCk​ gate is a generalized semi-Clifford operator. In this paper, we prove this conjecture for k=3k=3k=3. Using the techniques that we develop, we obtain more insight on how to characterize C3{\mathcal{C}}_3C3​ gates. Indeed, the more we understand C3{\mathcal{C}}_3C3​, the more intuition we have on Ck{\mathcal{C}}_kCk​, k≥4k\geq 4k≥4, and then we have a way of attacking the conjecture for larger kkk.