Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.07391

Unitary equivalence of Schrödinger and Heisenberg pictures survives in nonlinear quantum mechanics

Lajos Diósi

quant-phSubmitted Sep 7, 2026• Announced Sep 8, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The equivalence of Schrödinger and Heisenberg pictures is often thought to break down in nonlinear quantum mechanics due to the absence of a state-independent unitary propagator. We show that for Hamiltonians depending on the state through instantaneous expectation values, the equivalence is preserved. While the unitary intertwiner becomes initial-state dependent, it remains well-defined and ensures identical physical predictions in both pictures. We illustrate this with the analytically solvable examples of a nonlinear spin precession and a mean-field harmonic force, as well as in local field theory with mean-field coupling.

Comments
5pp

Related papers

Limitations on the use of the Heisenberg picture

J. D. Franson, R. A. Brewster

The Schrodinger and Heisenberg pictures are equivalent formulations of quantum mechanics in the sense that they give the same expectation value for any operator. We consider a sequence of two or more unitary transformations and show that the Heisenberg operator produced after the first transformation cannot be viewed as the input to the second transformation. The experimental consequences of this are illustrated by several examples in quantum optics.

•Nov 15, 2018•1 citation

The Heisenberg picture

Dževad Belkić

In this chapter, the authors describe the Heisenberg picture of quantum mechanics by formally accomplishing a time-dependent transformation of state vectors and operators of the Schrodinger picture. Any new picture of quantum mechanics will be acceptable, if the Schrodinger state vectors and operators are subjected to a transformation, which does not alter: the spectrum of the eigenvalues of the operators and the scalar product of an arbitrary state vector with the eigenstate vectors. These two conditions are easily fulfilled by means of the unitary transformations. The authors show that a unitary operator represents an isomorph mapping of a certain unitary vector space onto itself. Since the physical quantities measured in the experiment are, in fact, a measure of the scalar product, as implied by the definition of the probability W through the scalar product in, it is clear that the predictions based upon the new, Heisenberg picture must be identical to those obtained in the Schrodinger picture.

CRC Press eBooks•Jan 15, 2020•0 citations

Equation of Motion

Ahmad Amer

This chapter explores the Schrödinger and Heisenberg pictures in quantum mechanics, emphasizing their mathematical equivalence and physical consistency. The two formulations are shown to be connected by a unitary transformation. The Heisenberg equation of motion is derived, and the time evolution of operators—particularly those not explicitly dependent on time—is expressed in terms of their initial values. It is demonstrated that scalar products, expectation values, matrix elements, and commutation relations remain invariant under the change of picture. Drawing a close analogy with classical mechanics, Dirac's insight is presented: the quantum mechanical counterpart of the classical Poisson bracket is the operator commutator divided by iℏ . The chapter concludes by deriving the Lorentz force law within the quantum framework using commutator algebra. Metadata/Keywords: Schrödinger picture, Heisenberg picture, unitary transformation, Heisenberg equation of motion, Poisson bracket, Lorentz force, time evolution, expectation values

CRC Press eBooks•Nov 5, 2025•0 citations

On the (Non)Equivalence of the Schrodinger and Heisenberg Pictures of Quantum Mechanics

de Gosson, Anthony Maurice

The aim of this short Note is to show that the Schrodinger and Heisenberg pictures of quantum mechanics cannot be equivalent unless one uses a quantization rule clearly stated by Born and Jordan in their famous 1925 paper. This rule is sufficient and necessary to ensure energy conservation in Heisenberg's matrix mechanics. It follows, in particular, that Schrodinger and Heisenberg mechanics yield different theories if one quantizes the Hamiltonian using the Weyl prescription.

•Apr 27, 2014•0 citations

Complements

Bernard d’Espagnat

This chapter briefly explains the two elementary points concerning quantum mechanics: the mean value rule and the Heisenberg picture. The Schrodinger and Heisenberg pictures are two different but equivalent sets of rules. In other words, when applied to a given physical situation they lead to the same observable predictions. In some respects the Heisenberg picture has definite technical advantages. It is particularly convenient, for instance, in quantum field theory. For describing pure cases the use of wave functions in place of kets is sometimes convenient. The mean value of an observable A and the probability that a measurement of A yields eigenvalue a k can be expressed by means of wave functions. The state vector of a system that does not undergo a measurement does not change with time, obviously this state vector is suddenly modified—also in the Heisenberg picture—when a measurement takes place.

CRC Press eBooks•May 4, 2018•0 citations

Schrödinger, Heisenberg, and Dirac “Pictures” of Quantum Dynamics

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

A consistent description of the physical state of a system is provided by its wavefunction whose time-evolution is described by the Schrödinger equation The wavefunction, is the coordinate representation of the state vector in the Hilbert space that describes the system. Unitary transformations of an orthonormal basis set that spans the Hilbert space amount to rotation of the basis set. An example of this is the unitary transformation from basis to using the Clebsch– Gordan coefficients that we discussed in Chapter 4. Such unitary transformations preserve the norm of the state vectors, and alternative basis sets connected by them provide mathematically equivalent descriptions of quantum mechanics. Preference of using one basis over another is dictated by algebraic elegance. Alternative descriptions of the temporal evolution of a physical system are possible using generalized rotations that leave the physics invariant, but alter the description of the temporal evolution of the system. Whereas the Schrödinger picture describes temporal evolution of a physical system using methodologies in which the operators are independent of time, and all the time-dependence appears in the wavefunctions, in the Heisenberg picture all the time-dependence is contained in the operators, while the wavefunctions are considered independent of time. In the Dirac picture (also called as the Interaction picture ), both the wavefunctions and the operators are considered to be time-dependent. The three pictures are essentially equivalent, and transformations from any one of them to any other are effected using generalized rotations brought about by unitary transformations described below. The time-evolution operator in the Schrödinger picture is given by Eq. 1.86b (Chapter 1). If the reference time t 0 is considered to be zero, the time evolution of a physical state is described by where the exponential operator is which gives the dynamical phase (Eq. 1.114b in Chapter 1) of a stationary state: Operators like q, p, H are independent of time in the Schrödinger picture.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations
The equivalence of Schrödinger and Heisenberg pictures is often thought to break down in nonlinear quantum mechanics due to the absence of a state-independent unitary propagator. We show that for Hamiltonians depending on the state through instantaneous expectation values, the equivalence is preserved. While the unitary intertwiner becomes initial-state dependent, it remains well-defined and ensures identical physical predictions in both pictures. We illustrate this with the analytically solvable examples of a nonlinear spin precession and a mean-field harmonic force, as well as in local field theory with mean-field coupling.
In this chapter, the authors describe the Heisenberg picture of quantum mechanics by formally accomplishing a time-dependent transformation of state vectors and operators of the Schrodinger picture. Any new picture of quantum mechanics will be acceptable, if the Schrodinger state vectors and operators are subjected to a transformation, which does not alter: the spectrum of the eigenvalues of the operators and the scalar product of an arbitrary state vector with the eigenstate vectors. These two conditions are easily fulfilled by means of the unitary transformations. The authors show that a unitary operator represents an isomorph mapping of a certain unitary vector space onto itself. Since the physical quantities measured in the experiment are, in fact, a measure of the scalar product, as implied by the definition of the probability W through the scalar product in, it is clear that the predictions based upon the new, Heisenberg picture must be identical to those obtained in the Schrodinger picture.
This chapter explores the Schrödinger and Heisenberg pictures in quantum mechanics, emphasizing their mathematical equivalence and physical consistency. The two formulations are shown to be connected by a unitary transformation. The Heisenberg equation of motion is derived, and the time evolution of operators—particularly those not explicitly dependent on time—is expressed in terms of their initial values. It is demonstrated that scalar products, expectation values, matrix elements, and commutation relations remain invariant under the change of picture. Drawing a close analogy with classical mechanics, Dirac's insight is presented: the quantum mechanical counterpart of the classical Poisson bracket is the operator commutator divided by iℏ . The chapter concludes by deriving the Lorentz force law within the quantum framework using commutator algebra. Metadata/Keywords: Schrödinger picture, Heisenberg picture, unitary transformation, Heisenberg equation of motion, Poisson bracket, Lorentz force, time evolution, expectation values
This chapter briefly explains the two elementary points concerning quantum mechanics: the mean value rule and the Heisenberg picture. The Schrodinger and Heisenberg pictures are two different but equivalent sets of rules. In other words, when applied to a given physical situation they lead to the same observable predictions. In some respects the Heisenberg picture has definite technical advantages. It is particularly convenient, for instance, in quantum field theory. For describing pure cases the use of wave functions in place of kets is sometimes convenient. The mean value of an observable A and the probability that a measurement of A yields eigenvalue a k can be expressed by means of wave functions. The state vector of a system that does not undergo a measurement does not change with time, obviously this state vector is suddenly modified—also in the Heisenberg picture—when a measurement takes place.
A consistent description of the physical state of a system is provided by its wavefunction whose time-evolution is described by the Schrödinger equation The wavefunction, is the coordinate representation of the state vector in the Hilbert space that describes the system. Unitary transformations of an orthonormal basis set that spans the Hilbert space amount to rotation of the basis set. An example of this is the unitary transformation from basis to using the Clebsch– Gordan coefficients that we discussed in Chapter 4. Such unitary transformations preserve the norm of the state vectors, and alternative basis sets connected by them provide mathematically equivalent descriptions of quantum mechanics. Preference of using one basis over another is dictated by algebraic elegance. Alternative descriptions of the temporal evolution of a physical system are possible using generalized rotations that leave the physics invariant, but alter the description of the temporal evolution of the system. Whereas the Schrödinger picture describes temporal evolution of a physical system using methodologies in which the operators are independent of time, and all the time-dependence appears in the wavefunctions, in the Heisenberg picture all the time-dependence is contained in the operators, while the wavefunctions are considered independent of time. In the Dirac picture (also called as the Interaction picture ), both the wavefunctions and the operators are considered to be time-dependent. The three pictures are essentially equivalent, and transformations from any one of them to any other are effected using generalized rotations brought about by unitary transformations described below. The time-evolution operator in the Schrödinger picture is given by Eq. 1.86b (Chapter 1). If the reference time t 0 is considered to be zero, the time evolution of a physical state is described by where the exponential operator is which gives the dynamical phase (Eq. 1.114b in Chapter 1) of a stationary state: Operators like q, p, H are independent of time in the Schrödinger picture.