Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2608.30802

Chiral Color Ice: Exact Local Handedness Constraints and Möbius Zero Modes in Frustrated Magnets

Péter Kránitz, Yasir Iqbal, Karlo Penc

cond-mat.str-elmath-phquant-phSubmitted Aug 31, 2026• Announced Sep 1, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Local constraints govern the low-energy physics of frustrated matter, but familiar ice-type rules constrain flux-like quantities and are insensitive to handedness. Here we show that handedness itself can be imposed as an exact local quantum constraint without selecting an axis in spin space. We construct positive-semidefinite, SU(2)-invariant parent Hamiltonians whose complete zero-energy space on a tetrahedron has a prescribed chirality sign, rather than selecting a particular chiral wave function. For spin-1/2 the local term is a rank-one projector onto a chiral tetrahedral singlet, while for arbitrary spin it factorizes as $B^\dagger B$ through a singlet-annihilation operator, with a completely characterized kernel given by the span of the globally rotated chiral color-ice states. For coherent states, the same zero-energy condition becomes an $S$-independent nonlinear constraint in which three spin directions determine the fourth through a Möbius transformation; compositions of these maps define constraint holonomies on extended lattices. Connecting the same local constraint in different ways produces qualitatively different collective regimes: corner-sharing lattices retain exponentially large quantum ground-state kernels, with rigorous lower bounds exceeding conventional ice benchmarks; edge-sharing lattices support subdimensional plane or line zero modes; while triangular constructions suppress nonuniform coherent deformations and contain the complete Anderson tower of tetrahedral magnetic order at exactly zero energy. Two inequivalent triangular coverings further show that harmonic zero-mode counting does not determine the size of the quantum kernel. These results establish a tractable setting in which local handedness, nonlinear constraint geometry, and quantum degeneracy can be disentangled and related directly to the connectivity of the constraint network.

Comments
50 pages, 13 figures, 10 tables

Related papers

Microscopic Spin-1 Parent Hamiltonians for Emergent Valence-Bond Loop Manifolds

Hari Borutta, Yasir Iqbal, Kirill Shtengel

We construct an exact spin-$1$ parent Hamiltonian for constrained valence-bond loop manifolds on the checkerboard and pyrochlore lattices. The Hamiltonian is local, SU(2)- and time-reversal-invariant, and built from positive-semidefinite projectors acting on triangular faces. Each projector removes only the maximally polarized state of a triangle, so the model is frustration-free. Its zero-energy states are generated by an AKLT-like construction in which each spin-$1$ moment is resolved into two virtual spin-$\tfrac12$ degrees of freedom, singlets are formed inside every crossed plaquette or tetrahedron, and the physical spin-$1$ Hilbert space is recovered by projection. The resulting ground states are fully packed singlet-loop states on the corner-sharing lattice. Thus, a loop or dimer constraint, usually introduced as part of an effective Rokhsar--Kivelson description, appears here as the exact zero-energy manifold of a microscopic spin Hamiltonian. We analyze spin correlations within this manifold and show that, for a fixed loop covering, they are determined by loop connectivity. We also project symmetry-allowed perturbations into the ground-state manifold and derive the resulting low-energy pseudospin dynamics. The checkerboard and pyrochlore cases differ sharply. On the pyrochlore lattice, tetrahedral symmetry removes simple local bias terms, and the leading nontrivial next-nearest-neighbour Heisenberg perturbation gives an emergent spin-$\tfrac12$ XY model on the diamond lattice of tetrahedron centers. These results give an exact spin-$1$ microscopic starting point for constrained valence-bond physics in two and three dimensions, and show how loop, dimer, and gauge-theoretic descriptions can be approached from a small-spin, SU(2)-invariant frustrated magnet.

arXiv:2607.12925•Jul 14, 2026•1 citation

Restricted triangular ice beyond the solvable manifolds: chiral ice and the critical region of dominant chiral vertices

Josep Amengual i Batle

We study two restrictions of Baxter's symmetric twenty-vertex model on the triangular lattice, in which the three classes of vertices allowed by the ice rule carry the weights $a$, $b$ and $c$: chiral ice, in which only the twelve chiral vertices are allowed, and the model that excludes only the two alternating vertices. We show that neither model belongs to any of the known exactly solvable families of the twenty-vertex model, and we characterise chiral ice as the ice model in which every vertex has exactly one through line, a property that imposes a parity constraint along every closed lattice line. We compute the residual entropies of both models with transfer matrices on cylinders of up to twelve vertices in circumference, extrapolated with the finite-size correction predicted by conformal invariance, which we adapt to the triangular geometry and verify at two exactly solved points. The number of upward arrows crossing the cylinder is conserved, and the cost of changing it shows that both models are critical, with the long-distance behaviour of a free massless field. Chiral ice is the extreme point of a region of the phase diagram in which ordering had been suggested; along two paths through that region we find the same critical behaviour at every point, with no feature at the proposed boundary of the region. Along Baxter's exactly solved curve we obtain the corresponding exponents in closed form.

arXiv:2611.03760•Oct 17, 2026•0 citations

The fate of topological frustration in quantum spin ladders and generalizations

Po-Wei Lo, Michael J. Lawler

Topological frustration (or topological mechanics) is the existence of classical zero modes that are robust to many but not all distortions of the Hamiltonian. It arises naturally from locality in systems whose interactions form a set of constraints such as in geometrically frustrated magnets and balls and springs metamaterials. For a magnet whose classical limit exhibits topological frustration, an important question is what happens to this topology when the degrees of freedom are quantized and whether such frustration could lead to exotic quantum phases of matter like a spin liquid. We answer these questions for a geometrically frustrated spin ladder model. It has the feature of having infinitely many conserved quantities that aid the solution. We find classical zero modes all get lifted by quantum fluctuations and the system is left with a unique rung singlet ground state -- a trivial quantum spin liquid. Moreover, we find low-energy eigenstates corresponding to known symmetry protected topological (SPT) ground states, and a special role of $SU(2)$ symmetry, that it demands the existence of extra dimensions of classical zero modes -- the phenomena we call symmetry-enriched topological frustration (SETF). These results suggest small violations of the conservation laws in the nearly SETF regime could lead to quantum scars. We further study a two-dimensional bilayer triangular lattice model and find a similar SETF phenomena which also leads to suppressed low-energy topological eigenstates in the quantum regime. These results suggest that in the absence of magnetic order, classical topological frustration manifests at finite spin as asymptotically low energy modes with support for exotic quantum phenomena.

arXiv:2207.09549•Jul 19, 2022•0 citations

Frustrated spin systems, an MPS approach

S. N. Saadatmand

In spin lattices, frustration happens when there exists a competition between different terms of the Hamiltonian, which cannot be simultaneously minimized in all local physical bases. Frustration can destabilize the bipartite Neel order, which is the conventional groundstate of antiferromagnetic Heisenberg-type models in two dimensions. Hence, the focus of two-dimensional quantum magnetism studies has been directed toward elucidating the zero-temperature properties of Heisenberg-type models on the Archimedean lattices that exhibit geometrical frustration. This type of frustration is of great interest since it can lead to exotic forms of the quantum matter, such as topological spin-liquid (SL) and many-sublattice long-range-ordered phases. The spin-1/2 triangular Heisenberg model (THM) is a prototypical model with geometrical frustration, which has the highest coordination number of all Archimedean lattices. However, there exist two major, distinct difficulties for numerical methods to efficiently determine the groundstate properties of the THM: the immense dimension of the Hilbert space and the geometrical frustration phenomenon. In this thesis, to deal with such difficulties, we employ the state-of-the- art non-Abelian matrix product states (MPS) and density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) methods. We exploit the symmetries of the Hamiltonian to reduce the working dimension of the Hilbert space and, to lessen the effects of the geometrical frustration, we depend on the local entanglement (area-law) nature of the MPS as it scales with the size of a lattice subspace with reduced spatial dimensions. In such a way, we thoroughly examine the phase diagram of the THM with nearest and next-nearest neighbor (NN and NNN) exchange couplings on finite- and infinite-length cylinders of widths up to 12 sites. In addition, we develop new numerical tools to analyze topological and symmetry-broken phases in the context of the SU(2)-symmetric translation-invariant MPS algorithm. We establish that on infinite cylinders, the anyonic sectors of a topological order can be classified through the fractionalization of global symmetries and degeneracy patterns of the entanglement spectrum (ES). On the other hand, we detect symmetry-breaking phase transitions by a combination of the correlation lengths and second and fourth cumulants of the magnetic order parameters, even though symmetry implies that the order parameter itself is strictly zero. Furthermore, the appearance of Nambu-Goldstone modes in the excitation spectrum can be detected using “tower of states” (TOS) levels in the momentum-resolved ES. By applying the new tools to the THM, we discover a variety of exotic groundstates such as a Z2-gauge toric-code-type topological order (with vison and spinon excitations), a NNN Majumdar-Gosh, and a long-range 120◦-ordered state.

•Jun 28, 2017•3 citations

A classical chiral spin liquid from chiral interactions on the pyrochlore lattice

Daniel Lozano‐Gómez, Yasir Iqbal, Matthias Vojta C

Classical spin liquids are paramagnetic phases that feature nontrivial patterns of spin correlations within their ground-state manifold whose degeneracy scales with system size. Often they harbor fractionalized excitations, and their low-energy fluctuations are described by emergent gauge theories. In this work, we discuss a model composed of chiral three-body spin interactions on the pyrochlore lattice that realizes a novel classical chiral spin liquid whose excitations are fractonalized while also displaying a fracton-like behavior. We demonstrate that the ground-state manifold of this spin liquid is given by a subset of the so-called color-ice states. We show that the low-energy states are captured by an effective gauge theory which possesses a divergence-free condition and an additional chiral term that constrains the total flux of the fields through a single tetrahedron. The divergence-free constraint on the gauge fields results in two-fold pinch points in the spin structure factor and the identification of bionic charges as excitations of the system.

arXiv:2403.10601•Nature Communications•Nov 23, 2024•16 citations

Chiral Quantum Spin Liquids on Frustrated Lattices: Analytical Theory and Exact Constraints

Khamis Obaidelah

We present a comprehensive analytical theory of quantum spin liquids (QSLs) on the kagome lattice with Heisenberg exchange J1, next-nearest-neighbor exchange J2, Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction D, and scalar spin chirality interaction λ. The work contains three principal contributions. First, we derive new mean-field analytic relations connecting the chiral interaction λ to the spinon gap, low-temperature thermodynamics, and thermal Hall response, with explicit spin-S dependence and generalization across kagome, triangular, and honeycomb lattices. The central result is Δspinon ∝ S³λ/J12 with lattice-dependent prefactors derived from self-consistent mean-field equations. Second, we derive a controlled effective model by projecting the kagome Hamiltonian onto the triangle-doublet subspace, obtaining an effective spin-chirality model on the triangular lattice with complex-valued interactions arising from the C3 symmetry of the chirality eigenstates. We compute all matrix elements of the effective spin operator in the chirality basis and characterize the inter-chirality coupling mediated by shared lattice sites. Third, we provide a rigorous map of obstructions to exact analytical solutions, systematically examining eight classes of proof techniques and identifying the precise mathematical reason each fails for the kagome Hamiltonian. The Lieb-Schultz-Mattis theorem provides the single rigorous exact result: any gapped ground state on the kagome lattice with spin-1/2 per site must exhibit topological order. All other results are classified by derivation category with explicit uncertainty quantification. AI-Generated Content Statement: This manuscript was generated primarily with the assistance of artificial intelligence language models, including ChatGPT. The work represents an exploratory demonstration of AI-assisted knowledge generation and prompt engineering methods rather than traditional experimental research.

•Mar 20, 2026•0 citations
Local constraints govern the low-energy physics of frustrated matter, but familiar ice-type rules constrain flux-like quantities and are insensitive to handedness. Here we show that handedness itself can be imposed as an exact local quantum constraint without selecting an axis in spin space. We construct positive-semidefinite, SU(2)-invariant parent Hamiltonians whose complete zero-energy space on a tetrahedron has a prescribed chirality sign, rather than selecting a particular chiral wave function. For spin-1/2 the local term is a rank-one projector onto a chiral tetrahedral singlet, while for arbitrary spin it factorizes as B†BB^\dagger BB†B through a singlet-annihilation operator, with a completely characterized kernel given by the span of the globally rotated chiral color-ice states. For coherent states, the same zero-energy condition becomes an SSS-independent nonlinear constraint in which three spin directions determine the fourth through a Möbius transformation; compositions of these maps define constraint holonomies on extended lattices. Connecting the same local constraint in different ways produces qualitatively different collective regimes: corner-sharing lattices retain exponentially large quantum ground-state kernels, with rigorous lower bounds exceeding conventional ice benchmarks; edge-sharing lattices support subdimensional plane or line zero modes; while triangular constructions suppress nonuniform coherent deformations and contain the complete Anderson tower of tetrahedral magnetic order at exactly zero energy. Two inequivalent triangular coverings further show that harmonic zero-mode counting does not determine the size of the quantum kernel. These results establish a tractable setting in which local handedness, nonlinear constraint geometry, and quantum degeneracy can be disentangled and related directly to the connectivity of the constraint network.
We construct an exact spin-111 parent Hamiltonian for constrained valence-bond loop manifolds on the checkerboard and pyrochlore lattices. The Hamiltonian is local, SU(2)- and time-reversal-invariant, and built from positive-semidefinite projectors acting on triangular faces. Each projector removes only the maximally polarized state of a triangle, so the model is frustration-free. Its zero-energy states are generated by an AKLT-like construction in which each spin-111 moment is resolved into two virtual spin-12\tfrac1221​ degrees of freedom, singlets are formed inside every crossed plaquette or tetrahedron, and the physical spin-111 Hilbert space is recovered by projection. The resulting ground states are fully packed singlet-loop states on the corner-sharing lattice. Thus, a loop or dimer constraint, usually introduced as part of an effective Rokhsar--Kivelson description, appears here as the exact zero-energy manifold of a microscopic spin Hamiltonian. We analyze spin correlations within this manifold and show that, for a fixed loop covering, they are determined by loop connectivity. We also project symmetry-allowed perturbations into the ground-state manifold and derive the resulting low-energy pseudospin dynamics. The checkerboard and pyrochlore cases differ sharply. On the pyrochlore lattice, tetrahedral symmetry removes simple local bias terms, and the leading nontrivial next-nearest-neighbour Heisenberg perturbation gives an emergent spin-12\tfrac1221​ XY model on the diamond lattice of tetrahedron centers. These results give an exact spin-111 microscopic starting point for constrained valence-bond physics in two and three dimensions, and show how loop, dimer, and gauge-theoretic descriptions can be approached from a small-spin, SU(2)-invariant frustrated magnet.
We study two restrictions of Baxter's symmetric twenty-vertex model on the triangular lattice, in which the three classes of vertices allowed by the ice rule carry the weights aaa, bbb and ccc: chiral ice, in which only the twelve chiral vertices are allowed, and the model that excludes only the two alternating vertices. We show that neither model belongs to any of the known exactly solvable families of the twenty-vertex model, and we characterise chiral ice as the ice model in which every vertex has exactly one through line, a property that imposes a parity constraint along every closed lattice line. We compute the residual entropies of both models with transfer matrices on cylinders of up to twelve vertices in circumference, extrapolated with the finite-size correction predicted by conformal invariance, which we adapt to the triangular geometry and verify at two exactly solved points. The number of upward arrows crossing the cylinder is conserved, and the cost of changing it shows that both models are critical, with the long-distance behaviour of a free massless field. Chiral ice is the extreme point of a region of the phase diagram in which ordering had been suggested; along two paths through that region we find the same critical behaviour at every point, with no feature at the proposed boundary of the region. Along Baxter's exactly solved curve we obtain the corresponding exponents in closed form.
Topological frustration (or topological mechanics) is the existence of classical zero modes that are robust to many but not all distortions of the Hamiltonian. It arises naturally from locality in systems whose interactions form a set of constraints such as in geometrically frustrated magnets and balls and springs metamaterials. For a magnet whose classical limit exhibits topological frustration, an important question is what happens to this topology when the degrees of freedom are quantized and whether such frustration could lead to exotic quantum phases of matter like a spin liquid. We answer these questions for a geometrically frustrated spin ladder model. It has the feature of having infinitely many conserved quantities that aid the solution. We find classical zero modes all get lifted by quantum fluctuations and the system is left with a unique rung singlet ground state -- a trivial quantum spin liquid. Moreover, we find low-energy eigenstates corresponding to known symmetry protected topological (SPT) ground states, and a special role of SU(2)SU(2)SU(2) symmetry, that it demands the existence of extra dimensions of classical zero modes -- the phenomena we call symmetry-enriched topological frustration (SETF). These results suggest small violations of the conservation laws in the nearly SETF regime could lead to quantum scars. We further study a two-dimensional bilayer triangular lattice model and find a similar SETF phenomena which also leads to suppressed low-energy topological eigenstates in the quantum regime. These results suggest that in the absence of magnetic order, classical topological frustration manifests at finite spin as asymptotically low energy modes with support for exotic quantum phenomena.
In spin lattices, frustration happens when there exists a competition between different terms of the Hamiltonian, which cannot be simultaneously minimized in all local physical bases. Frustration can destabilize the bipartite Neel order, which is the conventional groundstate of antiferromagnetic Heisenberg-type models in two dimensions. Hence, the focus of two-dimensional quantum magnetism studies has been directed toward elucidating the zero-temperature properties of Heisenberg-type models on the Archimedean lattices that exhibit geometrical frustration. This type of frustration is of great interest since it can lead to exotic forms of the quantum matter, such as topological spin-liquid (SL) and many-sublattice long-range-ordered phases. The spin-1/2 triangular Heisenberg model (THM) is a prototypical model with geometrical frustration, which has the highest coordination number of all Archimedean lattices. However, there exist two major, distinct difficulties for numerical methods to efficiently determine the groundstate properties of the THM: the immense dimension of the Hilbert space and the geometrical frustration phenomenon. In this thesis, to deal with such difficulties, we employ the state-of-the- art non-Abelian matrix product states (MPS) and density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) methods. We exploit the symmetries of the Hamiltonian to reduce the working dimension of the Hilbert space and, to lessen the effects of the geometrical frustration, we depend on the local entanglement (area-law) nature of the MPS as it scales with the size of a lattice subspace with reduced spatial dimensions. In such a way, we thoroughly examine the phase diagram of the THM with nearest and next-nearest neighbor (NN and NNN) exchange couplings on finite- and infinite-length cylinders of widths up to 12 sites. In addition, we develop new numerical tools to analyze topological and symmetry-broken phases in the context of the SU(2)-symmetric translation-invariant MPS algorithm. We establish that on infinite cylinders, the anyonic sectors of a topological order can be classified through the fractionalization of global symmetries and degeneracy patterns of the entanglement spectrum (ES). On the other hand, we detect symmetry-breaking phase transitions by a combination of the correlation lengths and second and fourth cumulants of the magnetic order parameters, even though symmetry implies that the order parameter itself is strictly zero. Furthermore, the appearance of Nambu-Goldstone modes in the excitation spectrum can be detected using “tower of states” (TOS) levels in the momentum-resolved ES. By applying the new tools to the THM, we discover a variety of exotic groundstates such as a Z2-gauge toric-code-type topological order (with vison and spinon excitations), a NNN Majumdar-Gosh, and a long-range 120◦-ordered state.
Classical spin liquids are paramagnetic phases that feature nontrivial patterns of spin correlations within their ground-state manifold whose degeneracy scales with system size. Often they harbor fractionalized excitations, and their low-energy fluctuations are described by emergent gauge theories. In this work, we discuss a model composed of chiral three-body spin interactions on the pyrochlore lattice that realizes a novel classical chiral spin liquid whose excitations are fractonalized while also displaying a fracton-like behavior. We demonstrate that the ground-state manifold of this spin liquid is given by a subset of the so-called color-ice states. We show that the low-energy states are captured by an effective gauge theory which possesses a divergence-free condition and an additional chiral term that constrains the total flux of the fields through a single tetrahedron. The divergence-free constraint on the gauge fields results in two-fold pinch points in the spin structure factor and the identification of bionic charges as excitations of the system.
We present a comprehensive analytical theory of quantum spin liquids (QSLs) on the kagome lattice with Heisenberg exchange J1, next-nearest-neighbor exchange J2, Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction D, and scalar spin chirality interaction λ. The work contains three principal contributions. First, we derive new mean-field analytic relations connecting the chiral interaction λ to the spinon gap, low-temperature thermodynamics, and thermal Hall response, with explicit spin-S dependence and generalization across kagome, triangular, and honeycomb lattices. The central result is Δspinon ∝ S³λ/J12 with lattice-dependent prefactors derived from self-consistent mean-field equations. Second, we derive a controlled effective model by projecting the kagome Hamiltonian onto the triangle-doublet subspace, obtaining an effective spin-chirality model on the triangular lattice with complex-valued interactions arising from the C3 symmetry of the chirality eigenstates. We compute all matrix elements of the effective spin operator in the chirality basis and characterize the inter-chirality coupling mediated by shared lattice sites. Third, we provide a rigorous map of obstructions to exact analytical solutions, systematically examining eight classes of proof techniques and identifying the precise mathematical reason each fails for the kagome Hamiltonian. The Lieb-Schultz-Mattis theorem provides the single rigorous exact result: any gapped ground state on the kagome lattice with spin-1/2 per site must exhibit topological order. All other results are classified by derivation category with explicit uncertainty quantification. AI-Generated Content Statement: This manuscript was generated primarily with the assistance of artificial intelligence language models, including ChatGPT. The work represents an exploratory demonstration of AI-assisted knowledge generation and prompt engineering methods rather than traditional experimental research.