Despite its fundamental importance in the theory of strongly correlated electrons, the nature of the ground state of the two-dimensional doped Hubbard model remains intensely debated. Variational approaches provide a powerful route to this problem, but their conclusions can depend sensitively on the chosen wave-function parameterization, the mean-field initialization, or the pinning fields used to guide the optimization, as well as on boundary conditions. This can favor one type of symmetry breaking over another, making it difficult to distinguish the genuine interplay of intertwined or competing orders from biases induced by the variational parameterization. Here, we introduce the Symmetry-Preserving Backflow Pairing (SBP) ansatz, a neural-network wave function that respects translational symmetry by construction and thereby avoids these broken-symmetry minima. The SBP ansatz reaches state-of-the-art variational energies for the $t$-$t'$ Hubbard model on lattices up to $24\times24$ with $504$ electrons, below those of competing pure stripe solutions. By extrapolating to the thermodynamic limit, we find robust evidence for $d$-wave superconducting order, resolving a long-standing question about the $1/8$-doped model at $t'/t=-0.2$ and $U/t=8.0$. Built on general principles of symmetry and locality, the SBP wave function provides a broadly applicable variational representation for challenging interacting fermionic systems.
Superconductivity in the t-t′ Hubbard Model from Symmetry-Preserving Neural-Network Quantum States
Despite its fundamental importance in the theory of strongly correlated electrons, the nature of the ground state of the two-dimensional doped Hubbard model remains intensely debated. Variational approaches provide a powerful route to this problem, but their conclusions can depend sensitively on the chosen wave-function parameterization, the mean-field initialization, or the pinning fields used to guide the optimization, as well as on boundary conditions. This can favor one type of symmetry breaking over another, making it difficult to distinguish the genuine interplay of intertwined or competing orders from biases induced by the variational parameterization. Here, we introduce the Symmetry-Preserving Backflow Pairing (SBP) ansatz, a neural-network wave function that respects translational symmetry by construction and thereby avoids these broken-symmetry minima. The SBP ansatz reaches state-of-the-art variational energies for the t-t′ Hubbard model on lattices up to 24×24 with 504 electrons, below those of competing pure stripe solutions. By extrapolating to the thermodynamic limit, we find robust evidence for d-wave superconducting order, resolving a long-standing question about the 1/8-doped model at t′/t=−0.2 and U/t=8.0. Built on general principles of symmetry and locality, the SBP wave function provides a broadly applicable variational representation for challenging interacting fermionic systems.
The two-dimensional Hubbard model at finite doping hosts competing or intertwined orders, resulting in conflicting conclusions from different computational approaches regarding its ground state. We show that a key source of such discrepancies is the bias encoded in the variational ansatz. We consider three different Transformer backflow fermionic wave functions based on a Slater determinant, its particle-hole counterpart, and a Pfaffian, initialized without any mean-field pretraining. We show that, despite achieving nearly degenerate, state-of-the-art variational energies, each ansatz converges to a state with qualitatively different spin, charge, and pairing correlations. Upon improving accuracy via symmetry restoration and variance reduction, however, all three converge to the same physical picture: coexisting superconducting and stripe orders. These results demonstrate that variational energy alone is insufficient to identify the ground state in the presence of competing phases, and highlight the importance of tracking how correlation functions evolve as the wave function is systematically improved before drawing physical conclusions.
The two-dimensional Hubbard model was originally proposed as the minimal model of uniform d-wave superconductivity in the cuprate high-temperature superconductors, but recent calculations with relevant parameters in a realistic doping regime have often found other ground states. Further, uncertainty remains over such results due to the intrinsic bias of different computational methods. Here we address this uncertainty through state-of-the-art neural tensor network and neural backflow state simulations, enabled by large-scale GPU computation, that together reach an unprecedented variational accuracy on lattices with up to 1024 sites. At 1/8 doping in the pure Hubbard model, as well as with next-nearest-neighbor hopping relevant to the hole-doped cuprates, we reveal a near degeneracy among a low-energy uniform d-wave state, superconducting stripes, and non-superconducting stripe states on the milli-t energy scale. Our work rebalances the narrative that the Hubbard model supports a single dominant order in relevant parameter regimes towards a picture of extreme competition between stripes and superconductivity.
We apply the Tensor-Backflow method to investigate the Fermi-Hubbard model on two-dimensional lattices up to 256 sites, exploring various interaction strengths U, electron fillings n, next-nearest-neighbor hopping t′, and boundary conditions. By considering backflow terms from nearest- or next-nearest-neighbor sites, we achieve competitive results without enforcing geometric symmetries on the variational wave-function. The optimizations were stable from a prior unrestrictied Hartree-Fock state, followed by adding backflow corrections. Meanwhile, changing interaction strengths in the prior unrestrictied Hartree-Fock state is helpful to bypass the local minima. When t′=0, by considering nearest-neighbor backflow terms, linear stripe order emerges successfully for the case of n=0.875 and U=8 on a 16×16 lattice with periodic boundary conditions. In a similar case with open boundary conditions, the energy obtained is only 4.5×10−4 higher than the state-of-the-art method fPEPS with bond dimension D=20. Compared to state-of-the-art neural network methods, the energies obtained using the Tensor-Backflow approach are competitive, with relative errors below 5×10−3. For n=0.8 and n=0.9375, direct optimizations yield results consistent with the phase diagram from AFQMC. When t′=-0.2, considering next-nearest-neighbor backflow terms leads to energies that are either competitive with or even lower than those from state-of-the-art neural network approaches. For instance, for n=0.875 and U=8 on a 12×12 lattice with periodic boundary conditions, the energy obtained is 8.1×10−4 lower than that from the neural network result. Thus, the Tensor-Backflow method demonstrates strong representational capabilities for solving the Fermi-Hubbard model.
A systematically improvable wave function is proposed for the numerical solution of strongly correlated systems. With a stochastic optimization method, based on the auxiliary field quantum Monte Carlo technique, an effective temperature Teff is defined, probing the distance of the ground-state properties of the model in the thermodynamic limit from the ones of the proposed correlated mean-field ansatz. In this way, their uncertainties from the unbiased zero temperature limit may be estimated by simple and stable extrapolations well before the so-called sign problem gets prohibitive. At finite Teff, the convergence of the energy to the thermodynamic limit is indeed shown to already be possible in the Hubbard model for relatively small square lattices with linear dimension $L\ensuremath{\simeq}10$, thanks to appropriate averages over several twisted boundary conditions. Within the estimated energy accuracy of the proposed variational ansatz, two clear phases are identified, as the energy is lowered by spontaneously breaking some symmetries satisfied by the Hubbard Hamiltonian: (a) a stripe phase where both spin and translation symmetries are broken and (b) a strong coupling d-wave superconducting phase when the particle number is not conserved and global U(1) symmetry is broken. On the other hand, the symmetric phase is stable in a wide region at large doping and small coupling.
Multi-reference variational states resolve stripe selection and local d-wave pairing in the Hubbard model
Whether stripes compete with d-wave superconductivity or promote pairing through fluctuations remains unsettled in the two-dimensional Hubbard model. Using multi-reference neural variational auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo (MR-nVAFQMC) at U/t=8, we superpose unpaired Slater determinants across stripe periods and domain-wall positions, reaching variational energies competitive with leading benchmarks on periodic lattices up to 32×32 sites. For cuprate next-nearest-neighbor hopping (t′/t=−0.2), diagonal hopping preserves electron-doped antiferromagnetism while kinetically frustrating hole motion into Yamada stripes with a dome of short-range connected d-wave pairing. At 1/8 hole doping, hole delocalization across antiphase spin boundaries outweighs on-site repulsion, splitting the filled stripes of the pure model into half-filled walls with strong local pairing. Coherently delocalizing shifted walls strongly suppresses static charge modulation yet leaves short-range pairing unchanged, showing that local pairing is intrinsic to half-filled walls rather than driven by stripe fluctuations. Across intervening antiferromagnetic domains, however, pairing correlations become unresolved at one stripe period and beyond. Both parameter transfer to larger lattices without reoptimization and deep benchmark checkpoints retain stripe spin order without resolving long-range pairing, within uncertainties allowing weak superconductivity. Half-filled antiphase walls thus generate local d-wave pairs, whereas suppressing static stripe order alone yields no resolved coherence across stripes in the states studied.
Probing d-wave pairing in the t-t′-U Hubbard model with tensor-backflow wave functions
Building on the recently developed tensor-backflow method, which accurately describes energies and stripe states in the Fermi-Hubbard model, we investigate d-wave pairing in the two-dimensional t-t′-U Hubbard model. For the 8×8 lattice, we improve the wave function using symmetry projections followed by one Lanczos step, whereas for the 12×12 and 16×16 lattices, we apply one Lanczos step without symmetry projection. We focus primarily on the parameter regime with filling n=0.875, on-site repulsion U=8 and next-nearest-neighbor hopping t′=−0.2t, a regime in which enhanced d-wave pairing has been reported. The resulting energies are competitive with those obtained using state-of-the-art neural quantum states. For example, on a 16×16 lattice with periodic boundary conditions, the tensor-backflow wave function after one Lanczos step without explicit symmetry enforcement achieves a relative energy difference of 4.4×10−3 from the symmetry-preserving neural quantum state result. From the real space pair correlations, for t′=−0.2t, we observe stronger d-wave pair correlations together with the characteristic relative sign between horizontal and vertical bond-pair components. Compared with t′=0, finite negative t′ increases the spectral weight of the corresponding pair-density matrix, which indicates the enhanced overall d-wave pair fluctuations. The leading eigenvalue is enhanced on the 8×8 lattice for both with and without symmetry projections. For larger lattices such as 12×12 and 16×16, the leading pair-density matrix spectral weight is distributed among several nearly degenerate eigenmodes rather than being concentrated in a single dominant mode. This indicates enhanced and more broadly distributed d-wave pair fluctuations, but no single eigenvalue exhibits the extensive scaling required for ODLRO.