Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2607.25900

Effect-valued measurement models and contextuality

Samson Abramsky

quant-phSubmitted Jul 28, 2026• Announced Jul 29, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We generalize the Abramsky--Brandenburger sheaf-theoretic treatment of contextuality by replacing probability distributions with distributions valued in a convex effect algebra \(A\). This yields a notion of \(A\)-valued measurement model encompassing probabilistic, deterministic, and quantum measurement structures within a single framework. States \(σ:A\to[0,1]\) induce ordinary empirical models, allowing observable behaviour to be viewed as arising from effect-valued measurement data. This leads to a distinction between internal contextuality of \(A\)-models and observable contextuality after state evaluation. We analyze the relationship between these notions and identify coherence conditions under which observable classical explanations assemble into internal ones. Using the ordered-vector-space representation of effect modules, we show that non-contextuality is characterized by feasibility of an associated cone program, generalizing the linear-programming formulation of contextuality in the probabilistic case. We also introduce an effect-valued contextual fraction and study its relation to observable contextuality witnesses. We show how cone duality leads to a notion of Bell witnesses for contextuality as a direct generalization of Bell inequalities. Finally, we analyze sharp realizability and uniform dilation for measurement models, clarifying the relationship between general POVMs and projective measurements, and show how resource-indexed effect structures induce graded monads generalizing the quantum monad.

Comments
37 pages

Related papers

Everything is Contextual: Contextuality Beyond Quantum

Ryan J Buchanan

Contextuality has become a cornerstone of modern foundational approaches to quantum physics. This paper introduces contextual mathematics (CM), a categorical framework for context-indexed observations and agent-dependent evaluation. Contexts are organized into a category Ctx, and observation is modeled as a contravariant bifunctor into an epistemic category E; context refinements induce restriction maps, and a Grothendieck construction organizes evaluations over agent–context pairs. We show how the established sheaf-theoretic account of Kochen–Specker contextuality (Abramsky–Brandenburger) can be represented inside this framework, recovering non-existence of a global section as the relevant obstruction. We then formulate, as comparison problems rather than established equivalences, several further candidate obstruction theories that a fully developed CM might connect to this sheaf-theoretic core: homological extension classes (Ext1 ), Kan-extension reconstruction, deformation-quantization cocycles, and device-dependent restriction in algebraic quantum field theory (AQFT) over globally hyperbolic spacetimes. We are explicit about which of these connections are proved, which are illustrative analogies, and which remain open.

•Aug 17, 2026•0 citations

Putting Bell's inequalities into context by putting context into Bell's inequalities

Adam Stokes

Within the Dempster-Schafer theory of evidence a non-Kolmogorovian kind of epistemic uncertainty arises, which is encoded using multi-valued maps. We analyse the possible implications such non-Kolmogorovian epistemic uncertainty may have for Bell-type inequalities relating to the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-Bohm (EPRB) thought experiment. Our analysis leads to a notion of contextuality concerning complexes of physical measurement conditions. The use of multi-valued maps reveals an implicit link between this contextuality and counterfactual outcomes, and results in a formulation wherein the states of measurement devices are explicitly taken into account as part of the probabilistic event space. This reflects a conception of measurement that was advocated by Bell some time ago. It results in context-conditioned measure-theoretic probabilities, which do not obey Bell-type inequalities, but which are nonetheless perfectly compatible with local classical physical models. We give an example of a local classical model that reproduces the quantum mechanical predictions and that fits within the contextual framework.

arXiv:1503.08960•Mar 31, 2015•0 citations

Sımplısyal dağılımlar, çokyüzlüler ve kuantum bağlamsallığı

Serkan Doğan

Quantum contextuality is the phenomenon, established by the theorems of Bell and of Kochen and Specker, that the predictions of quantum mechanics cannot be reproduced by any assignment of measurement outcomes that is independent of the measurement context. The sheaf-theoretic approach of Abramsky and Brandenburger formulates contextuality as an obstruction to gluing local probability distributions into a global one. The theory of simplicial distributions carries this program further by modeling both measurements and outcomes as simplicial sets: a simplicial distribution is a simplicial map p: X →D(Y ) from a measurement space X to the probability monad applied to an outcome space Y . This thesis develops the theory of simplicial distributions as a polytope-theoretic framework for studying quantum contextuality. The simplicial distributions on a fixed scenario form a convex polytope in standard form. Its vertices encode the extremal probabilistic models, and its convex structure captures contextuality: a distribution is noncontextual precisely when it lies in the convex hull of the deterministic distributions, and quantum states give points of this polytope through the Born rule. The central tool is the support criterion: a point of a standard form polytope is a vertex if and only if its support is inclusion-minimal, which reduces the study of vertices to a combinatorial problem about supports and carrier faces. The main original contribution concerns collapsing maps, which identify a simplex of the measurement space with a degenerate one. For the pullback π∗along a collapsing map π: X →X, the equality π∗(carr(p)) = carr(π∗(p)) of carrier faces is proved. As corollaries, being a vertex, being deterministic, being strongly contextual, and being contextual are all preserved and reflected under pullback, and the homotopical collapsing results in the literature are recovered by a uniform polyhedral argument. These tools are then applied to one-dimensional scenarios, where the measurement space is a graph. It is proved that removing a leaf edge carries vertices to vertices; consequently every vertex of the distribution polytope of a tree is deterministic, so tree scenarios admit no contextuality. The vertices of the loop scenario with outcomes in Zd are classified: they are in bijection with cycles in Zd, and are in general contextual. Finally, two equivalent necessary criteria for extremality are given, one graph-theoretic and one algebraic: the support graphs of a vertex contain no cycle, equivalently the associated incidence matrices do not admit −2 as an eigenvalue.

•Jul 1, 2026•0 citations

Quantum contextuality from measurement invasiveness

Andrea Navoni, Marco G. Genoni, Andrea Smirne

Contextuality is a defining feature that separates the quantum from the classical descriptions of physical systems. Within the marginal-scenario framework, noncontextual models are characterized by the existence of a single joint probability distribution consistent with all measurable contexts, while contextual models violate this condition. Building on this approach, we introduce a general method to analyze contextuality in terms of stochastic linear maps that effectively model invasive measurements on an otherwise classical statistics. These maps transform probabilities within the noncontextuality polytope, which includes all classical probabilities, into probabilities that may lie outside the polytope, while preserving the compatibility structure of the scenario at hand. We derive general consistency conditions that such maps must satisfy to represent admissible invasive measurements, and we fully identify them for a paradigmatic example of contextuality for a single three-level quantum system. Furthermore, we introduce a quantifier of contextuality based on the minimal invasiveness required to reproduce a given probability distribution, which offers a distinct approach on how to evaluate the degree of contextuality in a general scenario.

arXiv:2507.16942•Physical Review A•Feb 27, 2026•0 citations

Possibilistic (and other) notions of contextuality

Andrew W. Simmons

Since Bell, Kochen and Specker formulated the first notions of contextuality, a number of frameworks have been created to help make philosophical and mathematical sense of the concept. Two of the most common are the Equivalence-based approach due to Spekkens, and the Sheaf-theoretic framework of Abramsky and Brandenburger. Each of these can support a hierarchy of strengths of contextuality, which can include possibilistic concepts. This thesis will explore the differences between the two approaches, and explore what can be demonstrated by using weaker notions of noncontextuality. Notions of noncontextuality are important for proving no-go theorems which highlight that many properties that are true of classical mechanics fail to be compatible with quantum predictions. Often, the notions of noncontextuality used are very strong assumptions, and even weaker flavours of noncontextuality can be used to draw the same, or similar conclusions. An important class of such notions are, possibilistic assumptions that only care about whether or not events are possible or impossible, rather than the exact Born rule probabilities that are applied to events. Even these weaker notions are often impossible to resolve with the logical structure and predictions of quantum theory. Contextuality has been demonstrated to be a resource for many quantum computational operations, and the contextual fraction has been shown to be an important resource. We introduce a metric that can differentiate between different quantum mechanical scenarios with contextual fraction 1, and demonstrate analogues of CHSH and Tsirelson bounds for this quantity. We also investigate the computational complexity of calculating the values of some metrics for nonlocality and contextuality, completing the classification of possibilistic nonlocality scenarios, as well as other metrics of nonlocality analogous to our metric of maximal contextuality.

•Sep 1, 2018•2 citations

Generalised Probabilistic Theories

Zujin Wen, Zihan Wang, Xiangjing Liu +1 more

We give an introduction to research associated with the generalised probabilistic theories framework, also known as the convex framework. States are real vectors representing lists of probabilities of measurement outcomes. Convex combinations of the vectors represent probabilistic combinations of different state preparations. Transformations are real matrices. Measurement outcomes are represented by functionals of the states, inner products of the state with a real vector, whose values are the probability of the measurement outcome in question. The framework generalises quantum theory. We describe the operational meaning of the framework, and how the concepts can be defined in terms of cones of states and measurement outcome vectors. We describe how the classical and quantum probability theories are represented in the framework. We describe Bell non-locality and the theory with super-quantum non-locality known as box world. We discuss generalised Hamiltonian mechanics in the discrete case and in continuous phase space, including the role of negativity of the phase space density in contextuality and tunnelling.

quant-pharXiv:2606.31097•Jul 1, 2026•1 citation
We generalize the Abramsky--Brandenburger sheaf-theoretic treatment of contextuality by replacing probability distributions with distributions valued in a convex effect algebra (A). This yields a notion of (A)-valued measurement model encompassing probabilistic, deterministic, and quantum measurement structures within a single framework.
States (σ:A\to[0,1]) induce ordinary empirical models, allowing observable behaviour to be viewed as arising from effect-valued measurement data. This leads to a distinction between internal contextuality of (A)-models and observable contextuality after state evaluation. We analyze the relationship between these notions and identify coherence conditions under which observable classical explanations assemble into internal ones.
Using the ordered-vector-space representation of effect modules, we show that non-contextuality is characterized by feasibility of an associated cone program, generalizing the linear-programming formulation of contextuality in the probabilistic case. We also introduce an effect-valued contextual fraction and study its relation to observable contextuality witnesses. We show how cone duality leads to a notion of Bell witnesses for contextuality as a direct generalization of Bell inequalities.
Finally, we analyze sharp realizability and uniform dilation for measurement models, clarifying the relationship between general POVMs and projective measurements, and show how resource-indexed effect structures induce graded monads generalizing the quantum monad.
Contextuality has become a cornerstone of modern foundational approaches to quantum physics. This paper introduces contextual mathematics (CM), a categorical framework for context-indexed observations and agent-dependent evaluation. Contexts are organized into a category Ctx, and observation is modeled as a contravariant bifunctor into an epistemic category E; context refinements induce restriction maps, and a Grothendieck construction organizes evaluations over agent–context pairs. We show how the established sheaf-theoretic account of Kochen–Specker contextuality (Abramsky–Brandenburger) can be represented inside this framework, recovering non-existence of a global section as the relevant obstruction. We then formulate, as comparison problems rather than established equivalences, several further candidate obstruction theories that a fully developed CM might connect to this sheaf-theoretic core: homological extension classes (Ext1 ), Kan-extension reconstruction, deformation-quantization cocycles, and device-dependent restriction in algebraic quantum field theory (AQFT) over globally hyperbolic spacetimes. We are explicit about which of these connections are proved, which are illustrative analogies, and which remain open.
Within the Dempster-Schafer theory of evidence a non-Kolmogorovian kind of epistemic uncertainty arises, which is encoded using multi-valued maps. We analyse the possible implications such non-Kolmogorovian epistemic uncertainty may have for Bell-type inequalities relating to the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-Bohm (EPRB) thought experiment. Our analysis leads to a notion of contextuality concerning complexes of physical measurement conditions. The use of multi-valued maps reveals an implicit link between this contextuality and counterfactual outcomes, and results in a formulation wherein the states of measurement devices are explicitly taken into account as part of the probabilistic event space. This reflects a conception of measurement that was advocated by Bell some time ago. It results in context-conditioned measure-theoretic probabilities, which do not obey Bell-type inequalities, but which are nonetheless perfectly compatible with local classical physical models. We give an example of a local classical model that reproduces the quantum mechanical predictions and that fits within the contextual framework.
Quantum contextuality is the phenomenon, established by the theorems of Bell and of Kochen and Specker, that the predictions of quantum mechanics cannot be reproduced by any assignment of measurement outcomes that is independent of the measurement context. The sheaf-theoretic approach of Abramsky and Brandenburger formulates contextuality as an obstruction to gluing local probability distributions into a global one. The theory of simplicial distributions carries this program further by modeling both measurements and outcomes as simplicial sets: a simplicial distribution is a simplicial map p: X →D(Y ) from a measurement space X to the probability monad applied to an outcome space Y . This thesis develops the theory of simplicial distributions as a polytope-theoretic framework for studying quantum contextuality. The simplicial distributions on a fixed scenario form a convex polytope in standard form. Its vertices encode the extremal probabilistic models, and its convex structure captures contextuality: a distribution is noncontextual precisely when it lies in the convex hull of the deterministic distributions, and quantum states give points of this polytope through the Born rule. The central tool is the support criterion: a point of a standard form polytope is a vertex if and only if its support is inclusion-minimal, which reduces the study of vertices to a combinatorial problem about supports and carrier faces. The main original contribution concerns collapsing maps, which identify a simplex of the measurement space with a degenerate one. For the pullback π∗along a collapsing map π: X →X, the equality π∗(carr(p)) = carr(π∗(p)) of carrier faces is proved. As corollaries, being a vertex, being deterministic, being strongly contextual, and being contextual are all preserved and reflected under pullback, and the homotopical collapsing results in the literature are recovered by a uniform polyhedral argument. These tools are then applied to one-dimensional scenarios, where the measurement space is a graph. It is proved that removing a leaf edge carries vertices to vertices; consequently every vertex of the distribution polytope of a tree is deterministic, so tree scenarios admit no contextuality. The vertices of the loop scenario with outcomes in Zd are classified: they are in bijection with cycles in Zd, and are in general contextual. Finally, two equivalent necessary criteria for extremality are given, one graph-theoretic and one algebraic: the support graphs of a vertex contain no cycle, equivalently the associated incidence matrices do not admit −2 as an eigenvalue.
Contextuality is a defining feature that separates the quantum from the classical descriptions of physical systems. Within the marginal-scenario framework, noncontextual models are characterized by the existence of a single joint probability distribution consistent with all measurable contexts, while contextual models violate this condition. Building on this approach, we introduce a general method to analyze contextuality in terms of stochastic linear maps that effectively model invasive measurements on an otherwise classical statistics. These maps transform probabilities within the noncontextuality polytope, which includes all classical probabilities, into probabilities that may lie outside the polytope, while preserving the compatibility structure of the scenario at hand. We derive general consistency conditions that such maps must satisfy to represent admissible invasive measurements, and we fully identify them for a paradigmatic example of contextuality for a single three-level quantum system. Furthermore, we introduce a quantifier of contextuality based on the minimal invasiveness required to reproduce a given probability distribution, which offers a distinct approach on how to evaluate the degree of contextuality in a general scenario.
Since Bell, Kochen and Specker formulated the first notions of contextuality, a number of frameworks have been created to help make philosophical and mathematical sense of the concept. Two of the most common are the Equivalence-based approach due to Spekkens, and the Sheaf-theoretic framework of Abramsky and Brandenburger. Each of these can support a hierarchy of strengths of contextuality, which can include possibilistic concepts. This thesis will explore the differences between the two approaches, and explore what can be demonstrated by using weaker notions of noncontextuality. Notions of noncontextuality are important for proving no-go theorems which highlight that many properties that are true of classical mechanics fail to be compatible with quantum predictions. Often, the notions of noncontextuality used are very strong assumptions, and even weaker flavours of noncontextuality can be used to draw the same, or similar conclusions. An important class of such notions are, possibilistic assumptions that only care about whether or not events are possible or impossible, rather than the exact Born rule probabilities that are applied to events. Even these weaker notions are often impossible to resolve with the logical structure and predictions of quantum theory. Contextuality has been demonstrated to be a resource for many quantum computational operations, and the contextual fraction has been shown to be an important resource. We introduce a metric that can differentiate between different quantum mechanical scenarios with contextual fraction 1, and demonstrate analogues of CHSH and Tsirelson bounds for this quantity. We also investigate the computational complexity of calculating the values of some metrics for nonlocality and contextuality, completing the classification of possibilistic nonlocality scenarios, as well as other metrics of nonlocality analogous to our metric of maximal contextuality.
We give an introduction to research associated with the generalised probabilistic theories framework, also known as the convex framework. States are real vectors representing lists of probabilities of measurement outcomes. Convex combinations of the vectors represent probabilistic combinations of different state preparations. Transformations are real matrices. Measurement outcomes are represented by functionals of the states, inner products of the state with a real vector, whose values are the probability of the measurement outcome in question. The framework generalises quantum theory. We describe the operational meaning of the framework, and how the concepts can be defined in terms of cones of states and measurement outcome vectors. We describe how the classical and quantum probability theories are represented in the framework. We describe Bell non-locality and the theory with super-quantum non-locality known as box world. We discuss generalised Hamiltonian mechanics in the discrete case and in continuous phase space, including the role of negativity of the phase space density in contextuality and tunnelling.