Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2607.13223 · The European Physical Journal D

Comparing the three W-like states with the W state

Dafa Li

quant-phSubmitted Jul 14, 2026• Announced Jul 16, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In [Phy. Rev. Lett., 98, 260501 (2007)] and previous papers, the W-like states were used in many quantum communication schemes, distillation, teleportation and superdense coding. So far, no one has compared the W-like states with the W state. We investigate the properties of three W-like states named as $|\vartheta ^{\prime }\rangle $, $|η^{\prime }\rangle $ and $|ξ^{\prime }\rangle $. We point out that $|\vartheta ^{\prime }\rangle $ (resp. $|η^{\prime }\rangle $ and $|ξ^{\prime }\rangle $) has the maximal von Neumann entanglement entropy (vNEE) $S(ρ_{A})=\ln 2$ (resp. $S(ρ_{B})=\ln 2$ and $S(ρ_{C})=\ln 2$) and the maximal tangle $τ_{A(BC)}=1$ (resp. $τ_{B(AC)}=1$ and $τ_{C(AB)}=1$) while the W state does not. We also indicate that if some one of three qubits is traced out, then the remaining two qubits of $|\vartheta ^{\prime }\rangle $ (resp. $|η^{\prime }\rangle $ and $|ξ^{\prime }\rangle $) are more entangled than the two qubits of the W state by several entanglement measures. It means that the three W-like states have higher robustness against some particle loss than the W state. We show that $|\vartheta ^{\prime }\rangle $, $|η^{\prime }\rangle $ and $|ξ^{\prime }\rangle $ can be suitable for perfect teleportation and superdense coding but the W state cannot.

Journal reference
Eur. Phys. J. D 80, 107 (2026)
Comments
11 pages

Related papers

Perfect teleportation and superdense coding with W states

Pankaj Agrawal, Arun Kumar Pati

True tripartite entanglement of the state of a system of three qubits can be classified on the basis of stochastic local operations and classical communications. Such states can be classified into two categories: GHZ states and $W$ states. It is known that GHZ states can be used for teleportation and superdense coding, but the prototype $W$ state cannot be. However, we show that there is a class of $W$ states that can be used for perfect teleportation and superdense coding.

arXiv:quant-ph/0610001•Physical Review A•Dec 26, 2006•488 citations

Optimal distillation of three-qubit W states

Ali Kerem Yildiz

Some of the asymmetric three-qubit $W$ states are used for perfect teleportation, superdense coding, and quantum-information splitting. We present the protocols for the optimal distillation of the asymmetric as well as the symmetric $W$ states from a single copy of any three-qubit $W$ class pure state.

arXiv:1007.3171•Physical Review A•Jul 19, 2010•32 citations

The states of W-class as shared resources for perfect teleportation and superdense coding

Lvzhou Li, Daowen Qiu

As we know, the states of triqubit systems have two important classes: GHZ-class and W-class. In this paper, the states of W-class are considered for teleportation and superdense coding, and they are generalized to multi-particle systems. First we describe two transformations on the shared resources for teleportation and superdense coding. With these transformations, we obtain a sufficient and necessary condition for a state of W-class being suitable for perfect teleportation and superdense coding. For the state which was thought to be not suitable for sending three classical bits by sending two qubits by Agrawal and Pati (2006 Phys. Rev. A 74 062320), we show that it may be used to fulfil that task, if entangled unitary operations on two qubits are allowed. We generalize the states of W-class to multi-qubit systems and multi-particle systems with higher dimension. We propose two protocols for teleportation and superdense coding by using W-states of multi-qubit systems that generalize the protocols by using | W ⟩ 123 proposed by Agrawal and Pati. We obtain an optimal way to partition some W-states of multi-qubit systems into two subsystems, such that the entanglement between them achieves maximum value.

arXiv:quant-ph/0701030•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Aug 14, 2007•93 citations

The necessary and sufficient condition for perfect teleportation and superdense coding and all the suitable states for teleportation and superdense coding

Dafa Li

It is known that two local unitaries (LU) equivalent states possess the same amount of entanglement and can be used to perform the same tasks in quantum information theory (QIT). For a protocol for a task in QIT, we call a protocol LU invariant if two LU-equivalent states are either both suitable for the protocol or neither is. So far, no one has discussed whether a protocol for a task in QIT is LU invariant. In [Phys. Rev. A, 74, 062320 (2006)], Agrawal and Pati proposed the perfect teleportation protocol (PTP) and the protocol for superdense coding to transmit 2-bit classical information by sending one qubit (PSDC-2) and 3-bit classical information by sending two qubits (PSDC-3). In this paper, we show that PTP and PSDC-2 are LU invariant. That is, two LU equivalent states are suitable for PTP and PSDC-2 or neither of them is. We show that PSDC-3 is not LU invariant. We also indicate that the teleportation proposed in <cite>Nielsen</cite> is not LU invariant. We give a necessary and sufficient condition for a state to be suitable for PTP, PSDC-2, and PSDC-3, respectively. Via the LU invariance of PTP and PSDC-2, we prove that a state is suitable for PTP and PSDC-2 if and only if it has 1 ebit of shared entanglement, respectively and find all genuine entangled states and separable states which are suitable for PTP and PSDC-2, respectively. So far, no one has indicated that PTP and PSDC-2 do not require genuine entanglement. Agrawal and Pati suggested to study if there are subclasses of W SLOCC class which are suitable for PSDC-3. So far, it still remains an unsolved question. We show that any state of the SLOCC class W is not suitable for PSDC-3.

quant-pharXiv:2602.11293•Annals of Physics•Feb 13, 2026•1 citation

All maximally entangled four-qubit states

Gilad Gour, Nolan R. Wallach

We find an operational interpretation for the 4-tangle as a type of residual entanglement, somewhat similar to the interpretation of the 3-tangle. Using this remarkable interpretation, we are able to find the class of maximally entangled four-qubits states which is characterized by four real parameters. The states in the class are maximally entangled in the sense that their average bipartite entanglement with respect to all possible bipartite cuts is maximal. We show that while all the states in the class maximize the average tangle, there are only a few states in the class that maximize the average Tsillas or Renyi α-entropy of entanglement. Quite remarkably, we find that up to local unitaries, there exists two unique states, one maximizing the average α-Tsallis entropy of entanglement for all α ⩾ 2, while the other maximizing it for all 0 < α ⩽ 2 (including the von-Neumann case of α = 1). Furthermore, among the maximally entangled four qubits states, there are only three maximally entangled states that have the property that for two, out of the three bipartite cuts consisting of two-qubits verses two-qubits, the entanglement is 2 ebits and for the remaining bipartite cut the entanglement between the two groups of two qubits is 1 ebit. The unique three maximally entangled states are the three cluster states that are related by a swap operator. We also show that the cluster states are the only states (up to local unitaries) that maximize the average α-Renyi entropy of entanglement for all α ⩾ 2.

arXiv:1006.0036•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Nov 1, 2010•149 citations

The necessary and sufficient condition for the uniqueness of Schmidt decomposition and the necessary condition for the maximal von Neumann entanglement entropy

Dafa Li, Maggie X. Cheng, Xiangrong Li +1 more

Schmidt decomposition (SD) has been proven to be an important tool in quantum information and computation. Ac{\' i}n et al. proposed the SD for three qubits, but in the meanwhile, they indicated that it is possible to have two different SDs for the same state. The more challenging quest of finding the sufficient and necessary condition for the uniqueness of SD has never been undertaken. In this paper, we propose a necessary and sufficient condition for the uniqueness of SD for three qubits. By examining the condition, one can tell what state has one SD and what state has two SDs without actually performing the Schmidt decomposition. We investigate the relation between the uniqueness of SD and the von Neumann entanglement entropy (vNEE). To this end, we prove that any state having the maximal vNEE $S(\rho _{x})=\ln 2$, $ x=A, B,$ or $C$ must have a unique SD. %Therefore, we should choose a state having a unique SD for its maximal vNEE for quantum information theory. This means if a state has two SDs, then the state does not have the maximal vNEE. Therefore, we should not choose a state having two SDs for its maximal vNEE for quantum information theory. In this paper, we also give all the SD states that have the maximal vNEE and a unique SD, as well as all the SD states that have a unique SD.

Quantum Information and Computation•Sep 1, 2024•1 citation
In [Phy. Rev. Lett., 98, 260501 (2007)] and previous papers, the W-like states were used in many quantum communication schemes, distillation, teleportation and superdense coding. So far, no one has compared the W-like states with the W state. We investigate the properties of three W-like states named as ∣ϑ′⟩|\vartheta ^{\prime }\rangle ∣ϑ′⟩, ∣η′⟩|η^{\prime }\rangle ∣η′⟩ and ∣ξ′⟩|ξ^{\prime }\rangle ∣ξ′⟩. We point out that ∣ϑ′⟩|\vartheta ^{\prime }\rangle ∣ϑ′⟩ (resp. ∣η′⟩|η^{\prime }\rangle ∣η′⟩ and ∣ξ′⟩|ξ^{\prime }\rangle ∣ξ′⟩) has the maximal von Neumann entanglement entropy (vNEE) S(ρA)=ln⁡2S(ρ_{A})=\ln 2S(ρA​)=ln2 (resp. S(ρB)=ln⁡2S(ρ_{B})=\ln 2S(ρB​)=ln2 and S(ρC)=ln⁡2S(ρ_{C})=\ln 2S(ρC​)=ln2) and the maximal tangle τA(BC)=1τ_{A(BC)}=1τA(BC)​=1 (resp. τB(AC)=1τ_{B(AC)}=1τB(AC)​=1 and τC(AB)=1τ_{C(AB)}=1τC(AB)​=1) while the W state does not. We also indicate that if some one of three qubits is traced out, then the remaining two qubits of ∣ϑ′⟩|\vartheta ^{\prime }\rangle ∣ϑ′⟩ (resp. ∣η′⟩|η^{\prime }\rangle ∣η′⟩ and ∣ξ′⟩|ξ^{\prime }\rangle ∣ξ′⟩) are more entangled than the two qubits of the W state by several entanglement measures. It means that the three W-like states have higher robustness against some particle loss than the W state. We show that ∣ϑ′⟩|\vartheta ^{\prime }\rangle ∣ϑ′⟩, ∣η′⟩|η^{\prime }\rangle ∣η′⟩ and ∣ξ′⟩|ξ^{\prime }\rangle ∣ξ′⟩ can be suitable for perfect teleportation and superdense coding but the W state cannot.
True tripartite entanglement of the state of a system of three qubits can be classified on the basis of stochastic local operations and classical communications. Such states can be classified into two categories: GHZ states and WWW states. It is known that GHZ states can be used for teleportation and superdense coding, but the prototype WWW state cannot be. However, we show that there is a class of WWW states that can be used for perfect teleportation and superdense coding.
Some of the asymmetric three-qubit WWW states are used for perfect teleportation, superdense coding, and quantum-information splitting. We present the protocols for the optimal distillation of the asymmetric as well as the symmetric WWW states from a single copy of any three-qubit WWW class pure state.
As we know, the states of triqubit systems have two important classes: GHZ-class and W-class. In this paper, the states of W-class are considered for teleportation and superdense coding, and they are generalized to multi-particle systems. First we describe two transformations on the shared resources for teleportation and superdense coding. With these transformations, we obtain a sufficient and necessary condition for a state of W-class being suitable for perfect teleportation and superdense coding. For the state which was thought to be not suitable for sending three classical bits by sending two qubits by Agrawal and Pati (2006 Phys. Rev. A 74 062320), we show that it may be used to fulfil that task, if entangled unitary operations on two qubits are allowed. We generalize the states of W-class to multi-qubit systems and multi-particle systems with higher dimension. We propose two protocols for teleportation and superdense coding by using W-states of multi-qubit systems that generalize the protocols by using | W ⟩ 123 proposed by Agrawal and Pati. We obtain an optimal way to partition some W-states of multi-qubit systems into two subsystems, such that the entanglement between them achieves maximum value.
It is known that two local unitaries (LU) equivalent states possess the same amount of entanglement and can be used to perform the same tasks in quantum information theory (QIT). For a protocol for a task in QIT, we call a protocol LU invariant if two LU-equivalent states are either both suitable for the protocol or neither is. So far, no one has discussed whether a protocol for a task in QIT is LU invariant. In [Phys. Rev. A, 74, 062320 (2006)], Agrawal and Pati proposed the perfect teleportation protocol (PTP) and the protocol for superdense coding to transmit 2-bit classical information by sending one qubit (PSDC-2) and 3-bit classical information by sending two qubits (PSDC-3). In this paper, we show that PTP and PSDC-2 are LU invariant. That is, two LU equivalent states are suitable for PTP and PSDC-2 or neither of them is. We show that PSDC-3 is not LU invariant. We also indicate that the teleportation proposed in <cite>Nielsen</cite> is not LU invariant. We give a necessary and sufficient condition for a state to be suitable for PTP, PSDC-2, and PSDC-3, respectively. Via the LU invariance of PTP and PSDC-2, we prove that a state is suitable for PTP and PSDC-2 if and only if it has 1 ebit of shared entanglement, respectively and find all genuine entangled states and separable states which are suitable for PTP and PSDC-2, respectively. So far, no one has indicated that PTP and PSDC-2 do not require genuine entanglement. Agrawal and Pati suggested to study if there are subclasses of W SLOCC class which are suitable for PSDC-3. So far, it still remains an unsolved question. We show that any state of the SLOCC class W is not suitable for PSDC-3.
We find an operational interpretation for the 4-tangle as a type of residual entanglement, somewhat similar to the interpretation of the 3-tangle. Using this remarkable interpretation, we are able to find the class of maximally entangled four-qubits states which is characterized by four real parameters. The states in the class are maximally entangled in the sense that their average bipartite entanglement with respect to all possible bipartite cuts is maximal. We show that while all the states in the class maximize the average tangle, there are only a few states in the class that maximize the average Tsillas or Renyi α-entropy of entanglement. Quite remarkably, we find that up to local unitaries, there exists two unique states, one maximizing the average α-Tsallis entropy of entanglement for all α ⩾ 2, while the other maximizing it for all 0 < α ⩽ 2 (including the von-Neumann case of α = 1). Furthermore, among the maximally entangled four qubits states, there are only three maximally entangled states that have the property that for two, out of the three bipartite cuts consisting of two-qubits verses two-qubits, the entanglement is 2 ebits and for the remaining bipartite cut the entanglement between the two groups of two qubits is 1 ebit. The unique three maximally entangled states are the three cluster states that are related by a swap operator. We also show that the cluster states are the only states (up to local unitaries) that maximize the average α-Renyi entropy of entanglement for all α ⩾ 2.
Schmidt decomposition (SD) has been proven to be an important tool in quantum information and computation. Ac{\' i}n et al. proposed the SD for three qubits, but in the meanwhile, they indicated that it is possible to have two different SDs for the same state. The more challenging quest of finding the sufficient and necessary condition for the uniqueness of SD has never been undertaken. In this paper, we propose a necessary and sufficient condition for the uniqueness of SD for three qubits. By examining the condition, one can tell what state has one SD and what state has two SDs without actually performing the Schmidt decomposition. We investigate the relation between the uniqueness of SD and the von Neumann entanglement entropy (vNEE). To this end, we prove that any state having the maximal vNEE S(ρx)=ln⁡2S(\rho _{x})=\ln 2S(ρx​)=ln2, $ x=A, B,$ or CCC must have a unique SD. %Therefore, we should choose a state having a unique SD for its maximal vNEE for quantum information theory. This means if a state has two SDs, then the state does not have the maximal vNEE. Therefore, we should not choose a state having two SDs for its maximal vNEE for quantum information theory. In this paper, we also give all the SD states that have the maximal vNEE and a unique SD, as well as all the SD states that have a unique SD.