Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2607.06876

XOR Games at Full Tilt: The Hardness of Binary Nonlocal Games

Richard Cleve, Eric Culf, Aviv Taller

quant-phcs.CCSubmitted Jul 8, 2026• Announced Jul 9, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is well known that the quantum value of an XOR nonlocal game, where the winning condition depends only on the XOR of the two players' output bits, may be approximated in polynomial time. We study a variant of the XOR game model, which we call tilted XOR games, where the winning condition can additionally depend on only one of the output bits. We show that this dramatically increases the expressive power: the computational complexity of the problem of approximating the quantum value of tilted XOR games to constant precision is RE-complete. Also, our result extends to succinct versions of tilted XOR games, where the questions can be polynomial-length binary strings, generated by a polynomial-time verifier. For classical strategies, the distinction between XOR games and tilted XOR games is inconsequential. Håstad (J. ACM, 2001) shows that they are both NP-complete to approximate, by using a reduction from linear systems to XOR games. Our approach is to show that this is also quantum-sound, but as a reduction from linear system games to tilted XOR games. Since titled XOR games are a special case of binary games (where each party outputs a single bit), our result implies that binary games are RE-hard to approximate.

Comments
44 pages, 4 figures

Related papers

Three-Player Entangled XOR Games are NP-Hard to Approximate

Thomas Vidick

We show that for any $\varepsilon>0$ the problem of finding a factor $(2-\varepsilon)$ approximation to the entangled value of a three-player XOR game is NP-hard. Equivalently, the problem of approximating the largest possible quantum violation of a tripartite Bell correlation inequality to within any multiplicative constant is NP-hard. These results are the first constant-factor hardness of approximation results for entangled games or quantum violations of Bell inequalities shown under the sole assumption that P$\neq$NP. They can be thought of as an extension of H\aastad's optimal hardness of approximation results for MAX-E3-LIN2 [J. ACM, 48 (2001), pp. 798--859] to the entangled-player setting. The key technical component of our work is a soundness analysis of a plane-vs-point low-degree test against entangled players. This extends and simplifies the analysis of the multilinearity test by Ito and Vidick [Proceedings of the $53$rd FOCS, IEEE, Piscataway, NJ, 2012, pp. 243--252]. Our results demonstrate the possibility of efficient reductions between entangled-player games and our techniques may lead to further hardness of approximation results.

arXiv:1302.1242•SIAM Journal on Computing•Jan 1, 2016•59 citations

Decidability of Fully Quantum Nonlocal Games with Noisy Maximally Entangled States

Minglong Qin, Penghui Yao

This paper considers the decidability of fully quantum nonlocal games with noisy maximally entangled states. Fully quantum nonlocal games are a generalization of nonlocal games, where both questions and answers are quantum and the referee performs a binary POVM measurement to decide whether they win the game after receiving the quantum answers from the players. The quantum value of a fully quantum nonlocal game is the supremum of the probability that they win the game, where the supremum is taken over all the possible entangled states shared between the players and all the valid quantum operations performed by the players. The seminal work $$\text {MIP}^*=\text {RE}$$ ( Ji et al. MIP ∗ = RE, 2020; Ji et al. Quantum soundness of the classical low individual degree test, 2020) implies that it is undecidable to approximate the quantum value of a fully nonlocal game. This still holds even if the players are only allowed to share (arbitrarily many copies of) maximally entangled states. This paper investigates the case that the shared maximally entangled states are noisy. We prove that there is a computable upper bound on the copies of noisy maximally entangled states for the players to win a fully quantum nonlocal game with a probability arbitrarily close to the quantum value. This implies that it is decidable to approximate the quantum values of these games. Hence, the hardness of approximating the quantum value of a fully quantum nonlocal game is not robust against the noise in the shared states. This paper is built on the framework for the decidability of non-interactive simulations of joint distributions (Ghazi et al. in: 2016 IEEE 57th Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science (FOCS), Los Alamitos, 2016; De et al. in: Proceedings of the Twenty-Ninth Annual ACM-SIAM Symposium on Discrete Algorithms, Philadelphia, 2018; Ghazi et al. Proceedings of the 33rd Computational Complexity Conference, 2018) and generalizes the analogous result for nonlocal games in Qin and Yao (SIAM J Comput 50(6):1800–1891, 2021). We extend the theory of Fourier analysis to the space of super-operators and prove several key results including an invariance principle and a dimension reduction for super-operators. These results are interesting in their own right and are believed to have further applications.

arXiv:2211.10613•Algorithmica•Aug 13, 2025•7 citations

A lower bound on the value of entangled binary games

Salman Beigi

A two-player one-round binary game consists of two cooperative players who each replies by one bit to a message that he receives privately; they win the game if both questions and answers satisfy some predetermined property. A game is called entangled if the players are allowed to share a priori entanglement. It is well-known that the maximum winning probability (value) of entangled XOR-games (binary games in which the predetermined property depends only on the XOR of the two output bits) can be computed by a semidefinite program. In this paper we extend this result in the following sense; if a binary game is uniform, meaning that in an optimal strategy the marginal distributions of the output of each player are uniform, then its entangled value can be efficiently computed by a semidefinite program. We also introduce a lower bound on the entangled value of a general two-player one-round game; this bound depends on the size of the output set of each player and can be computed by a semidefinite program. In particular, we show that if the game is binary, $\omega_q$ is its entangled value, and $\omega_{sdp}$ is the optimum value of the corresponding semidefinite program, then $0.68\,\omega_{sdp} < \omega_q \leq \omega_{sdp}$.

arXiv:0909.5518•Quantum Information and Computation•Nov 1, 2010•1 citation

Generalized xor games with d outcomes and the task of nonlocal computation

Ravishankar Ramanathan, Remigiusz Augusiak, Gláucia Murta

Two-party xor games (correlation Bell inequalities with two outcomes per party) are the most studied Bell inequalities, and one of the few classes for which the optimal quantum value is known to be exactly calculable. We study a natural generalization of the binary xor games to the class of linear games with $d>2$ outcomes, and propose an easily computable bound on the quantum value of these games. Many interesting properties such as the impossibility of a quantum strategy to win these games, and the quantum bound on the CHSH game generalized to $d$ outcomes are derived. We also use the proposed bound to prove a large-alphabet generalization of the principle of no quantum advantage in nonlocal computation, showing that quantum theory provides no advantage in the task of nonlocal distributed computation of a class of functions with $d$ outcomes for prime $d$, while general no-signaling boxes do. This task is one of the information-theoretic principles attempting to characterize the set of quantum correlations from amongst general no-signaling ones.

arXiv:1502.02974•Physical Review A•Feb 29, 2016•23 citations

Quantum strategies are better than classical in almost any XOR game

Andris Ambainis, Artūrs Bačkurs, Kaspars Balodis +4 more

We initiate a study of random instances of nonlocal games. We show that quantum strategies are better than classical for almost any 2-player XOR game. More precisely, for large n, the entangled value of a random 2-player XOR game with n questions to every player is at least 1.21... times the classical value, for 1-o(1) fraction of all 2-player XOR games.

arXiv:1112.3330•Dec 14, 2011•2 citations

Bounding Quantum-Classical Separations for Classes of Nonlocal Games

Tom Bannink, Jop Briët, Harry Buhrman +2 more

We bound separations between the entangled and classical values for several classes of nonlocal $t$-player games. Our motivating question is whether there is a family of $t$-player XOR games for which the entangled bias is $1$ but for which the classical bias goes down to $0$, for fixed $t$. Answering this question would have important consequences in the study of multi-party communication complexity, as a positive answer would imply an unbounded separation between randomized communication complexity with and without entanglement. Our contribution to answering the question is identifying several general classes of games for which the classical bias can not go to zero when the entangled bias stays above a constant threshold. This rules out the possibility of using these games to answer our motivating question. A previously studied set of XOR games, known not to give a positive answer to the question, are those for which there is a quantum strategy that attains value 1 using a so-called Schmidt state. We generalize this class to mod-$m$ games and show that their classical value is always at least $\frac{1}{m} + \frac{m-1}{m} t^{1-t}$. Secondly, for free XOR games, in which the input distribution is of product form, we show $β(G) \geq β^*(G)^{2^t}$ where $β(G)$ and $β^*(G)$ are the classical and entangled biases of the game respectively. We also introduce so-called line games, an example of which is a slight modification of the Magic Square game, and show that they can not give a positive answer to the question either. Finally we look at two-player unique games and show that if the entangled value is $1-ε$ then the classical value is at least $1-\mathcal{O}(\sqrt{ε\log k})$ where $k$ is the number of outputs in the game. Our proofs use semidefinite-programming techniques, the Gowers inverse theorem and hypergraph norms.

arXiv:1811.11068•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Nov 27, 2018•11 citations
It is well known that the quantum value of an XOR nonlocal game, where the winning condition depends only on the XOR of the two players' output bits, may be approximated in polynomial time. We study a variant of the XOR game model, which we call tilted XOR games, where the winning condition can additionally depend on only one of the output bits. We show that this dramatically increases the expressive power: the computational complexity of the problem of approximating the quantum value of tilted XOR games to constant precision is RE-complete. Also, our result extends to succinct versions of tilted XOR games, where the questions can be polynomial-length binary strings, generated by a polynomial-time verifier.
For classical strategies, the distinction between XOR games and tilted XOR games is inconsequential. Håstad (J. ACM, 2001) shows that they are both NP-complete to approximate, by using a reduction from linear systems to XOR games. Our approach is to show that this is also quantum-sound, but as a reduction from linear system games to tilted XOR games.
Since titled XOR games are a special case of binary games (where each party outputs a single bit), our result implies that binary games are RE-hard to approximate.
We show that for any ε>0\varepsilon>0ε>0 the problem of finding a factor (2−ε)(2-\varepsilon)(2−ε) approximation to the entangled value of a three-player XOR game is NP-hard. Equivalently, the problem of approximating the largest possible quantum violation of a tripartite Bell correlation inequality to within any multiplicative constant is NP-hard. These results are the first constant-factor hardness of approximation results for entangled games or quantum violations of Bell inequalities shown under the sole assumption that P≠\neq=NP. They can be thought of as an extension of H\aastad's optimal hardness of approximation results for MAX-E3-LIN2 [J. ACM, 48 (2001), pp. 798--859] to the entangled-player setting. The key technical component of our work is a soundness analysis of a plane-vs-point low-degree test against entangled players. This extends and simplifies the analysis of the multilinearity test by Ito and Vidick [Proceedings of the 535353rd FOCS, IEEE, Piscataway, NJ, 2012, pp. 243--252]. Our results demonstrate the possibility of efficient reductions between entangled-player games and our techniques may lead to further hardness of approximation results.
This paper considers the decidability of fully quantum nonlocal games with noisy maximally entangled states. Fully quantum nonlocal games are a generalization of nonlocal games, where both questions and answers are quantum and the referee performs a binary POVM measurement to decide whether they win the game after receiving the quantum answers from the players. The quantum value of a fully quantum nonlocal game is the supremum of the probability that they win the game, where the supremum is taken over all the possible entangled states shared between the players and all the valid quantum operations performed by the players. The seminal work MIP∗=RE\text {MIP}^*=\text {RE}MIP∗=RE ( Ji et al. MIP ∗ = RE, 2020; Ji et al. Quantum soundness of the classical low individual degree test, 2020) implies that it is undecidable to approximate the quantum value of a fully nonlocal game. This still holds even if the players are only allowed to share (arbitrarily many copies of) maximally entangled states. This paper investigates the case that the shared maximally entangled states are noisy. We prove that there is a computable upper bound on the copies of noisy maximally entangled states for the players to win a fully quantum nonlocal game with a probability arbitrarily close to the quantum value. This implies that it is decidable to approximate the quantum values of these games. Hence, the hardness of approximating the quantum value of a fully quantum nonlocal game is not robust against the noise in the shared states. This paper is built on the framework for the decidability of non-interactive simulations of joint distributions (Ghazi et al. in: 2016 IEEE 57th Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science (FOCS), Los Alamitos, 2016; De et al. in: Proceedings of the Twenty-Ninth Annual ACM-SIAM Symposium on Discrete Algorithms, Philadelphia, 2018; Ghazi et al. Proceedings of the 33rd Computational Complexity Conference, 2018) and generalizes the analogous result for nonlocal games in Qin and Yao (SIAM J Comput 50(6):1800–1891, 2021). We extend the theory of Fourier analysis to the space of super-operators and prove several key results including an invariance principle and a dimension reduction for super-operators. These results are interesting in their own right and are believed to have further applications.
A two-player one-round binary game consists of two cooperative players who each replies by one bit to a message that he receives privately; they win the game if both questions and answers satisfy some predetermined property. A game is called entangled if the players are allowed to share a priori entanglement. It is well-known that the maximum winning probability (value) of entangled XOR-games (binary games in which the predetermined property depends only on the XOR of the two output bits) can be computed by a semidefinite program. In this paper we extend this result in the following sense; if a binary game is uniform, meaning that in an optimal strategy the marginal distributions of the output of each player are uniform, then its entangled value can be efficiently computed by a semidefinite program. We also introduce a lower bound on the entangled value of a general two-player one-round game; this bound depends on the size of the output set of each player and can be computed by a semidefinite program. In particular, we show that if the game is binary, ωq\omega_qωq​ is its entangled value, and ωsdp\omega_{sdp}ωsdp​ is the optimum value of the corresponding semidefinite program, then 0.68 ωsdp<ωq≤ωsdp0.68\,\omega_{sdp} < \omega_q \leq \omega_{sdp}0.68ωsdp​<ωq​≤ωsdp​.
Two-party xor games (correlation Bell inequalities with two outcomes per party) are the most studied Bell inequalities, and one of the few classes for which the optimal quantum value is known to be exactly calculable. We study a natural generalization of the binary xor games to the class of linear games with d>2d>2d>2 outcomes, and propose an easily computable bound on the quantum value of these games. Many interesting properties such as the impossibility of a quantum strategy to win these games, and the quantum bound on the CHSH game generalized to ddd outcomes are derived. We also use the proposed bound to prove a large-alphabet generalization of the principle of no quantum advantage in nonlocal computation, showing that quantum theory provides no advantage in the task of nonlocal distributed computation of a class of functions with ddd outcomes for prime ddd, while general no-signaling boxes do. This task is one of the information-theoretic principles attempting to characterize the set of quantum correlations from amongst general no-signaling ones.
We bound separations between the entangled and classical values for several classes of nonlocal ttt-player games. Our motivating question is whether there is a family of ttt-player XOR games for which the entangled bias is 111 but for which the classical bias goes down to 000, for fixed ttt. Answering this question would have important consequences in the study of multi-party communication complexity, as a positive answer would imply an unbounded separation between randomized communication complexity with and without entanglement. Our contribution to answering the question is identifying several general classes of games for which the classical bias can not go to zero when the entangled bias stays above a constant threshold. This rules out the possibility of using these games to answer our motivating question. A previously studied set of XOR games, known not to give a positive answer to the question, are those for which there is a quantum strategy that attains value 1 using a so-called Schmidt state. We generalize this class to mod-mmm games and show that their classical value is always at least 1m+m−1mt1−t\frac{1}{m} + \frac{m-1}{m} t^{1-t}m1​+mm−1​t1−t. Secondly, for free XOR games, in which the input distribution is of product form, we show β(G)≥β∗(G)2tβ(G) \geq β^*(G)^{2^t}β(G)≥β∗(G)2t where β(G)β(G)β(G) and β∗(G)β^*(G)β∗(G) are the classical and entangled biases of the game respectively. We also introduce so-called line games, an example of which is a slight modification of the Magic Square game, and show that they can not give a positive answer to the question either. Finally we look at two-player unique games and show that if the entangled value is 1−ε1-ε1−ε then the classical value is at least 1−O(εlog⁡k)1-\mathcal{O}(\sqrt{ε\log k})1−O(εlogk​) where kkk is the number of outputs in the game. Our proofs use semidefinite-programming techniques, the Gowers inverse theorem and hypergraph norms.