Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2606.26220

Interpretable rule-based learning in an autonomous thermodynamic network

Sparrow Suderman, Giulia Rubino

quant-phSubmitted Jun 24, 2026• Announced Jun 26, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Machine learning is typically described in terms of deterministic logical operations, whereas physical systems generally operate in the presence of noise, dissipation and irreversibility. Here, we turn these physical effects into computational resources for an autonomous, interpretable learning architecture. We develop a classifier based on thermodynamic neurons, which are autonomous quantum thermal machines that implement logical operations through heat flow, and use these to construct a stochastic version of the Tsetlin machine, an interpretable rule-based learning architecture. By combining thermodynamic AND, NOT and OR gates with an autonomous coupling mechanism, we realise a learning system whose computation unfolds without the need for external time-dependent control. Despite its noisy components, the resulting classifier achieves classification accuracy that is statistically comparable to that of the standard Tsetlin machine. Reliability arises from architectural mechanisms such as thresholding and redundancy, rather than exact logical operations. Our results highlight that accurate and interpretable learning can emerge from autonomous stochastic dynamics, and establish thermodynamic computation as a viable framework for physical machine learning.

Comments
12 pages + 3 pages of Appendices + 3 pages of Suppl. Materials; 5 figures + 2 in the Suppl. Materials

Related papers

Thermodynamic computing via autonomous quantum thermal machines

Patryk Lipka-Bartosik, Martí Perarnau-Llobet, Nicolas Brunner

We develop a physics-based model for classical computation based on autonomous quantum thermal machines. These machines consist of few interacting quantum bits (qubits) connected to several environments at different temperatures. Heat flows through the machine are here exploited for computing. The process starts by setting the temperatures of the environments according to the logical input. The machine evolves, eventually reaching a nonequilibrium steady state, from which the output of the computation can be determined via the temperature of an auxilliary finite-size reservoir. Such a machine, which we term a "thermodynamic neuron," can implement any linearly separable function, and we discuss explicitly the cases of NOT, 3-MAJORITY, and NOR gates. In turn, we show that a network of thermodynamic neurons can perform any desired function. We discuss the close connection between our model and artificial neurons (perceptrons) and argue that our model provides an alternative physics-based analog implementation of neural networks, and more generally a platform for thermodynamic computing.

arXiv:2308.15905•Science Advances•Sep 4, 2024•41 citations

The Thermodynamic Cost of Computing with Heat

M. W. AlMasri

Autonomous quantum thermal machines have recently been proposed as physics-based computing substrates where logical inputs and outputs are encoded in temperature gradients. While such ``thermodynamic neurons'' exhibit a clear trade-off between computational fidelity and heat dissipation, the fundamental information-theoretic limits of temperature-encoded computation remain uncharacterized. Here, we derive rigorous bounds linking average error probability, channel capacity, and entropy production for finite-capacity thermal reservoirs operating far from equilibrium. We prove that the minimal dissipation required to achieve a target average error probability $\langle ξ\rangle$ diverges as $\langle ξ\rangle$ approaches a fundamental minimum error floor $\epsMin$ imposed by finite-reservoir thermal fluctuations. We further establish a thermodynamic channel capacity that saturates at high dissipation, and quantify the minimal dissipation required for cascaded networks to maintain target fidelity. We demonstrate that the required dissipation grows linearly $\mathcal{O}(L)$ with network depth for shallow networks, but diverges as the network depth $L$ approaches a fundamental maximum limit $L_{\max} = \epsNet/\epsMin$ imposed by the minimum error floor. Furthermore, under strong noise amplification conditions, the required dissipation can grow up to $\mathcal{O}(L^3)$. Our framework bridges stochastic thermodynamics, finite-time information theory, and autonomous computation, providing rigorous design principles for energy-efficient analog thermodynamic hardware.

quant-pharXiv:2608.10027•Aug 11, 2026

Learning thermodynamics with Boltzmann machines

Giacomo Torlai, Roger G. Melko

A Boltzmann machine is a stochastic neural network that has been extensively used in the layers of deep architectures for modern machine learning applications. In this paper, we develop a Boltzmann machine that is capable of modeling thermodynamic observables for physical systems in thermal equilibrium. Through unsupervised learning, we train the Boltzmann machine on data sets constructed with spin configurations importance sampled from the partition function of an Ising Hamiltonian at different temperatures using Monte Carlo (MC) methods. The trained Boltzmann machine is then used to generate spin states, for which we compare thermodynamic observables to those computed by direct MC sampling. We demonstrate that the Boltzmann machine can faithfully reproduce the observables of the physical system. Further, we observe that the number of neurons required to obtain accurate results increases as the system is brought close to criticality.

arXiv:1606.02718•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 17, 2016•254 citations

Thermodynamic functionality of autonomous quantum networks

Heiko Schröder

Thermodynamics is a theory of impressive success and a wide range of applicability. Nevertheless, it took about two hundred years after the basic formulation of phenomenological thermodynamics until Boltzmann and Maxwell gave a foundation in terms statistical mechanics based on classical mechanics. The invention of quantum mechanics has triggered various attempts to establish a theory of quantum thermodynamics, i.e., to explain and derive thermodynamics by quantum mechanics only. Recently, a new approach to this question has been developed by Gemmer et al. focusing on the role of the partitioning of the universe into "system" and "environment" and on how the entanglement between those parts and the properties of typical environments lead to a thermal state in the system for almost any instant in time. Within this approach, the emergence of thermodynamic behavior in subsystems of a wide class of autonomous quantum networks could be established although the state of the total system is a pure. This turns our understanding of the emergence of thermodynamics upside down: No longer the presence of ideal (infinitely large and always in equilibrium) makes the system thermodynamic, but thermodynamic behavior of the system itself induced by an appropriate embedding - which by itself does not need to be thermodynamic in any way - becomes the crucial ingredient. Moreover, it was found that not only macroscopic embeddings but also quantum networks as small as 10 spins may serve already as excellent thermal embeddings. In this context, this thesis approaches a number of questions: First, complementary to the emergence of relaxation (heat), how does mechanical control over a system (work) emerge in autonomous quantum systems? What types of embeddings allow for this control, and is there a lower limit of their size? The answer is discussed by making the connection between work, parametric control of a Hamiltonian, and classical driving with the help of the factorization approximation. Using this link, we propose the local effective measurement basis method to determine heat and work currents in arbitrary bipartite quantum systems, and discuss measures of how to assess the thermodynamic functionality of an arbitrary embedding. We then apply these concepts to a minimal model consisting of only a spin and a quantum harmonic oscillator (spin-oscillator model) to demonstrate that even a single oscillator may act as an ideal work reservoir. A slight variation of the model then illustrates the pros and cons of the proposed measures of thermodynamic functionality. Second, since thermodynamics is first and foremost a theory of processes, which need both, thermal and mechanical control, we ask if autonomous quantum networks can implement thermodynamic cycles. We do so by first reviewing some specialties of quantum thermodynamic processes in general and then presenting the autonomous dynamic three spin machine, an autonomous quantum network implementing a thermodynamic cycle, which is driven by a emergent quantum work reservoir as discussed in the first part. Finally, we discuss quantum thermodynamic pseudomachines, a class of models that exhibit machine-like functionality without use of a thermodynamic cycle. This gives an answer to the question how new forms of control that are only found in quantum systems lead to new thermodynamic functionalities. The presented models can all be understood as thermodynamic laser models. In particular, we discuss the extended dissipative Jaynes-Cummings model and its thermodynamic properties. We resolve a conflict between different interpretations of the model by a careful analysis of the model itself and the thermodynamic concepts used by different authors. It is found that the model is an intricate heat transport model and no machine and that its thermodynamic functionality relies on the transition-selective coupling of heat baths to a few-level quantum system.

•Jan 1, 2010•0 citations

Autonomous machines and clocks in quantum thermodynamics

Max F. Frenzel

Thermodynamics is one of the core disciplines of physics, and despite its long history it is still a very active area of research. Particularly in the regime of non-equilibrium processes and at small scales many open questions remain. In this thesis we critically study the role that autonomous machines play in the emerging field of quantum thermodynamics. We show that autonomous machines generally comprise several interacting subsystems that can take on various roles. In Part I we look at the issue of external control. Any non-autonomous machine by definition requires some external agent to interact with the machine. This agent is generally assumed to be classical and to not suffer any back-actions from the machine. If all the involved systems are of microscopic size this approximation is no longer valid and we have to include all the control mechanisms within a unified quantum framework. We show that in order to avoid external control and operate autonomously, a machine that is to extract work from another system requires an inbuilt quantum clock. Being itself a finite-size quantum system, such a clock will inevitably experience back-actions and develop correlations with the other systems, which lead to its degradation as a time keeping device. We show that this degradation can be counteracted by a judicious choice of quantum measurements. These measurements not only allow us to stabilise the clock, but also magnify thermodynamic properties such as work from the quantum scale, where their definition can be ambiguous, to the well understood classical scale. In Part II we consider the scenario of an autonomous quantum machine interacting with a thermal environment, for which we are experimentally restricted to only observe a subset of all the possible environment interactions, while the remaining ones are hidden from direct observation. Using a modification of the notion of quantum jump trajectories we show that the visible interactions in many cases still allow us to make some inferences about the hidden interactions. We introduce a new quantity, the coarse-grained hidden entropy, which quantifies the entropy production in the hidden subsystem conditioned on our observations of the visible part. The total entropy production consisting of the sum of visible and coarse-grained hidden entropy is shown to satisfy an integral fluctuations theorem. Depending on the information flow between the subsystems, the hidden entropy can assume negative values in which case the hidden systems acts as a Maxwell's demon. This behaviour is also captured by a modified second law like inequality which gives a refinement of the conventional second law for autonomous quantum machines with continuous information flows between the machine's subsystems.

•Oct 1, 2016•0 citations

Certifying quantum enhancements in thermal machines beyond the Thermodynamic Uncertainty Relation

José A. Almanza-Marrero, Gonzalo Manzano

Quantum coherence has been shown to impact the operational capabilities of quantum systems performing thermodynamic tasks in a significant way, and yet the possibility and conditions for genuine coherence-enhanced thermodynamic operation remain unclear. Introducing a comparison with classical machines using the same set of thermodynamic resources, we show that for steady-state quantum thermal machines – both autonomous and externally driven – that interact weakly with thermal reservoirs and work sources, the presence of coherence induced by perturbations in the machine Hamiltonian guarantees a genuine thermodynamic advantage under mild conditions. This advantage applies to both cases where the induced coherence is between levels with different energies or between degenerate levels. On the other hand, we show that engines subjected to noise-induced coherence can be outperformed by classical stochastic engines using exactly the same set of (incoherent) resources. We illustrate our results with three prototypical models of heat engines and refrigerators: the three-level amplifier, the three-qubit autonomous refrigerator, and a noise-induced-coherence machine.

arXiv:2403.19280•Quantum•Oct 7, 2025•15 citations
Machine learning is typically described in terms of deterministic logical operations, whereas physical systems generally operate in the presence of noise, dissipation and irreversibility. Here, we turn these physical effects into computational resources for an autonomous, interpretable learning architecture. We develop a classifier based on thermodynamic neurons, which are autonomous quantum thermal machines that implement logical operations through heat flow, and use these to construct a stochastic version of the Tsetlin machine, an interpretable rule-based learning architecture. By combining thermodynamic AND, NOT and OR gates with an autonomous coupling mechanism, we realise a learning system whose computation unfolds without the need for external time-dependent control. Despite its noisy components, the resulting classifier achieves classification accuracy that is statistically comparable to that of the standard Tsetlin machine. Reliability arises from architectural mechanisms such as thresholding and redundancy, rather than exact logical operations. Our results highlight that accurate and interpretable learning can emerge from autonomous stochastic dynamics, and establish thermodynamic computation as a viable framework for physical machine learning.
We develop a physics-based model for classical computation based on autonomous quantum thermal machines. These machines consist of few interacting quantum bits (qubits) connected to several environments at different temperatures. Heat flows through the machine are here exploited for computing. The process starts by setting the temperatures of the environments according to the logical input. The machine evolves, eventually reaching a nonequilibrium steady state, from which the output of the computation can be determined via the temperature of an auxilliary finite-size reservoir. Such a machine, which we term a "thermodynamic neuron," can implement any linearly separable function, and we discuss explicitly the cases of NOT, 3-MAJORITY, and NOR gates. In turn, we show that a network of thermodynamic neurons can perform any desired function. We discuss the close connection between our model and artificial neurons (perceptrons) and argue that our model provides an alternative physics-based analog implementation of neural networks, and more generally a platform for thermodynamic computing.
Autonomous quantum thermal machines have recently been proposed as physics-based computing substrates where logical inputs and outputs are encoded in temperature gradients. While such ``thermodynamic neurons'' exhibit a clear trade-off between computational fidelity and heat dissipation, the fundamental information-theoretic limits of temperature-encoded computation remain uncharacterized. Here, we derive rigorous bounds linking average error probability, channel capacity, and entropy production for finite-capacity thermal reservoirs operating far from equilibrium. We prove that the minimal dissipation required to achieve a target average error probability ⟨ξ⟩\langle ξ\rangle⟨ξ⟩ diverges as ⟨ξ⟩\langle ξ\rangle⟨ξ⟩ approaches a fundamental minimum error floor $\epsMin$ imposed by finite-reservoir thermal fluctuations. We further establish a thermodynamic channel capacity that saturates at high dissipation, and quantify the minimal dissipation required for cascaded networks to maintain target fidelity. We demonstrate that the required dissipation grows linearly O(L)\mathcal{O}(L)O(L) with network depth for shallow networks, but diverges as the network depth LLL approaches a fundamental maximum limit $L_{\max} = \epsNet/\epsMin$ imposed by the minimum error floor. Furthermore, under strong noise amplification conditions, the required dissipation can grow up to O(L3)\mathcal{O}(L^3)O(L3). Our framework bridges stochastic thermodynamics, finite-time information theory, and autonomous computation, providing rigorous design principles for energy-efficient analog thermodynamic hardware.
A Boltzmann machine is a stochastic neural network that has been extensively used in the layers of deep architectures for modern machine learning applications. In this paper, we develop a Boltzmann machine that is capable of modeling thermodynamic observables for physical systems in thermal equilibrium. Through unsupervised learning, we train the Boltzmann machine on data sets constructed with spin configurations importance sampled from the partition function of an Ising Hamiltonian at different temperatures using Monte Carlo (MC) methods. The trained Boltzmann machine is then used to generate spin states, for which we compare thermodynamic observables to those computed by direct MC sampling. We demonstrate that the Boltzmann machine can faithfully reproduce the observables of the physical system. Further, we observe that the number of neurons required to obtain accurate results increases as the system is brought close to criticality.
Thermodynamics is a theory of impressive success and a wide range of applicability. Nevertheless, it took about two hundred years after the basic formulation of phenomenological thermodynamics until Boltzmann and Maxwell gave a foundation in terms statistical mechanics based on classical mechanics. The invention of quantum mechanics has triggered various attempts to establish a theory of quantum thermodynamics, i.e., to explain and derive thermodynamics by quantum mechanics only. Recently, a new approach to this question has been developed by Gemmer et al. focusing on the role of the partitioning of the universe into "system" and "environment" and on how the entanglement between those parts and the properties of typical environments lead to a thermal state in the system for almost any instant in time. Within this approach, the emergence of thermodynamic behavior in subsystems of a wide class of autonomous quantum networks could be established although the state of the total system is a pure. This turns our understanding of the emergence of thermodynamics upside down: No longer the presence of ideal (infinitely large and always in equilibrium) makes the system thermodynamic, but thermodynamic behavior of the system itself induced by an appropriate embedding - which by itself does not need to be thermodynamic in any way - becomes the crucial ingredient. Moreover, it was found that not only macroscopic embeddings but also quantum networks as small as 10 spins may serve already as excellent thermal embeddings. In this context, this thesis approaches a number of questions: First, complementary to the emergence of relaxation (heat), how does mechanical control over a system (work) emerge in autonomous quantum systems? What types of embeddings allow for this control, and is there a lower limit of their size? The answer is discussed by making the connection between work, parametric control of a Hamiltonian, and classical driving with the help of the factorization approximation. Using this link, we propose the local effective measurement basis method to determine heat and work currents in arbitrary bipartite quantum systems, and discuss measures of how to assess the thermodynamic functionality of an arbitrary embedding. We then apply these concepts to a minimal model consisting of only a spin and a quantum harmonic oscillator (spin-oscillator model) to demonstrate that even a single oscillator may act as an ideal work reservoir. A slight variation of the model then illustrates the pros and cons of the proposed measures of thermodynamic functionality. Second, since thermodynamics is first and foremost a theory of processes, which need both, thermal and mechanical control, we ask if autonomous quantum networks can implement thermodynamic cycles. We do so by first reviewing some specialties of quantum thermodynamic processes in general and then presenting the autonomous dynamic three spin machine, an autonomous quantum network implementing a thermodynamic cycle, which is driven by a emergent quantum work reservoir as discussed in the first part. Finally, we discuss quantum thermodynamic pseudomachines, a class of models that exhibit machine-like functionality without use of a thermodynamic cycle. This gives an answer to the question how new forms of control that are only found in quantum systems lead to new thermodynamic functionalities. The presented models can all be understood as thermodynamic laser models. In particular, we discuss the extended dissipative Jaynes-Cummings model and its thermodynamic properties. We resolve a conflict between different interpretations of the model by a careful analysis of the model itself and the thermodynamic concepts used by different authors. It is found that the model is an intricate heat transport model and no machine and that its thermodynamic functionality relies on the transition-selective coupling of heat baths to a few-level quantum system.
Thermodynamics is one of the core disciplines of physics, and despite its long history it is still a very active area of research. Particularly in the regime of non-equilibrium processes and at small scales many open questions remain. In this thesis we critically study the role that autonomous machines play in the emerging field of quantum thermodynamics. We show that autonomous machines generally comprise several interacting subsystems that can take on various roles. In Part I we look at the issue of external control. Any non-autonomous machine by definition requires some external agent to interact with the machine. This agent is generally assumed to be classical and to not suffer any back-actions from the machine. If all the involved systems are of microscopic size this approximation is no longer valid and we have to include all the control mechanisms within a unified quantum framework. We show that in order to avoid external control and operate autonomously, a machine that is to extract work from another system requires an inbuilt quantum clock. Being itself a finite-size quantum system, such a clock will inevitably experience back-actions and develop correlations with the other systems, which lead to its degradation as a time keeping device. We show that this degradation can be counteracted by a judicious choice of quantum measurements. These measurements not only allow us to stabilise the clock, but also magnify thermodynamic properties such as work from the quantum scale, where their definition can be ambiguous, to the well understood classical scale. In Part II we consider the scenario of an autonomous quantum machine interacting with a thermal environment, for which we are experimentally restricted to only observe a subset of all the possible environment interactions, while the remaining ones are hidden from direct observation. Using a modification of the notion of quantum jump trajectories we show that the visible interactions in many cases still allow us to make some inferences about the hidden interactions. We introduce a new quantity, the coarse-grained hidden entropy, which quantifies the entropy production in the hidden subsystem conditioned on our observations of the visible part. The total entropy production consisting of the sum of visible and coarse-grained hidden entropy is shown to satisfy an integral fluctuations theorem. Depending on the information flow between the subsystems, the hidden entropy can assume negative values in which case the hidden systems acts as a Maxwell's demon. This behaviour is also captured by a modified second law like inequality which gives a refinement of the conventional second law for autonomous quantum machines with continuous information flows between the machine's subsystems.
Quantum coherence has been shown to impact the operational capabilities of quantum systems performing thermodynamic tasks in a significant way, and yet the possibility and conditions for genuine coherence-enhanced thermodynamic operation remain unclear. Introducing a comparison with classical machines using the same set of thermodynamic resources, we show that for steady-state quantum thermal machines – both autonomous and externally driven – that interact weakly with thermal reservoirs and work sources, the presence of coherence induced by perturbations in the machine Hamiltonian guarantees a genuine thermodynamic advantage under mild conditions. This advantage applies to both cases where the induced coherence is between levels with different energies or between degenerate levels. On the other hand, we show that engines subjected to noise-induced coherence can be outperformed by classical stochastic engines using exactly the same set of (incoherent) resources. We illustrate our results with three prototypical models of heat engines and refrigerators: the three-level amplifier, the three-qubit autonomous refrigerator, and a noise-induced-coherence machine.