Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2606.04763

Imaginarity witness

Zhiqi Liang, Yufan Lin, Yu Guo, Yuqi Sun

quant-phSubmitted Jun 3, 2026• Announced Jun 4, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Imaginarity has shown to be an important resource in quantum information. The witness theory of quantum resource, such as entanglement witness, coherence witness, and imaginarity witness, has been established, in particular entanglement witness and coherence witness have been extensively explored. We present here another class of imaginarity witnesses beyond the one in [{Phys. Lett. A} \textbf{530}, 130135 (2025)]. Within our framework, any nonreal Hermitian operator under the reference basis is an imaginarity witness and only finite of them can detect all the imaginarity states. As the common approaches that were explored in the witness theories of entanglement and coherence, we then explore the relations between these imaginarity witnesses in different cases: (i) when they can detect common imaginary states, (ii) when they can detect the same sets of imaginary states, and (ii) when they obey the finer relation. Finally, we define an imaginarity measure in terms of witnesses, termed witnessed imaginarity, and prove that it coincides with both the trace norm of imaginarity and the robustness of imaginarity.

Comments
12 pages. Comments are welcome

Related papers

Imaginarity witnessing enhancement via spectral norms of witnesses

Yuhang Xie, Yanjun Chu, Yushan Ding +1 more

Quantum imaginarity is an essential physical resource that underpins key functionalities of modern quantum technologies. We improve imaginarity witnessing via the prior knowledge of imaginarity-witness operators. To this end, we derive a rigorous upper bound on the maximum expectation value of an imaginarity witness operator over the set of all free (real) quantum states, which is given by the spectral norm of the real component of the corresponding witness operator. We demonstrate via detailed examples that this bound substantially improves imaginarity detection. We further classify all imaginarity-witness operators into four distinct families based on this bound. For these four witness classes, we perform a comprehensive analysis of their completeness and finite completeness, the joint detection of shared imaginary quantum states by different witnesses, and the conditions for distinct witnesses to identify identical imaginary states. Our results advance the fundamental understanding of imaginarity detection and offer useful insights for both theoretical studies and experimental implementations of quantum imaginarity.

quant-pharXiv:2609.00534•Sep 2, 2026•0 citations

Broadcasting of imaginarity

Zijian Zhang, Nan Li, Shunlong Luo

Recently, the resource theory of imaginarity was proposed, viewing the imaginary part of a quantum state as a basic resource leading to quantum advantages. As with other quantum resources such as correlations, coherence, and asymmetry, a natural question arises: Can imaginarity resource be broadcast by a real operation which is free in the resource theory of imaginarity? In this work, we introduce two concepts of imaginarity broadcasting. The first pertains to nonreal states, while the second is related to the imaginarity resource. For nonreal states, we demonstrate that a specific type of nonreal states can be broadcast. However, when it comes to broadcasting the imaginarity resource, we get a surprising result that any imaginarity resource can be perfectly broadcast via a real operation. By comparing different (no-)broadcasting theorems, we distinguish the resource theory of imaginarity from the resource theories of correlations, coherence, and asymmetry, and reveal certain distinctive features of the resource theory of imaginarity.

Physical Review A•Nov 26, 2024•20 citations

Analysis of the relationship between imaginarity and entanglement

Yanna Sun, Ruonan Ren, Yiran Wang +1 more

Imaginary numbers play an important role in physics, especially in quantum physics. They are not only a part of describing the dynamic behavior of quantum systems, but also play a key role in the phase and interference phenomena of quantum states. Similar to coherence and entanglement, the imaginarity has been regarded as a quantum resource, further revealing the nonclassical properties of quantum systems and providing new research directions and applications for fields such as quantum computing and quantum communication. In our work, we mainly explore the quantitative relationship between imaginarity and entanglement. For an arbitrary quantum state, there exists a general quantitative relationship between imaginarity and entanglement. For a given class of quantum states, where the closest real states to them are diagonal states, there exists an imaginarity-entanglement inequality. We demonstrate that for these quantum states, any degree of imaginarity with respect to some reference basis can be transformed into entanglement through incoherent real operations. This discovery allows us to define an entanglement-based imaginarity quantifier for these states in quantum systems of arbitrary dimensions and to study their properties. It is shown that for these quantum states, imaginarity and entanglement are operationally equivalent. Our work provides a clear quantitative and operational link between imaginarity and entanglement.

Physical Review A•Mar 21, 2025•10 citations

Unitary-Invariant Witnesses of Quantum Imaginarity

Carlos Fernandes, Rafael Wagner, Leonardo Novo +1 more

Quantum theory is traditionally formulated using complex numbers. This imaginarity of quantum theory has been quantified as a resource with applications in discrimination tasks, pseudorandomness generation, and quantum metrology. In the standard formulation, a quantum state is said to have "imaginarity" if the associated density matrix is not real-valued in a given, fixed basis. If instead we consider a set of states, it is possible to devise tests that guarantee imaginarity of some state in the set, independently of the basis chosen. Here we propose such basis-independent witnesses for imaginarity that rely on measurements of unitary-invariant properties of sets of states. For three pure states, we completely characterize the invariant values attainable by quantum theory, and give a partial characterization for four pure states. We show that simple pairwise overlap measurements suffice to witness imaginarity of sets of four states, but not for sets of three. Our witnesses are experimentally friendly, opening up a new path for measuring and using imaginarity as a resource.

arXiv:2403.15066•Physical Review Letters•Nov 8, 2024•56 citations

Detecting and estimating coherence based on coherence witnesses

Zhao Ma, Zhou Zhang, Yue Dai +2 more

Quantum coherence has wide-ranging applications from quantum thermodynamics to quantum metrology, quantum channel discrimination, and even quantum biology. Thus, detecting and quantifying coherence are two fundamental problems in quantum resource theory. Here, we introduce feasible methods to detect and estimate the coherence by constructing coherence witnesses for any finite-dimensional states. Our coherence witnesses detect coherent states by testing whether the expectation value of the witness is negative or not. Two typical coherence witnesses are proposed and discussed based on our witness-constructing method, which are also used to estimate the robustness of coherence, the ${l}_{1}$ norm, and the ${l}_{2}$ norm of coherence measures. Furthermore, we compare one of our coherence witnesses with a previously introduced witness by proving that our witness is strictly stronger than that previous witness. We also present an application of coherence in a quantum metrology task, in which we estimate an unknown parameter by measuring our coherence witness.

arXiv:2012.13038•Physical Review A•Jan 13, 2021•30 citations

Measure of set imaginarity

Yu Guo, Jiabo Pan, Yuqin Wang +1 more

Recent studies have shown that Bargmann invariants provide effective detectors of set imaginarity. In this paper, we investigate set imaginarity as a quantum resource in qubit systems. By exploiting the structure of Bargmann invariants, we show that the free operations for qubit set imaginarity consist precisely of common unital operations and common planarized operations. Based on this characterization, we introduce an axiomatic framework for set-imaginarity measures (SIMs). In particular, we propose two refined notions, namely unified SIMs and complete SIMs, which allow a more fine-grained quantification of set imaginarity. To make these notions concrete, we construct two qubit SIMs from the Bargmann invariants of three-state subsets. We prove that one of them is a unified SIM, while the other satisfies the stronger requirements of a complete SIM. Furthermore, we revisit the robustness of set imaginarity previously introduced in the literature. We show that, although this robustness is a valid SIM for qubit systems, it is neither a unified SIM nor a complete SIM. To overcome this limitation, we propose an improved robustness-type measure and rigorously prove that it defines a complete qubit SIM.

quant-pharXiv:2608.28985•Physical Review A•Sep 1, 2026•0 citations
Imaginarity has shown to be an important resource in quantum information. The witness theory of quantum resource, such as entanglement witness, coherence witness, and imaginarity witness, has been established, in particular entanglement witness and coherence witness have been extensively explored. We present here another class of imaginarity witnesses beyond the one in [{Phys. Lett. A} \textbf{530}, 130135 (2025)]. Within our framework, any nonreal Hermitian operator under the reference basis is an imaginarity witness and only finite of them can detect all the imaginarity states. As the common approaches that were explored in the witness theories of entanglement and coherence, we then explore the relations between these imaginarity witnesses in different cases: (i) when they can detect common imaginary states, (ii) when they can detect the same sets of imaginary states, and (ii) when they obey the finer relation. Finally, we define an imaginarity measure in terms of witnesses, termed witnessed imaginarity, and prove that it coincides with both the trace norm of imaginarity and the robustness of imaginarity.
Quantum imaginarity is an essential physical resource that underpins key functionalities of modern quantum technologies. We improve imaginarity witnessing via the prior knowledge of imaginarity-witness operators. To this end, we derive a rigorous upper bound on the maximum expectation value of an imaginarity witness operator over the set of all free (real) quantum states, which is given by the spectral norm of the real component of the corresponding witness operator. We demonstrate via detailed examples that this bound substantially improves imaginarity detection. We further classify all imaginarity-witness operators into four distinct families based on this bound. For these four witness classes, we perform a comprehensive analysis of their completeness and finite completeness, the joint detection of shared imaginary quantum states by different witnesses, and the conditions for distinct witnesses to identify identical imaginary states. Our results advance the fundamental understanding of imaginarity detection and offer useful insights for both theoretical studies and experimental implementations of quantum imaginarity.
Recently, the resource theory of imaginarity was proposed, viewing the imaginary part of a quantum state as a basic resource leading to quantum advantages. As with other quantum resources such as correlations, coherence, and asymmetry, a natural question arises: Can imaginarity resource be broadcast by a real operation which is free in the resource theory of imaginarity? In this work, we introduce two concepts of imaginarity broadcasting. The first pertains to nonreal states, while the second is related to the imaginarity resource. For nonreal states, we demonstrate that a specific type of nonreal states can be broadcast. However, when it comes to broadcasting the imaginarity resource, we get a surprising result that any imaginarity resource can be perfectly broadcast via a real operation. By comparing different (no-)broadcasting theorems, we distinguish the resource theory of imaginarity from the resource theories of correlations, coherence, and asymmetry, and reveal certain distinctive features of the resource theory of imaginarity.
Imaginary numbers play an important role in physics, especially in quantum physics. They are not only a part of describing the dynamic behavior of quantum systems, but also play a key role in the phase and interference phenomena of quantum states. Similar to coherence and entanglement, the imaginarity has been regarded as a quantum resource, further revealing the nonclassical properties of quantum systems and providing new research directions and applications for fields such as quantum computing and quantum communication. In our work, we mainly explore the quantitative relationship between imaginarity and entanglement. For an arbitrary quantum state, there exists a general quantitative relationship between imaginarity and entanglement. For a given class of quantum states, where the closest real states to them are diagonal states, there exists an imaginarity-entanglement inequality. We demonstrate that for these quantum states, any degree of imaginarity with respect to some reference basis can be transformed into entanglement through incoherent real operations. This discovery allows us to define an entanglement-based imaginarity quantifier for these states in quantum systems of arbitrary dimensions and to study their properties. It is shown that for these quantum states, imaginarity and entanglement are operationally equivalent. Our work provides a clear quantitative and operational link between imaginarity and entanglement.
Quantum theory is traditionally formulated using complex numbers. This imaginarity of quantum theory has been quantified as a resource with applications in discrimination tasks, pseudorandomness generation, and quantum metrology. In the standard formulation, a quantum state is said to have "imaginarity" if the associated density matrix is not real-valued in a given, fixed basis. If instead we consider a set of states, it is possible to devise tests that guarantee imaginarity of some state in the set, independently of the basis chosen. Here we propose such basis-independent witnesses for imaginarity that rely on measurements of unitary-invariant properties of sets of states. For three pure states, we completely characterize the invariant values attainable by quantum theory, and give a partial characterization for four pure states. We show that simple pairwise overlap measurements suffice to witness imaginarity of sets of four states, but not for sets of three. Our witnesses are experimentally friendly, opening up a new path for measuring and using imaginarity as a resource.
Quantum coherence has wide-ranging applications from quantum thermodynamics to quantum metrology, quantum channel discrimination, and even quantum biology. Thus, detecting and quantifying coherence are two fundamental problems in quantum resource theory. Here, we introduce feasible methods to detect and estimate the coherence by constructing coherence witnesses for any finite-dimensional states. Our coherence witnesses detect coherent states by testing whether the expectation value of the witness is negative or not. Two typical coherence witnesses are proposed and discussed based on our witness-constructing method, which are also used to estimate the robustness of coherence, the l1{l}_{1}l1​ norm, and the l2{l}_{2}l2​ norm of coherence measures. Furthermore, we compare one of our coherence witnesses with a previously introduced witness by proving that our witness is strictly stronger than that previous witness. We also present an application of coherence in a quantum metrology task, in which we estimate an unknown parameter by measuring our coherence witness.
Recent studies have shown that Bargmann invariants provide effective detectors of set imaginarity. In this paper, we investigate set imaginarity as a quantum resource in qubit systems. By exploiting the structure of Bargmann invariants, we show that the free operations for qubit set imaginarity consist precisely of common unital operations and common planarized operations. Based on this characterization, we introduce an axiomatic framework for set-imaginarity measures (SIMs). In particular, we propose two refined notions, namely unified SIMs and complete SIMs, which allow a more fine-grained quantification of set imaginarity. To make these notions concrete, we construct two qubit SIMs from the Bargmann invariants of three-state subsets. We prove that one of them is a unified SIM, while the other satisfies the stronger requirements of a complete SIM. Furthermore, we revisit the robustness of set imaginarity previously introduced in the literature. We show that, although this robustness is a valid SIM for qubit systems, it is neither a unified SIM nor a complete SIM. To overcome this limitation, we propose an improved robustness-type measure and rigorously prove that it defines a complete qubit SIM.