Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2606.03249 · Leibniz international proceedings in informatics

Quantum-Classical Equivalence for AND-Functions

Sreejata Kishor Bhattacharya, Farzan Byramji, Arkadev Chattopadhyay, Yogesh Dahiya, Shachar Lovett

cs.CCquant-phSubmitted Jun 2, 2026• Announced Jun 3, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A major open problem in quantum communication complexity is whether quantum protocols can be exponentially more efficient than classical protocols for computing total Boolean functions; the prevailing conjecture is that they cannot be so. In a seminal work, Razborov (2002) resolved this question for AND-functions of the form $$ F(x,y) = f(x_1 \land y_1, \ldots, x_n \land y_n), $$ when the outer function $f$ is symmetric, by proving that their bounded-error quantum and classical communication complexities are polynomially related. Since then, extending this result to all AND-functions has remained open and has been posed by several authors. In this work, we settle this problem in a strong way. We show that for every Boolean function $f$, the bounded-error quantum and classical deterministic communication complexities of the function $f \circ \mathrm{AND}_2$ are polynomially related, up to polylogarithmic factors in $n$. We prove this by showing that both are characterized--up to polynomial loss--by the logarithm of the De Morgan sparsity of $f$. Our results build on the recent work of Chattopadhyay, Dahiya, and Lovett (2025) on structural characterizations of non-sparse Boolean functions, which we extend to resolve the conjecture for general AND-functions.

Related papers

Quantum communication complexity of block-composed functions

Yaoyun Shi, Y.-F. Zhu

A major open problem in communication complexity is whether or not quantum protocols can be exponentially more efficient than classical ones for computing a {\em total} Boolean function in the two-party interactive model. Razborov's result ({\em Izvestiya: Mathematics}, 67(1):145--159, 2002) implies the conjectured negative answer for functions $F$ of the following form: $F(x, y)=f_n(x_1\cdot y_1, x_2\cdot y_2, ..., x_n\cdot y_n)$, where $f_n$ is a {\em symmetric} Boolean function on $n$ Boolean inputs, and $x_i$, $y_i$ are the $i$'th bit of $x$ and $y$, respectively. His proof critically depends on the symmetry of $f_n$. We develop a lower-bound method that does not require symmetry and prove the conjecture for a broader class of functions. Each of those functions $F$ is the ``block-composition'' of a ``building block'' $g_k : \{0, 1\}^k \times \{0, 1\}^k \rightarrow \{0, 1\}$, and an $f_n : \{0, 1\}^n \rightarrow \{0, 1\}$, such that $F(x, y) = f_n( g_k(x_1, y_1), g_k(x_2, y_2), ..., g_k(x_n, y_n) )$, where $x_i$ and $y_i$ are the $i$'th $k$-bit block of $x, y\in\{0, 1\}^{nk}$, respectively. We show that as long as g_k itself is "hard'' enough, its block-composition with an arbitrary f_n has polynomially related quantum and classical communication complexities. For example, when g_k is the Inner Product function with k=\Omega(\log n), the deterministic communication complexity of its block-composition with any f_n is asymptotically at most the quantum complexity to the power of 7.

arXiv:0710.0095•Quantum Information and Computation•May 1, 2009•78 citations

On quantum-classical equivalence for composed communication problems

Alexander A. Sherstov

An open problem in communication complexity proposed by several authors is to prove that for every Boolean function $f,$ the task of computing $f(x\wedge y)$ has polynomially related classical and quantum bounded-error complexities. We solve a variant of this question. For every $f,$ we prove that the task of computing, on input \mbox{$x$ and $y,$} \emph{both} of the quantities $f(x\wedge y)$ and $f(x\vee y)$ has polynomially related classical and quantum bounded-error complexities. We further show that the quantum bounded-error complexity is polynomially related to the classical deterministic complexity and the block sensitivity of $f.$ This result holds regardless of prior entanglement.

arXiv:0906.1399•Quantum Information and Computation•May 1, 2010•19 citations

Quantum Communication Complexity and Nonlocality of Bipartite Quantum Operations.

Yufan Zhu

This dissertation is motivated by the following fundamental questions: (a) are there any exponential gaps between quantum and classical communication complexities? (b) what is the role of entanglement in assisting quantum communications? (c) how to characterize the nonlocality of quantum operations? We study four specific problems below. 1. The communication complexity of the Hamming Distance problem. The Hamming Distance problem is for two parties to determine whether or not the Hamming distance between two n-bit strings is more than a given threshold. We prove tighter quantum lower bounds in the general two-party, interactive communication model. We also construct an efficient classical protocol in the more restricted Simultaneous Message Passing model, improving previous results. 2. The Log-Equivalence Conjecture. A major open problem in communication complexity is whether or not quantum protocols can be exponentially more efficient than classical ones for computing a total Boolean function in the two-party, interactive model. The answer is believed to be No. Razborov proved this conjecture for the most general class of functions so far. We prove this conjecture for a broader class of functions that we called block-composed functions. Our proof appears to be the first demonstration of the dual approach of the polynomial method in proving new results. 3. Classical simulations of bipartite quantum measurement. We define a new ix concept that measures the nonlocality of bipartite quantum operations. From this measure, we derive an upper bound that shows the limitation of entanglement in reducing communication costs. 4. The maximum tensor norm of bipartite superoperators. We define a maximum tensor norm to quantify the nonlocality of bipartite superoperators. We show that a bipartite physically realizable superoperator is bi-local if and only if its maximum tensor norm is 1. Furthermore, the estimation of the maximum tensor norm can also be used to prove quantum lower bounds on communication complexities.

•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Quantum and Classical Communication Complexity of Permutation-Invariant Functions

Ziyi Guan, Yunqi Huang, Penghui Yao +1 more

This paper gives a nearly tight characterization of the quantum communication complexity of permutation-invariant Boolean functions. With such a characterization, we show that the quantum and randomized communication complexity of permutation-invariant Boolean functions are quadratically equivalent (up to a polylogarithmic factor of the input size). Our results extend a recent line of research regarding query complexity to communication complexity, showing symmetry prevents exponential quantum speedups. Furthermore, we show that the Log-rank Conjecture holds for any non-trivial total permutation-invariant Boolean function. Moreover, we establish a relationship between the quantum/classical communication complexity and the approximate rank of permutation-invariant Boolean functions. This implies the correctness of the Log-approximate-rank Conjecture for permutation-invariant Boolean functions in both randomized and quantum settings (up to a polylogarithmic factor of the input size).

arXiv:2401.00454•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Jan 27, 2025•3 citations

Characterization of non-deterministic quantum query and quantum communication complexity

Ronald de Wolf

It is known that the classical and quantum query complexities of a total Boolean function f are polynomially related to the degree of its representing polynomial, but the optimal exponents in these relations are unknown. We show that the non-deterministic quantum query complexity of f is linearly related to the degree of a "non-deterministic" polynomial for f. We also prove a quantum-classical gap of 1 vs. N for non-deterministic query complexity for a total f. In the case of quantum communication complexity there is a (partly undetermined) relation between the complexity of f and the logarithm of the rank of its communication matrix. We show that the non-deterministic quantum communication complexity of f is linearly related to the logarithm of the rank of a non-deterministic version of the communication matrix and that it can be exponentially smaller than its classical counterpart.

IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Nov 7, 2002•29 citations

Dual polynomials and communication complexity of $\textsf{XOR}$ functions

Arkadev Chattopadhyay, Nikhil S. Mande

We show a new duality between the polynomial margin complexity of $f$ and the discrepancy of the function $f \circ \textsf{XOR}$, called an $\textsf{XOR}$ function. Using this duality, we develop polynomial based techniques for understanding the bounded error ($\textsf{BPP}$) and the weakly-unbounded error ($\textsf{PP}$) communication complexities of $\textsf{XOR}$ functions. We show the following. A weak form of an interesting conjecture of Zhang and Shi (Quantum Information and Computation, 2009) (The full conjecture has just been reported to be independently settled by Hatami and Qian (Arxiv, 2017). However, their techniques are quite different and are not known to yield many of the results we obtain here). Zhang and Shi assert that for symmetric functions $f : \{0, 1\}^n \rightarrow \{-1, 1\}$, the weakly unbounded-error complexity of $f \circ \textsf{XOR}$ is essentially characterized by the number of points $i$ in the set $\{0,1, \dots,n-2\}$ for which $D_f(i) \neq D_f(i+2)$, where $D_f$ is the predicate corresponding to $f$. The number of such points is called the odd-even degree of $f$. We show that the $\textsf{PP}$ complexity of $f \circ \textsf{XOR}$ is $Ω(k/ \log(n/k))$. We resolve a conjecture of a different Zhang characterizing the Threshold of Parity circuit size of symmetric functions in terms of their odd-even degree. We obtain a new proof of the exponential separation between $\textsf{PP}^{cc}$ and $\textsf{UPP}^{cc}$ via an $\textsf{XOR}$ function. We provide a characterization of the approximate spectral norm of symmetric functions, affirming a conjecture of Ada et al. (APPROX-RANDOM, 2012) which has several consequences. Additionally, we prove strong $\textsf{UPP}$ lower bounds for $f \circ \textsf{XOR}$, when $f$ is symmetric and periodic with period $O(n^{1/2-ε})$, for any constant $ε> 0$.

arXiv:1704.02537•Apr 8, 2017•2 citations
A major open problem in quantum communication complexity is whether quantum protocols can be exponentially more efficient than classical protocols for computing total Boolean functions; the prevailing conjecture is that they cannot be so. In a seminal work, Razborov (2002) resolved this question for AND-functions of the form F(x,y)=f(x1∧y1,…,xn∧yn),F(x,y) = f(x_1 \land y_1, \ldots, x_n \land y_n),F(x,y)=f(x1​∧y1​,…,xn​∧yn​), when the outer function fff is symmetric, by proving that their bounded-error quantum and classical communication complexities are polynomially related. Since then, extending this result to all AND-functions has remained open and has been posed by several authors.
In this work, we settle this problem in a strong way. We show that for every Boolean function fff, the bounded-error quantum and classical deterministic communication complexities of the function f∘AND2f \circ \mathrm{AND}_2f∘AND2​ are polynomially related, up to polylogarithmic factors in nnn. We prove this by showing that both are characterized--up to polynomial loss--by the logarithm of the De Morgan sparsity of fff.
Our results build on the recent work of Chattopadhyay, Dahiya, and Lovett (2025) on structural characterizations of non-sparse Boolean functions, which we extend to resolve the conjecture for general AND-functions.
A major open problem in communication complexity is whether or not quantum protocols can be exponentially more efficient than classical ones for computing a {\em total} Boolean function in the two-party interactive model. Razborov's result ({\em Izvestiya: Mathematics}, 67(1):145--159, 2002) implies the conjectured negative answer for functions FFF of the following form: F(x,y)=fn(x1⋅y1,x2⋅y2,...,xn⋅yn)F(x, y)=f_n(x_1\cdot y_1, x_2\cdot y_2, ..., x_n\cdot y_n)F(x,y)=fn​(x1​⋅y1​,x2​⋅y2​,...,xn​⋅yn​), where fnf_nfn​ is a {\em symmetric} Boolean function on nnn Boolean inputs, and xix_ixi​, yiy_iyi​ are the iii'th bit of xxx and yyy, respectively. His proof critically depends on the symmetry of fnf_nfn​. We develop a lower-bound method that does not require symmetry and prove the conjecture for a broader class of functions. Each of those functions FFF is the ``block-composition'' of a ``building block'' gk:{0,1}k×{0,1}k→{0,1}g_k : \{0, 1\}^k \times \{0, 1\}^k \rightarrow \{0, 1\}gk​:{0,1}k×{0,1}k→{0,1}, and an fn:{0,1}n→{0,1}f_n : \{0, 1\}^n \rightarrow \{0, 1\}fn​:{0,1}n→{0,1}, such that F(x,y)=fn(gk(x1,y1),gk(x2,y2),...,gk(xn,yn))F(x, y) = f_n( g_k(x_1, y_1), g_k(x_2, y_2), ..., g_k(x_n, y_n) )F(x,y)=fn​(gk​(x1​,y1​),gk​(x2​,y2​),...,gk​(xn​,yn​)), where xix_ixi​ and yiy_iyi​ are the iii'th kkk-bit block of x,y∈{0,1}nkx, y\in\{0, 1\}^{nk}x,y∈{0,1}nk, respectively. We show that as long as g_k itself is "hard'' enough, its block-composition with an arbitrary f_n has polynomially related quantum and classical communication complexities. For example, when g_k is the Inner Product function with k=\Omega(\log n), the deterministic communication complexity of its block-composition with any f_n is asymptotically at most the quantum complexity to the power of 7.
An open problem in communication complexity proposed by several authors is to prove that for every Boolean function f,f,f, the task of computing f(x∧y)f(x\wedge y)f(x∧y) has polynomially related classical and quantum bounded-error complexities. We solve a variant of this question. For every f,f,f, we prove that the task of computing, on input \mbox{xxx and y,y,y,} \emph{both} of the quantities f(x∧y)f(x\wedge y)f(x∧y) and f(x∨y)f(x\vee y)f(x∨y) has polynomially related classical and quantum bounded-error complexities. We further show that the quantum bounded-error complexity is polynomially related to the classical deterministic complexity and the block sensitivity of f.f.f. This result holds regardless of prior entanglement.
This dissertation is motivated by the following fundamental questions: (a) are there any exponential gaps between quantum and classical communication complexities? (b) what is the role of entanglement in assisting quantum communications? (c) how to characterize the nonlocality of quantum operations? We study four specific problems below. 1. The communication complexity of the Hamming Distance problem. The Hamming Distance problem is for two parties to determine whether or not the Hamming distance between two n-bit strings is more than a given threshold. We prove tighter quantum lower bounds in the general two-party, interactive communication model. We also construct an efficient classical protocol in the more restricted Simultaneous Message Passing model, improving previous results. 2. The Log-Equivalence Conjecture. A major open problem in communication complexity is whether or not quantum protocols can be exponentially more efficient than classical ones for computing a total Boolean function in the two-party, interactive model. The answer is believed to be No. Razborov proved this conjecture for the most general class of functions so far. We prove this conjecture for a broader class of functions that we called block-composed functions. Our proof appears to be the first demonstration of the dual approach of the polynomial method in proving new results. 3. Classical simulations of bipartite quantum measurement. We define a new ix concept that measures the nonlocality of bipartite quantum operations. From this measure, we derive an upper bound that shows the limitation of entanglement in reducing communication costs. 4. The maximum tensor norm of bipartite superoperators. We define a maximum tensor norm to quantify the nonlocality of bipartite superoperators. We show that a bipartite physically realizable superoperator is bi-local if and only if its maximum tensor norm is 1. Furthermore, the estimation of the maximum tensor norm can also be used to prove quantum lower bounds on communication complexities.
This paper gives a nearly tight characterization of the quantum communication complexity of permutation-invariant Boolean functions. With such a characterization, we show that the quantum and randomized communication complexity of permutation-invariant Boolean functions are quadratically equivalent (up to a polylogarithmic factor of the input size). Our results extend a recent line of research regarding query complexity to communication complexity, showing symmetry prevents exponential quantum speedups. Furthermore, we show that the Log-rank Conjecture holds for any non-trivial total permutation-invariant Boolean function. Moreover, we establish a relationship between the quantum/classical communication complexity and the approximate rank of permutation-invariant Boolean functions. This implies the correctness of the Log-approximate-rank Conjecture for permutation-invariant Boolean functions in both randomized and quantum settings (up to a polylogarithmic factor of the input size).
It is known that the classical and quantum query complexities of a total Boolean function f are polynomially related to the degree of its representing polynomial, but the optimal exponents in these relations are unknown. We show that the non-deterministic quantum query complexity of f is linearly related to the degree of a "non-deterministic" polynomial for f. We also prove a quantum-classical gap of 1 vs. N for non-deterministic query complexity for a total f. In the case of quantum communication complexity there is a (partly undetermined) relation between the complexity of f and the logarithm of the rank of its communication matrix. We show that the non-deterministic quantum communication complexity of f is linearly related to the logarithm of the rank of a non-deterministic version of the communication matrix and that it can be exponentially smaller than its classical counterpart.
Dual polynomials and communication complexity of XOR\textsf{XOR}XOR functions
We show a new duality between the polynomial margin complexity of fff and the discrepancy of the function f∘XORf \circ \textsf{XOR}f∘XOR, called an XOR\textsf{XOR}XOR function. Using this duality, we develop polynomial based techniques for understanding the bounded error (BPP\textsf{BPP}BPP) and the weakly-unbounded error (PP\textsf{PP}PP) communication complexities of XOR\textsf{XOR}XOR functions. We show the following. A weak form of an interesting conjecture of Zhang and Shi (Quantum Information and Computation, 2009) (The full conjecture has just been reported to be independently settled by Hatami and Qian (Arxiv, 2017). However, their techniques are quite different and are not known to yield many of the results we obtain here). Zhang and Shi assert that for symmetric functions f:{0,1}n→{−1,1}f : \{0, 1\}^n \rightarrow \{-1, 1\}f:{0,1}n→{−1,1}, the weakly unbounded-error complexity of f∘XORf \circ \textsf{XOR}f∘XOR is essentially characterized by the number of points iii in the set {0,1,…,n−2}\{0,1, \dots,n-2\}{0,1,…,n−2} for which Df(i)≠Df(i+2)D_f(i) \neq D_f(i+2)Df​(i)=Df​(i+2), where DfD_fDf​ is the predicate corresponding to fff. The number of such points is called the odd-even degree of fff. We show that the PP\textsf{PP}PP complexity of f∘XORf \circ \textsf{XOR}f∘XOR is Ω(k/log⁡(n/k))Ω(k/ \log(n/k))Ω(k/log(n/k)). We resolve a conjecture of a different Zhang characterizing the Threshold of Parity circuit size of symmetric functions in terms of their odd-even degree. We obtain a new proof of the exponential separation between PPcc\textsf{PP}^{cc}PPcc and UPPcc\textsf{UPP}^{cc}UPPcc via an XOR\textsf{XOR}XOR function. We provide a characterization of the approximate spectral norm of symmetric functions, affirming a conjecture of Ada et al. (APPROX-RANDOM, 2012) which has several consequences. Additionally, we prove strong UPP\textsf{UPP}UPP lower bounds for f∘XORf \circ \textsf{XOR}f∘XOR, when fff is symmetric and periodic with period O(n1/2−ε)O(n^{1/2-ε})O(n1/2−ε), for any constant ε>0ε> 0ε>0.