Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2605.31537

Nonperturbative renormalization of Haldane pseudopotentials from the exact two-electron spectrum

G.‐Q. Hai, M. T. Matsubara, Ladir Cândido, B. G. A. Brito

Published May 29, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate how exact two-electron energies and radial wavefunctions can improve many-electron descriptions of Landau-level (LL) mixing. Renormalized pseudopotentials are defined from the lowest interacting relative-motion branch in each lowest-LL angular-momentum channel. They include changes in Coulomb and magnetic kinetic expectation values nonperturbatively and recover the leading two-body perturbative correction. Matched three- and four-electron benchmarks show that the scalar renormalized model improves lowest fixed-sector energies and first fixed-sector spacings over conventional lowest-LL projection, although the tested perturbative models give more accurate lowest energies. Retaining the same second-order induced three-body term while replacing the perturbative two-body input by the renormalized pseudopotentials yields a hybrid with smaller absolute lowest-energy errors throughout the sampled coupling range. At the Coulomb-to-cyclotron energy ratio $γ_B=3.5$, the errors decrease by approximately $58\%$ and $57\%$ for three and four electrons, respectively, relative to the tail-completed two-plus-three-body perturbative comparator. At the same coupling, complementary antisymmetric multi-LL variational states built from the pair radial amplitudes recover $99.41\%$ and $99.11\%$ of the matched finite-cutoff LL-mixing energy lowering for five and six electrons, outperforming equal-rank first-order-pair controls. These results establish pair energies and radial structure as complementary, quantitatively useful inputs for many-electron treatments of LL mixing.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2605.31537

Related papers

Haldane pseudopotentials and Landau level mixing in the quantum Hall effect

Rachel Wooten

The discovery of the quantum Hall effect in 1980 opened to physics one of the simplest systems for studying many-body correlations. Numerical techniques and trial wavefunctions have proven useful for describing the novel collective behavior of the electrons, but have not fully explained all features of the fractional quantum Hall effect. For example, it is predicted that Landau level mixing should have a moderate effect on the system for all but the very strongest magnetic fields, but this effect has not been extensively studied. Among the tools most useful to modeling and describing the quantum Hall system is the Haldane pseudopotential, which is the energy of electron pairs as a function of their coupled total angular momentum. Because the pseudopotential uniquely determines the correlative behaviors in the quantum Hall system, the study of the pseudopotential is particularly important. In this dissertation I will first derive novel analytic expressions for the pair interactions and the pseudopotential using the techniques of angular momentum algebra. Then, I will use these results to numerically determine the effect of Landau level mixing on the pair pseudopotentials.

•Jan 1, 2013•2 citations

Landau level mixing in the perturbative limit

Steven H. Simon, Edward H. Rezayi

We study the effects of Landau level mixing in the limit of weak electron interaction. We use a numerical method to obtain the two- and three-body corrections to quantum Hall pseudopotentials, which are exact to lowest order in the Landau level mixing parameter. Our results are in general agreement with certain analytic results (some derived here; some derived by other authors) in the thermodynamic limit. We find that the convergence to this thermodynamic limit can be slow. This suggests that errors could occur if one tries to use pseudopotentials derived in a thermodynamic limit for numerical work on finite systems.

arXiv:1303.2809•Physical Review B•Apr 22, 2013•80 citations

Sub-Landau levels in two-dimensional electron system in magnetic field

G.‐Q. Hai

We study two interacting electrons in a two-dimensional system under a strong magnetic field and show that their numerically exact solutions organize into a set of {\em sub-Landau levels} characterized by relative angular momentum quantum number $m$. These sub-levels define correlation-resolved subspaces of the Landau-level Hilbert space, while retaining the full degeneracy associated with center-of-mass motion. Within this structure, the accessible states in each correlation channel are effectively reduced, leading to a natural organization of guiding-center states consistent with a fractional occupancy. We further analyze the role of electron correlation, Zeeman splitting, and disorder in stabilizing spin-polarized electron-pair states. Building on the two-electron states, we construct a class of many-electron trial wavefunctions based on correlated electron pairs with fixed $m$, which encode short-range correlations through the vanishing of the pair wavefunction at small separation. Our results establish a direct connection between exact two-body physics and the organization of correlated many-electron states in the lowest Landau level, providing a microscopic perspective on how relative angular momentum structures can underpin the emergence of correlated phases in quantum Hall systems.

arXiv:2406.06212•Jun 10, 2024•2 citations

Three-body correlations and finite-size effects in Moore-Read states on a sphere

Arkadiusz Wójs, John J. Quinn

Two- and three-body correlations in partially filled degenerate fermion shells are studied numerically for various interactions between the particles. Three distinct correlation regimes are defined, depending on the superharmonic, subharmonic, or harmonic forms of Haldane pair pseudopotential at short range. The harmonic form applies to electrons in the first excited Landau level $({\mathrm{LL}}_{1})$. Their correlations near half filling are confirmed to have a simple three-body form characteristic of the Moore-Read (MR) Pfaffian state, consisting of the maximum avoidance of the triplet state with the smallest relative angular momentum. To study MR correlations quantitatively, three-body amplitudes and pseudopotentials are introduced and calculated. Exact sum rules derived for the amplitudes imply that MR correlations depend on the actual (pair) interaction largely through the short-range behavior of the corresponding three-body interaction. In the calculated spectra of a model three-body repulsion, higher-energy bands are identified in addition to (previously known) MR ground state and its elementary charged (quasiparticle) and neutral (pair-breaking) excitations. The pair-breaker dispersion curve is determined, and the quasiparticles are correctly described by a generalization of the composite fermion model appropriate for Halperin $p$-type electron pairing with Laughlin correlations between the pairs. The known problem of the exact few-electron ground states having small overlaps with MR trial states on a sphere is also resolved by showing that the short-range three-body pseudopotential coefficients are more sensitive to the surface curvature than the two-body ones (leading to a slow convergence of the overlaps as a function of the electron number). Hence, the MR state and its excitations are believed to be a more accurate description of the experimental $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{5}{2}$ quantum Hall states than could be inferred from previous, small-size calculations.

arXiv:cond-mat/0407448•Physical Review B•Jan 19, 2005•20 citations

Emergence of Jack ground states from two-body pseudopotentials in fractional quantum Hall systems

Bartosz Kuśmierz, Arkadiusz Wójs

The family of ``Jack states'' related to antisymmetric Jack polynomials are the exact zero-energy ground states of particular model short-range many-body repulsive interactions, defined by a few nonvanishing leading pseudopotentials. Some Jack states are known or anticipated to accurately describe many-electron incompressible ground states emergent from the two-body Coulomb repulsion in the fractional quantum Hall effect. By extensive numerical diagonalization, we demonstrate the emergence of Jack states from suitable pair interactions. We find empirically a simple formula for the optimal two-body pseudopotentials for the series of most prominent Jack states generated by contact many-body repulsion. Furthermore, we seek a realization of arbitrary Jack states in realistic quantum Hall systems with Coulomb interaction, i.e., in the partially filled lowest and excited Landau levels in quasi-two-dimensional layers of conventional semiconductors such as GaAs or in graphene.

arXiv:1802.06666•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 15, 2018•22 citations

Electron correlations in partially filled lowest and excited Landau levels

Arkadiusz Wójs

The electron correlations near the half-filling of the lowest and excited Landau levels (LL's) are studied using numerical diagonalization. It is shown that in the low-lying states electrons avoid pair states with relative angular momenta $\mathcal{R}$ corresponding to positive anharmonicity of the interaction pseudopotential $V(\mathcal{R}).$ In the lowest LL, the superharmonic behavior of $V(\mathcal{R})$ causes Laughlin correlations (avoiding pairs with $\mathcal{R}=1)$ and the Laughlin-Jain series of incompressible ground states. In the first excited LL, $V(\mathcal{R})$ is harmonic at short range and a different series of incompressible states results. Similar correlations occur in the paired Moore-Read $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{5}{2}$ state and in the $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{7}{3}$ and $\frac{8}{3}$ states, all having small total parentage from $\mathcal{R}=1$ and 3 and large parentage from $\mathcal{R}=5.$ The $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{7}{3}$ and $\frac{8}{3}$ states are different from Laughlin $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{1}{3}$ and $\frac{2}{3}$ states and, in finite systems, occur at a different LL degeneracy (flux). The series of Laughlin-correlated states of electron pairs at $\ensuremath{\nu}{=2+2/(q}_{2}+2)=\frac{8}{3},$ $\frac{5}{2},$ $\frac{12}{5},$ and $\frac{7}{3}$ is proposed, although only in the $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{5}{2}$ state pairing has been confirmed numerically. In the second excited LL, $V(\mathcal{R})$ is subharmonic at short range and (near the half-filling) the electrons group into spatially separated larger $\ensuremath{\nu}=1$ droplets to minimize the number of strongly repulsive pair states at $\mathcal{R}=3$ and 5.

arXiv:cond-mat/0009046•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Mar 7, 2001•40 citations
We investigate how exact two-electron energies and radial wavefunctions can improve many-electron descriptions of Landau-level (LL) mixing. Renormalized pseudopotentials are defined from the lowest interacting relative-motion branch in each lowest-LL angular-momentum channel. They include changes in Coulomb and magnetic kinetic expectation values nonperturbatively and recover the leading two-body perturbative correction. Matched three- and four-electron benchmarks show that the scalar renormalized model improves lowest fixed-sector energies and first fixed-sector spacings over conventional lowest-LL projection, although the tested perturbative models give more accurate lowest energies. Retaining the same second-order induced three-body term while replacing the perturbative two-body input by the renormalized pseudopotentials yields a hybrid with smaller absolute lowest-energy errors throughout the sampled coupling range. At the Coulomb-to-cyclotron energy ratio γB=3.5γ_B=3.5γB​=3.5, the errors decrease by approximately 58%58\%58% and 57%57\%57% for three and four electrons, respectively, relative to the tail-completed two-plus-three-body perturbative comparator. At the same coupling, complementary antisymmetric multi-LL variational states built from the pair radial amplitudes recover 99.41%99.41\%99.41% and 99.11%99.11\%99.11% of the matched finite-cutoff LL-mixing energy lowering for five and six electrons, outperforming equal-rank first-order-pair controls. These results establish pair energies and radial structure as complementary, quantitatively useful inputs for many-electron treatments of LL mixing.
The discovery of the quantum Hall effect in 1980 opened to physics one of the simplest systems for studying many-body correlations. Numerical techniques and trial wavefunctions have proven useful for describing the novel collective behavior of the electrons, but have not fully explained all features of the fractional quantum Hall effect. For example, it is predicted that Landau level mixing should have a moderate effect on the system for all but the very strongest magnetic fields, but this effect has not been extensively studied. Among the tools most useful to modeling and describing the quantum Hall system is the Haldane pseudopotential, which is the energy of electron pairs as a function of their coupled total angular momentum. Because the pseudopotential uniquely determines the correlative behaviors in the quantum Hall system, the study of the pseudopotential is particularly important. In this dissertation I will first derive novel analytic expressions for the pair interactions and the pseudopotential using the techniques of angular momentum algebra. Then, I will use these results to numerically determine the effect of Landau level mixing on the pair pseudopotentials.
We study the effects of Landau level mixing in the limit of weak electron interaction. We use a numerical method to obtain the two- and three-body corrections to quantum Hall pseudopotentials, which are exact to lowest order in the Landau level mixing parameter. Our results are in general agreement with certain analytic results (some derived here; some derived by other authors) in the thermodynamic limit. We find that the convergence to this thermodynamic limit can be slow. This suggests that errors could occur if one tries to use pseudopotentials derived in a thermodynamic limit for numerical work on finite systems.
We study two interacting electrons in a two-dimensional system under a strong magnetic field and show that their numerically exact solutions organize into a set of {\em sub-Landau levels} characterized by relative angular momentum quantum number mmm. These sub-levels define correlation-resolved subspaces of the Landau-level Hilbert space, while retaining the full degeneracy associated with center-of-mass motion. Within this structure, the accessible states in each correlation channel are effectively reduced, leading to a natural organization of guiding-center states consistent with a fractional occupancy. We further analyze the role of electron correlation, Zeeman splitting, and disorder in stabilizing spin-polarized electron-pair states. Building on the two-electron states, we construct a class of many-electron trial wavefunctions based on correlated electron pairs with fixed mmm, which encode short-range correlations through the vanishing of the pair wavefunction at small separation. Our results establish a direct connection between exact two-body physics and the organization of correlated many-electron states in the lowest Landau level, providing a microscopic perspective on how relative angular momentum structures can underpin the emergence of correlated phases in quantum Hall systems.
Two- and three-body correlations in partially filled degenerate fermion shells are studied numerically for various interactions between the particles. Three distinct correlation regimes are defined, depending on the superharmonic, subharmonic, or harmonic forms of Haldane pair pseudopotential at short range. The harmonic form applies to electrons in the first excited Landau level (LL1)({\mathrm{LL}}_{1})(LL1​). Their correlations near half filling are confirmed to have a simple three-body form characteristic of the Moore-Read (MR) Pfaffian state, consisting of the maximum avoidance of the triplet state with the smallest relative angular momentum. To study MR correlations quantitatively, three-body amplitudes and pseudopotentials are introduced and calculated. Exact sum rules derived for the amplitudes imply that MR correlations depend on the actual (pair) interaction largely through the short-range behavior of the corresponding three-body interaction. In the calculated spectra of a model three-body repulsion, higher-energy bands are identified in addition to (previously known) MR ground state and its elementary charged (quasiparticle) and neutral (pair-breaking) excitations. The pair-breaker dispersion curve is determined, and the quasiparticles are correctly described by a generalization of the composite fermion model appropriate for Halperin ppp-type electron pairing with Laughlin correlations between the pairs. The known problem of the exact few-electron ground states having small overlaps with MR trial states on a sphere is also resolved by showing that the short-range three-body pseudopotential coefficients are more sensitive to the surface curvature than the two-body ones (leading to a slow convergence of the overlaps as a function of the electron number). Hence, the MR state and its excitations are believed to be a more accurate description of the experimental $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{5}{2}$ quantum Hall states than could be inferred from previous, small-size calculations.
The family of ``Jack states'' related to antisymmetric Jack polynomials are the exact zero-energy ground states of particular model short-range many-body repulsive interactions, defined by a few nonvanishing leading pseudopotentials. Some Jack states are known or anticipated to accurately describe many-electron incompressible ground states emergent from the two-body Coulomb repulsion in the fractional quantum Hall effect. By extensive numerical diagonalization, we demonstrate the emergence of Jack states from suitable pair interactions. We find empirically a simple formula for the optimal two-body pseudopotentials for the series of most prominent Jack states generated by contact many-body repulsion. Furthermore, we seek a realization of arbitrary Jack states in realistic quantum Hall systems with Coulomb interaction, i.e., in the partially filled lowest and excited Landau levels in quasi-two-dimensional layers of conventional semiconductors such as GaAs or in graphene.
The electron correlations near the half-filling of the lowest and excited Landau levels (LL's) are studied using numerical diagonalization. It is shown that in the low-lying states electrons avoid pair states with relative angular momenta R\mathcal{R}R corresponding to positive anharmonicity of the interaction pseudopotential V(R).V(\mathcal{R}).V(R). In the lowest LL, the superharmonic behavior of V(R)V(\mathcal{R})V(R) causes Laughlin correlations (avoiding pairs with R=1)\mathcal{R}=1)R=1) and the Laughlin-Jain series of incompressible ground states. In the first excited LL, V(R)V(\mathcal{R})V(R) is harmonic at short range and a different series of incompressible states results. Similar correlations occur in the paired Moore-Read $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{5}{2}$ state and in the $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{7}{3}$ and 83\frac{8}{3}38​ states, all having small total parentage from R=1\mathcal{R}=1R=1 and 3 and large parentage from R=5.\mathcal{R}=5.R=5. The $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{7}{3}$ and 83\frac{8}{3}38​ states are different from Laughlin $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{1}{3}$ and 23\frac{2}{3}32​ states and, in finite systems, occur at a different LL degeneracy (flux). The series of Laughlin-correlated states of electron pairs at $\ensuremath{\nu}{=2+2/(q}_{2}+2)=\frac{8}{3},$ 52,\frac{5}{2},25​, 125,\frac{12}{5},512​, and 73\frac{7}{3}37​ is proposed, although only in the $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{5}{2}$ state pairing has been confirmed numerically. In the second excited LL, V(R)V(\mathcal{R})V(R) is subharmonic at short range and (near the half-filling) the electrons group into spatially separated larger $\ensuremath{\nu}=1$ droplets to minimize the number of strongly repulsive pair states at R=3\mathcal{R}=3R=3 and 5.