Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2605.31519

Entanglement in quantum channel discrimination: sometimes less is more

Kristin Sundal Lien, Marco Túlio Quintino

quant-phSubmitted May 29, 2026• Announced Jun 1, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Entanglement is known to be a powerful resource that improves performance in various quantum information and computational tasks. A standard example of such a phenomenon is the possibility of perfectly discriminating all four Pauli operations in a single shot via the superdense coding protocol. While entanglement is often a powerful resource for quantum channel discrimination, this is not necessarily the case. In this work, we identify scenarios in which the maximally entangled state is a bad choice of input state and, more generally, show that excessive entanglement can reduce channel discriminability dramatically. To do so, we present an explicit pair of unitary channels which are perfectly discriminable without entanglement, but for which any strategy with maximally entangled input states is $ε$-close to a blind uniform guessing strategy. To develop a systematic approach, we introduce the concepts of Maximal Entanglement Worst Case (MEWC) and Maximal Entanglement Best Case (MEBC) pairs of channels, and present conditions for a pair of channels to be MEWC or MEBC. With these conditions, we show that the optimal input states for discriminating MEWC pairs of channels are necessarily separable, and provide non-trivial examples of measurement channels for which entanglement necessarily reduces the maximum probability of discrimination.

Comments
17 pages, 7 figures, comments welcome

Related papers

Single shot distinguishability of noisy quantum channels

Satyaki Manna

Among the intriguing features of quantum theory, the problem of distinguishing quantum channels is of fundamental interest. In this paper, we focus on the single-shot discrimination of two noisy quantum channels using two distinct classes of probes: single-system (product) probes and entangled probes. Our aim is to identify optimal probing state for specific discrimination tasks and to analyze the necessity and role of entanglement in enhancing channel distinguishability. We show that maximally entangled probes are optimal for discriminating two qubit depolarizing channels, with any nonzero entanglement providing an advantage over single-system probes. In contrast, for dephasing channels in arbitrary dimensions, we prove that single-system probe can be optimal and that entanglement offers no improvement, even when the dephasing unitary is generalized. For qubit amplitude-damping channels, we identify distinct noise-dependent regimes in which either single-system probe outperforms maximally entangled probes and vice-versa. Moreover, we demonstrate that non-maximally entangled probes can act as the optimum probe if the noise parameters restricted to certain values in this task. We also present examples of noisy unitary channels for which discrimination is possible using non-maximally entangled probe, while both single-systems and maximally entangled probes fail. We introduce another class of noisy unitary channels for which perfect discrimination is achievable with a single system, while maximally entangled probes are insufficient. Finally, we show that two erasure channels can be optimally discriminated using any pure single-system probe, with no advantage gained from entanglement.

quant-pharXiv:2602.05521•Feb 6, 2026•2 citations

Entanglement in channel discrimination with restricted measurements

William Matthews, Marco Piani, John Watrous

We study the power of measurements implementable with local quantum operations and classical communication (LOCC) measurements in the setting of quantum channel discrimination. More precisely, we consider discrimination procedures that attempt to identify an unknown channel, chosen uniformly from two known alternatives, that take the following form: (i) the input to the unknown channel is prepared in a possibly entangled state with an ancillary system, (ii) the unknown channel is applied to the input system, and (iii) an LOCC measurement is performed on the output and ancillary systems, resulting in a guess for which of the two channels was given. The restriction of the measurement in such a procedure to be an LOCC measurement is of interest because it isolates the entanglement in the initial input-ancillary systems as a resource in the setting of channel discrimination. We prove that there exist channel discrimination problems for which restricted procedures of this sort can be at either of the two extremes: they may be optimal within the set of all discrimination procedures (and simultaneously outperform all strategies that make no use of entanglement), or they may be no better than unentangled strategies (and simultaneously suboptimal within the set of all discrimination procedures).

arXiv:1004.0888•Physical Review A•Sep 7, 2010•33 citations

Minimum error discrimination of Pauli channels

M F Sacchi

We solve the problem of discriminating with minimum error probability two given Pauli channels. We show that, unlike in the case of discrimination between unitary transformations, the use of entanglement with an ancillary system can strictly improve the discrimination, and any maximally entangled state allows one to achieve the optimal discrimination. We also provide a simple necessary and sufficient condition in terms of the structure of the channels for which the ultimate minimum error probability can be achieved without entanglement assistance. When such a condition is satisfied, the optimal input state is simply an eigenstate of one of the Pauli matrices.

arXiv:quant-ph/0506072•Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Sep 21, 2005•24 citations

Entanglement in single-shot quantum channel discrimination

Daniel Puzzuoli

Single-shot quantum channel discrimination is the fundamental task of determining, given only a single use, which of two known quantum channels is acting on a system. In this thesis we investigate the well-known phenomenon that entanglement to an auxiliary system can provide an advantage in this task. In particular, we consider the questions: (1) How much entanglement is in general necessary to achieve an optimal discrimination strategy? (2) What is the maximal advantage provided by entanglement? \n \nGiven a linear map Ψ : L(Cn) → L(Cm), its multiplicity maps are defined as the family of linear maps Ψ ⊗ 1L(Ck) : L(Cn ⊗ Ck) → L(Cm ⊗ Ck), where 1L(Ck) is the identity on L(Ck). Due to the Holevo-Helstrom theorem, the optimal performance using an auxiliary system of dimension k is quantified in terms of the norm of Ψ⊗1L(Ck), where Ψ is a linear map that depends on the parameters of the discrimination problem. Hence, the advantage provided by entanglement is represented in the growth of the norm of Ψ ⊗ 1L(Ck ) with k, a classic phenomenon in the theory of operator algebras. \n \nWe formalize question (1) by investigating, relative to the input and output dimensions of the channels to be discriminated, how large of an auxiliary system is necessary to achieve an optimal strategy. Mathematically, this is connected to when the norm of Ψ ⊗ 1L(Ck) stops growing with k. It is well- known that an auxiliary system of dimension equal to the input is always sufficient to achieve an optimal strategy, and that this is sometimes necessary when the output dimension is at least as large as the input. We prove that, even when the output dimension is arbitrarily small compared to the input, it is still sometimes necessary to use an auxiliary system as large as the input to achieve an optimal strategy. \n \nFor question (2), we investigate, with respect to a fixed input dimension, how large the gap between the optimal performances with and without entanglement can be. Mathematically, this is quantified by the rate of growth of the norm of Ψ ⊗ 1L(Ck ) in k. It is known that matrix transposition has the fastest possible growth, and we prove that it is essentially the unique linear map with this property. We use this to prove that a discrimination problem defined in terms of the Werner-Holevo channels is essentially the unique game satisfying a norm relation that states that the game can be won with certainty using entanglement, but is hard to win without entanglement. \n \nAlong the way, we prove characterizations of the structure of maximal entanglement, as measured according to the entanglement negativity, as well as relative to a large class of entanglement measures. We also give various characterizations of complete trace-norm isometries, and reversible quantum channels.

•Aug 30, 2018•0 citations

Minimum error discrimination of Pauli channels

Massimiliano Federico Sacchi

We solve the problem of discriminating with minimum error probability two given Pauli channels. We show that, differently from the case of discrimination between unitary transformations, the use of entanglement with an ancillary system can strictly improve the discrimination, and any maximally entangled state allows to achieve the optimal discrimination. We also provide a simple necessary and sufficient condition in terms of the structure of the channels for which the ultimate minimum error probability can be achieved without entanglement assistance. When such a condition is satisfied, the optimal input state is simply an eigenstate of one of the Pauli matrices.

•Jun 9, 2005•17 citations

Entanglement cost of bipartite quantum channel discrimination under positive partial transpose operations

Chengkai Zhu, Shuyu He, Gereon Koßmann +1 more

Quantum channel discrimination is a fundamental task in quantum information processing. In the one-shot regime, discrimination between two candidate channels is characterized by the diamond norm. Beyond this basic setting, however, many scenarios in distributed quantum information processing remain unresolved, motivating notions of distinguishability that capture the power of the available resources. In this work, we formulate a theory of testers for bipartite channel discrimination, leading to the concept of the entanglement cost of bipartite channel discrimination: the minimum Schmidt rank $k$ of a shared maximally entangled state required for local protocols to achieve the globally optimal success probability. We introduce $k$-injectable testers as a tester-based description of entanglement-assisted local discrimination and, in particular, study the class of $k$-injectable positive-partial-transpose (PPT) testers, which constitutes a numerically tractable relaxation of the practically relevant class of LOCC testers. For every $k$, we derive a semidefinite program (SDP) for the optimal success probability, which in turn yields an efficiently computable one-shot PPT entanglement cost. To render these optimization problems numerically feasible, we prove a symmetry-reduction principle for covariant channel pairs, thereby reducing the effective dimension of the associated SDPs. Finally, by dualizing the SDP, we derive bounds on the composite channel-discrimination problem and illustrate our framework with proof-of-principle examples based on the depolarizing channel, the depolarized SWAP channel, and the Werner--Holevo channels.

quant-pharXiv:2603.12130•Mar 13, 2026•0 citations
Entanglement is known to be a powerful resource that improves performance in various quantum information and computational tasks. A standard example of such a phenomenon is the possibility of perfectly discriminating all four Pauli operations in a single shot via the superdense coding protocol. While entanglement is often a powerful resource for quantum channel discrimination, this is not necessarily the case. In this work, we identify scenarios in which the maximally entangled state is a bad choice of input state and, more generally, show that excessive entanglement can reduce channel discriminability dramatically. To do so, we present an explicit pair of unitary channels which are perfectly discriminable without entanglement, but for which any strategy with maximally entangled input states is εεε-close to a blind uniform guessing strategy. To develop a systematic approach, we introduce the concepts of Maximal Entanglement Worst Case (MEWC) and Maximal Entanglement Best Case (MEBC) pairs of channels, and present conditions for a pair of channels to be MEWC or MEBC. With these conditions, we show that the optimal input states for discriminating MEWC pairs of channels are necessarily separable, and provide non-trivial examples of measurement channels for which entanglement necessarily reduces the maximum probability of discrimination.
Among the intriguing features of quantum theory, the problem of distinguishing quantum channels is of fundamental interest. In this paper, we focus on the single-shot discrimination of two noisy quantum channels using two distinct classes of probes: single-system (product) probes and entangled probes. Our aim is to identify optimal probing state for specific discrimination tasks and to analyze the necessity and role of entanglement in enhancing channel distinguishability. We show that maximally entangled probes are optimal for discriminating two qubit depolarizing channels, with any nonzero entanglement providing an advantage over single-system probes. In contrast, for dephasing channels in arbitrary dimensions, we prove that single-system probe can be optimal and that entanglement offers no improvement, even when the dephasing unitary is generalized. For qubit amplitude-damping channels, we identify distinct noise-dependent regimes in which either single-system probe outperforms maximally entangled probes and vice-versa. Moreover, we demonstrate that non-maximally entangled probes can act as the optimum probe if the noise parameters restricted to certain values in this task. We also present examples of noisy unitary channels for which discrimination is possible using non-maximally entangled probe, while both single-systems and maximally entangled probes fail. We introduce another class of noisy unitary channels for which perfect discrimination is achievable with a single system, while maximally entangled probes are insufficient. Finally, we show that two erasure channels can be optimally discriminated using any pure single-system probe, with no advantage gained from entanglement.
We study the power of measurements implementable with local quantum operations and classical communication (LOCC) measurements in the setting of quantum channel discrimination. More precisely, we consider discrimination procedures that attempt to identify an unknown channel, chosen uniformly from two known alternatives, that take the following form: (i) the input to the unknown channel is prepared in a possibly entangled state with an ancillary system, (ii) the unknown channel is applied to the input system, and (iii) an LOCC measurement is performed on the output and ancillary systems, resulting in a guess for which of the two channels was given. The restriction of the measurement in such a procedure to be an LOCC measurement is of interest because it isolates the entanglement in the initial input-ancillary systems as a resource in the setting of channel discrimination. We prove that there exist channel discrimination problems for which restricted procedures of this sort can be at either of the two extremes: they may be optimal within the set of all discrimination procedures (and simultaneously outperform all strategies that make no use of entanglement), or they may be no better than unentangled strategies (and simultaneously suboptimal within the set of all discrimination procedures).
We solve the problem of discriminating with minimum error probability two given Pauli channels. We show that, unlike in the case of discrimination between unitary transformations, the use of entanglement with an ancillary system can strictly improve the discrimination, and any maximally entangled state allows one to achieve the optimal discrimination. We also provide a simple necessary and sufficient condition in terms of the structure of the channels for which the ultimate minimum error probability can be achieved without entanglement assistance. When such a condition is satisfied, the optimal input state is simply an eigenstate of one of the Pauli matrices.
Single-shot quantum channel discrimination is the fundamental task of determining, given only a single use, which of two known quantum channels is acting on a system. In this thesis we investigate the well-known phenomenon that entanglement to an auxiliary system can provide an advantage in this task. In particular, we consider the questions: (1) How much entanglement is in general necessary to achieve an optimal discrimination strategy? (2) What is the maximal advantage provided by entanglement? \n \nGiven a linear map Ψ : L(Cn) → L(Cm), its multiplicity maps are defined as the family of linear maps Ψ ⊗ 1L(Ck) : L(Cn ⊗ Ck) → L(Cm ⊗ Ck), where 1L(Ck) is the identity on L(Ck). Due to the Holevo-Helstrom theorem, the optimal performance using an auxiliary system of dimension k is quantified in terms of the norm of Ψ⊗1L(Ck), where Ψ is a linear map that depends on the parameters of the discrimination problem. Hence, the advantage provided by entanglement is represented in the growth of the norm of Ψ ⊗ 1L(Ck ) with k, a classic phenomenon in the theory of operator algebras. \n \nWe formalize question (1) by investigating, relative to the input and output dimensions of the channels to be discriminated, how large of an auxiliary system is necessary to achieve an optimal strategy. Mathematically, this is connected to when the norm of Ψ ⊗ 1L(Ck) stops growing with k. It is well- known that an auxiliary system of dimension equal to the input is always sufficient to achieve an optimal strategy, and that this is sometimes necessary when the output dimension is at least as large as the input. We prove that, even when the output dimension is arbitrarily small compared to the input, it is still sometimes necessary to use an auxiliary system as large as the input to achieve an optimal strategy. \n \nFor question (2), we investigate, with respect to a fixed input dimension, how large the gap between the optimal performances with and without entanglement can be. Mathematically, this is quantified by the rate of growth of the norm of Ψ ⊗ 1L(Ck ) in k. It is known that matrix transposition has the fastest possible growth, and we prove that it is essentially the unique linear map with this property. We use this to prove that a discrimination problem defined in terms of the Werner-Holevo channels is essentially the unique game satisfying a norm relation that states that the game can be won with certainty using entanglement, but is hard to win without entanglement. \n \nAlong the way, we prove characterizations of the structure of maximal entanglement, as measured according to the entanglement negativity, as well as relative to a large class of entanglement measures. We also give various characterizations of complete trace-norm isometries, and reversible quantum channels.
We solve the problem of discriminating with minimum error probability two given Pauli channels. We show that, differently from the case of discrimination between unitary transformations, the use of entanglement with an ancillary system can strictly improve the discrimination, and any maximally entangled state allows to achieve the optimal discrimination. We also provide a simple necessary and sufficient condition in terms of the structure of the channels for which the ultimate minimum error probability can be achieved without entanglement assistance. When such a condition is satisfied, the optimal input state is simply an eigenstate of one of the Pauli matrices.
Quantum channel discrimination is a fundamental task in quantum information processing. In the one-shot regime, discrimination between two candidate channels is characterized by the diamond norm. Beyond this basic setting, however, many scenarios in distributed quantum information processing remain unresolved, motivating notions of distinguishability that capture the power of the available resources. In this work, we formulate a theory of testers for bipartite channel discrimination, leading to the concept of the entanglement cost of bipartite channel discrimination: the minimum Schmidt rank kkk of a shared maximally entangled state required for local protocols to achieve the globally optimal success probability. We introduce kkk-injectable testers as a tester-based description of entanglement-assisted local discrimination and, in particular, study the class of kkk-injectable positive-partial-transpose (PPT) testers, which constitutes a numerically tractable relaxation of the practically relevant class of LOCC testers. For every kkk, we derive a semidefinite program (SDP) for the optimal success probability, which in turn yields an efficiently computable one-shot PPT entanglement cost. To render these optimization problems numerically feasible, we prove a symmetry-reduction principle for covariant channel pairs, thereby reducing the effective dimension of the associated SDPs. Finally, by dualizing the SDP, we derive bounds on the composite channel-discrimination problem and illustrate our framework with proof-of-principle examples based on the depolarizing channel, the depolarized SWAP channel, and the Werner--Holevo channels.