Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2605.30967

Evaluating higher-order product formulae for molecular ground-state energy estimation

Hiromu Abe, Keita Kanno, Ryosuke Kimura, Masahiko Kamoshita, Kosuke Mitarai

quant-phSubmitted May 29, 2026• Announced Jun 1, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We evaluate deterministic higher-order product formulae for molecular ground-state energy estimation. Motivated by recent fault-tolerant architectures in which non-Clifford operations may be generated more locally and cheaply than in conventional assumptions, we re-examine such formulae as practical candidates for quantum chemistry. Using one-dimensional hydrogen chains from $\mathrm{H}_2$ to $\mathrm{H}_{15}$ as benchmarks, we estimate both the total gate count and the depth of $R_Z$-rotation layers required to reach a target energy error. To make this comparison feasible at larger system sizes, we use a perturbative method to estimate the eigenvalue error induced by each product formula and thereby evaluate the cost of the corresponding phase-estimation procedure. Among the previously considered formulae, the eighth-order construction introduced by Morales et al. [M. E. S. Morales et al., "Greatly improved higher-order product formulae for quantum simulation," arXiv:2210.15817v2 (2024)] minimizes both cost metrics in the benchmark at a chemically relevant target error. We also find that increasing the formal order does not automatically reduce the total cost: near chemical accuracy, the tenth-order formula introduced in the same work can be less efficient than the eighth-order one. Motivated by this observation, we construct a new fourth-order formula; it achieves the lowest total gate count among the formulae considered for all H-chain instances near chemical accuracy and over much of the 0.1-10 mHa target-error window for most instances, while also reducing the $R_Z$-layer depth. These results clarify how deterministic higher-order product formulae should be selected for molecular ground-state energy estimation.

Comments
12 pages, 11 figures

Related papers

Quantum computation, quantum chemistry and Hamiltonian moments

Michael Alexander Jones

While sufficiently large and accurate quantum computers are expected to exploit quantum effects such as superposition and entanglement to gain an advantage over their classical counterparts for specific problems, it is unclear whether near- and medium-term quantum devices can provide such an advantage. For the problem of ground-state energy estimation, which is of particular interest as a first step into quantum chemistry, small-scale proof-of-principle experiments have been performed on current noisy devices, but scaling to larger problem instances has been hindered by noise inherent in today's quantum hardware making it difficult to achieve the required precision. In this thesis, we investigate the use of Hamiltonian moments for improving on ground-state energy estimates from quantum devices, finding that the additional information incorporated into moments-corrected ground-state energy estimates allows accuracy beyond what would normally be possible for a given quantum circuit depth. This, combined with the inherent error robustness of the moments-based method, allowed us to perform calculations for Hydrogen chains beyond the Hartree-Fock approximation (Chapter 2), and subsequently, the largest quantum chemical calculation to date to achieve millihartree accuracy on existing quantum hardware (Chapter 3) - computing the ground-state energy of the water molecule on 8 qubits. We then consider extensions to the moments-based method allowing for estimation of non-energetic properties, obtaining the electric dipole moment of the water molecule to an error of 2% (Chapter 4) and qualitatively accurate molecular forces over a range of molecular geometries from a single quantum calculation (Chapter 5). Finally, we examine the scaling of the Hamiltonian moments evaluation through three different methods and verify the analytic results with numerical simulation (Chapter 6). While the methods do not scale as well as quantum phase estimation in the asymptotic limit, and further work is needed to provide concrete resource estimates, the hope is that the required circuit depths will be more reasonable for early fault-tolerant quantum devices.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Quantum algorithm for ground state energy estimation using circuit depth with exponentially improved dependence on precision

Guoming Wang, Daniel Stilck França, Ruizhe Zhang +2 more

A milestone in the field of quantum computing will be solving problems in quantum chemistry and materials faster than state-of-the-art classical methods. The current understanding is that achieving quantum advantage in this area will require some degree of fault tolerance. While hardware is improving towards this milestone, optimizing quantum algorithms also brings it closer to the present. Existing methods for ground state energy estimation are costly in that they require a number of gates per circuit that grows exponentially with the desired number of bits in precision. We reduce this cost exponentially, by developing a ground state energy estimation algorithm for which this cost grows linearly in the number of bits of precision. Relative to recent resource estimates of ground state energy estimation for the industrially-relevant molecules of ethylene-carbonate and PF 6 − , the estimated gate count and circuit depth is reduced by a factor of 43 and 78, respectively. Furthermore, the algorithm can use additional circuit depth to reduce the total runtime. These features make our algorithm a promising candidate for realizing quantum advantage in the era of early fault-tolerant quantum computing.

arXiv:2209.06811•Quantum•Nov 6, 2023•78 citations

Energy Accuracy Is Not Enough: A Structure-Aware Benchmark and Evaluation Protocol for Quantum Architecture Search

Jiayang Niu, Akib Karim, Yan Wang +5 more

Quantum architecture search for molecular ground-state estimation is commonly evaluated through energy accuracy, which does not describe circuit cost or the physical properties of the prepared state. We introduce HamQASBench, a structure-aware benchmark comprising eleven molecular Hamiltonians of up to fourteen qubits, selected using Hamiltonian and target-state properties and supplied with exact references. Its evaluation protocol combines energy accuracy and success rates with reference-relative circuit cost, local entropy profiles for non-degenerate targets, and state identification within degenerate ground subspaces. Experiments with five methods spanning four search paradigms reveal differences hidden by energy-only comparisons. On a near-product instance under the shallow search budget, the best outputs of all five methods reach chemical accuracy while using between two and sixty-two gates. Equal-energy outputs on a degenerate instance occupy distinct spin components. Local entropy profiles distinguish inaccurate outputs and show that entangling-gate counts need not reflect realized entanglement. Across the molecular instance ladder, product-state outputs can meet or miss chemical accuracy, motivating interpretation of success alongside target-state properties. These results support retaining energy as the task-success criterion while using circuit-cost and state diagnostics for more informative comparisons. The benchmark instances, references, evaluation implementation, and per-run data are released for reuse.

quant-pharXiv:2607.04845•Jul 7, 2026•2 citations

High-precision Quantum Phase Estimation on a Trapped-ion Quantum Computer

Tranter, Andrew, Gowland, Duncan, Yamamoto, Kentaro +2 more

Emergent quantum computing technologies are widely expected to provide novel approaches in the simulation of quantum chemistry. Despite rapid improvements in the scale and fidelity of quantum computers, high resource requirements make the execution of quantum chemistry experiments challenging. Typical experiments are limited in the number of qubits used, incur a substantial shot cost, or require complex architecture-specific optimization and error mitigation techniques. In this paper, we propose a conceptually simple benchmarking approach involving the use of multi-ancilla quantum phase estimation. Our approach is restricted to very small chemical systems, and does not scale favorably beyond molecular systems that can be described with $2$ qubits; however, this restriction allows us to generate circuits that scale quadratically in gate count with the number of qubits in the readout register. This enables the execution of quantum chemistry circuits that act on many qubits, while producing meaningful results with limited shot counts. We use this technique (with $200$ shots per experiment) to calculate the ground state energy of molecular hydrogen to $50$ bits of precision ($8.9 \times 10^{-16}$ hartree) on a $56$-qubit trapped-ion quantum computer, negating Trotter error. Including Trotter error, we obtain between $32$ and $36$ bits of precision ($1.5 * 10^{-10}$ and $6.0 * 10^{-11}$ hartree respectively), vastly exceeding chemical accuracy ($1.6 * 10^{-3}$ hartree) against Full Configuration Interaction. We consider application of the approach to deeper circuits, and discuss potential as a benchmark task for near-term quantum devices.

arXiv:2506.17207•Jun 20, 2025•6 citations

Better product formulas for quantum phase estimation

Kasra Hejazi, Soni, Jay, Modjtaba Shokrian Zini +1 more

Quantum phase estimation requires simulating the evolution of the Hamiltonian, for which product formulas are attractive due to their smaller qubit cost and ease of implementation. However, the estimation of the error incurred by product formulas is usually pessimistic and task-agnostic, which poses problems for assessing their performance in practice for problems of interest. In this work, we study the error of product formulas for the specific task of quantum energy estimation. To this end, we employ the theory of Trotter error with a Magnus-based expansion of the effectively simulated Hamiltonian. The result is a generalization of previous energy estimation error analysis of gapped eigenstates to arbitrary order product formulas. As an application, we discover a 9-term second-order product formula with an energy estimation error that is quadratically better than Trotter-Suzuki. Furthermore, by leveraging recent work on low-energy dynamics of product formulas, we provide tighter bounds for energy estimation error in the low-energy subspace. We show that for Hamiltonians with some locality and positivity properties, the cost can achieve up to a quadratic asymptotic speedup in terms of the target error.

arXiv:2412.16811•Dec 22, 2024•4 citations

Quantum algorithm for weakly correlated molecular electronic ground states with sub-quintic scaling in the system size

Oskar Leimkuhler, Marvin Kronenberger, Davide Castaldo +8 more

Weakly correlated electronic structures are predominant among molecules, and are routinely solved with heuristic classical methods such as the ``gold standard'' CCSD(T) coupled cluster model, incurring a formal time complexity $O(n^7)$ in the number of molecular orbitals and with no guarantee of energy error $\varepsilon$ at or below chemical accuracy. In this work, a quantum algorithm is presented for ground state energy estimation of weakly correlated molecules using Trotterized time evolution, with an end-to-end quantum operations cost that scales as $\tilde{O}(n^{4.8}/\varepsilon^2)$ in the limit of high-order product formulae when run as a low-depth, shot-noise limited algorithm, or $\tilde{O}(n^{4.8} + n^{3.8}/\varepsilon)$ when scaling the simulation time $T\propto 1/\varepsilon$. The algorithm combines adiabatic state preparation using a smoothed Gevrey schedule with eigenstate filtering via quantum prolate diagonalization (QPD). Both steps of the algorithm rely on a size-independent spectral gap assumption, which is validated by numerical studies on alanine chains with up to 64 monomers. We benchmark the performance of our eigenstate filtering algorithm on a set of 28 molecules to compare our approach against prior phase estimation algorithms, finding that QPD achieves state-of-the-art cost tradeoffs for $\varepsilon$-accurate results. Physical quantum resource estimates are obtained for running Trotter step circuits with up to 40 spin-orbitals, providing a clear path for scaling up quantum simulation of chemistry on early fault-tolerant hardware.

quant-pharXiv:2611.00751•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations
We evaluate deterministic higher-order product formulae for molecular ground-state energy estimation. Motivated by recent fault-tolerant architectures in which non-Clifford operations may be generated more locally and cheaply than in conventional assumptions, we re-examine such formulae as practical candidates for quantum chemistry. Using one-dimensional hydrogen chains from H2\mathrm{H}_2H2​ to H15\mathrm{H}_{15}H15​ as benchmarks, we estimate both the total gate count and the depth of RZR_ZRZ​-rotation layers required to reach a target energy error. To make this comparison feasible at larger system sizes, we use a perturbative method to estimate the eigenvalue error induced by each product formula and thereby evaluate the cost of the corresponding phase-estimation procedure. Among the previously considered formulae, the eighth-order construction introduced by Morales et al. [M. E. S. Morales et al., "Greatly improved higher-order product formulae for quantum simulation," arXiv:2210.15817v2 (2024)] minimizes both cost metrics in the benchmark at a chemically relevant target error. We also find that increasing the formal order does not automatically reduce the total cost: near chemical accuracy, the tenth-order formula introduced in the same work can be less efficient than the eighth-order one. Motivated by this observation, we construct a new fourth-order formula; it achieves the lowest total gate count among the formulae considered for all H-chain instances near chemical accuracy and over much of the 0.1-10 mHa target-error window for most instances, while also reducing the RZR_ZRZ​-layer depth. These results clarify how deterministic higher-order product formulae should be selected for molecular ground-state energy estimation.
While sufficiently large and accurate quantum computers are expected to exploit quantum effects such as superposition and entanglement to gain an advantage over their classical counterparts for specific problems, it is unclear whether near- and medium-term quantum devices can provide such an advantage. For the problem of ground-state energy estimation, which is of particular interest as a first step into quantum chemistry, small-scale proof-of-principle experiments have been performed on current noisy devices, but scaling to larger problem instances has been hindered by noise inherent in today's quantum hardware making it difficult to achieve the required precision. In this thesis, we investigate the use of Hamiltonian moments for improving on ground-state energy estimates from quantum devices, finding that the additional information incorporated into moments-corrected ground-state energy estimates allows accuracy beyond what would normally be possible for a given quantum circuit depth. This, combined with the inherent error robustness of the moments-based method, allowed us to perform calculations for Hydrogen chains beyond the Hartree-Fock approximation (Chapter 2), and subsequently, the largest quantum chemical calculation to date to achieve millihartree accuracy on existing quantum hardware (Chapter 3) - computing the ground-state energy of the water molecule on 8 qubits. We then consider extensions to the moments-based method allowing for estimation of non-energetic properties, obtaining the electric dipole moment of the water molecule to an error of 2% (Chapter 4) and qualitatively accurate molecular forces over a range of molecular geometries from a single quantum calculation (Chapter 5). Finally, we examine the scaling of the Hamiltonian moments evaluation through three different methods and verify the analytic results with numerical simulation (Chapter 6). While the methods do not scale as well as quantum phase estimation in the asymptotic limit, and further work is needed to provide concrete resource estimates, the hope is that the required circuit depths will be more reasonable for early fault-tolerant quantum devices.
A milestone in the field of quantum computing will be solving problems in quantum chemistry and materials faster than state-of-the-art classical methods. The current understanding is that achieving quantum advantage in this area will require some degree of fault tolerance. While hardware is improving towards this milestone, optimizing quantum algorithms also brings it closer to the present. Existing methods for ground state energy estimation are costly in that they require a number of gates per circuit that grows exponentially with the desired number of bits in precision. We reduce this cost exponentially, by developing a ground state energy estimation algorithm for which this cost grows linearly in the number of bits of precision. Relative to recent resource estimates of ground state energy estimation for the industrially-relevant molecules of ethylene-carbonate and PF 6 − , the estimated gate count and circuit depth is reduced by a factor of 43 and 78, respectively. Furthermore, the algorithm can use additional circuit depth to reduce the total runtime. These features make our algorithm a promising candidate for realizing quantum advantage in the era of early fault-tolerant quantum computing.
Quantum architecture search for molecular ground-state estimation is commonly evaluated through energy accuracy, which does not describe circuit cost or the physical properties of the prepared state. We introduce HamQASBench, a structure-aware benchmark comprising eleven molecular Hamiltonians of up to fourteen qubits, selected using Hamiltonian and target-state properties and supplied with exact references. Its evaluation protocol combines energy accuracy and success rates with reference-relative circuit cost, local entropy profiles for non-degenerate targets, and state identification within degenerate ground subspaces. Experiments with five methods spanning four search paradigms reveal differences hidden by energy-only comparisons. On a near-product instance under the shallow search budget, the best outputs of all five methods reach chemical accuracy while using between two and sixty-two gates. Equal-energy outputs on a degenerate instance occupy distinct spin components. Local entropy profiles distinguish inaccurate outputs and show that entangling-gate counts need not reflect realized entanglement. Across the molecular instance ladder, product-state outputs can meet or miss chemical accuracy, motivating interpretation of success alongside target-state properties. These results support retaining energy as the task-success criterion while using circuit-cost and state diagnostics for more informative comparisons. The benchmark instances, references, evaluation implementation, and per-run data are released for reuse.
Emergent quantum computing technologies are widely expected to provide novel approaches in the simulation of quantum chemistry. Despite rapid improvements in the scale and fidelity of quantum computers, high resource requirements make the execution of quantum chemistry experiments challenging. Typical experiments are limited in the number of qubits used, incur a substantial shot cost, or require complex architecture-specific optimization and error mitigation techniques. In this paper, we propose a conceptually simple benchmarking approach involving the use of multi-ancilla quantum phase estimation. Our approach is restricted to very small chemical systems, and does not scale favorably beyond molecular systems that can be described with 222 qubits; however, this restriction allows us to generate circuits that scale quadratically in gate count with the number of qubits in the readout register. This enables the execution of quantum chemistry circuits that act on many qubits, while producing meaningful results with limited shot counts. We use this technique (with 200200200 shots per experiment) to calculate the ground state energy of molecular hydrogen to 505050 bits of precision (8.9×10−168.9 \times 10^{-16}8.9×10−16 hartree) on a 565656-qubit trapped-ion quantum computer, negating Trotter error. Including Trotter error, we obtain between 323232 and 363636 bits of precision (1.5∗10−101.5 * 10^{-10}1.5∗10−10 and 6.0∗10−116.0 * 10^{-11}6.0∗10−11 hartree respectively), vastly exceeding chemical accuracy (1.6∗10−31.6 * 10^{-3}1.6∗10−3 hartree) against Full Configuration Interaction. We consider application of the approach to deeper circuits, and discuss potential as a benchmark task for near-term quantum devices.
Quantum phase estimation requires simulating the evolution of the Hamiltonian, for which product formulas are attractive due to their smaller qubit cost and ease of implementation. However, the estimation of the error incurred by product formulas is usually pessimistic and task-agnostic, which poses problems for assessing their performance in practice for problems of interest. In this work, we study the error of product formulas for the specific task of quantum energy estimation. To this end, we employ the theory of Trotter error with a Magnus-based expansion of the effectively simulated Hamiltonian. The result is a generalization of previous energy estimation error analysis of gapped eigenstates to arbitrary order product formulas. As an application, we discover a 9-term second-order product formula with an energy estimation error that is quadratically better than Trotter-Suzuki. Furthermore, by leveraging recent work on low-energy dynamics of product formulas, we provide tighter bounds for energy estimation error in the low-energy subspace. We show that for Hamiltonians with some locality and positivity properties, the cost can achieve up to a quadratic asymptotic speedup in terms of the target error.
Weakly correlated electronic structures are predominant among molecules, and are routinely solved with heuristic classical methods such as the ``gold standard'' CCSD(T) coupled cluster model, incurring a formal time complexity O(n7)O(n^7)O(n7) in the number of molecular orbitals and with no guarantee of energy error ε\varepsilonε at or below chemical accuracy. In this work, a quantum algorithm is presented for ground state energy estimation of weakly correlated molecules using Trotterized time evolution, with an end-to-end quantum operations cost that scales as O~(n4.8/ε2)\tilde{O}(n^{4.8}/\varepsilon^2)O~(n4.8/ε2) in the limit of high-order product formulae when run as a low-depth, shot-noise limited algorithm, or O~(n4.8+n3.8/ε)\tilde{O}(n^{4.8} + n^{3.8}/\varepsilon)O~(n4.8+n3.8/ε) when scaling the simulation time T∝1/εT\propto 1/\varepsilonT∝1/ε. The algorithm combines adiabatic state preparation using a smoothed Gevrey schedule with eigenstate filtering via quantum prolate diagonalization (QPD). Both steps of the algorithm rely on a size-independent spectral gap assumption, which is validated by numerical studies on alanine chains with up to 64 monomers. We benchmark the performance of our eigenstate filtering algorithm on a set of 28 molecules to compare our approach against prior phase estimation algorithms, finding that QPD achieves state-of-the-art cost tradeoffs for ε\varepsilonε-accurate results. Physical quantum resource estimates are obtained for running Trotter step circuits with up to 40 spin-orbitals, providing a clear path for scaling up quantum simulation of chemistry on early fault-tolerant hardware.