Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2605.30165

Tunneling phase diagram: A machine-learning framework for multidimensional kinetic isotope effects

Xinrui Yang, Zhigang Wang

quant-phphysics.chem-phphysics.comp-phSubmitted May 28, 2026• Announced May 29, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The kinetic isotope effect (KIE) is the conventional probe for quantum tunneling, yet its composite nature conflates tunneling with zero-point energy and classical kinetics. Here, we introduce the tunneling phase diagram, a machine-learning framework that decouples true tunneling strength by decoding the nonlinear relationship between KIE and the tunneling factor (\k{appa}). With exceptional fidelity (R^2 > 0.98, RMSE = 0.21), this framework reveals an anomalous high KIE-low \k{appa} spanning 300-600 K, thereby defining a paradigm for the quantitative assessment of quantum tunneling.

Comments
17 pages, 7 figures

Related papers

Quantum Tunneling as a Transition of Observation Conditions

SHUHEI CORMIER

This paper proposes an alternative interpretation of quantum tunneling within the framework of TIMED THEORY.Rather than treating tunneling as a particle’s penetration through an energy barrier, we argue thattunneling is the ability of a particle to exist without leaving an observable record in regions where observation conditions are fundamentally unstable. We define such regions as the jari-michi (gravel road): domains in which the coordinate and time axes fail to stabilize long enough to form persistent measurement records.Within this framework, particle mass and de Broglie wavelength determine observability, which in turn governs whether a particle can enter and traverse these regions. Using published kinetic isotope effect (KIE) data from enzyme-catalyzed reactions — where hydrogen exhibits strong tunneling contributions while deuterium does not — we show that these experimental results are naturally explained by an observability-based mechanism rather than by wavefunction decay alone. This work does not reject the mathematical formalism of standard quantum mechanics.Instead, it reinterprets the physical mechanism underlying tunneling, reframing it as observational evasion rather than barrier penetration.The proposed framework offers new insight into why hydrogen occupies a unique tunneling “sweet spot” under ambient conditions and clarifies the minimal physical requirements for observation to occur. 本稿は、量子トンネリングを「粒子がエネルギー障壁を貫通する現象」とみなす標準的解釈に対し、トンネリングとは観測条件が不安定な領域において、粒子が観測記録を残さずに存在できる性質であるという代替的枠組みを、TIMED THEORYに基づいて提示する。 本研究では、座標軸および時間軸が安定した観測足場を形成できない領域を「砂利道(jari-michi)」として定義し、質量・ド・ブロイ波長・観測可能性の関係が、トンネリング現象をどのように制御しているかを示す。 特に、酵素触媒反応における速度論的同位体効果(Kinetic Isotope Effect, KIE)の公開データ——水素は効率的にトンネリングするが、重水素は著しく抑制される——が、本枠組みにより自然に説明できることを論証する。 本稿は、標準量子力学の数学的記述を否定するものではない。しかし、トンネリングを「透過」ではなく「観測回避」として再定義することで、水素が室温条件において特異的なトンネリング粒子となる理由、および観測事象が成立する物理的最小条件について、新たな解釈可能性を与える。

•Feb 10, 2026•0 citations

A Classical Explanation of Quantum Tunneling: An Energy Transfer Model Based on Electron Collisions

Fan Xie

This paper proposes a classical alternative explanation for the tunneling effect in quantum mechanics. Standard quantum theory describes tunneling as a particle "penetrating" a potential barrier whose energy exceeds the particle's own kinetic energy with a certain probability. However, this explanation focuses only on the mathematical initial and final states, completely ignoring any dynamical process the electron may undergo before the barrier, and lacks a physical picture. This paper argues that tunneling is not an intrinsic quantum property of a single electron, but rather a collective statistical fluctuation event involving multiple electrons: electrons near the barrier, through a series of random collisions in the correct direction, gradually transfer and concentrate kinetic energy onto the electron closest to the barrier, enabling it to instantaneously acquire kinetic energy exceeding the barrier threshold and thus classically fly over the barrier. During the crossing, the electron must do work against the barrier, converting kinetic energy into potential energy; therefore, after crossing, its kinetic energy is reduced and it cannot cross the same barrier again. Tunneling probability is reinterpreted as the success probability of such a "directed energy relay" event. This model is fully self-consistent within the framework of classical electromagnetism and statistical mechanics, requiring no wave functions or probability waves, with a clear physical picture and explicit causal chain. This paper further points out that under strictly single-electron conditions, this model predicts that tunneling will completely disappear, a prediction that stands in fundamental opposition to the standard quantum model and can serve as a decisive experiment to test the two theories.

•Aug 13, 2026•0 citations

Static-Field Tunneling Ionization in Space-Fractional Quantum Mechanics

Marcelo F. Ciappina

Tunneling ionization in static or slowly varying electric fields is a cornerstone of strong-field physics and provides the entry point for semiclassical descriptions of above-threshold ionization and high-harmonic generation. In conventional quantum mechanics, the Perelomov--Popov--Terent'ev (PPT) theory and its Ammosov--Delone--Krainov (ADK) form yield an ionization rate whose defining feature is an exponential dependence governed by an under-barrier (imaginary-time) action. Here we develop an analytical ADK-like tunneling model within \emph{space-fractional} quantum mechanics, where the quadratic kinetic energy is replaced by the Riesz fractional Laplacian of order $1<α\le2$. Working in a static electric field in the length gauge, we derive a closed-form tunneling exponent for a triangular exit barrier. The fractional kinetic operator deforms the conventional $I_p^{3/2}$ scaling to $I_p^{1+1/α}$ and introduces a characteristic $\sin(π/α)$ factor encoding the complex-phase structure associated with nonlocal dispersion. We position this benchmark relative to prior tunneling studies in fractional quantum mechanics (primarily scattering through model barriers and fractal potentials) and provide a validation protocol for testing the exponent in time-dependent simulations of the fractional Schrödinger equation under a constant field. The result establishes a transparent reference for static-field ionization in nonlocal quantum dynamics and a baseline for strong-field approaches extensions.

quant-pharXiv:2605.05617•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•May 8, 2026•1 citation

Catalysis of quantum tunneling by ancillary system learning

Renzo Testa, Álex Rodríguez, Alberto d’Onofrio +3 more

Given the key role that quantum tunneling plays in a wide range of applications, a crucial objective is to maximize the probability of tunneling from one quantum state/level to another, while keeping the resources of the underlying physical system fixed. In this work, we demonstrate that an effective solution to this challenge can be achieved by coupling the tunneling system with an ancillary system of the same kind. By utilizing machine learning techniques, the parameters of both the ancillary system and the coupling can be optimized, leading to the maximization of the tunneling probability. We provide illustrative examples for the paradigmatic scenario involving a two-mode system and a two-mode ancilla with arbitrary couplings and in the presence of several interacting particles. Importantly, the enhancement of the tunneling probability appears to be minimally affected by noise and decoherence in both the system and the ancilla.

arXiv:2308.06060•Aug 11, 2023•0 citations

Machine Learning Catalysis of Quantum Tunneling

Renzo Testa, Álex Rodríguez, Alberto d’Onofrio +3 more

Optimizing the probability of quantum tunneling between two states, while keeping the resources of the underlying physical system constant, is a task of key importance due to its critical role in various applications. We show that, by applying Machine Learning techniques when the system is coupled to an ancilla, one optimizes the parameters of both the ancillary component and the coupling, ultimately resulting in the maximization of the tunneling probability. We provide illustrative examples for the paradigmatic scenario involving a two-mode system and a two-mode ancilla in the presence of several interacting particles. Physically, the increase of the tunneling probability is rooted in the decrease of the two-well asymmetry due to the coherent oscillations induced by the coupling to the ancilla. We also argue that the enhancement of the tunneling probability is not hampered by weak coupling to noisy environments.

arXiv:2310.10165•Oct 16, 2023•0 citations

QUANTUM TUNNELING IN SYNAPTIC ENZYMES AS A SOURCE OF GENUINE NEURAL VARIABILITY

Julian Julian Raul Collados

We propose that proton quantum tunneling in presynaptic enzymes constitutes a source of genuine synaptic variability, qualitatively distinct from classical thermal noise and detectable via the kinetic isotope effect (KIE). The central prediction is that H→D isotopic substitution in neuronal cultures should reduce the coefficient of variation of interspike intervals (CV of ISI) by a factor KIE_net in the range 1.5–3.5×, derived from a quantitative three-scale model (molecular → vesicular → network). The prediction rests on documented proton tunneling in enzymes (KIE up to 100×), a PCET-mediated vesicle fusion model, and experimental evidence that heavy water modulates hippocampal synaptic transmission. The hypothesis requires no macroscopic quantum coherence or new physics. The falsification threshold is explicit: KIE_net < 1.5× under controlled conditions with adequate statistical power (N ≥ 15 per group, α = 0.0125) refutes the hypothesis in its current formulation. The protocol includes explicit controls for osmotic, viscous, and thermal confounds of heavy water.

•Mar 5, 2026•0 citations
The kinetic isotope effect (KIE) is the conventional probe for quantum tunneling, yet its composite nature conflates tunneling with zero-point energy and classical kinetics. Here, we introduce the tunneling phase diagram, a machine-learning framework that decouples true tunneling strength by decoding the nonlinear relationship between KIE and the tunneling factor (\k{appa}). With exceptional fidelity (R^2 > 0.98, RMSE = 0.21), this framework reveals an anomalous high KIE-low \k{appa} spanning 300-600 K, thereby defining a paradigm for the quantitative assessment of quantum tunneling.
This paper proposes an alternative interpretation of quantum tunneling within the framework of TIMED THEORY.Rather than treating tunneling as a particle’s penetration through an energy barrier, we argue thattunneling is the ability of a particle to exist without leaving an observable record in regions where observation conditions are fundamentally unstable. We define such regions as the jari-michi (gravel road): domains in which the coordinate and time axes fail to stabilize long enough to form persistent measurement records.Within this framework, particle mass and de Broglie wavelength determine observability, which in turn governs whether a particle can enter and traverse these regions. Using published kinetic isotope effect (KIE) data from enzyme-catalyzed reactions — where hydrogen exhibits strong tunneling contributions while deuterium does not — we show that these experimental results are naturally explained by an observability-based mechanism rather than by wavefunction decay alone. This work does not reject the mathematical formalism of standard quantum mechanics.Instead, it reinterprets the physical mechanism underlying tunneling, reframing it as observational evasion rather than barrier penetration.The proposed framework offers new insight into why hydrogen occupies a unique tunneling “sweet spot” under ambient conditions and clarifies the minimal physical requirements for observation to occur. 本稿は、量子トンネリングを「粒子がエネルギー障壁を貫通する現象」とみなす標準的解釈に対し、トンネリングとは観測条件が不安定な領域において、粒子が観測記録を残さずに存在できる性質であるという代替的枠組みを、TIMED THEORYに基づいて提示する。 本研究では、座標軸および時間軸が安定した観測足場を形成できない領域を「砂利道(jari-michi)」として定義し、質量・ド・ブロイ波長・観測可能性の関係が、トンネリング現象をどのように制御しているかを示す。 特に、酵素触媒反応における速度論的同位体効果(Kinetic Isotope Effect, KIE)の公開データ——水素は効率的にトンネリングするが、重水素は著しく抑制される——が、本枠組みにより自然に説明できることを論証する。 本稿は、標準量子力学の数学的記述を否定するものではない。しかし、トンネリングを「透過」ではなく「観測回避」として再定義することで、水素が室温条件において特異的なトンネリング粒子となる理由、および観測事象が成立する物理的最小条件について、新たな解釈可能性を与える。
This paper proposes a classical alternative explanation for the tunneling effect in quantum mechanics. Standard quantum theory describes tunneling as a particle "penetrating" a potential barrier whose energy exceeds the particle's own kinetic energy with a certain probability. However, this explanation focuses only on the mathematical initial and final states, completely ignoring any dynamical process the electron may undergo before the barrier, and lacks a physical picture. This paper argues that tunneling is not an intrinsic quantum property of a single electron, but rather a collective statistical fluctuation event involving multiple electrons: electrons near the barrier, through a series of random collisions in the correct direction, gradually transfer and concentrate kinetic energy onto the electron closest to the barrier, enabling it to instantaneously acquire kinetic energy exceeding the barrier threshold and thus classically fly over the barrier. During the crossing, the electron must do work against the barrier, converting kinetic energy into potential energy; therefore, after crossing, its kinetic energy is reduced and it cannot cross the same barrier again. Tunneling probability is reinterpreted as the success probability of such a "directed energy relay" event. This model is fully self-consistent within the framework of classical electromagnetism and statistical mechanics, requiring no wave functions or probability waves, with a clear physical picture and explicit causal chain. This paper further points out that under strictly single-electron conditions, this model predicts that tunneling will completely disappear, a prediction that stands in fundamental opposition to the standard quantum model and can serve as a decisive experiment to test the two theories.
Tunneling ionization in static or slowly varying electric fields is a cornerstone of strong-field physics and provides the entry point for semiclassical descriptions of above-threshold ionization and high-harmonic generation. In conventional quantum mechanics, the Perelomov--Popov--Terent'ev (PPT) theory and its Ammosov--Delone--Krainov (ADK) form yield an ionization rate whose defining feature is an exponential dependence governed by an under-barrier (imaginary-time) action. Here we develop an analytical ADK-like tunneling model within \emph{space-fractional} quantum mechanics, where the quadratic kinetic energy is replaced by the Riesz fractional Laplacian of order 1<α≤21<α\le21<α≤2. Working in a static electric field in the length gauge, we derive a closed-form tunneling exponent for a triangular exit barrier. The fractional kinetic operator deforms the conventional Ip3/2I_p^{3/2}Ip3/2​ scaling to Ip1+1/αI_p^{1+1/α}Ip1+1/α​ and introduces a characteristic sin⁡(π/α)\sin(π/α)sin(π/α) factor encoding the complex-phase structure associated with nonlocal dispersion. We position this benchmark relative to prior tunneling studies in fractional quantum mechanics (primarily scattering through model barriers and fractal potentials) and provide a validation protocol for testing the exponent in time-dependent simulations of the fractional Schrödinger equation under a constant field. The result establishes a transparent reference for static-field ionization in nonlocal quantum dynamics and a baseline for strong-field approaches extensions.
Given the key role that quantum tunneling plays in a wide range of applications, a crucial objective is to maximize the probability of tunneling from one quantum state/level to another, while keeping the resources of the underlying physical system fixed. In this work, we demonstrate that an effective solution to this challenge can be achieved by coupling the tunneling system with an ancillary system of the same kind. By utilizing machine learning techniques, the parameters of both the ancillary system and the coupling can be optimized, leading to the maximization of the tunneling probability. We provide illustrative examples for the paradigmatic scenario involving a two-mode system and a two-mode ancilla with arbitrary couplings and in the presence of several interacting particles. Importantly, the enhancement of the tunneling probability appears to be minimally affected by noise and decoherence in both the system and the ancilla.
Optimizing the probability of quantum tunneling between two states, while keeping the resources of the underlying physical system constant, is a task of key importance due to its critical role in various applications. We show that, by applying Machine Learning techniques when the system is coupled to an ancilla, one optimizes the parameters of both the ancillary component and the coupling, ultimately resulting in the maximization of the tunneling probability. We provide illustrative examples for the paradigmatic scenario involving a two-mode system and a two-mode ancilla in the presence of several interacting particles. Physically, the increase of the tunneling probability is rooted in the decrease of the two-well asymmetry due to the coherent oscillations induced by the coupling to the ancilla. We also argue that the enhancement of the tunneling probability is not hampered by weak coupling to noisy environments.
We propose that proton quantum tunneling in presynaptic enzymes constitutes a source of genuine synaptic variability, qualitatively distinct from classical thermal noise and detectable via the kinetic isotope effect (KIE). The central prediction is that H→D isotopic substitution in neuronal cultures should reduce the coefficient of variation of interspike intervals (CV of ISI) by a factor KIE_net in the range 1.5–3.5×, derived from a quantitative three-scale model (molecular → vesicular → network). The prediction rests on documented proton tunneling in enzymes (KIE up to 100×), a PCET-mediated vesicle fusion model, and experimental evidence that heavy water modulates hippocampal synaptic transmission. The hypothesis requires no macroscopic quantum coherence or new physics. The falsification threshold is explicit: KIE_net < 1.5× under controlled conditions with adequate statistical power (N ≥ 15 per group, α = 0.0125) refutes the hypothesis in its current formulation. The protocol includes explicit controls for osmotic, viscous, and thermal confounds of heavy water.