We prove a trade-off theorem for order and disorder parameters in one-dimensional quantum spin systems with quenched disorder. For a disordered ensemble with exact Ising symmetry and average translation symmetry, any gapped ensemble must have one and only one of the following: an $O(1)$ order parameter or an $O(1)$ disorder parameter with even parity, both of the Edwards-Anderson type. The result extends to nearly gapped ensembles that accommodate Griffiths-type rare-region effects. These results offer a powerful and rigorous framework to understand the disorder effects beyond perturbative approaches. As applications, we (1) establish the existence of string order parameters for SPT phases; (2) derive a Lieb-Schultz-Mattis-type constraint for disordered ensembles, which requires a nearly gapped ensemble to spontaneously break the symmetry; and (3) discuss similar trade-off relations for disordered fermion chains, leading to an improved understanding of certain "intrinsically disordered" topological phases.
We prove a trade-off theorem for order and disorder parameters in one-dimensional quantum spin systems with quenched disorder. For a disordered ensemble with exact Ising symmetry and average translation symmetry, any gapped ensemble must have one and only one of the following: an O(1) order parameter or an O(1) disorder parameter with even parity, both of the Edwards-Anderson type. The result extends to nearly gapped ensembles that accommodate Griffiths-type rare-region effects. These results offer a powerful and rigorous framework to understand the disorder effects beyond perturbative approaches. As applications, we (1) establish the existence of string order parameters for SPT phases; (2) derive a Lieb-Schultz-Mattis-type constraint for disordered ensembles, which requires a nearly gapped ensemble to spontaneously break the symmetry; and (3) discuss similar trade-off relations for disordered fermion chains, leading to an improved understanding of certain "intrinsically disordered" topological phases.
We investigate the extension of pure-state symmetry protected topological phases to mixed-state regime with a strong U(1) and a weak Z2 symmetries in one-dimensional spin systems by the concept of quantum channels. We propose a corresponding topological phase order parameter for short-range entangled mixed states by showing that it is quantized and its distinct values can be realized by concrete spin systems with disorders, sharply signaling phase transitions among them. We also give a model-independent way to generate two distinct phases by various types of translation and reflection transformations. These results on the short-range entangled mixed states further enable us to generalize the conventional Lieb-Schultz-Mattis theorem to mixed states, even without the concept of spectral gaps and lattice Hamiltonians.
Quantum criticality in the presence of strong quenched randomness remains a challenging topic in modern condensed matter theory. We show that the topology and anomaly associated with average symmetry can be used to predict certain nontrivial universal properties. Our focus is on systems subject to average Lieb--Schultz--Mattis constraints, where lattice translation symmetry is preserved only on average, while on-site symmetries remain exact. We argue that in the absence of spontaneous symmetry breaking and intrinsic topological order, the system must exhibit critical correlations of local operators in two distinct ways: (i) for some operator Oe charged under exact symmetries, the first absolute moment correlation ∣⟨Oe(x)Oe†(y)⟩∣ decays slowly; and (ii) for some operator Oa charged under average symmetries, the first-moment correlation ⟨Oa(x)Oa†(y)⟩ decays slowly. We verify these predictions in a few examples: the random-singlet Heisenberg spin chain in one dimension, and the disordered free-fermion critical states in symmetry class BDI in one and two dimensions. Surprisingly, even for these well-studied systems, our anomaly-based argument reveals critical correlations overlooked in previous literature. We also discuss the experimental feasibility of measuring these critical correlations.
We investigate disordered phases realized in one-dimensional quantum spin systems.We revisit an effective field theory proposed by Schulz [Phys.Rev. B 34, 6372 (1986)], which encapsulates several essential properties in low energy, from the point of view of symmetry.Although this effective theory was originally derived by perturbation theory, we find that it is fully consistent with the symmetry of the Hamiltonian and thus uniquely identified in the non-perturbative sense.This theory explains many possible phase transitions known to occur among valence-bond-solid phases, which are typical disordered phases in one-dimensional spin systems.Furthermore, this theory indicates that the phase transitions only occur under one of four symmetries: time reversal, bond-centered inversion, dihedral group of spin rotations, and site-centered inversion combined with a spin rotation.Surprisingly, the first three symmetries are consistent with those protecting the Haldane phase in spin-1 chains, which have already been found by a completely different approach using the matrix-product state (MPS).On the other hand, the last one is not known so far.To understand it, we explicitly construct a microscopic model that has two distinct disordered phases protected by the combined inversion symmetry.We examine this model and confirm the existence of those disordered phases by perturbation theory and numerical simulations.For completeness, we further give a more rigorous proof of their existence, based on the non-translation-invariant MPS.We also propose an extension of the Lieb-Schultz-Mattis theorem for the absence of a unique gapped ground state in half-odd-integer spin systems with site-centered inversion symmetry.
We study quantum phases and phase transitions in a one-dimensional interacting fermion system with a Lieb-Schultz-Mattis (LSM) type anomaly. Specifically, the inversion symmetry enforces any symmetry-preserving gapped ground state of the system to be a Kitaev chain, following an LSM type theorem that we prove. Alternatively, via the Jordan-Wigner transformation, this system describes a spin system whose gapped ground states must break either the inversion or the Ising symmetry associated with fermion parity. We obtain a phase diagram using analytical methods and variational matrix product state simulations and study the critical behaviors of the quantum phase transitions therein using entanglement entropy, energy variance, and finite-size scaling of order parameters. In particular, we observe a continuous phase transition between two ordered phases that are beyond the Ginzburg-Landau-Wilson paradigm, in analogy to the deconfined quantum critical points in two spatial dimensions. We show this type of a 1D deconfined quantum critical point is described by the Tomonaga-Luttinger liquid theory and extract its Luttinger parameter and critical exponents. We also identify a gapless phase that emerges from a deconfined quantum critical point between two ordered phases, which cannot be described by a U(1) Luttinger liquid.
We study symmetric gapped ground states of one-dimensional spin S chains with a continuous exponential symmetry U(1)⋊Z2 with integer base q, where the U(1) charge has a modulated unit of charge qL−j decaying exponentially with site j. The simplest model is a quantum breakdown model that can be viewed as a q-deformation of the XXZ Haldane spin chain. We show that the topology of their symmetric ground states crucially depends on S and q. For integer S, odd q allows a nontrivial Z2 Haldane-type symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phase with protected edge modes, while even q allows no nontrivial SPT phase. For half-odd integer S, odd q prohibits any unique symmetric gapped ground state due to a Lieb-Schultz-Mattis obstruction, whereas even q enforces a novel symmetric gapped phase which we name as the ``half-SPT" phase. Unconventionally, the half-SPT phase only has a symmetry protected edge mode on one edge, and has half of the string orders of an SPT phase. Our results uncover a new type of symmetry-protected gapped phases beyond existing classification schemes.
Quantum phases with different orders exist with or without breaking the symmetry of the system. Recently, a classification of gapped quantum phases which do not break time reversal, parity, or on-site unitary symmetry has been given for 1D spin systems by X. Chen, Z.-C. Gu, and X.-G. Wen [Phys. Rev. B 83, 035107 (2011)]. It was found that such symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases are labeled by the projective representations of the symmetry group which can be viewed as a symmetry fractionalization. In this paper, we extend the classification of 1D gapped phases by considering SPT phases with combined time reversal, parity, and/or on-site unitary symmetries and also the possibility of symmetry breaking. We clarify how symmetry fractionalizes with combined symmetries and also how symmetry fractionalization coexists with symmetry breaking. In this way, we obtain a complete classification of gapped quantum phases in 1D spin systems. We find that in general, symmetry fractionalization, symmetry breaking, and long-range entanglement (present in 2 or higher dimensions) represent three main mechanisms to generate a very rich set of gapped quantum phases. As an application of our classification, we study the possible SPT phases in 1D fermionic systems, which can be mapped to spin systems by Jordan-Wigner transformation.