Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2604.26325

Schroedinger's Equation at 100: The Wave Picture That Helped and Possibly Hurt

Caslav Brukner

quant-phSubmitted Apr 29, 2026• Announced Apr 30, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Schroedinger's equation gave early quantum theory a visual language that looked like physics again: a wave evolving by a linear differential equation. This essay argues that the same success also seeded a recurring impulse to keep quantum theory "classical-looking" by treating the wave function as a physical wave. Schroedinger quickly realized that, for many-particle systems, the wave function is naturally defined on configuration space rather than ordinary physical space, blocking any straightforward reading of it as a literal classical wave. Read through Mach and Boltzmann, who shaped his intellectual outlook most deeply, his achievement appears double-edged: it provided an extraordinarily powerful picture for calculation and discovery, while also warning against taking that picture too literally. I argue that this tension never fully disappeared. It still reappears in modern physics whenever the wave function, or in quantum field theory the field itself, is treated as ontology rather than as part of a representation tied to measurement and observational context, a point sharpened by Bell-type no-go theorems. The centenary moral is: use pictures boldly, but demote them ontologically.

Comments
7 pages

Related papers

Representation of the wave function on the three-dimensional space

Ovidiu Cristinel Stoica

One of the major concerns of Schr\"odinger, Lorentz, Einstein, and many others about the wave function is that it is defined on the $3\mathbf{N}$-dimensional configuration space, rather than on the three-dimensional (3D) physical space. This gives the impression that quantum mechanics cannot have a $3\mathrm{D}$ space or space-time ontology, even in the absence of quantum measurements. In particular, this seems to affect interpretations which take the wave function as a physical entity, in particular, the many-worlds and the spontaneous collapse interpretations, and some versions of the pilot wave theory. Here, a representation of the many-particle states is given, as multilayered fields defined on the three-dimensional physical space. This representation is equivalent to the usual representation on the configuration space, but it makes it explicit that it is possible to interpret the wave functions as defined on the physical space. As long as only unitary evolution is involved, the interactions are local. I intended this representation to capture and formalize the nonexplicit and informal intuition of many working quantum physicists, who, by considering the wave function sometimes to be defined on the configuration space and sometimes on the physical space, may seem to researchers in the foundations of quantum theory as adopting an inconsistent view about its ontology. This representation does not aim to solve the measurement problem, and it allows for Schr\"odinger cats just like the usual one. But, it may help various interpretations to solve these problems, through inclusion of the wave function as (part of) their primitive ontology. In appendices, it is shown how the multilayered field representation can be extended to quantum field theory.

arXiv:1906.12229•Physical Review A•Oct 21, 2019•11 citations

Historical Debates over the Physical Reality of the Wave Function

Jacob A. Barandes

This paper provides a detailed and unified historical account of early debates over wave-function realism, the modern term for the view that the wave function of quantum theory is physically real. As this paper will show, the idea of physical waves associated with particles had its roots in work by Einstein and de Broglie, who both originally thought of these waves as propagating in three-dimensional physical space. De Broglie quickly turned this wave--particle duality into an early pilot-wave theory, on which a particle's associated ``phase wave'' piloted or guided the particle along its trajectory. Schrödinger built on de Broglie's phase-wave hypothesis to provide a comprehensive account of the nascent quantum theory. However, Schrödinger's new ``undulatory mechanics'' came at the cost of replacing de Broglie's phase waves propagating in physical space with a wave function propagating in a system's abstract configuration space. The present work will argue that this move from three-dimensional physical space to a many-dimensional configuration space was a decisive reason why the founders of quantum theory uniformly abandoned the physical reality of the wave function. This paper will further clarify that de Broglie introduced two distinct pilot-wave theories, and will then argue that it was Bohm's rediscovery of the second of these two pilot-wave theories over two decades later, as well as Bohm's vociferous defense of wave-function realism, that were responsible for resurrecting the idea of an ontological wave function. Finally, this paper will describe how the influence of Schrödinger and Bohmended up playing a central role in Everett's development of the ``many worlds'' interpretation.

physics.hist-phCross-listedarXiv:2602.09397•The European Physical Journal H•Feb 11, 2026•3 citations

Schrödinger's Dream: A New Wave-Based Approach to Unified Field Theory

Tam Hunt

Almost 100 years ago, Erwin Schrödinger’s pioneering contributions provided the foundation for quantum mechanics, yet his deeper ontological vision of a purely wave-based reality was largely sidelined by the rise of the Copenhagen interpretation and its rejection of realism. This paper revisits and extends Schrödinger's wave-based ontology, exploring its potential evolution in light of contemporary physics challenges. The Quantum Ocean Theory (QOT) theory developed here reconceptualizes the quantum ocean as a dynamic, oscillatory field from which all physical phenomena emerge. Through a single wave equation, QOT describes particles as localized standing waves and forces as traveling waves of different frequencies of the underlying medium, with physical constants like the speed of light emerging naturally from the vacuum's underlying properties. All forces emerge organically from the wave equation. Drawing from Schrödinger's philosophical commitments and scientific insights, alongside complementary ideas from Einstein, Whitehead, Bohm, and Bell, we argue that QOT provides both a unified mathematical framework and coherent ontological foundation for physics. The framework offers novel solutions to persistent challenges in modern physics, including the Hubble tension, quantum measurement problem, and the quest for quantum gravity. It makes specific, testable predictions regarding galactic synchrony, early galaxy formation, and quantum coherence phenomena. Beyond its empirical implications, QOT represents a return to the kind of realist, deterministic physics that Einstein and Schrödinger advocated, while incorporating modern insights about non-locality and quantum behavior.

•Sep 30, 2025•1 citation

Schrodinger's Wave Mechanics: Remarkable Dates and Place One Hundred Years Ago

Sergei K. Suslov

We discuss, at a level accessible to a wide audience, including students and teachers of physics and mathematics, the fundamental transition from classical mechanics to wave equations made by Schroedinger a century ago. These historical events clarify the structure and significance of quantum mechanics and are of interest to the global scientific community. Valuable sources for further studies are provided throughout the article.

physics.hist-phCross-listedarXiv:2601.05337•Jan 12, 2026•0 citations

What Persists in Neutrino Oscillation? Trajectory-States and the Ontological Surplus of Particle Language in QFT

Philip Rey

What Persists in Neutrino Oscillation? Trajectory-States and the Ontological Surplus of Particle Language in QFT Quantum field theory is routinely interpreted through the language of particles, even though its formalism is built from fields, amplitudes, excitations, and transition structures. This paper asks whether that vocabulary should be treated as literal ontology or as operational shorthand. It argues that, while particle language remains pragmatically indispensable, it may encode more ontological confidence than either QFT or detector practice strictly warrants. To sharpen this issue, the paper introduces Active Memory Engineering (AME) as an interpretive framework based on two operations: reconstruction and trajectory tracking through state change. On this view, what is physically continuous across a process is not primarily a microscopic object with fixed intrinsic identity, but a phase-evolving, reconstruction-dependent trajectory-state shaped by propagation history, coupling, and detection context. Neutrino oscillation provides the decisive case study. Rather than supporting naive object persistence, oscillation theory and experimental practice suggest a stronger picture of continuity through transformation. The paper concludes that particle language should be retained as an effective descriptive instrument, but not automatically elevated into a fundamental ontology.

•Mar 23, 2026•0 citations

A Three–Dimensional Ontological Formulation of Bohmian Mechanics

Pablo Yepes

We present a three-dimensional field ontology for Bohmian mechanics in which the single-particle wave functions defined in ordinary physical space are taken as ontological elements alongside particle positions. In this view, each particle is associated with a wave function in three-dimensional space conditioned on the actual positions of the remaining particles. The universal wave function on configuration space is retained within the formalism, but its role is interpreted as nomological: it determines the coupled evolution of the three-dimensional fields without itself being treated as a fundamental physical field. The corresponding evolution equations for the conditioned three-dimensional wave functions follow from the standard Bohmian formalism and, together with the guidance equation, yield dynamics fully equivalent to those of the conventional theory. The empirical and predictive content of Bohmian mechanics is thereby preserved, while its ontological structure is expressed in explicitly three-dimensional terms. Within a ψ-ontic perspective, this proposal makes explicit an ontological organization of Bohmian mechanics in which the dynamical fields are defined on physical space. While fully equivalent to the conventional formulation, expressing the theory in these terms may facilitate interpretation, visualization, and pedagogical presentation.

Entropy•Mar 31, 2026•0 citations
Schroedinger's equation gave early quantum theory a visual language that looked like physics again: a wave evolving by a linear differential equation. This essay argues that the same success also seeded a recurring impulse to keep quantum theory "classical-looking" by treating the wave function as a physical wave. Schroedinger quickly realized that, for many-particle systems, the wave function is naturally defined on configuration space rather than ordinary physical space, blocking any straightforward reading of it as a literal classical wave. Read through Mach and Boltzmann, who shaped his intellectual outlook most deeply, his achievement appears double-edged: it provided an extraordinarily powerful picture for calculation and discovery, while also warning against taking that picture too literally. I argue that this tension never fully disappeared. It still reappears in modern physics whenever the wave function, or in quantum field theory the field itself, is treated as ontology rather than as part of a representation tied to measurement and observational context, a point sharpened by Bell-type no-go theorems. The centenary moral is: use pictures boldly, but demote them ontologically.
One of the major concerns of Schr\"odinger, Lorentz, Einstein, and many others about the wave function is that it is defined on the 3N3\mathbf{N}3N-dimensional configuration space, rather than on the three-dimensional (3D) physical space. This gives the impression that quantum mechanics cannot have a 3D3\mathrm{D}3D space or space-time ontology, even in the absence of quantum measurements. In particular, this seems to affect interpretations which take the wave function as a physical entity, in particular, the many-worlds and the spontaneous collapse interpretations, and some versions of the pilot wave theory. Here, a representation of the many-particle states is given, as multilayered fields defined on the three-dimensional physical space. This representation is equivalent to the usual representation on the configuration space, but it makes it explicit that it is possible to interpret the wave functions as defined on the physical space. As long as only unitary evolution is involved, the interactions are local. I intended this representation to capture and formalize the nonexplicit and informal intuition of many working quantum physicists, who, by considering the wave function sometimes to be defined on the configuration space and sometimes on the physical space, may seem to researchers in the foundations of quantum theory as adopting an inconsistent view about its ontology. This representation does not aim to solve the measurement problem, and it allows for Schr\"odinger cats just like the usual one. But, it may help various interpretations to solve these problems, through inclusion of the wave function as (part of) their primitive ontology. In appendices, it is shown how the multilayered field representation can be extended to quantum field theory.
This paper provides a detailed and unified historical account of early debates over wave-function realism, the modern term for the view that the wave function of quantum theory is physically real. As this paper will show, the idea of physical waves associated with particles had its roots in work by Einstein and de Broglie, who both originally thought of these waves as propagating in three-dimensional physical space. De Broglie quickly turned this wave--particle duality into an early pilot-wave theory, on which a particle's associated ``phase wave'' piloted or guided the particle along its trajectory. Schrödinger built on de Broglie's phase-wave hypothesis to provide a comprehensive account of the nascent quantum theory. However, Schrödinger's new ``undulatory mechanics'' came at the cost of replacing de Broglie's phase waves propagating in physical space with a wave function propagating in a system's abstract configuration space. The present work will argue that this move from three-dimensional physical space to a many-dimensional configuration space was a decisive reason why the founders of quantum theory uniformly abandoned the physical reality of the wave function. This paper will further clarify that de Broglie introduced two distinct pilot-wave theories, and will then argue that it was Bohm's rediscovery of the second of these two pilot-wave theories over two decades later, as well as Bohm's vociferous defense of wave-function realism, that were responsible for resurrecting the idea of an ontological wave function. Finally, this paper will describe how the influence of Schrödinger and Bohmended up playing a central role in Everett's development of the ``many worlds'' interpretation.
Almost 100 years ago, Erwin Schrödinger’s pioneering contributions provided the foundation for quantum mechanics, yet his deeper ontological vision of a purely wave-based reality was largely sidelined by the rise of the Copenhagen interpretation and its rejection of realism. This paper revisits and extends Schrödinger's wave-based ontology, exploring its potential evolution in light of contemporary physics challenges. The Quantum Ocean Theory (QOT) theory developed here reconceptualizes the quantum ocean as a dynamic, oscillatory field from which all physical phenomena emerge. Through a single wave equation, QOT describes particles as localized standing waves and forces as traveling waves of different frequencies of the underlying medium, with physical constants like the speed of light emerging naturally from the vacuum's underlying properties. All forces emerge organically from the wave equation. Drawing from Schrödinger's philosophical commitments and scientific insights, alongside complementary ideas from Einstein, Whitehead, Bohm, and Bell, we argue that QOT provides both a unified mathematical framework and coherent ontological foundation for physics. The framework offers novel solutions to persistent challenges in modern physics, including the Hubble tension, quantum measurement problem, and the quest for quantum gravity. It makes specific, testable predictions regarding galactic synchrony, early galaxy formation, and quantum coherence phenomena. Beyond its empirical implications, QOT represents a return to the kind of realist, deterministic physics that Einstein and Schrödinger advocated, while incorporating modern insights about non-locality and quantum behavior.
What Persists in Neutrino Oscillation? Trajectory-States and the Ontological Surplus of Particle Language in QFT Quantum field theory is routinely interpreted through the language of particles, even though its formalism is built from fields, amplitudes, excitations, and transition structures. This paper asks whether that vocabulary should be treated as literal ontology or as operational shorthand. It argues that, while particle language remains pragmatically indispensable, it may encode more ontological confidence than either QFT or detector practice strictly warrants. To sharpen this issue, the paper introduces Active Memory Engineering (AME) as an interpretive framework based on two operations: reconstruction and trajectory tracking through state change. On this view, what is physically continuous across a process is not primarily a microscopic object with fixed intrinsic identity, but a phase-evolving, reconstruction-dependent trajectory-state shaped by propagation history, coupling, and detection context. Neutrino oscillation provides the decisive case study. Rather than supporting naive object persistence, oscillation theory and experimental practice suggest a stronger picture of continuity through transformation. The paper concludes that particle language should be retained as an effective descriptive instrument, but not automatically elevated into a fundamental ontology.
We present a three-dimensional field ontology for Bohmian mechanics in which the single-particle wave functions defined in ordinary physical space are taken as ontological elements alongside particle positions. In this view, each particle is associated with a wave function in three-dimensional space conditioned on the actual positions of the remaining particles. The universal wave function on configuration space is retained within the formalism, but its role is interpreted as nomological: it determines the coupled evolution of the three-dimensional fields without itself being treated as a fundamental physical field. The corresponding evolution equations for the conditioned three-dimensional wave functions follow from the standard Bohmian formalism and, together with the guidance equation, yield dynamics fully equivalent to those of the conventional theory. The empirical and predictive content of Bohmian mechanics is thereby preserved, while its ontological structure is expressed in explicitly three-dimensional terms. Within a ψ-ontic perspective, this proposal makes explicit an ontological organization of Bohmian mechanics in which the dynamical fields are defined on physical space. While fully equivalent to the conventional formulation, expressing the theory in these terms may facilitate interpretation, visualization, and pedagogical presentation.